Go Back  British Expats > Living & Moving Abroad > Europe > Spain
Reload this Page >

The Monty Hall problem

The Monty Hall problem

Old Sep 12th 2013, 2:59 pm
  #1  
Banned
Thread Starter
 
Joined: Feb 2011
Location: Mallorca
Posts: 19,367
amideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond repute
Default The Monty Hall problem

Things are not always as they seem.

Imagine a TV game show not unlike Deal or No Deal in which you choose one of three closed doors and win whatever is behind it.

One door conceals a Cadillac - behind the other two doors are goats. The game show host, Monty Hall (of Let's Make a Deal fame), knows where the Cadillac is and opens one of the doors that you did not choose. You are duly greeted by a goat, and then offered the chance to switch your choice to the other remaining door.

Most people will think that with two choices remaining and one Cadillac, the chances are 50-50.

The most eloquent reasoning I could find is from Emerson Kamarose of San Jose, California (from the Chicago Reader's Straight Dope column in 1991): "As any fool can plainly see, when the game-show host opens a door you did not pick and then gives you a chance to change your pick, he is starting a new game. It makes no difference whether you stay or switch, the odds are 50-50."

But the inconvenient truth here is that it's not 50-50 - in fact, switching doubles your chances of winning. Why?
The Monty Hall problem
amideislas is offline  
Old Sep 12th 2013, 3:41 pm
  #2  
FreeThinker
 
jimenato's Avatar
 
Joined: Nov 2009
Location: the moors and levels
Posts: 9,702
jimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

It's easy to see why but somewhat more difficult to explain.

Essentially, if your door conceals a Goat then Monty has shown you exactly which door conceals the Cadillac.

It is twice as likely that your door conceals a goat as a Cadillac - so you should change your choice.
jimenato is offline  
Old Sep 12th 2013, 4:51 pm
  #3  
Banned
Thread Starter
 
Joined: Feb 2011
Location: Mallorca
Posts: 19,367
amideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

Originally Posted by jimenato
It's easy to see why but somewhat more difficult to explain.

Essentially, if your door conceals a Goat then Monty has shown you exactly which door conceals the Cadillac.

It is twice as likely that your door conceals a goat as a Cadillac - so you should change your choice.
Most people never get it at all (most don't care). It took me far longer than you to wrestle with this.

Very good. Impressed!
amideislas is offline  
Old Sep 12th 2013, 5:29 pm
  #4  
FreeThinker
 
jimenato's Avatar
 
Joined: Nov 2009
Location: the moors and levels
Posts: 9,702
jimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

I'm a bit of a nerd.
jimenato is offline  
Old Sep 13th 2013, 12:20 pm
  #5  
Banned
Thread Starter
 
Joined: Feb 2011
Location: Mallorca
Posts: 19,367
amideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond reputeamideislas has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

Well here it is:

amideislas is offline  
Old Sep 13th 2013, 6:14 pm
  #6  
VFR
BE Forum Addict
 
Joined: Jun 2009
Location: Valencia area
Posts: 1,154
VFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

Originally Posted by jimenato
It's easy to see why but somewhat more difficult to explain.

Essentially, if your door conceals a Goat then Monty has shown you exactly which door conceals the Cadillac.

It is twice as likely that your door conceals a goat as a Cadillac - so you should change your choice.
How has he shown which door conceals the caddy ?, as all he has done is show that the door he opened contained a goat.
VFR is offline  
Old Sep 13th 2013, 7:36 pm
  #7  
BE Forum Addict
 
Joined: Mar 2011
Posts: 1,518
stuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

Originally Posted by jimenato
It's easy to see why but somewhat more difficult to explain.

Essentially, if your door conceals a Goat then Monty has shown you exactly which door conceals the Cadillac.

It is twice as likely that your door conceals a goat as a Cadillac - so you should change your choice.
Well done mate, I actually understood you explanation better and quicker than the one in the link.
stuboy is offline  
Old Sep 13th 2013, 7:40 pm
  #8  
BE Forum Addict
 
Joined: Mar 2011
Posts: 1,518
stuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond reputestuboy has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

Originally Posted by playamonte
How has he shown which door conceals the caddy ?, as all he has done is show that the door he opened contained a goat.
He hasn't shown you which door conceals the caddy, He is only increased the probability of the caddy being in the box you didn't chose.
stuboy is offline  
Old Sep 13th 2013, 8:11 pm
  #9  
On the road again.
 
Dick Dasterdly's Avatar
 
Joined: Aug 2008
Location: On Top of the World
Posts: 17,507
Dick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

Originally Posted by stuboy
He hasn't shown you which door conceals the caddy, He is only increased the probability of the caddy being in the box you didn't chose.
Surely by identifying an empty box he also increased the chances of the Caddy being in the chosen box.
Dick Dasterdly is offline  
Old Sep 13th 2013, 9:12 pm
  #10  
VFR
BE Forum Addict
 
Joined: Jun 2009
Location: Valencia area
Posts: 1,154
VFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond reputeVFR has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

Originally Posted by stuboy
He hasn't shown you which door conceals the caddy, He is only increased the probability of the caddy being in the box you didn't chose.
Yes that I can understand, but I still do not understand why it pays to switch ?
VFR is offline  
Old Sep 13th 2013, 9:52 pm
  #11  
On the road again.
 
Dick Dasterdly's Avatar
 
Joined: Aug 2008
Location: On Top of the World
Posts: 17,507
Dick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

Originally Posted by playamonte
Yes that I can understand, but I still do not understand why it pays to switch ?
Still looks an even bet to me and I've yet to see anything to convince me otherwise, there again maybe I'm starting to lose the plot a little.

To think I used to be a Maths whizz kid at one time,....but now...
Dick Dasterdly is offline  
Old Sep 14th 2013, 5:54 am
  #12  
BE Positive
 
Jon-Bxl's Avatar
 
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 3,980
Jon-Bxl has a reputation beyond reputeJon-Bxl has a reputation beyond reputeJon-Bxl has a reputation beyond reputeJon-Bxl has a reputation beyond reputeJon-Bxl has a reputation beyond reputeJon-Bxl has a reputation beyond reputeJon-Bxl has a reputation beyond reputeJon-Bxl has a reputation beyond reputeJon-Bxl has a reputation beyond reputeJon-Bxl has a reputation beyond reputeJon-Bxl has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

Originally Posted by Dick Dasterdly
Still looks an even bet to me and I've yet to see anything to convince me otherwise, there again maybe I'm starting to lose the plot a little.

To think I used to be a Maths whizz kid at one time,....but now...
I thought I was pretty good at maths too, and take comfort that de Sautoy said that this caused a lot of consternation in the maths intelligencia community.

This is one of the best puzzles I've seen, got me head scratching for a good while THANKS Ami for the OP. i couldnt get my head around the previous explanations sadly for me, proving I am not a whizz!

Fantastic !

Here' how I figured it (finally).. Having had to split out the 2 goat option:

Choice. ...... Odds. .....Change. .....Dont change

Car............... 1/3 ............. Lose. .............. Win
Goat. ............ 1/3. ............. Win. ............. Lose
Goat. ............ 1/3. ............. Win. ............. Lose

Total. ......... 100%. ........ 2 wins. .............1 win

Its absolutely amazing that you can double, yes double your chances to win just by changing... Its so counter intuitive.... An amazing puzzle. I should have done the break down straight away rather than scratch a groove in my head

Made my day thanks again

Jon

Last edited by Jon-Bxl; Sep 14th 2013 at 6:02 am.
Jon-Bxl is offline  
Old Sep 14th 2013, 7:53 am
  #13  
FreeThinker
 
jimenato's Avatar
 
Joined: Nov 2009
Location: the moors and levels
Posts: 9,702
jimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond reputejimenato has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

The thing to remember is that your original choice is twice as likely to be a goat than a car and this fact does not change throughout the game.

When the other goat has been eliminated, you are left with a choice of two, your original choice and one other.

Remembering that your original choice is still twice as likely to be a goat than a car then it follows that the only other possible choice is twice as likely to be a car than a goat.
jimenato is offline  
Old Sep 14th 2013, 8:19 am
  #14  
On the road again.
 
Dick Dasterdly's Avatar
 
Joined: Aug 2008
Location: On Top of the World
Posts: 17,507
Dick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond reputeDick Dasterdly has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

Still not convinced myself.

I keep comparing it to the old coin puzzle where a coin is tossed ten times and comes down as heads the first nine times.
That doesn't alter the fact that it's still an even money 50/50 bet on the last throw, or at least that's what I've always been given to understand.
Dick Dasterdly is offline  
Old Sep 14th 2013, 8:24 am
  #15  
Joined on April fools day
 
Beaverstate's Avatar
 
Joined: Apr 2012
Location: 30 miles from a decent grocery store.
Posts: 10,642
Beaverstate has a reputation beyond reputeBeaverstate has a reputation beyond reputeBeaverstate has a reputation beyond reputeBeaverstate has a reputation beyond reputeBeaverstate has a reputation beyond reputeBeaverstate has a reputation beyond reputeBeaverstate has a reputation beyond reputeBeaverstate has a reputation beyond reputeBeaverstate has a reputation beyond reputeBeaverstate has a reputation beyond reputeBeaverstate has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: The Monty Hall problem

I call shenanigans.. 1 in 3 chance change or not.
Beaverstate is offline  

Contact Us - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service -

Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.