Problems in Gibraltar again
#16










Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 12,053
From: In the middle of 10million Olive Trees











This is not like you Fred, I have you down as Steady Eddie.
I cannot get the CFG website to work, nor any other connection
We both know that Member of Parliament is much maligned and abused and to profess to be the Chairman of an organisation that from the (dodgy) web seems to be exceedingly dodgy indeed makes me wonder what use he really is.
Sri to be negative, have visited Gib many times - from the sea side,
As you know I didnt agree with giving back HK, a territory ceeded "in perpetuity" but given back because 200 years ago Lord Palmerston couldnt see the purpose of it.
So with Gib ceeded "in perpetuity" but the giver wanting it back for their own purposes whilst not wanting to give back other territories they have "borrowed" I can see the FCO caving in on this one - eventually.
.
#17
Forum Regular


Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 55
From: Andalucia



Sophia wont be at the ball due to fishermen and other royaltys proposed future visits http://www.thinkspain.com/news-spain...-hots-up-again
#18
Sophia wont be at the ball due to fishermen and other royaltys proposed future visits http://www.thinkspain.com/news-spain...-hots-up-again
#19
Forum Regular


Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 55
From: Andalucia



whoops, sorry missed that one, thanks for the link
#20
To answer all the nonsense I'm reading ...
1) Gibraltar is not an conquest, is an cession that gave Spain to the UK in reference to the Treaty of Utrecht, because of a war which Spain won. Gibraltar has no territorial waters of their own, this is in the Treaty of Utrecht, only the waters of its harbor. Then why they bother to the Spanish fishermen?
2) Comparisons of Gibraltar with Ceuta and Melilla are absurd, because Ceuta and Melilla were Spanish cities long before Morocco existed as a country
3) Gibraltar in Spain, is indifferent. Nobody remembers Gibraltar, except when cases like this, where they cause inconvenience to their spanish neighbors. And possibly, the foreign minister also he is indifferent, but his salary also is claiming Gibraltar. Not previously had problems, but since that this grandson of a republican spanish woman is the mayor of Gibraltar, only is causing discord, with excuses like that Spanish fishermen used fishing gear are prohibited, when are certified by EU, and even recently, they served. Coincidentally, today do not serve
4) The Gibraltarians always are british while they are considered as tax haven. For example, if the UK don't want Gibraltar, and Spain says Gibraltarians: " You will be Spanish and also a tax haven" ...I can then ensure that the Gibraltarians would feel the most Spanish of the world. This is not an issue of nationality, is of economic status
5) The United Kingdom believes very overrated. The UK has lost many battles, many (I know the military history of the UK) and many of these battles are lost against Spain, Cartagena de Indias and Tenerife, to give some examples, where if we had not been magnanimous with Nelson, there would have been Trafalgar. Another thing is that the UK in its history books never said the defeats, only the victories, unlike Spain. A defeat could have been the Falklands War. The help of US and Chile were decisive, also of convincing France to stop supply of missiles and airplanes to Argentina. Otherwise, today we would be talking about something else, but not of a victory
6) It is a great pity that because of this colony, the last colony in Europe (an anachronism in our time, in our continent and our democracies) clouding relations between Spain and the UK
Spain helped to Gibraltar in the early nineteenth century in a case of plague. I hope history does not repeat
1) Gibraltar is not an conquest, is an cession that gave Spain to the UK in reference to the Treaty of Utrecht, because of a war which Spain won. Gibraltar has no territorial waters of their own, this is in the Treaty of Utrecht, only the waters of its harbor. Then why they bother to the Spanish fishermen?
2) Comparisons of Gibraltar with Ceuta and Melilla are absurd, because Ceuta and Melilla were Spanish cities long before Morocco existed as a country
3) Gibraltar in Spain, is indifferent. Nobody remembers Gibraltar, except when cases like this, where they cause inconvenience to their spanish neighbors. And possibly, the foreign minister also he is indifferent, but his salary also is claiming Gibraltar. Not previously had problems, but since that this grandson of a republican spanish woman is the mayor of Gibraltar, only is causing discord, with excuses like that Spanish fishermen used fishing gear are prohibited, when are certified by EU, and even recently, they served. Coincidentally, today do not serve
4) The Gibraltarians always are british while they are considered as tax haven. For example, if the UK don't want Gibraltar, and Spain says Gibraltarians: " You will be Spanish and also a tax haven" ...I can then ensure that the Gibraltarians would feel the most Spanish of the world. This is not an issue of nationality, is of economic status
5) The United Kingdom believes very overrated. The UK has lost many battles, many (I know the military history of the UK) and many of these battles are lost against Spain, Cartagena de Indias and Tenerife, to give some examples, where if we had not been magnanimous with Nelson, there would have been Trafalgar. Another thing is that the UK in its history books never said the defeats, only the victories, unlike Spain. A defeat could have been the Falklands War. The help of US and Chile were decisive, also of convincing France to stop supply of missiles and airplanes to Argentina. Otherwise, today we would be talking about something else, but not of a victory
6) It is a great pity that because of this colony, the last colony in Europe (an anachronism in our time, in our continent and our democracies) clouding relations between Spain and the UK
Spain helped to Gibraltar in the early nineteenth century in a case of plague. I hope history does not repeat
Last edited by Relampago; May 25th 2012 at 7:35 am.
#21
BE Enthusiast





Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 985











Spain already has its own tax haven - it's called Andorra (shhh). Many years ago, our town twinned with a town in Andorra so that the local paletos could go up there once a year on the subsidised bus to handle their bank accounts and property there.
What you gonna do?
What you gonna do?
#22
Straw Man.










Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 46,302
From: That, there, that's not my post count... nothing to see here, move along.











How the hell is that possible? I know you have a very biased, right wing view of Spain but how can Spain have been a country before Morocco? Morocco was the mother nation of the vast majority of Spain, it ruled Spain from Marakesh! Some of you Spaniards have the same warped view of your own history as do the Argentines! It must be a latin thing! Cueta only became Spanish in 1668 the Empire of Morocco began in the 11th century! Nuts, absolutely stark raving nuts.
#23
How the hell is that possible? I know you have a very biased, right wing view of Spain but how can Spain have been a country before Morocco? Morocco was the mother nation of the vast majority of Spain, it ruled Spain from Marakesh! Some of you Spaniards have the same warped view of your own history as do the Argentines! It must be a latin thing! Cueta only became Spanish in 1668 the Empire of Morocco began in the 11th century! Nuts, absolutely stark raving nuts.
The Moors may have controlled a large part of Iberia, but there was no such country as Morocco - an earlier state was later over-run by the Berbers from the 11th century. There were various caliphates (either Berbers or Arabs) that controlled northern Africa as well as bits of Iberia.
Having said that, you could argue that there wasn't really a Spain until the 17th century.
Ceuta and Melilla are in the same boat as the Isle of Wight, the Orkneys, or even northern Ireland - citizens have full rights and vote in the national elections. Do the citizens of Gibraltar vote in UK elections? If not, they are part of a colony, like it or not.
#24
How the hell is that possible? I know you have a very biased, right wing view of Spain but how can Spain have been a country before Morocco? Morocco was the mother nation of the vast majority of Spain, it ruled Spain from Marakesh! Some of you Spaniards have the same warped view of your own history as do the Argentines! It must be a latin thing! Cueta only became Spanish in 1668 the Empire of Morocco began in the 11th century! Nuts, absolutely stark raving nuts.
Last edited by Relampago; May 25th 2012 at 8:16 am.
#25
Someone forgets that if it wasn't for Wellington and a few of his pals Spaniards would be French
#26
Straw Man.










Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 46,302
From: That, there, that's not my post count... nothing to see here, move along.











No you are nuts RM.
The Moors may have controlled a large part of Iberia, but there was no such country as Morocco - an earlier state was later over-run by the Berbers from the 11th century. There were various caliphates (either Berbers or Arabs) that controlled northern Africa as well as bits of Iberia.
Having said that, you could argue that there wasn't really a Spain until the 17th century.
Ceuta and Melilla are in the same boat as the Isle of Wight, the Orkneys, or even northern Ireland - citizens have full rights and vote in the national elections. Do the citizens of Gibraltar vote in UK elections? If not, they are part of a colony, like it or not.
The Moors may have controlled a large part of Iberia, but there was no such country as Morocco - an earlier state was later over-run by the Berbers from the 11th century. There were various caliphates (either Berbers or Arabs) that controlled northern Africa as well as bits of Iberia.
Having said that, you could argue that there wasn't really a Spain until the 17th century.
Ceuta and Melilla are in the same boat as the Isle of Wight, the Orkneys, or even northern Ireland - citizens have full rights and vote in the national elections. Do the citizens of Gibraltar vote in UK elections? If not, they are part of a colony, like it or not.
Oh and of the 14 B.O.T's I believe Gibraltar and the Falklands have FULL British citizenship.... and all that goes with it.
#27
Straw Man.










Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 46,302
From: That, there, that's not my post count... nothing to see here, move along.











Your cheap demagoguery, you take the ass. Spain has never been dominated by Islam, because if so, we would be another Bosnia or another Chechnya. And Morocco, as a country, never existed before that Ceuta or Melilla. So the demagoguery the just. I am not argentine, moron. So you don't compare my country and its people with Argentina, because we are not seemed in nothing, except the language
Even when you say " Hola" you are paying respect to Allah.... how does that feel?
#28
Napoleon always regretted of to invaded Spain. His army in Spain it was already wear and tear when arrived Wellington. He invaded Spain, taking advantage of our army was in America, when then began independence conflicts
Last edited by Relampago; May 25th 2012 at 8:58 am.
#29
This is getting interesting so I am moving it to PDT so you can indulge yourselves!
#30
BE Enthusiast





Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 985











It's true enough - 'The name Gibraltar is the Spanish derivation of the Arabic name Jabal TÄriq (جبل طارق), meaning "mountain of Tariq"' (Wikipedia).
Still and all - it's the right of the people who live there to live there in peace.
My own solution for the conflict - make Spain (unemployment rate 25%) part of Gibraltar (1.8% unemployment) , instead of the other way round.
Call the place Giberia.
Still and all - it's the right of the people who live there to live there in peace.
My own solution for the conflict - make Spain (unemployment rate 25%) part of Gibraltar (1.8% unemployment) , instead of the other way round.
Call the place Giberia.



