No tip with a tip
#82
Re: No tip with a tip
[QUOTE=AishaA;9675143]Well, you're a feisty lot aren't you? I'm still not sure I understand the thinking behind tipping, but I'm more informed about it...
Thanks for the helpful link - the system is very different here from in the UK, but it seems that a person is rewarded for their skills, therefore a student (acquiring skills) is paid slightly more than a bartender (unskilled). I have worked in hotels, restaurants and pubs. Tipping was not unheard of, but generally practised by wealthy people or Americans or a combination of the two. Working in a bar, a customer buying you a drink was more common than leaving a tip.
I don't dispute that tipping is the norm in North America, but I disagree that a belief in fairness and justice is irrelevant.
If it is a widely held belief that people in the service industry are underpaid, then steps should be taken to rectify the situation. Maybe someone should bring it up around election time.
Thanks to everyone for sharing your knowledge and views, please put me straight if I'm wrong but it seems tipping in Canada is about supplementing the wages of the lowest earners, more than an appreciation of exceptional service.
I believe it's more of a thank you, you've done a good job. I remember my Dad working out how much to tip when we went for family meals (I remember Berni Inns), when I was a little girl. He was neither wealthy or American, I think tipping has been done since time begun, whether it's buying the bartender a drink - which they usually take after their shift OR monetary value as especially in the UK it is illegal to be intoxicated and serving alcohol.
Tipping is the norm in the UK too (and in any other country I have visited). I can't believe you worked in the hospitality industry and think that not tipping is acceptable if the meal and service was good.
I don't think you should tip if the service and or food is substandard.
Thanks for the helpful link - the system is very different here from in the UK, but it seems that a person is rewarded for their skills, therefore a student (acquiring skills) is paid slightly more than a bartender (unskilled). I have worked in hotels, restaurants and pubs. Tipping was not unheard of, but generally practised by wealthy people or Americans or a combination of the two. Working in a bar, a customer buying you a drink was more common than leaving a tip.
I don't dispute that tipping is the norm in North America, but I disagree that a belief in fairness and justice is irrelevant.
If it is a widely held belief that people in the service industry are underpaid, then steps should be taken to rectify the situation. Maybe someone should bring it up around election time.
Thanks to everyone for sharing your knowledge and views, please put me straight if I'm wrong but it seems tipping in Canada is about supplementing the wages of the lowest earners, more than an appreciation of exceptional service.
Tipping is the norm in the UK too (and in any other country I have visited). I can't believe you worked in the hospitality industry and think that not tipping is acceptable if the meal and service was good.
I don't think you should tip if the service and or food is substandard.
#83
Re: No tip with a tip
[QUOTE=Piff Poff;9675821]
OOOH Berni Inns!!!
Well, you're a feisty lot aren't you? I'm still not sure I understand the thinking behind tipping, but I'm more informed about it...
I believe it's more of a thank you, you've done a good job. I remember my Dad working out how much to tip when we went for family meals (I remember Berni Inns), when I was a little girl. He was neither wealthy or American, I think tipping has been done since time begun, whether it's buying the bartender a drink - which they usually take after their shift OR monetary value as especially in the UK it is illegal to be intoxicated and serving alcohol.
Tipping is the norm in the UK too (and in any other country I have visited). I can't believe you worked in the hospitality industry and think that not tipping is acceptable if the meal and service was good.
I don't think you should tip if the service and or food is substandard.
I believe it's more of a thank you, you've done a good job. I remember my Dad working out how much to tip when we went for family meals (I remember Berni Inns), when I was a little girl. He was neither wealthy or American, I think tipping has been done since time begun, whether it's buying the bartender a drink - which they usually take after their shift OR monetary value as especially in the UK it is illegal to be intoxicated and serving alcohol.
Tipping is the norm in the UK too (and in any other country I have visited). I can't believe you worked in the hospitality industry and think that not tipping is acceptable if the meal and service was good.
I don't think you should tip if the service and or food is substandard.
#84
Re: No tip with a tip
Do people argue against that? I have no idea, I have never worked in a tip driven environment.
It would be interesting to hear the point of view of bartenders & servers. Are they happy to receive a reduced minimum wage with tips on top? Or would they support a change to receive just a minimum wage, but one which is equal to everyone else.
It would be interesting to hear the point of view of bartenders & servers. Are they happy to receive a reduced minimum wage with tips on top? Or would they support a change to receive just a minimum wage, but one which is equal to everyone else.
#85
Re: No tip with a tip
Being a tight-arsed Brit, I believe people get a tip when they deserve one. If the service was better than average or if, as a customer, you've been hard work, fine, no problem tipping. People get paid for the job they do. If the wages are low, join a union or get another job. Tipping has soooo been taken out of context - it is now a reflection on the customer not the employee.
I disagree. A standard tip for standard service is part of the cost of the meal.
Sure, they could increase the prices and pay the staff more but they don't. By not tipping you are expecting the workers in the restaurant to provide you with good food and and enjoyable experience on minimum wage. I am not comfortable with that.
Sure, they could increase the prices and pay the staff more but they don't. By not tipping you are expecting the workers in the restaurant to provide you with good food and and enjoyable experience on minimum wage. I am not comfortable with that.
Do people argue against that? I have no idea, I have never worked in a tip driven environment.
It would be interesting to hear the point of view of bartenders & servers. Are they happy to receive a reduced minimum wage with tips on top? Or would they support a change to receive just a minimum wage, but one which is equal to everyone else.
It would be interesting to hear the point of view of bartenders & servers. Are they happy to receive a reduced minimum wage with tips on top? Or would they support a change to receive just a minimum wage, but one which is equal to everyone else.
I was very happy to work for crap wages and tips because I was a good waitress and a good bartender. My customers always had attention and I tried hard to always provide a positive experience for them. I see here how truly awful the service is and they don't care. They'll still make the same $20/hr whether you get good service or not. Restaurants and bars are called the "Service Industry". It's a pay for service type job and the better the service, the better the pay.
#86
Account Closed
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 2,404
Re: No tip with a tip
I must admit that the tip potential for a day/nights work makes me a little uncomfortable. If everyone leaves 15%, a server can earn a very tidy wage.
OK, it's shift work, etc etc, but the hourly amount can almost resemble that of an engineer or other tradesperson.
OK, it's shift work, etc etc, but the hourly amount can almost resemble that of an engineer or other tradesperson.
#87
Banned
Joined: Dec 2010
Location: Durham Region Extension
Posts: 3,342
Re: No tip with a tip
Or a nurse doing 15+ hours shift
#88
Re: No tip with a tip
I don't think nurses do 15+ hour shifts anymore and the RN's get paid at least four times minimum wage and then they get shift bonuses and extra pay if they are called in on days/nights off.
Some nights a person waiting on tables can bring in a hefty bonus, these nights are the busy ones and the ones where everything just works right and you get an above average tip off one or two tables, a lot of nights you might clear an extra 30 quid (or less), for working 6-8 hours, without a break - you can't take a break if your customers need you.
Some nights a person waiting on tables can bring in a hefty bonus, these nights are the busy ones and the ones where everything just works right and you get an above average tip off one or two tables, a lot of nights you might clear an extra 30 quid (or less), for working 6-8 hours, without a break - you can't take a break if your customers need you.
#89
Forum Regular
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 89
Re: No tip with a tip
Some nights a person waiting on tables can bring in a hefty bonus, these nights are the busy ones and the ones where everything just works right and you get an above average tip off one or two tables, a lot of nights you might clear an extra 30 quid (or less), for working 6-8 hours, without a break - you can't take a break if your customers need you.
pretty much every restaurant ive come across will give their staff breaks on double shifts for at least half an hour if not an hour. we simply do not have time though and it is not at all possible for us to have a break as the restaurant is pretty much full all day and from 5 o clock there will then be a waiting list for tables.
obvs its illegal but if you want to keep your job...
tbh though i often pick up more double shifts than i already have. and after ive finished working we'll go out drinking till 8am and then start back again at 12. might as well do it, and earn money whilst im still young and can survive it!
#90
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Dec 2008
Location: Ottawa
Posts: 487
Re: No tip with a tip
I have no problem not leaving a tip when I have been on the other end of rude, incompetent waiting staff who think they're doing me a whole big favour.
But I would always stop and tell them why. I firstly start with "do you enjoy your job?" if the answer is "yes" I then go on to say why it looked like they didn't!
If it was "no, I hate my job, and I'm only doing it because of ........." and a decent enough excuse and a conversation is struck up I might change my mind and leave them a cash tip in their hands.
However, if I have a great night out with the girls and the waiting staff have remembered my drink, always kept me topped up, been 1st class in their interaction I am an "extremely" generous tipper. They've actually contributed into the night becoming a success.
My new hairdresser does exactly what I want, we have a good old chin wag and the last tip was half of the cost of the bill because she's great and I really like her. If things change, the tip will.
One thing that really bothers me is the practice of young girls (only the waitresses) half way through an evening out with the girlies (never when I'm with my husband) giving us the bill and asking us to divvy up so they can collect their tip because they've finished for the evening and the next shift are coming in.
They obviously don't want to lose their tips to the next set of waiting staff. Very wrong, the second I caught on to this the tip was down to 10%. I shouldn't have to be getting my credit card out half way through my evening and stopping my conversation because you've finished your shift and want paying. This is of course a management problem which I have taken up with them but would simply never go back. I never go back to a restaurant/pub a second time if they messed up.
But I would always stop and tell them why. I firstly start with "do you enjoy your job?" if the answer is "yes" I then go on to say why it looked like they didn't!
If it was "no, I hate my job, and I'm only doing it because of ........." and a decent enough excuse and a conversation is struck up I might change my mind and leave them a cash tip in their hands.
However, if I have a great night out with the girls and the waiting staff have remembered my drink, always kept me topped up, been 1st class in their interaction I am an "extremely" generous tipper. They've actually contributed into the night becoming a success.
My new hairdresser does exactly what I want, we have a good old chin wag and the last tip was half of the cost of the bill because she's great and I really like her. If things change, the tip will.
One thing that really bothers me is the practice of young girls (only the waitresses) half way through an evening out with the girlies (never when I'm with my husband) giving us the bill and asking us to divvy up so they can collect their tip because they've finished for the evening and the next shift are coming in.
They obviously don't want to lose their tips to the next set of waiting staff. Very wrong, the second I caught on to this the tip was down to 10%. I shouldn't have to be getting my credit card out half way through my evening and stopping my conversation because you've finished your shift and want paying. This is of course a management problem which I have taken up with them but would simply never go back. I never go back to a restaurant/pub a second time if they messed up.