LCD Vs Plasma
#32
The data content required for true holographic TV is frightening. Maybe by 2020 someone will have got to grips with the how-the-f*** aspects, but in the meantime transmitting stereo pair 3D is *much* easier (main picture+low rate difference channel). That's why I think it will take off, its well within the capabilities of blu-ray, HDMI, DVB-T2, etc.
Only problem is LCD isn't the best match technology-wise. However they aren't that far of delivering fast enough refresh rates cheaply, so maybe it will get there before 2012.
Main thing to remember, the sets are backwards compatible and the extra cost of adding it to existing designs is low if your technology is right.
Oh, and there as all that new 3D content from the cinemas, and they are adding 3D to old as we speak.
Only problem is LCD isn't the best match technology-wise. However they aren't that far of delivering fast enough refresh rates cheaply, so maybe it will get there before 2012.
Main thing to remember, the sets are backwards compatible and the extra cost of adding it to existing designs is low if your technology is right.
Oh, and there as all that new 3D content from the cinemas, and they are adding 3D to old as we speak.
As for the 3D and the ability to pirate.... there will always be someone like the following to rise to the challenge.
PS3 now Hacked.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8478764.stm
Last edited by ozzieeagle; Mar 15th 2010 at 8:35 pm.
#33
Agreed, I'm bringing my Pioneer 8G over, just wish I'd bought the bigger model when they where available.
The general arguments on plasma vs LCD are...
LCD -
Pro
Lower power usage, cheaper, available in smaller sizes
Con
Lesser black levels, motion blur, worse SD pic quality
Plasma -
Pro
Deeper blacks, better motion handling, better SD pic quality
Con
Can suffer screen burn (pixel orbiters help), use more power
My next TV will also be a plasma
The general arguments on plasma vs LCD are...
LCD -
Pro
Lower power usage, cheaper, available in smaller sizes
Con
Lesser black levels, motion blur, worse SD pic quality
Plasma -
Pro
Deeper blacks, better motion handling, better SD pic quality
Con
Can suffer screen burn (pixel orbiters help), use more power
My next TV will also be a plasma
#34
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 16,623
From: Hill overlooking the SE Melbourne suburbs











Well..welll..well tomorrow we get a 42inch Panasonic Plasma.
Out CRT developed a blur on Sunday after only 6 years - my wife suspected sabotage.
We got the plasma for AUS999 plus a free blue ray.
A mate paid 8k for his 5 years ago and had to buy a huge set top box.
Out CRT developed a blur on Sunday after only 6 years - my wife suspected sabotage.
We got the plasma for AUS999 plus a free blue ray.
A mate paid 8k for his 5 years ago and had to buy a huge set top box.
#35
If you find a supplier still selling the 9G could you let me know, I assumed TV;s would continue to improve, but I was wrong, its never been bettered.
#37
EDIT - Hmm maybe not...http://www.hdtvtest.co.uk/news/panas...0100308169.htm
Oh yeah and I have no interest at all in 3D ATM
Last edited by freebo; Mar 15th 2010 at 11:01 pm.
#38
Devil's Advocate







Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 2,269
From: Mandurah











Ho ho ho this is very good and difficult question.
Firstly, have a look at this video below for some informed and general advice. Now this was made in 2008 and of course technology has moved on.
The difference between the two is getting smaller but differences do exist.
Be careful with the "LED" TV being put about at the moment and what you are really looking at. There is a new technology called OLED which is potentially brilliant - its not the same as an LED TV which is still LCD but with different back light.
Also, depending on how serious you are, be careful in shops like Harvey Norman, Retravision etc - most people in there know nothing. If you serious about best quality get a TV which can be ISF calibrated.
When comparing TV sets in shops be very careful of how they are setup. In bright shop fluro lighting they often turn settings right up in whats often called "dynamic" mode which makes things look very vivid which seems great when first seen but at home you'll find very harsh over the period of the evening - its not how they were designed to be watched.
Even if for info, go to proper home cinema shops for advice.
Personally I'm a plasma fan but I must admit some of the recent large size LCDs are impressive.
If you fancy plasma I'd go Panasonic only. Now Pioneer are out, they are No1. However I did see recently a Pioneer 9the Gen Kuro being advertised; must be oldish stock but if you can get one its probably the best panel (LCD or plasma) ever made.
Firstly, have a look at this video below for some informed and general advice. Now this was made in 2008 and of course technology has moved on.
The difference between the two is getting smaller but differences do exist.
Be careful with the "LED" TV being put about at the moment and what you are really looking at. There is a new technology called OLED which is potentially brilliant - its not the same as an LED TV which is still LCD but with different back light.
Also, depending on how serious you are, be careful in shops like Harvey Norman, Retravision etc - most people in there know nothing. If you serious about best quality get a TV which can be ISF calibrated.
When comparing TV sets in shops be very careful of how they are setup. In bright shop fluro lighting they often turn settings right up in whats often called "dynamic" mode which makes things look very vivid which seems great when first seen but at home you'll find very harsh over the period of the evening - its not how they were designed to be watched.
Even if for info, go to proper home cinema shops for advice.
Personally I'm a plasma fan but I must admit some of the recent large size LCDs are impressive.
If you fancy plasma I'd go Panasonic only. Now Pioneer are out, they are No1. However I did see recently a Pioneer 9the Gen Kuro being advertised; must be oldish stock but if you can get one its probably the best panel (LCD or plasma) ever made.
#39

Rushed out and bought a Panasonic plasma then got the CRT fixed under extended warranty and sold it on ebay.

A month later John Lewis had dropped their price on it by £100, so I phoned them up and they sent me cheque for £100.
Last edited by Alfresco; Mar 16th 2010 at 3:34 am.
#40
Just Joined

Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 24
From: Homeless but finally in Qld!








I was told a while back that LCD is better for the smaller size screens and that plasma is better for the larger screens, I presume 42" and over.
#41
Forum Regular


Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 59








#43
Account Closed







Joined: May 2009
Posts: 2,708

Pity they look crap, panasonic always drop the ball with design. Titanium finish for the V20 and metallic brown for the VT20. Why can't they just have a nice, classy, gloss piano black finish like the Pioneers.
Last edited by Deancm; Mar 16th 2010 at 9:30 am.
#44
Account Closed










Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 10,784

Right now the current Panny's are just the run of the mill stuff. The new 2010 range of plasmas to be released around June (the G20, V20 and VT20 3D) are the ones that are incorporating Pioneers Kuro tech. The G20, by all accounts falls short of the Kuro's but the V20 and VT20 are the ones to watch out for. Going to be interesting to see the Kuro v Panny side by side comparisons.
#45
Right now the current Panny's are just the run of the mill stuff. The new 2010 range of plasmas to be released around June (the G20, V20 and VT20 3D) are the ones that are incorporating Pioneers Kuro tech. The G20, by all accounts falls short of the Kuro's but the V20 and VT20 are the ones to watch out for. Going to be interesting to see the Kuro v Panny side by side comparisons.
Pity they look crap, panasonic always drop the ball with design. Titanium finish for the V20 and metallic brown for the VT20. Why can't they just have a nice, classy, gloss piano black finish like the Pioneers.
Pity they look crap, panasonic always drop the ball with design. Titanium finish for the V20 and metallic brown for the VT20. Why can't they just have a nice, classy, gloss piano black finish like the Pioneers.



