2016 Election
#4201
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 13,212
From: San Francisco











How many other politicians release all the transcripts of speeches made to private organizations? Usually these kind of things seep into the public domain through someone's surreptitious cell phone recording etc - remember Romney's 47% speech?
#4202
Bloody Yank









Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 4,186
From: USA! USA!











You don't really help your cause with the continued facile comparisons to McGovern. It shows you're either ignorant or disingenuous.
McGovern lost because:
1) His VP pick was nuts. Literally, he had the psych report to prove it.
2) Hubert Humphrey was working to get Nixon elected.
3) The unions turned against McGovern because he supported "the gays".
4) That little matter of Watergate.
Also, I note that you recently said that it didn't matter that Clinton was risking losing the Sanders supporters because of her divisive surrogates. Which is it? Does is matter or not?
McGovern lost because:
1) His VP pick was nuts. Literally, he had the psych report to prove it.
2) Hubert Humphrey was working to get Nixon elected.
3) The unions turned against McGovern because he supported "the gays".
4) That little matter of Watergate.
Also, I note that you recently said that it didn't matter that Clinton was risking losing the Sanders supporters because of her divisive surrogates. Which is it? Does is matter or not?
Those progressives who are nutty enough to stay home instead of voting for the Democratic party nominee obviously don't want a seat at the table, which by its nature must represent a coalition of interests and not just the interests of what may be 10% of the population. Why should anyone who leads the Democratic party bother to listen to those who won't support them?
#4203
McGovern lost because he was too far left to hold together the Democratic coalition or appeal to swing voters.
Those progressives who are nutty enough to stay home instead of voting for the Democratic party nominee obviously don't want a seat at the table, which by its nature must represent a coalition of interests and not just the interests of what may be 10% of the population. Why should anyone who leads the Democratic party bother to listen to those who won't support them?
Those progressives who are nutty enough to stay home instead of voting for the Democratic party nominee obviously don't want a seat at the table, which by its nature must represent a coalition of interests and not just the interests of what may be 10% of the population. Why should anyone who leads the Democratic party bother to listen to those who won't support them?
As for progressives staying at home. It doesn't look like they stayed at home last night does it.
#4204
As you all know, the FBI has assigned 150 agents to investigate Hillary's use of a private email server for State Department business. IF the FBI should recommend an indictment AND the DOJ should decline, it will be fascinating to see whether Comey and anyone else would then resign on principle. [It probably wouldn't hurt Comey (who also served as Deputy Attorney General under W) to resign.] Should a Republican win the Presidency, and Comey had resigned, he would be on the shortest of lists to be named the next Attorney General. We'll see how this drama plays out, potentially the second biggest political story of 2016.
Here's what's wrong with Jeb Bush saying Hillary Clinton is under FBI investigation | PolitiFact
#4207
Bloody Yank









Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 4,186
From: USA! USA!











Again, Bill Clinton lost the 1992 New Hampshire primary and Hillary Clinton won the 2008 New Hampshire primary. New Hampshire sifts out losers, but it doesn't choose winners.
The reasons for McGovern's defeat aren't a mystery. Americans were not ready in 1972 for a president who favored draft dodgers. Democrats had labeled him as a "Goldwater of the Left" prior to the election, and sure enough, Nixon's percentage of the popular vote in 1972 was similar to LBJ's win over Goldwater in 1964.
#4208
You might want to dial that back a bit.
Here's what's wrong with Jeb Bush saying Hillary Clinton is under FBI investigation | PolitiFact
Here's what's wrong with Jeb Bush saying Hillary Clinton is under FBI investigation | PolitiFact
#4209
Also, Romney, McCain, Gore, Kerry, Dukakis, Carter, Bush 41, Nixon, Reagan all won NH, so it's not nothing.
The reasons for McGovern's defeat aren't a mystery. Americans were not ready in 1972 for a president who favored draft dodgers. Democrats had labeled him as a "Goldwater of the Left" prior to the election, and sure enough, Nixon's percentage of the popular vote in 1972 was similar to LBJ's win over Goldwater in 1964.
Again, why is it relevant to 2016?
#4210
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 13,212
From: San Francisco











Bill was able spin second place as a comeback after a poor showing in Iowa, Hillary used her victory to drag the nomination out a lot longer than it would have been if she had lost.
Also, Romney, McCain, Gore, Kerry, Dukakis, Carter, Bush 41, Nixon, Reagan all won NH, so it's not nothing.
Also, Romney, McCain, Gore, Kerry, Dukakis, Carter, Bush 41, Nixon, Reagan all won NH, so it's not nothing.
I agree that it's "not nothing". But I would be wary of attaching that much significance to the result given that Sanders is the senator for the neighbouring state. It's going to be much more interesting to see what kind of support Sanders gets in South Carolina in the light of this victory. Right now Clinton is about 30 points ahead, but that's on dated polls.
#4211
Clinton won the New Hampshire primary in '92.
I agree that it's "not nothing". But I would be wary of attaching that much significance to the result given that Sanders is the senator for the neighbouring state. It's going to be much more interesting to see what kind of support Sanders gets in South Carolina in the light of this victory. Right now Clinton is about 30 points ahead, but that's on dated polls.
I agree that it's "not nothing". But I would be wary of attaching that much significance to the result given that Sanders is the senator for the neighbouring state. It's going to be much more interesting to see what kind of support Sanders gets in South Carolina in the light of this victory. Right now Clinton is about 30 points ahead, but that's on dated polls.
Also, the whole neighbouring state thing is nonsense.
Why Have New Hampshire Democrats Gone Gaga for Bernie Sanders? | Mother Jones
I agree about SC, but there hasn't been any polling since before IA, so we'll have to wait to see if the results in IA and NH move the needle for Sanders now he's getting all this publicity.
#4212
Bloody Yank









Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 4,186
From: USA! USA!











McGovern's excessive tilt to the left as the basis for his 1972 defeat is not exactly a secret -- take a political science class about presidential elections, and this is what you will be taught.
McGovern would have lost even if had a different VP. Like Sanders, he had progressive grassroots support that came at the expense of losing swing voters: he was labeled by Nixon as the candidate of "amnesty (for Vietnam War draft dodgers), abortion, and acid." I can only imagine what the GOP would do with all of Sanders' remarks about how much of a socialist that he is.
McGovern would have lost even if had a different VP. Like Sanders, he had progressive grassroots support that came at the expense of losing swing voters: he was labeled by Nixon as the candidate of "amnesty (for Vietnam War draft dodgers), abortion, and acid." I can only imagine what the GOP would do with all of Sanders' remarks about how much of a socialist that he is.
#4213
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 13,212
From: San Francisco











No he didn't, he came second to Paul Tsongas.
Also, the whole neighbouring state thing is nonsense.
Why Have New Hampshire Democrats Gone Gaga for Bernie Sanders? | Mother Jones
Also, the whole neighbouring state thing is nonsense.
Why Have New Hampshire Democrats Gone Gaga for Bernie Sanders? | Mother Jones
#4215
I stand corrected. But the fact that Tsongas won New Hampshire, came very close to winning Maine (along with his overwhelming home state victory in Massachusetts) lends weight to the point that being from a neighbouring state to New Hampshire certainly has an impact. I wouldn't be so dismissive of that.



