EU Referendum
#181
We could quibble on % but the point is that a large mass of voters are economically illiterate and fairly ill equipped to weigh the pros and cons of social policy. It's plain whenever there is a public debate. Politicians are generally more informed and capable than the average punter, so would prefer it to be left in their hands, if it needs to be addressed at all.
#182
It's pretty clear the UK is not an isolated case...
In a traumatised Netherlands, faith in the EU is plummeting | Joris Luyendijk | Opinion | The Guardian
This paragraph seems particularly apt...
"Each of these debacles made the traditional elites look helpless and inept – in Wilders’ favourite slur, “naiveâ€. When those same elites then implore their voters to trust them on the EU, the euro and immigration, many voters now think twice."
In a traumatised Netherlands, faith in the EU is plummeting | Joris Luyendijk | Opinion | The Guardian
This paragraph seems particularly apt...
"Each of these debacles made the traditional elites look helpless and inept – in Wilders’ favourite slur, “naiveâ€. When those same elites then implore their voters to trust them on the EU, the euro and immigration, many voters now think twice."
#183
Actually, it wasn't the "wise" political elite who decided to hold the referendum. It was David Cameron who stuck it into the last election platform to make the Brexiters in his party toe the line until after he and Gorgeous George could sell the lie to the electorate that the economic meltdown was the previous Labour government's fault rather than their own.
#184
It's evening again in France and benignity is still not a word in English or any other language of which I'm aware.
#187
Last edited by Oink; Jun 6th 2016 at 8:38 am.
#188
Do you think that the EU policy making bodies are a mystical conspiratorial sect intent on subverting democracy? I don't.
#190
It's pretty clear the UK is not an isolated case...
In a traumatised Netherlands, faith in the EU is plummeting | Joris Luyendijk | Opinion | The Guardian
This paragraph seems particularly apt...
"Each of these debacles made the traditional elites look helpless and inept – in Wilders’ favourite slur, “naiveâ€. When those same elites then implore their voters to trust them on the EU, the euro and immigration, many voters now think twice."
In a traumatised Netherlands, faith in the EU is plummeting | Joris Luyendijk | Opinion | The Guardian
This paragraph seems particularly apt...
"Each of these debacles made the traditional elites look helpless and inept – in Wilders’ favourite slur, “naiveâ€. When those same elites then implore their voters to trust them on the EU, the euro and immigration, many voters now think twice."
The rising EU dissent in other EU nations is precisely why this referendum is turning into a time bomb. For all its democratic failings and budget wastage, the union has kept members from each other's throats for the past 60 years. If Brexit triggers a domino effect, who's to say where we will end up. The stability, cooperation and integration we take for granted now could easily be swept away in a decade or two. And for what gain? The economic arguments are impossible to pin down, so it really comes down to migration control. There is something to be said for that, but leaving the EU is not necessarily the way to achieve it.
Getting back to the wisdom of the masses:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/...d-anger---and/
Last edited by Shard; Jun 6th 2016 at 10:46 am.
#191
How is the UK going to manage in that situation? If you don't want to be dominated by the EU, surely being in the EU and having a vote in what happens is the solution?
The only reason for this referendum is for the Tories to stuff UKIP. That was the deciding factor I reckon, because Cameron wanted Tory unity by having a referendum and it had the added bonus of: win or lose, UKIP is finished.
If they win, well the UK is independent of the EU, so they're done. If they lose, they've lost in the referendum they've wanted for years, so they're done.
#192
At the moment, it has to implement all directives that the EU issues. I happen to think that the vast majority of the directives that the EU issues are better than those made by the UK parliament and that this has been the case for some time but one cannot credibly argue that the UK has not deferred a huge amount of its sovereignty to the EU.
I'll leave it for others to determine whether this is a good, or bad, thing.
I'll leave it for others to determine whether this is a good, or bad, thing.
But as for sovereignty, the powers of the EU are limited by what the treaties allow and the UK has MEPs and is in the EU Council. I have no doubt many member states would breath a sigh of relief if the UK left because consensus would be easier to achieve. And that consensus would not be in the best interests of the UK, most likely.
Also I looked up the net migration figures - 5.46/1,000 for the UK from last year and 5.66/1,000 for Canada! But we control our immigration.
This migration argument is another one - all these UKIP and BNP types going on about it. Well, the EU member states are mostly Christian and white countries. "We can do more with the Commonwealth." Oh you mean those Commonwealth countries like India, Bangladesh and Pakistan whose immigrants you complain about?
Is Polish sausage really that great of a threat to British culture?
Anyway I think Eddie Izzard made the best comment about how EU regulation has done away with roaming charges.
Yes - of course, when you go and sit on a beach near some shithole in Spain it will cost you more to gaze into your phone if the UK leaves the EU.
Brexit defeated...
#194
We arrived back from a 2 week holiday today to be greeted by our postal ballot letters for the EU referendum.
We shall send them back tomorrow - so glad to see they've arrived promptly.
We shall send them back tomorrow - so glad to see they've arrived promptly.
#195
Wow, the pound has tanked. 1.82 Clearly the jitters are setting in. Good timing for our forthcoming UK trip








