Starmer hatches new free movement plot with Spain
#121
BE Forum Addict









Joined: May 2007
Posts: 4,393
From: England











Most people I know believe we did make brexit stronger and still believe in trying to change this, except for being able to live Europe whenever the fancy took you for mere mortals it has not mattered we now do not belong to a European Union and that it’s Europe that’s keeps telling us we “want back inâ€
their homes in Spain and Italy)and not one person (we are from all walks of life) said they wanted or missed being in Europe, it had not effected our lives at all and as one German friend said it appears Europe keep “telling us†we are missing them when we are not, I don’t give being in Europe a thought unless planning my holidays.
#122
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 6,172











We had this conversation they other week at a party (because a person at the party had just sold both of
their homes in Spain and Italy)and not one person (we are from all walks of life) said they wanted or missed being in Europe, it had not effected our lives at all and as one German friend said it appears Europe keep “telling us†we are missing them when we are not, I don’t give being in Europe a thought unless planning my holidays.
their homes in Spain and Italy)and not one person (we are from all walks of life) said they wanted or missed being in Europe, it had not effected our lives at all and as one German friend said it appears Europe keep “telling us†we are missing them when we are not, I don’t give being in Europe a thought unless planning my holidays.
Last edited by bobd22; Aug 29th 2024 at 4:08 am.
#123
BE Forum Addict






Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 1,500











And that's how the referendum was decided.
Businesses selling goods and services, logistics and transport, support and services, research and development, recognition of chemicals and medicines, cross-frontier workers, studying, recognition of education, training, and diplomas, residency for family members of different nationalities, living, working, retirement, etc... etc... etc... none of that matters. Just the two weeks holiday.
Businesses selling goods and services, logistics and transport, support and services, research and development, recognition of chemicals and medicines, cross-frontier workers, studying, recognition of education, training, and diplomas, residency for family members of different nationalities, living, working, retirement, etc... etc... etc... none of that matters. Just the two weeks holiday.
#124
BE Forum Addict








Joined: May 2023
Posts: 3,310











And that's how the referendum was decided.
Businesses selling goods and services, logistics and transport, support and services, research and development, recognition of chemicals and medicines, cross-frontier workers, studying, recognition of education, training, and diplomas, residency for family members of different nationalities, living, working, retirement, etc... etc... etc... none of that matters. Just the two weeks holiday.
Businesses selling goods and services, logistics and transport, support and services, research and development, recognition of chemicals and medicines, cross-frontier workers, studying, recognition of education, training, and diplomas, residency for family members of different nationalities, living, working, retirement, etc... etc... etc... none of that matters. Just the two weeks holiday.
#125
BE Forum Addict








Joined: May 2023
Posts: 3,310











We had this conversation they other week at a party (because a person at the party had just sold both of
their homes in Spain and Italy)and not one person (we are from all walks of life) said they wanted or missed being in Europe, it had not effected our lives at all and as one German friend said it appears Europe keep “telling us†we are missing them when we are not, I don’t give being in Europe a thought unless planning my holidays.
their homes in Spain and Italy)and not one person (we are from all walks of life) said they wanted or missed being in Europe, it had not effected our lives at all and as one German friend said it appears Europe keep “telling us†we are missing them when we are not, I don’t give being in Europe a thought unless planning my holidays.
#126
BE Forum Addict









Joined: May 2007
Posts: 4,393
From: England











And that's how the referendum was decided.
Businesses selling goods and services, logistics and transport, support and services, research and development, recognition of chemicals and medicines, cross-frontier workers, studying, recognition of education, training, and diplomas, residency for family members of different nationalities, living, working, retirement, etc... etc... etc... none of that matters. Just the two weeks holiday.
Businesses selling goods and services, logistics and transport, support and services, research and development, recognition of chemicals and medicines, cross-frontier workers, studying, recognition of education, training, and diplomas, residency for family members of different nationalities, living, working, retirement, etc... etc... etc... none of that matters. Just the two weeks holiday.
#127
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Jul 2016
Posts: 11,628











Lol I have much more than two weeks holidays overseas, having lived and worked in countries outside of Europe I do not see any difference to the above than when applying for work etc in over non Europe countries and to be honest unless I spoke a European language being employed in my or my husbands skills was a no go in Europe, my SIL has a business as do two of my nephews and they think it’s better for them outside of the UK as they have more options where they did not have before to buy good at a cheaper price etc. Universities in Europe still have UK students and visa versa so that has not really changed and as for buying goods the UK have much more choice than just being within the European block but we still do trade with Europe.
Rather than reducing immigration the reverse has happened - and at the same time labour shortages in some sectors directly related to ending FOM with Europe.
As far as universities it is a bit hard to believe EU students not affected by the increase in costs, and vice versa- and leaving the Erasmus scheme definitely reduces opportunities for young Brits. And just an anecdotal observation- this summer in France locals pointed out less young Brits in various programs, or even taking summer jobs.
Lower prices ? While there are a variety of factors affecting prices, I certainly have not seen for basic food prices some benefit from Brexit.
Hopefully Starmer can step by step start reversing aspect of Brexit in particular on freedom of movement. That not all Brits may seek to have the advantages of FOM. for many it is a negative FOM ended .
#128
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 6,172











For the young and pensioners Brexit has reduced their opportunities by definition - I have yet to encounter a Brexiter who cane employ basic logic to explain how reducing opportunity is a benefit.
Rather than reducing immigration the reverse has happened - and at the same time labour shortages in some sectors directly related to ending FOM with Europe.
As far as universities it is a bit hard to believe EU students not affected by the increase in costs, and vice versa- and leaving the Erasmus scheme definitely reduces opportunities for young Brits. And just an anecdotal observation- this summer in France locals pointed out less young Brits in various programs, or even taking summer jobs.
Lower prices ? While there are a variety of factors affecting prices, I certainly have not seen for basic food prices some benefit from Brexit.
Hopefully Starmer can step by step start reversing aspect of Brexit in particular on freedom of movement. That not all Brits may seek to have the advantages of FOM. for many it is a negative FOM ended .
Rather than reducing immigration the reverse has happened - and at the same time labour shortages in some sectors directly related to ending FOM with Europe.
As far as universities it is a bit hard to believe EU students not affected by the increase in costs, and vice versa- and leaving the Erasmus scheme definitely reduces opportunities for young Brits. And just an anecdotal observation- this summer in France locals pointed out less young Brits in various programs, or even taking summer jobs.
Lower prices ? While there are a variety of factors affecting prices, I certainly have not seen for basic food prices some benefit from Brexit.
Hopefully Starmer can step by step start reversing aspect of Brexit in particular on freedom of movement. That not all Brits may seek to have the advantages of FOM. for many it is a negative FOM ended .
#129
BE Enthusiast




Joined: Nov 2021
Posts: 300
From: Alzira











#130
I dont think thats is true at all. Take out Ireland (not FOM as CTA) there are less than a million UK citizens living in the EU. Whilst there were more than 6m applications for settled status from EU citizens in the UK after Brexit. For the vast majority of UK citizens FOM isnt a concern. Perhaps some opinion polls may say UK ppl would want it, but very few would actually use it in reality. No chance Starmer will either bring back FOM, or join the single market/customs union, Thats just wishful thinking on your part, not reality.
There may not be that many who actually live somewhere else in Europe but there are others affected. Like those for whom that option in the future has been cut off.
If dad can't do what his dad was able to do then that potentially adversely impacts in a variety of ways the grandkids, grandparents, spouses, siblings, friends etc....all those people affected by one person being hindered by the change.
It's similar to "not many people die" but their death affects many more people.
#131
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Jul 2016
Posts: 11,628











I dont think thats is true at all. Take out Ireland (not FOM as CTA) there are less than a million UK citizens living in the EU. Whilst there were more than 6m applications for settled status from EU citizens in the UK after Brexit. For the vast majority of UK citizens FOM isnt a concern. Perhaps some opinion polls may say UK ppl would want it, but very few would actually use it in reality. No chance Starmer will either bring back FOM, or join the single market/customs union, Thats just wishful thinking on your part, not reality.
For example local care home has consistent shortages in did not have before Brexit, letting in hundreds of thousands of non-EU citizens has not helped, and to the extent raising wages the solution, that has not helped them either.
No I do not think Starmer will bring back FOM in the short term, though I do hope he can chip away at some of the Brexit idiocy.
And giving up access to the EU markets based on fantasies of trade deals with non-EU countries making up for it another weird idea.
#132
BE Enthusiast




Joined: Nov 2021
Posts: 300
From: Alzira











That most Brits would not take advantage not the issue- and a million not a small number, plus all those in the future whether students or pensioners now with less opportunity. And the reverse affect on labor shortages.
For example local care home has consistent shortages in did not have before Brexit, letting in hundreds of thousands of non-EU citizens has not helped, and to the extent raising wages the solution, that has not helped them either.
No I do not think Starmer will bring back FOM in the short term, though I do hope he can chip away at some of the Brexit idiocy.
And giving up access to the EU markets based on fantasies of trade deals with non-EU countries making up for it another weird idea.
For example local care home has consistent shortages in did not have before Brexit, letting in hundreds of thousands of non-EU citizens has not helped, and to the extent raising wages the solution, that has not helped them either.
No I do not think Starmer will bring back FOM in the short term, though I do hope he can chip away at some of the Brexit idiocy.
And giving up access to the EU markets based on fantasies of trade deals with non-EU countries making up for it another weird idea.
The UK has access to the single market, the TCA includes......
- A free trade agreement (with zero tariffs and zero quotas on all goods that comply with the relevant rules of origin);
- Cooperation on other economic issues, such as investments, competition, State aid, tax transparency, air and road transport, energy and sustainability, social security coordination and fisheries;
- A new partnership for citizens’ security through police and judicial cooperation, including data protection and data exchange;
- A comprehensive governance system
#133
I dont think thats is true at all. Take out Ireland (not FOM as CTA) there are less than a million UK citizens living in the EU. Whilst there were more than 6m applications for settled status from EU citizens in the UK after Brexit. For the vast majority of UK citizens FOM isnt a concern. Perhaps some opinion polls may say UK ppl would want it, but very few would actually use it in reality. No chance Starmer will either bring back FOM, or join the single market/customs union, Thats just wishful thinking on your part, not reality.
Many thousands of UK citizens were able to (and did) hop across to Europe to work summer or winter seasons in hospitality. Likewise performing artists, now subject to individual member state rules which in some cases means no more than a single night without a work visa.
#134
BE Enthusiast




Joined: Nov 2021
Posts: 300
From: Alzira











I've never understood this "only affects a few" argument.
There may not be that many who actually live somewhere else in Europe but there are others affected. Like those for whom that option in the future has been cut off.
If dad can't do what his dad was able to do then that potentially adversely impacts in a variety of ways the grandkids, grandparents, spouses, siblings, friends etc....all those people affected by one person being hindered by the change.
It's similar to "not many people die" but their death affects many more people.
There may not be that many who actually live somewhere else in Europe but there are others affected. Like those for whom that option in the future has been cut off.
If dad can't do what his dad was able to do then that potentially adversely impacts in a variety of ways the grandkids, grandparents, spouses, siblings, friends etc....all those people affected by one person being hindered by the change.
It's similar to "not many people die" but their death affects many more people.
Everyone will die, so I don't understand what that's all about.
#135
BE Forum Addict






Joined: Mar 2019
Posts: 1,010











EU freedom of movement comes in different shapes and sizes and is used in different ways depending on the member state concerned.
"UK nationals didn't use freedom of movement" is a popular Brexit trope but it's complete nonsense. People from other EU states mostly went to the UK for work so they are easy to identify but many people using FoM are not counted in the actual FoM stats because they are travelling around or staying in their holiday homes for six months. A good example of this is the British pressure group of holiday homeowners in France who can no longer stay in said homes for six consecutive months - something they did for many years and probably took for granted.
Freedom of movement is used in many different ways and a lot of British people didn't even know they were using it. It's a dreadful loss and people are really feeling it now.
"UK nationals didn't use freedom of movement" is a popular Brexit trope but it's complete nonsense. People from other EU states mostly went to the UK for work so they are easy to identify but many people using FoM are not counted in the actual FoM stats because they are travelling around or staying in their holiday homes for six months. A good example of this is the British pressure group of holiday homeowners in France who can no longer stay in said homes for six consecutive months - something they did for many years and probably took for granted.
Freedom of movement is used in many different ways and a lot of British people didn't even know they were using it. It's a dreadful loss and people are really feeling it now.



