Can Spain convince Brussels
#46
BE Forum Addict






Joined: Mar 2019
Posts: 1,010











#48
BE Forum Addict






Joined: Jan 2017
Posts: 1,171
From: Dubai UK Spain











Last edited by UKMS; Dec 16th 2023 at 6:03 am.
#49
BE Forum Addict






Joined: Jan 2017
Posts: 1,171
From: Dubai UK Spain











Thats as may be, but the EU is now actively attempting to get its member countries to remove the Golden Visa as it is a way of 'buying' residency that is not fair.
This article has more details
https://www.euronews.com/travel/2023...em-up-for-good
For my 2c I think its a good thing to end it. The rich already have far more privileges than they deserve, why should just throwing cash around allow you move wherever you want?
This article has more details
https://www.euronews.com/travel/2023...em-up-for-good
For my 2c I think its a good thing to end it. The rich already have far more privileges than they deserve, why should just throwing cash around allow you move wherever you want?
#52
[...]
I wouldn't get too excited about this. It would appear to be the workings of a British pressure group who have managed to cobble together some support in the French senate but the real difficulty they face is getting it through the far more powerful national assembly that is heavily influenced by the president of the day.[...]
I wouldn't get too excited about this. It would appear to be the workings of a British pressure group who have managed to cobble together some support in the French senate but the real difficulty they face is getting it through the far more powerful national assembly that is heavily influenced by the president of the day.[...]
The Senate and National Assembly in Paris have voted to ease the impact of Brexit on British second-home owners after pressure from French politicians who have large numbers of UK-owned properties in their constituencies.
The plan is automatically to grant long-stay visas to British property owners. This would allow them to spend as much of the year as they wish in France – and not count towards the 90-day limit in the rest of the Schengen Area.
The plan is automatically to grant long-stay visas to British property owners. This would allow them to spend as much of the year as they wish in France – and not count towards the 90-day limit in the rest of the Schengen Area.
growinspain had better brief his lawyers, too. It's specifically UK citizens and not all non-EU citizens who will benefit from this concession.
#53
BE Forum Addict






Joined: Mar 2019
Posts: 1,010











The real difficulty appears to have been overcome :
Brexit pain could be eased for Brits with homes in France under new law
growinspain had better brief his lawyers, too. It's specifically UK citizens and not all non-EU citizens who will benefit from this concession.
Brexit pain could be eased for Brits with homes in France under new law
growinspain had better brief his lawyers, too. It's specifically UK citizens and not all non-EU citizens who will benefit from this concession.
The Times (paywall) has a more pessimistic view ie it could be overturned by the high court and could be watered down considerably.
If this is some kind of Brexit win, God help them!
#54
BE Forum Addict






Joined: Jan 2017
Posts: 1,171
From: Dubai UK Spain











I still wouldn't get too excited and I doubt this is the Brexit benefit you have been looking for.
The Times (paywall) has a more pessimistic view ie it could be overturned by the high court and could be watered down considerably.
If this is some kind of Brexit win, God help them!
The Times (paywall) has a more pessimistic view ie it could be overturned by the high court and could be watered down considerably.
If this is some kind of Brexit win, God help them!
#55
You must have me confused with somebody else. Looking for Brexit benefits would be a fools errand, and as the best pro-Brexit brains in the land have already scoured for anything that could possibly be described as a benefit and drawn a complet blank, I'd hardly be likely to do any better.
The Times (paywall) has a more pessimistic view ie it could be overturned by the high court and could be watered down considerably.
Reports I've read seem to coalesce around the process not being complete, firstly the entire law requiring scrutiny by the Constitutional Council to ensure it doesn't breach the Constitution in any way (can't see why it would if the MPs know their job), and secondly this part of it requiring a decree to determine exact conditions and application.
Ah, well - that's a little different to "It's never going to happen" on this one, anyway.
The supposed Spanish lobbying seems to have been a bit of a fantasy, though.
#56
BE Forum Addict






Joined: Mar 2019
Posts: 1,010











I still don't think it's going to happen in the way the Independent thinks it will which is littered with a very heavy dose of wishful thinking. I very much doubt the EU will allow a member state to devise a visa that completely bypasses freedom of movement and offers equal benefits to a third country. There is still a very long way to go on this and it could be chucked out or seriously watered down.
I think it's all terribly sad really when you consider a few desperate people are thrown a few crumbs by the French state that are a mere shadow of the enormous benefits they enjoyed pre Brexit and it's being championed as some kind of win.
I think it's all terribly sad really when you consider a few desperate people are thrown a few crumbs by the French state that are a mere shadow of the enormous benefits they enjoyed pre Brexit and it's being championed as some kind of win.
#57
BE Forum Addict








Joined: May 2023
Posts: 3,310











I still don't think it's going to happen in the way the Independent thinks it will which is littered with a very heavy dose of wishful thinking. I very much doubt the EU will allow a member state to devise a visa that completely bypasses freedom of movement and offers equal benefits to a third country. There is still a very long way to go on this and it could be chucked out or seriously watered down.
I think it's all terribly sad really when you consider a few desperate people are thrown a few crumbs by the French state that are a mere shadow of the enormous benefits they enjoyed pre Brexit and it's being championed as some kind of win.
I think it's all terribly sad really when you consider a few desperate people are thrown a few crumbs by the French state that are a mere shadow of the enormous benefits they enjoyed pre Brexit and it's being championed as some kind of win.
The idea, whatever it's motivation, makes a mockery of the present system. While one can sympathise with home owners whose use is now restricted (assuming they did (were able) to vote remain) the fact is that the UK voted for Brexit and as somebody said "Brexit is Brexit" and the UK population has to accept it.
#58
BE Forum Addict






Joined: Mar 2019
Posts: 1,010











Agreed, however (posted by me elsewhere) -
The idea, whatever it's motivation, makes a mockery of the present system. While one can sympathise with home owners whose use is now restricted (assuming they did (were able) to vote remain) the fact is that the UK voted for Brexit and as somebody said "Brexit is Brexit" and the UK population has to accept it.
The idea, whatever it's motivation, makes a mockery of the present system. While one can sympathise with home owners whose use is now restricted (assuming they did (were able) to vote remain) the fact is that the UK voted for Brexit and as somebody said "Brexit is Brexit" and the UK population has to accept it.
​​​​​​As an aside although relevant, many of these people were residing in France full time prior to Brexit (not strictly legit of course) so six months in one go is not much use to them, they need good old EU freedom of movement.
Good luck with thrashing out the finer details of this scheme, it sounds like a logistical nightmare!
#59
BE Forum Addict








Joined: May 2023
Posts: 3,310











I remember clearly, before Brexit actually became a fact, the exhortations of the British Ambassador and the Hungarian Minister of State who kept repeating - if your not registered, GET registered - NOW!
Last edited by Finknottle; Dec 21st 2023 at 6:11 am.
#60
BE Forum Addict






Joined: Mar 2019
Posts: 1,010











Bit confused here now Lou, the above you now mention, residing full time, should not have had a problem - makes a mockery of those of us who were (are) fully legitimate.
I remember clearly, before Brexit actually became a fact, the exhortations of the British Ambassador and the Hungarian Minister of State who kept repeating - if your not registered, GET registered - NOW!
I remember clearly, before Brexit actually became a fact, the exhortations of the British Ambassador and the Hungarian Minister of State who kept repeating - if your not registered, GET registered - NOW!
Back in the day, I came across people pre Brexit who more or less lived full time in France but were not actually resident ie registered and paying tax there. These are the people I was referring to who will not benefit from this new visa if it ever happens because they will not be able to go back to what they were doing pre Brexit. It's not legit obviously but it is what they were doing.
​​​
I remember Lawson tried to obtain residency in France post Brexit but refused to pay tax there so they gave him the bum's rush!






