Go Back  British Expats > Living & Moving Abroad > Australia > The Barbie
Reload this Page >

Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Wikiposts
View Poll Results: Will you vote for or against the Voice. Poll choice is NOT public
Yes
9
40.91%
No
13
59.09%
Voters: 22. You may not vote on this poll

Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Thread Tools
 
Old Apr 19th 2023 | 10:37 pm
  #16  
BE Forum Addict
 
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 4,393
From: England
brits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Originally Posted by Beoz
I doubt the British media will ever mention it unless there is a No vote. Then they can lick their lips and bring out the headline. "Australia is the most racist country on earth".
I have not heard anything about this in the media but then again I don’t really follow a lot of news channels unless something is important to me. I would hardly think we Brits would think and say that about Australia if anything most people I know here very much like the way Australia “goes about” things. Here in the UK some who think differently from say the Woke, Environmentalists /Greens/migrants/animal rights
etc then your a biggot and racist
 
Old Apr 20th 2023 | 8:20 am
  #17  
BE Forum Addict
 
Joined: Jan 2022
Posts: 2,621
From: Cheshire darling!
Chocolate eclair has a reputation beyond reputeChocolate eclair has a reputation beyond reputeChocolate eclair has a reputation beyond reputeChocolate eclair has a reputation beyond reputeChocolate eclair has a reputation beyond reputeChocolate eclair has a reputation beyond reputeChocolate eclair has a reputation beyond reputeChocolate eclair has a reputation beyond reputeChocolate eclair has a reputation beyond reputeChocolate eclair has a reputation beyond reputeChocolate eclair has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Originally Posted by brits1
just curious … what referendum?
Hadn't heard about it in NZ either, so I was pondering the same question.
 
Old Apr 20th 2023 | 11:22 am
  #18  
Thread Starter
Lost in BE Cyberspace
 
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 14,040
Beoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Originally Posted by Chocolate eclair
Hadn't heard about it in NZ either, so I was pondering the same question.
https://www.niaa.gov.au/indigenous-a...islander-voice

Point 3 in the constitutional amendments is the divider.

 
Old Apr 20th 2023 | 12:19 pm
  #19  
old.sparkles's Avatar
MODERATOR
 
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 31,928
From: Adelaide
old.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Originally Posted by Beoz
https://www.niaa.gov.au/indigenous-a...islander-voice

Point 3 in the constitutional amendments is the divider.
Thanks for the link Beoz.

I think the constitutional change is quite balanced - yes there will be a voice (1), and yes the voice can make representations to parliament (2), but at the end of the day parliament retains control (3)
 
Old Apr 20th 2023 | 2:52 pm
  #20  
Amazulu's Avatar
Proudly Deplorable
 
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 24,249
From: Alloha snack bar
Amazulu has a reputation beyond reputeAmazulu has a reputation beyond reputeAmazulu has a reputation beyond reputeAmazulu has a reputation beyond reputeAmazulu has a reputation beyond reputeAmazulu has a reputation beyond reputeAmazulu has a reputation beyond reputeAmazulu has a reputation beyond reputeAmazulu has a reputation beyond reputeAmazulu has a reputation beyond reputeAmazulu has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Originally Posted by old.sparkles
Thanks for the link Beoz.

I think the constitutional change is quite balanced - yes there will be a voice (1), and yes the voice can make representations to parliament (2), but at the end of the day parliament retains control (3)
It's the bit about executive government that's the sticking point. It was not in the original proposal but was put in at the insistence of the people developing the voice. Because it's so vague, it's open to interpretation - and potentially the courts will have the final say, effectively overriding parliament. Airbus Albanese needs to give much more detail on this but is currently refusing to do so. This really needs to be sorted out because without doing so, it will probably fail.
 
Old Apr 20th 2023 | 7:41 pm
  #21  
BE Forum Addict
 
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 4,393
From: England
brits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond reputebrits1 has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Originally Posted by Amazulu
It's the bit about executive government that's the sticking point. It was not in the original proposal but was put in at the insistence of the people developing the voice. Because it's so vague, it's open to interpretation - and potentially the courts will have the final say, effectively overriding parliament. Airbus Albanese needs to give much more detail on this but is currently refusing to do so. This really needs to be sorted out because without doing so, it will probably fail.
Its only fair and right that the voters know exactly what they are voting for…..if on a “vague” this is how it will work by the PM and it’s a major point then I would be very wary in which way I would vote (not that I would even if I could)
 
Old Apr 20th 2023 | 9:41 pm
  #22  
Thread Starter
Lost in BE Cyberspace
 
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 14,040
Beoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Originally Posted by old.sparkles
Thanks for the link Beoz.

I think the constitutional change is quite balanced - yes there will be a voice (1), and yes the voice can make representations to parliament (2), but at the end of the day parliament retains control (3)
And its supposed to be an advisory body. Do we need a referendum to create an advisory body which advises politicians about decisions effect on indigenous people? Surely an advisory body can be created if needed? There are all sorts of advisory bodies available to politicians that didn't need a referendum. Which then leads to my next question. If it does require a referendum, which binds this advisory into the constitution, how much power will they have over decisions which serve a few over the many?

Last edited by Beoz; Apr 20th 2023 at 9:46 pm.
 
Old Apr 26th 2023 | 10:25 pm
  #23  
Forum Regular
 
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 140
scotty9000 is just really nicescotty9000 is just really nicescotty9000 is just really nicescotty9000 is just really nicescotty9000 is just really nicescotty9000 is just really nicescotty9000 is just really nicescotty9000 is just really nice
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

How will this change to the constitution operate in 10 years time, 100 years time, 1000 years time?
 
Old Apr 26th 2023 | 10:52 pm
  #24  
old.sparkles's Avatar
MODERATOR
 
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 31,928
From: Adelaide
old.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Originally Posted by scotty9000
How will this change to the constitution operate in 10 years time, 100 years time, 1000 years time?
The constitution has changed in the past. Before 1967:
51. The Parliament shall, subject to this Constitution, have power to make laws for the peace, order, and good government of the Commonwealth with respect to:…(xxvi) the people of any race, other than the aboriginal race in any State, for whom it is deemed necessary to make special laws.
127. In reckoning the numbers of people of the Commonwealth, or of a State or other part of the Commonwealth, aboriginal natives shall not be counted.
The change in 1967 removed 'other than the aboriginal race in any state' from point 51 (xxvi), and point 127 was repealed in entirety.

I think the last change was in the 1970's, but Google can probably give you the facts.

I'm going to guess if it was changed before, and maybe changed now, then it can also be changed in the future.
 
Old Apr 28th 2023 | 9:51 pm
  #25  
Charismatic's Avatar
Truth is the safest lie.
 
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 7,307
From: @ the beach.
Charismatic has a reputation beyond reputeCharismatic has a reputation beyond reputeCharismatic has a reputation beyond reputeCharismatic has a reputation beyond reputeCharismatic has a reputation beyond reputeCharismatic has a reputation beyond reputeCharismatic has a reputation beyond reputeCharismatic has a reputation beyond reputeCharismatic has a reputation beyond reputeCharismatic has a reputation beyond reputeCharismatic has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

I'm ineligible. This problem is all yours to deal with.
 
Old May 1st 2023 | 10:26 am
  #26  
BE Enthusiast
 
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 705
abner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Originally Posted by old.sparkles
Thanks for the link Beoz.

I think the constitutional change is quite balanced - yes there will be a voice (1), and yes the voice can make representations to parliament (2), but at the end of the day parliament retains control (3)
Yes, yes, and yes.

And long overdue.

If it passes, it won't create any wrenching, immediate change, for good or ill. It will be more like the Mabo case: ground-breaking, in the sense that Mabo broke the illusion of the 'Terra Nullius' argument, and created a "seat at the table" for Aboriginal stakeholders, based on property rights.

Rather, the Voice will create a different seat at a different table, i.e. one which decides on federal social policy, especially as it applies to ATSI people.

Last edited by abner; May 1st 2023 at 11:23 am.
 
Old May 1st 2023 | 11:24 am
  #27  
BE Enthusiast
 
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 705
abner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond reputeabner has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Yes
 
Old May 1st 2023 | 12:33 pm
  #28  
Thread Starter
Lost in BE Cyberspace
 
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 14,040
Beoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Originally Posted by abner
Yes, yes, and yes.

And long overdue.

If it passes, it won't create any wrenching, immediate change, for good or ill. It will be more like the Mabo case: ground-breaking, in the sense that Mabo broke the illusion of the 'Terra Nullius' argument, and created a "seat at the table" for Aboriginal stakeholders, based on property rights.

Rather, the Voice will create a different seat at a different table, i.e. one which decides on federal social policy, especially as it applies to ATSI people.
Do we not already have federal social policies that apply to ATSI people?
Do we not already have vocal bodies giving advice on social policies that apply to ATSI people?
Should "one" seat at the table decide on the social policies for ALL ATSI people?
How does this one decision, decided by one body affect non ATSI people?
Every decision made by governments affect Australian citizens which includes ATSI people. Can this body have the power to change all government decisions?

I could rattle these questions off for days but some for a starter.
 
Old May 1st 2023 | 8:23 pm
  #29  
old.sparkles's Avatar
MODERATOR
 
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 31,928
From: Adelaide
old.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond reputeold.sparkles has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Originally Posted by Beoz
Do we not already have federal social policies that apply to ATSI people?
Do we not already have vocal bodies giving advice on social policies that apply to ATSI people?
Should "one" seat at the table decide on the social policies for ALL ATSI people?
How does this one decision, decided by one body affect non ATSI people?
Every decision made by governments affect Australian citizens which includes ATSI people. Can this body have the power to change all government decisions?

I could rattle these questions off for days but some for a starter.
As posted above, the current wording of the constitution allows "51. The Parliament shall, subject to this Constitution, have power to make laws for the peace, order, and good government of the Commonwealth with respect to:…(xxvi) the people of any race, for whom it is deemed necessary to make special laws" so the argument could be that creating the voice is already allowed for.

A seat at the table doesn't necessarily mean a single seat.
 
Old May 1st 2023 | 11:36 pm
  #30  
Thread Starter
Lost in BE Cyberspace
 
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 14,040
Beoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond reputeBeoz has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Will I Vote In The Referendum?

Originally Posted by old.sparkles
As posted above, the current wording of the constitution allows "51. The Parliament shall, subject to this Constitution, have power to make laws for the peace, order, and good government of the Commonwealth with respect to:…(xxvi) the people of any race, for whom it is deemed necessary to make special laws" so the argument could be that creating the voice is already allowed for.

A seat at the table doesn't necessarily mean a single seat.
So the Voice virtue signalling if its already allowed for in the constitution? And if its already allowed for then why is it being pushed?
 


Contact Us - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service - Your Privacy Choices

Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.