British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Spain (https://britishexpats.com/forum/spain-75/)
-   -   Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit? (https://britishexpats.com/forum/spain-75/will-like-brits-visiting-spain-post-brexit-904470/)

Novocastrian Oct 26th 2017 4:46 am

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

Originally Posted by Pulaski (Post 12368566)
If I can't speak the language before I go, I won't find work, so how do I move to Germany, or anywhere else, and "immerse" my self to pick up the language so I can find work. ..... And what if I don't have the aptitude to learn the language?

There's nothing I can do or say about your lack of aptitude, but I had no difficulty finding a very good job in Germany (this was in 1986). Really, it was more that they found me.

At the time, I had virtually no German language capability, but I managed, and eventually acquired fluency to a level where I gave lectures at Universities in German with no complaints (on either side).

One incident was fun: a very senior "Pope" in my academic field (ask a German what that means) got into an argument with another scientist. The Pope was wrong, but I intervened, speaking in German of course, and convinced him that, while he was wrong, he was right in another way, saving face for him.

He later offered that I take his job when he retired.

Different folks, different strokes.

bobd22 Oct 26th 2017 4:49 am

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

Originally Posted by holly_1948 (Post 12369084)
Well a country can have f ree market access to capital and goods without services or movement of people. Canada does.

The real sticking point is Services. Unfortunately for Britain its goods manufacturing was mostly destroyed (in the 1980s).

Maybe they do but they have negotiated that outside of the EU as not EU members. Is that not what the UK is trying to do on leaving. I think that's what I said in final part of my post.

scrubbedexpat142 Oct 26th 2017 5:05 am

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

Originally Posted by Novocastrian (Post 12369088)
There's nothing I can do or say about your lack of aptitude, but I had no difficulty finding a very good job in Germany (this was in 1986). Really, it was more that they found me.

At the time, I had virtually no German language capability, but I managed, and eventually acquired fluency to a level where I gave lectures at Universities in German with no complaints (on either side).

One incident was fun: a very senior "Pope" in my academic field (ask a German what that means) got into an argument with another scientist. The Pope was wrong, but I intervened, speaking in German of course, and convinced him that, while he was wrong, he was right in another way, saving face for him.

He later offered that I take his job when he retired.

Different folks, different strokes.

I have also managed to work successfully in Europe without prior knowledge of the local language.

Novocastrian Oct 26th 2017 5:21 am

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

Originally Posted by Expatrick (Post 12369099)
I have also managed to work successfully in Europe without prior knowledge of the local language.

Well done. At no time did I suspect that I was unique. Pulaski is an intelligent guy who has missed out on a great amount of life experience by sticking to English language countries. IMHO.

OTA63 Oct 26th 2017 5:23 am

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 
I don't think ones nationality has anything to do with the ability to learn another language. More to do with the individual's intelligence and willingness to learn. Or maybe it's the old British disease of apathy.
Unfortunately there are still too many Brits (and I am generalising) that think why bother "the foreigners can all speak English and if they can't just speak louder"

Red_Wine_Fairy Oct 26th 2017 5:26 am

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

Originally Posted by Pulaski (Post 12368311)
My point was based on the observation that there have been extremely high levels of unemployment in Spain for at least a decade - 25%, and I have seen figures as high a 50% in some age groups in some areas. If "freedom of movement" was all it is cracked up to be, then most of the unemployed would have decamped to Germany or another country in the area, such as the Netherlands, Austria, Switzerland, etc. My post was based on the fact that very few Spaniards have made that move.

Although not representative I'm sure of most companies, my husband works in a company consisting (locally) of around 50% Spaniards. In the Netherlands. In IT. Most are too highly qualified (Masters, PhD) in their own fields (Maths, Physics) for the work they now do, but it's a start into a career that pays decently. There are enough Spaniards in the company where I work for them to have their own social/lunch groups. I think you could be underestimating what we see on the ground here.

Pulaski Oct 26th 2017 5:44 am

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

Originally Posted by Red_Wine_Fairy (Post 12369125)
Although not representative I'm sure of most companies, my husband works in a company consisting (locally) of around 50% Spaniards. ..... I think you could be underestimating what we see on the ground here.

How often do I have to repeat this, my point is about the tens of millions people who stay put, not the hundreds of thousands (in any one country) who move! .... I know as well as all of you who posted in this thread, that large numbers of people move internationally, and I am not disputing that, but the percentage of people who exercise their personal freedom of movement rights is small, very small.

Annetje Oct 26th 2017 6:28 am

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

Originally Posted by Pulaski (Post 12369143)
How often do I have to repeat this, my point is about the tens of millions people who stay put, not the hundreds of thousands (in any one country) who move! .... I know as well as all of you who posted in this thread, that large numbers of people move internationally, and I am not disputing that, but the percentage of people who exercise their personal freedom of movement rights is small, very small.

To be fair, I also know some people who were born in a small village of 200 inhabitants, now 300 ;), have never moved out and will probably be buried there.
They do occasionally go to Holland (Putte :lol:) to buy the good Dutch cheese though. Even them enjoying FOM.
And I remember this village which is half Dutch half Belgian. We often crossed it before FOM and before Benelux and spent at least half an hour (during the week it might be much and much more) for custom checks.....
Trucks were parked all over the place and drivers running around with papers.

Novocastrian Oct 26th 2017 8:39 am

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

Originally Posted by Pulaski (Post 12369143)
How often do I have to repeat this, my point is about the tens of millions people who stay put, not the hundreds of thousands (in any one country) who move! .... I know as well as all of you who posted in this thread, that large numbers of people move internationally, and I am not disputing that, but the percentage of people who exercise their personal freedom of movement rights is small, very small.

Every single citizen in the EU has the right to live and work in any other EU country. This is has no comparison in history.

If most or many didn't exercise that right then either they are happy where they are (I hope so) or are afraid or incapable of exercising that opportunity. One that the <snip> government is trying to take away,

carcajou Oct 26th 2017 10:37 pm

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

Originally Posted by Novocastrian (Post 12369237)
Every single citizen in the EU has the right to live and work in any other EU country. This is has no comparison in history.

If most or many didn't exercise that right then either they are happy where they are (I hope so) or are afraid or incapable of exercising that opportunity. One that the <snip> government is trying to take away,

As Pulaski points out, 99% do not exercise these rights.

Does this make the small number who do, "one percenters?"

Those of you who blast government policy that is advantageous for, and vigourously defends the interests of, "one percenters" - does this criticism also apply to this situation?

If not, why not?

The 99% of the population who are not interested in Free Movement need some other benefit to the European Union, other than that one-percenters who speak German can go live in Frankfurt.

Telling them that they, too, can go live in Frankfurt if only they would get off their duff and learn German, is incredibly tone-deaf.

Right now the entire "stay" campaigns across Europe are based around promoting a benefit to the one-percenters. Oh, and singing the virtues of the Euro, which is more of a millstone than a balloon and has a theoretical framework that has never before been successful, anywhere in the world. Never has there been a successful monetary union that did not also include a fiscal union.

Most of the posters on this thread - except for Pulaski - seem to be having a "let them eat cake" moment.

Annetje Oct 26th 2017 11:00 pm

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

Originally Posted by carcajou (Post 12369496)
As Pulaski points out, 99% do not exercise these rights.

Does this make the small number who do, "one percenters?"

Those of you who blast government policy that is advantageous for, and vigourously defends the interests of, "one percenters" - does this criticism also apply to this situation?

If not, why not?

The 99% of the population who are not interested in Free Movement need some other benefit to the European Union, other than that one-percenters who speak German can go live in Frankfurt.

Telling them that they, too, can go live in Frankfurt if only they would get off their duff and learn German, is incredibly tone-deaf.

Right now the entire "stay" campaigns across Europe are based around promoting a benefit to the one-percenters. Oh, and singing the virtues of the Euro, which is more of a millstone than a balloon and has a theoretical framework that has never before been successful, anywhere in the world. Never has there been a successful monetary union that did not also include a fiscal union.

Most of the posters on this thread - except for Pulaski - seem to be having a "let them eat cake" moment.


Why do you only concentrate on living and working ? FOM includes traveling as well and one has to assume it is more than 1 % who travels around within the EU.
As I mentioned earlier, traveling around was a lot more difficult before the EU (I know, having lived on the border seeing the queues every single day).

BritInParis Oct 26th 2017 11:11 pm

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

Originally Posted by Annetje (Post 12369503)
Why do you only concentrate on living and working ? FOM includes traveling as well and one has to assume it is more than 1 % who travels around within the EU.
As I mentioned earlier, traveling around was a lot more difficult before the EU (I know, having lived on the border seeing the queues every single day).

You are conflating FOM with the Schengen Agreement.

Fredbargate Oct 27th 2017 12:49 am

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

Originally Posted by Annetje (Post 12369503)
Why do you only concentrate on living and working ? FOM includes traveling as well and one has to assume it is more than 1 % who travels around within the EU.
As I mentioned earlier, traveling around was a lot more difficult before the EU (I know, having lived on the border seeing the queues every single day).

I live on a border between two EU countries and I see queues every day

scrubbedexpat142 Oct 27th 2017 12:58 am

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

As Pulaski points out, 99% do not exercise these rights.
Over 15 million, (3 %) living & working in other EU Countries.

Annetje Oct 27th 2017 1:08 am

Re: Will it be like this for Brits visiting Spain post Brexit?
 

Originally Posted by BritInParis (Post 12369508)
You are conflating FOM with the Schengen Agreement.

Oups, yes, sorry


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 8:53 am.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.