The Beatles
#121
Banned




Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 294











They are "ok" Them and the Beatles in the same breath is "amusing"
If someone had said Crowded House(Kiwi) I would have understood. I don't claim for a second they are comparable to the Beatles but Neil Finn is a songwriter of some talent and has produced stuff that moves me. My opinion of course..
If someone had said Crowded House(Kiwi) I would have understood. I don't claim for a second they are comparable to the Beatles but Neil Finn is a songwriter of some talent and has produced stuff that moves me. My opinion of course..

Cold Chisel are not great precisely because they've been around for decades and are loved by loads of Aussies but their output doesn't justify that. Three or four good songs at the most, which is not much.
#122
Account Closed










Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 14,188

First decent laugh of the day, thanks 
What day is it? Hold On ... 31st January ... it's a Sunday ... must be extra careful ... hold on, my Sensitive Poppet Year Planner hasn't arrived yet so I'll Google it ...
0314 - St Silvester I begins his reign as Catholic Pope
< snip >
1999 - NFL Pro Bowl

What day is it? Hold On ... 31st January ... it's a Sunday ... must be extra careful ... hold on, my Sensitive Poppet Year Planner hasn't arrived yet so I'll Google it ...
0314 - St Silvester I begins his reign as Catholic Pope
< snip >
1999 - NFL Pro Bowl
#123
Account Closed










Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 14,188

Agree 100%. Neil Finn is one of the best songwriters ever, in my view. Countless brilliant songs.
Cold Chisel are not great precisely because they've been around for decades and are loved by loads of Aussies but their output doesn't justify that. Three or four good songs at the most, which is not much.
Cold Chisel are not great precisely because they've been around for decades and are loved by loads of Aussies but their output doesn't justify that. Three or four good songs at the most, which is not much.

I can remember when I first got here responding to a question about Jimmy Barnes with "who?". Nobody would believe I'd never heard of the bloke.
#124
Banned




Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 294











Most Australian media stuff (films, TV, music) is essentially an irrelevance as far as the rest of the world is concerned.
Note that I said ''most'' not ''all''.
Last edited by mono; Jan 30th 2010 at 11:22 am.
#126
I shall try and find a better one, I'd hate to miss out on a massacre.
#129
I'm going to see Jimmy Barnes at the Bluesfest ... now I'm a citizen it's the law ... some of the Cold Chisel stuff is OK but it's overrated (here) for me.
Another band nobody has heard of outside Oz ... The Angels ... Love 'em, been to 3 gigs and would happily go again. Doc Neeson is getting on a bit now (not helped by injuries sustained in a car accident) but still has something.
Am I Ever Going To See Your Face Again?
Another band nobody has heard of outside Oz ... The Angels ... Love 'em, been to 3 gigs and would happily go again. Doc Neeson is getting on a bit now (not helped by injuries sustained in a car accident) but still has something.
Am I Ever Going To See Your Face Again?
#130
The Angels,Cold Chisel ..... I'd never heard of any of them either before.
Whos the most famous....Macca v's Jimmy Barnes....theres only one way to find out....
FIGHT !!!!
Whos the most famous....Macca v's Jimmy Barnes....theres only one way to find out....
FIGHT !!!!
#131
Account Closed










Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 10,784

I can appreciate that some people may prefer Cold Chisel to The Beatles but a comparison is just ludicrous
#132
You definitely can't compare, it's apples and oranges.
#133
Account Closed










Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 10,784

I don't think Aus should be put down for not producing musical genius to the same level as the UK or USA, their output has been unbelievable.
There is a lot of good music here.
#134
There is lots of Aussie music I enjoy but as far as music goes, the UK has consistently produced talent. It goes beyond population or any other marker. It is just something we have always done well.
I don't think Aus should be put down for not producing musical genius to the same level as the UK or USA, their output has been unbelievable.
There is a lot of good music here.
I don't think Aus should be put down for not producing musical genius to the same level as the UK or USA, their output has been unbelievable.
There is a lot of good music here.
) and without doubt if you do that Aus will fall flat but I agree, there's some good Aussie stuff out there. I do think that with music, along with a number of other things, you simply can't compare, it's too individual and each person can change their preferences on a daily basis, let alone discuss it with others.
#135
Account Closed










Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 10,784

Some people like to compare the UK to Aus on everything (in case you'd not noticed
) and without doubt if you do that Aus will fall flat but I agree, there's some good Aussie stuff out there. I do think that with music, along with a number of other things, you simply can't compare, it's too individual and each person can change their preferences on a daily basis, let alone discuss it with others. 
) and without doubt if you do that Aus will fall flat but I agree, there's some good Aussie stuff out there. I do think that with music, along with a number of other things, you simply can't compare, it's too individual and each person can change their preferences on a daily basis, let alone discuss it with others. 
They just want to knock out good music.



