Iced Hockey...
#123
The original quote that sparked this recent debate shows no mention of Ice or Field so one must decide which avenue to pursue.
I merely showed that, in fact, the Brits can play "hockey" and had proven so in the last summer olympics
Can Brits play Ice Hockey? Probably can't play for toffee
I merely showed that, in fact, the Brits can play "hockey" and had proven so in the last summer olympics

Can Brits play Ice Hockey? Probably can't play for toffee
#125










Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 15,883

The original quote that sparked this recent debate shows no mention of Ice or Field so one must decide which avenue to pursue.
I merely showed that, in fact, the Brits can play "hockey" and had proven so in the last summer olympics
Can Brits play Ice Hockey? Probably can't play for toffee
I merely showed that, in fact, the Brits can play "hockey" and had proven so in the last summer olympics

Can Brits play Ice Hockey? Probably can't play for toffee

When a Canadian (Willmore is a cradle) says hockey there is only one hockey and it's played on ice.
#126
Then I refer the honourable gentleman to the 1936 Garmisch winter games

Ok, so many of those brits were dual Canadian citizens or residents at some point, but still, they beat Canada to gold!


Ok, so many of those brits were dual Canadian citizens or residents at some point, but still, they beat Canada to gold!
Last edited by iaink; Feb 24th 2010 at 3:20 am.
#128
For example, writing "i have a smelly boot/fanny" could divert a topic completely down the wrong path without clear definition.

I do agree that given the thread title is "Iced Hockey" you have a point, BUT one should never assume context until it is clearly defined
#129
Surely field hockey is the more popular game, in terms of geographic distribution, number of participants and inclusiveness (iced hockey for women is a novelty act, field hockey is widely commonly by women) and should therefore be assumed when only hockey is mentioned. Knowing that Canadians use "hockey" as shorthand for "iced hockey" is like knowing that residents of the Isle of Man use "billiards" to mean "bar billiards"; it's an interesting piece of trivia but scarcely relevant to the rest of us.
#131










Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 15,883

Then I refer the honourable gentleman to the 1936 Garmisch winter games
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_TwAbZhMGVE...atbritain3.jpg
Ok, so many of those brits were dual Canadian citizens or residents at some point, but still, they beat Canada to gold!

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_TwAbZhMGVE...atbritain3.jpg
Ok, so many of those brits were dual Canadian citizens or residents at some point, but still, they beat Canada to gold!
Oh yeah 74.

Time to move on.
#133










Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 15,883

When people mention Hockey to a British person, i would assume the majority would think immediately of the field variety. On a website dedicated to British people, i feel a more detailed description was warranted to avoid opening doors such as has occurred.
For example, writing "i have a smelly boot/fanny" could divert a topic completely down the wrong path without clear definition.
I do agree that given the thread title is "Iced Hockey" you have a point, BUT one should never assume context until it is clearly defined
For example, writing "i have a smelly boot/fanny" could divert a topic completely down the wrong path without clear definition.

I do agree that given the thread title is "Iced Hockey" you have a point, BUT one should never assume context until it is clearly defined


And you claim Canadians have no sense of humour.
Last edited by Steve_P; Feb 24th 2010 at 3:29 am.






