EU Referendum
#691
I can't imagine that the slight structural shudders in the economy will affect you terribly so what's is your real concern? Is it an identity issue?
#692
There's no fence, metaphorical or real for you, you'll still be able to go on your holidays to Magaluf and Ayia Napa, there just might be some restrictions on bringing back booze and fags again.
I can't imagine that the slight structural shudders in the economy will affect you terribly so what's is your real concern? Is it an identity issue?
I can't imagine that the slight structural shudders in the economy will affect you terribly so what's is your real concern? Is it an identity issue?
#693
It is certainly being framed that way, and hard core Brexit factions (Wesminster, media, etc.) are setting that tone. The man on the street in Barnsley or Harlow is right pissed. Instead, the tone should be that the elite is questioning the will of the electorate. As Bristol said, is that your final answer.
The fact that so many are now questioning the integrity of the high court judges, and even imploring that they be more political, further evidences the widespread ignorance in the electorate.
As Ken Clarke has pointed out, if you asked the electorate whether we should invest in the National Gallery or a theme park, you would probably end up with a theme park.
The referendum was a mistake, the result may have been an error, the impact is enormous, and therefore at very least, the country should be certain it wants to travel down this rocky path.
The fact that so many are now questioning the integrity of the high court judges, and even imploring that they be more political, further evidences the widespread ignorance in the electorate.
As Ken Clarke has pointed out, if you asked the electorate whether we should invest in the National Gallery or a theme park, you would probably end up with a theme park.
The referendum was a mistake, the result may have been an error, the impact is enormous, and therefore at very least, the country should be certain it wants to travel down this rocky path.
#695
1. Young people won't easily be able to live/work in Europe/Britain (including young Shard)
2. UK economy will suffer for a decade plus
3. Britain becomes a nastier place, many Europeans already reporting this, and I feel a sense of indirect shame
4. The existing arrangement, though imperfect, is vastly superior in most ways, and is being undone by a narrow slice of clueless citizens (not all the Brexiteers, but the ignorant ones). That smacks of national incompetence.
5. Identity. Absolutely. Much prefer to be a European than a Brit, let alone a Little Englander.
#696
That's the type of condescending attitude that causing the cultural rift. People like Clarke are simply privileging one view over the other but positing that theirs is somehow correct. This sort of attitude is vile and corrosive. In a democracy, it is rule by the people, by the demos, not by rule by some old flaccid fat white bloke.
#698
You really don't know whether to laugh or be worried.
#699
That's the type of condescending attitude that causing the cultural rift. People like Clarke are simply privileging one view over the other but positing that theirs is somehow correct. This sort of attitude is vile and corrosive. In a democracy, it is rule by the people, by the demos, not by rule by some old flaccid fat white bloke.
In a Parliamentary democracy, it's rule by democratically elected representatives of the people. If the people are fool enough to vote for flaccid fat blokes or similar, then so be it.
I assume you'll be voting for Drumpf?
#700
#702
1. Young people won't easily be able to live/work in Europe/Britain (including young Shard)
2. UK economy will suffer for a decade plus
3. Britain becomes a nastier place, many Europeans already reporting this, and I feel a sense of indirect shame
4. The existing arrangement, though imperfect, is vastly superior in most ways, and is being undone by a narrow slice of clueless citizens (not all the Brexiteers, but the ignorant ones). That smacks of national incompetence.
5. Identity. Absolutely. Much prefer to be a European than a Brit, let alone a Little Englander.
2. UK economy will suffer for a decade plus
3. Britain becomes a nastier place, many Europeans already reporting this, and I feel a sense of indirect shame
4. The existing arrangement, though imperfect, is vastly superior in most ways, and is being undone by a narrow slice of clueless citizens (not all the Brexiteers, but the ignorant ones). That smacks of national incompetence.
5. Identity. Absolutely. Much prefer to be a European than a Brit, let alone a Little Englander.
2. Anybody with a passing interest in economics knows there's absolutely no way to predict the future. We can tell you what happened but but not what's going to happen.
3. A nastier place? You probably need to define this and operationalize this, because I have no idea what you're talking about.
4. A narrow slice? 52% of those who voted with a 72% turn out is hardly a narrow slice.
5. I hypothesize that none of us identify with a single cultural entity. So we value cultural symbols and signs at a local, regional, national and transnational level. Its not, either or. Someone from Orkney may value things that are specific to Orkney, Scotland and Europe. We are all cultural schizophrenics in some way.
Last edited by Oink; Nov 5th 2016 at 12:12 pm.
#703
What I am just saying that upper classes have long their views, practices and interests while denigrating those that are particular to the working class. Parliament chose to consult the people on a very important issue and a majority of people who voted for leaving the European Union, the decision should be respected rather than derided.
#704
Ideally, the 'brow' interest or status of any voter, whether high or low, should not affect the weight associated with any individual vote.
However.. in the USA, I believe some democratically based election strategies have ensured that US presidents have been elected on a monority vote and it's well understood that there is still a reluctance to allow universal suffrage where the coloured or poor voter is concerned.
Some understand these to be too 'low brow' to vote and thereby negate any interests they may have in favour of the 'high brows', a shameful argument in my view.
Last edited by dave_j; Nov 5th 2016 at 1:54 pm.
#705
BE user by choice









Joined: Oct 2010
Posts: 4,854
From: A Briton, married to a Canadian, now in Fredericton.















