Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
#76
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
If the restored cathedral is comprised entirely of stone, concrete/ mortar, steel, lead, and glass, with only nominal amounts of wooden furniture and fabric carpets, and curtains (and none of these combustible items are in the roof space), what is going to catch fire? ….. Therefore I would argue that the strength of steel in a fire is entirely moot in this context.
#77
Account Closed
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 0
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
If the restored cathedral is comprised entirely of stone, concrete/ mortar, steel, lead, and glass, with only nominal amounts of wooden furniture and fabric carpets, and curtains (and none of these combustible items are in the roof space), what is going to catch fire? ….. Therefore I would argue that the strength of steel in a fire is entirely moot in this context.
#78
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
FWIW churches and cathedrals have been replacing bell frames for decades that were timber, and had been for centuries, with steel bell frames. Nobody has ever, to my knowledge, argued that that a steel bell frame isn't authentic and has no place in a Norman cathedral or church, concealed high up in the tower, where it is has little visibility, but function (strength and resistance to wood-eating insects) is paramount.
#80
Account Closed
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 0
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
Further discussion has become pointless.
#81
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
It is if you can't be bothered to explain what you mean.
None of stone, concrete/ mortar, steel, lead, and glass can burn on their own (without fuel, such as timber or oil) under anything but rare and peculiar circumstances, such as concrete in an "oxygen fire". So if your building comprises only these materials, what is going to burn?
And if the answer is "nothing", when will steel ever reach 560ºC?
And if the answer to that question is "never", then why is steel losing 50% of its strength at 560ºC relevant?
None of stone, concrete/ mortar, steel, lead, and glass can burn on their own (without fuel, such as timber or oil) under anything but rare and peculiar circumstances, such as concrete in an "oxygen fire". So if your building comprises only these materials, what is going to burn?
And if the answer is "nothing", when will steel ever reach 560ºC?
And if the answer to that question is "never", then why is steel losing 50% of its strength at 560ºC relevant?
#82
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
I'm old school when it comes to materials, Oak worked perfectly well over the centuries and would be my first choice. As a time served shipwright I can say with some authority that I wouldn't touch French Oak with a barge pole, it is good for railway sleepers and that's about it, perhaps it's just the way it grows nowadays but I doubt it, German Oak isn't much better.
I have used Glulam beams a few times here and in the UK, structural engineers like it but just how well does it last over time? I am always wary of modern laminated products because the bottom line always wins out and I'd like to know just what they use as a glue. Epoxy is a modern favourite but it is crap when used with wood in hot and/or wet environments, Cascophen for the win but I know it isn't used in Glulam - awaits response from the pro-epoxy brigade who have never seen epoxy turn to a gooey useless mess when it suffers from repeated heating and cooling and had to sort it out...
Steel is a great medium but does it have the same kind of low maintenance lifespan that oak does?
I think the first question that should be asked is what kind of exterior aesthetics do you want from the roof, closely followed by do you want it to be low maintenance with high initial outset or settle for lower initial build coats but resign yourself to higher maintenance costs?
I have used Glulam beams a few times here and in the UK, structural engineers like it but just how well does it last over time? I am always wary of modern laminated products because the bottom line always wins out and I'd like to know just what they use as a glue. Epoxy is a modern favourite but it is crap when used with wood in hot and/or wet environments, Cascophen for the win but I know it isn't used in Glulam - awaits response from the pro-epoxy brigade who have never seen epoxy turn to a gooey useless mess when it suffers from repeated heating and cooling and had to sort it out...
Steel is a great medium but does it have the same kind of low maintenance lifespan that oak does?
I think the first question that should be asked is what kind of exterior aesthetics do you want from the roof, closely followed by do you want it to be low maintenance with high initial outset or settle for lower initial build coats but resign yourself to higher maintenance costs?
#83
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
I'm old school when it comes to materials, Oak worked perfectly well over the centuries and would be my first choice. As a time served shipwright I can say with some authority that I wouldn't touch French Oak with a barge pole, it is good for railway sleepers and that's about it, perhaps it's just the way it grows nowadays but I doubt it, German Oak isn't much better.
I have used Glulam beams a few times here and in the UK, structural engineers like it but just how well does it last over time? I am always wary of modern laminated products because the bottom line always wins out and I'd like to know just what they use as a glue. Epoxy is a modern favourite but it is crap when used with wood in hot and/or wet environments, Cascophen for the win but I know it isn't used in Glulam - awaits response from the pro-epoxy brigade who have never seen epoxy turn to a gooey useless mess when it suffers from repeated heating and cooling and had to sort it out...
Steel is a great medium but does it have the same kind of low maintenance lifespan that oak does? ....
I have used Glulam beams a few times here and in the UK, structural engineers like it but just how well does it last over time? I am always wary of modern laminated products because the bottom line always wins out and I'd like to know just what they use as a glue. Epoxy is a modern favourite but it is crap when used with wood in hot and/or wet environments, Cascophen for the win but I know it isn't used in Glulam - awaits response from the pro-epoxy brigade who have never seen epoxy turn to a gooey useless mess when it suffers from repeated heating and cooling and had to sort it out...
Steel is a great medium but does it have the same kind of low maintenance lifespan that oak does? ....
However steel frames do go rusty, even if they were painted originally, and scrambling around in the confines of a bell tower with a wire brush, scrubbing off rust, then painting with red oxide primer isn't much fun. In any case many of the surfaces are inaccessible - imagine a climbing frame assembled inside a room where the framend almost touches all four walls and you'll get the picture.
It'll be about 300 years before we'll know if steel frames can last as long as timber frames.
Last edited by Pulaski; Apr 18th 2019 at 1:08 am.
#84
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
If strength and weight are an issue, and judging by the amount of money pouring in and the French government's promise to restore it fully, why not just go with Carbon Fiber beams.
Resistance to combustion should be more than suitable.
" Flammability: Though Carbon Fiber is constituted of carbon which is flammable, the fiber itself dose not flare up even if ignited by flame of match or gas burners. If heated up higher than 400 degree C together with some fuel, the fiber slowly burns (oxidized) but stops burning right after the burning fuel is removed. In this aspect, Carbon Fiber is categorized as "incombustible" under the Building Code of Japan. "
https://www.carbonfiber.gr.jp/englis...al/safety.html
Resistance to combustion should be more than suitable.
" Flammability: Though Carbon Fiber is constituted of carbon which is flammable, the fiber itself dose not flare up even if ignited by flame of match or gas burners. If heated up higher than 400 degree C together with some fuel, the fiber slowly burns (oxidized) but stops burning right after the burning fuel is removed. In this aspect, Carbon Fiber is categorized as "incombustible" under the Building Code of Japan. "
https://www.carbonfiber.gr.jp/englis...al/safety.html
#85
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
If strength and weight are an issue, and judging by the amount of money pouring in and the French government's promise to restore it fully, why not just go with Carbon Fiber beams.
Resistance to combustion should be more than suitable.
" Flammability: Though Carbon Fiber is constituted of carbon which is flammable, the fiber itself dose not flare up even if ignited by flame of match or gas burners. If heated up higher than 400 degree C together with some fuel, the fiber slowly burns (oxidized) but stops burning right after the burning fuel is removed. In this aspect, Carbon Fiber is categorized as "incombustible" under the Building Code of Japan. "
https://www.carbonfiber.gr.jp/englis...al/safety.html
Resistance to combustion should be more than suitable.
" Flammability: Though Carbon Fiber is constituted of carbon which is flammable, the fiber itself dose not flare up even if ignited by flame of match or gas burners. If heated up higher than 400 degree C together with some fuel, the fiber slowly burns (oxidized) but stops burning right after the burning fuel is removed. In this aspect, Carbon Fiber is categorized as "incombustible" under the Building Code of Japan. "
https://www.carbonfiber.gr.jp/englis...al/safety.html
#86
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
Wood borers are not a problem in oak heartwood, unless it is already rotten, it's the sapwood they love.
#87
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
Honestly, I am not certain if the insect damage I saw was in oak or another hardwood. In any case for timber that had been sawn at least 200 years ago, the damage was very modest.
#88
Banned
Joined: Dec 2015
Location: california
Posts: 6,035
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
Hundreds of millions of Euros suddenly appear out of the woodwork to re-build a shrine dedicated to the virgin mother of a man who spent a lot of his life working among the poor. Paris has one of the worst homeless problems in Europe. Irony hardly describes it.
#89
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
The Christian church has always had money or had access to money that it does not redistribute, and its priests and other staff have always lived well and loaded with riches. As an institution it is corrupt and always has been. It could always have put more money into the preservation work so direly necessary for Notre Dame as well, well before the fire. The restoration needs had reached crisis proportions. However, in terms of the preservation of history I am still glad that work will now be done.
#90
Account Closed
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 2
Re: Notre Dame de Paris is Burning
The Christian church has always had money or had access to money that it does not redistribute, and its priests and other staff have always lived well and loaded with riches. As an institution it is corrupt and always has been. It could always have put more money into the preservation work so direly necessary for Notre Dame as well, well before the fire. The restoration needs had reached crisis proportions. However, in terms of the preservation of history I am still glad that work will now be done.
So it is the responsibility of Macron not the Church.