![]() |
Re: Do you stand up?
We were in Newfoundland recently, and happened to be there for Memorial Day, the anniversary of the battle of Beaumont-Hamel, 1 July, 1916. That day the Newfoundland regiment was all but wiped out, 90% of the men involved in the attack being killed or wounded.
We attended the ceremonies at the Newfoundland National War Memorial in St. John's and the band played all three National Anthems several times; God Save The Queen, O Canada, and the Ode to Newfoundland. Interesting gradation, empire, confederation and country. I noticed that the local people listened to the first two politely but only sang the Ode to Newfoundland. |
Re: Do you stand up?
Originally Posted by hungryhorace
(Post 10813297)
Absolutely not a hope in hell that I would stand up. If the sheeple want to, that's fine, but i chose to have my own opinions and not subject myself to brain washing of the stars and stripes thanks.
|
Re: Do you stand up?
Originally Posted by Pulaski
(Post 10813415)
But you're on a L visa, so you're a guest here in the US. .... Unfortunately you're a pompous and arrogant one. What an @rse. With that attitude you're going to have a lot of fun settling in and making friends with your colleagues and neighbors! :rolleyes:
|
Re: Do you stand up?
Originally Posted by hungryhorace
(Post 10813433)
If it makes you feel any better, I have the same attitude towards the British flag, though the brain washing levels of patriotism are minuscule compared to here in the US.
|
Re: Do you stand up?
Originally Posted by kimilseung
(Post 10813138)
Not likely to be an educated answer on this from me, as it is a bit of a gut reaction.
To me the anthem at the drop of a hat demonstrates an insecurity, that I find surprising from what is still the only real super-power, but at the heart of it, isn't that what all this nationalism and flag waving is? It reminds me of Zhou Enlais famous words "It is too early to tell" but the question is about the American Revolution, The outcome of the revolution is still being fought, the Brits have been defeated but the true nature of America is unknown as yet, that can explain the Fox viewers fears of everything. 250 years or whatever it is since the Revolution seems like a long time, but in History I guess it is not. The Anthem, the pledge and the flags are part of a state propaganda that tries to instil, as Orwell (from Carl Schurz) put it "My country, right or wrong", That is why I hate it, it is part of the hegemony of the USA, to dampen down opposition to unpopular wars, inequitable social policies, all based upon My country, right or wrong. First they had some military guy in full uniform paraded out so we could whoop it up about kicking some Iraqi ass, then we had the anthem - flags slide out and everyone turned and put the hand on heart deal before singing their hearts out. I stood up - seemed like basic good manners. What I couldn't help but feel, with the glistening eyes, electric atmosphere, strident singing, huge flags and hand on heart pose, was that it reminded me of TV footage of the Nuremburg rallies in mid-30's Nazi Germany. It seemed like a similar ****-yea USA chauvinism and state-driven propaganda |
Re: Do you stand up?
Originally Posted by Pulaski
(Post 10813415)
But you're on a L visa, so you're a guest here in the US. .... Unfortunately you're a pompous and arrogant one. What an @rse. With that attitude you're going to have a lot of fun settling in and making friends with your colleagues and neighbors! :rolleyes:
|
Re: Do you stand up?
Originally Posted by Pulaski
(Post 10813440)
Nope. You're still a pompous @rse. :)
|
Re: Do you stand up?
Originally Posted by Cape Blue
(Post 10813445)
I think I've said before, I went to a hockey game in Chicago and it was an interesting experience.
First they had some military guy in full uniform paraded out so we could whoop it up about kicking some Iraqi ass, |
Re: Do you stand up?
Originally Posted by hungryhorace
(Post 10813314)
Exactly. If others want to stand up, then that's fine - I won't object - but don't expect me to stand also. Your praying analogy really falls down btw.
If someone is praying I remain silent, I don't deliberately stand if they are sitting or kneeling, or move around and talk. |
Re: Do you stand up?
I stand out of politeness. It's utterly meaningless to me so why cause a (possible) scene over it?
|
Re: Do you stand up?
Originally Posted by Trixie_b
(Post 10813454)
What I meant is just because someone is praying, I copy their body language as a mark or respect.
If someone is praying I remain silent, I don't deliberately stand if they are sitting or kneeling, or move around and talk. |
Re: Do you stand up?
Originally Posted by Nutek
(Post 10813456)
I stand out of politeness. It's utterly meaningless to me so why cause a (possible) scene over it?
|
Re: Do you stand up?
:popcorn:
|
Re: Do you stand up?
Originally Posted by civilservant
(Post 10813493)
:popcorn:
|
Re: Do you stand up?
Originally Posted by Nutek
(Post 10813456)
I stand out of politeness. It's utterly meaningless to me so why cause a (possible) scene over it?
You have to be aware of your surroundings too. I recall going to my first football game in the midwest with what would turn out to be my future inlaws. A quick jab in the ribs to stand and a request to remove my hat, nothing to gain in complaining and a lot to lose by being contrary. Now that I am a USC I go as far as putting my hand on my heart but don't sing because to be honest i don't know the words. |
| All times are GMT -12. The time now is 3:00 pm. |
Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.