Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
#871
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 41,518
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
Here's the definition. I only scanned it briefly but it looks like they divide your savings by the number of years until you have to make an application for indefinite leave to remain. Then you have to make a fresh application and meet the requirements anew:
http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/si...df?view=Binary
"An amount based on the cash savings above £16,000 held by the applicant.s partner, the applicant or both jointly for at least the 6 months prior to the date of application and under their control. At the entry clearance/initial leave to remain stage and the further leave stage, the amount above £16,000 must be divided by 2.5 (to reflect the 2.5 year or 30-month period before the applicant will have to make a further application) to give the amount which can be added to income. At the indefinite leave to remain stage, the whole of the amount above £16,000 can be added to income"
http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/si...df?view=Binary
"An amount based on the cash savings above £16,000 held by the applicant.s partner, the applicant or both jointly for at least the 6 months prior to the date of application and under their control. At the entry clearance/initial leave to remain stage and the further leave stage, the amount above £16,000 must be divided by 2.5 (to reflect the 2.5 year or 30-month period before the applicant will have to make a further application) to give the amount which can be added to income. At the indefinite leave to remain stage, the whole of the amount above £16,000 can be added to income"
#872
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2006
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 12,865
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
One thing I didn't realize is that you have to go through the process again after 2.5 years. That means that people whose economic position has deteriorated in that period (unemployment, for example) are in deep shit. It's truly a horrible system.
#873
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 41,518
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
It's one of those knee-jerk popularist reactions to the concept of getting benefits down.
#874
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 3,396
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
#875
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 3,396
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
With 2,490,000 people unemployed - and the added issue of serious underemployment - it is going to take a very long time for this employment situation to get anywhere close to good.
Unemployment isn't expected to get below 7% for 2-3 years by the MPC of the Bank of England. We've got to remember that unemployment in the UK got up to the current level 4½ years ago. This means the UK could be just half way through a decade-long period of high unemployment - presuming things go the way they currently are, and no major shocks happen to the economy.
I really don't think this is such an achievement as you think it is.
#876
Banned
Joined: Jan 2011
Location: The REAL Utopia.
Posts: 9,910
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
It seems to me Pug that you are simply voicing an opinion. And a pretty narrow one at that.
I would be interested in seeing the statistics to which you refer. The indices of deprivation to which you refer are relative indices, so would not seem to support your conclusion, in fact, logically, would do the opposite.
There are a couple of points I would make. Firstly, most people on this thread are looking to return to the UK and are interested in the economics of how they survive in the UK. The number in work in the UK is rising, and has done so for several years now. Therefore they are more likely to get a job. (73.6 percent of the population is economically active in the UK. In the USA, for example, the equivalent measure is 63.1 percent.)
Pay levels - Broadly, job losses have mainly been in the public sector, (about 400 thousand) and job creation in the private (about 1Million). As the public sector is paid more than the private sector, average pay will necessarily decline – which it has. However, the Government has reduced substantially the tax levied in the lower paid, as a result of which , real take home pay has fallen in just the one year since the Coalition took office.
Real take home pay in the UK remains the third highest in the developed world according to the latest OECD survey, far ahead of the USA, Australia or even Germany.
Perhaps the thread ought to be renamed "Is the situation in the UK really that good".
I would be interested in seeing the statistics to which you refer. The indices of deprivation to which you refer are relative indices, so would not seem to support your conclusion, in fact, logically, would do the opposite.
There are a couple of points I would make. Firstly, most people on this thread are looking to return to the UK and are interested in the economics of how they survive in the UK. The number in work in the UK is rising, and has done so for several years now. Therefore they are more likely to get a job. (73.6 percent of the population is economically active in the UK. In the USA, for example, the equivalent measure is 63.1 percent.)
Pay levels - Broadly, job losses have mainly been in the public sector, (about 400 thousand) and job creation in the private (about 1Million). As the public sector is paid more than the private sector, average pay will necessarily decline – which it has. However, the Government has reduced substantially the tax levied in the lower paid, as a result of which , real take home pay has fallen in just the one year since the Coalition took office.
Real take home pay in the UK remains the third highest in the developed world according to the latest OECD survey, far ahead of the USA, Australia or even Germany.
Perhaps the thread ought to be renamed "Is the situation in the UK really that good".
#877
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 3,396
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
Austria 4.8%
Germany 5.3%
Luxembourg 5.7%
Malta 6%
Netherlands 7%
Outside of the Eurozone, but still in the EU we have:
Denmark 6.7%
Czech Republic 6.8%
Romania 7.5%
Outside of the EU, but still in the EEA we also have:
Iceland 5.5%
The 7.7% in the UK is not good by itself, it's also not good when looking at quite a few other nearby countries.
(figures taken from eurostat)
#878
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 41,518
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
Meaning UK has unemployment above a number of countries in the Eurozone. Let's see what some of these unemployment rates are:
Austria 4.8%
Germany 5.3%
Luxembourg 5.7%
Malta 6%
Netherlands 7%
Outside of the Eurozone, but still in the EU we have:
Denmark 6.7%
Czech Republic 6.8%
Romania 7.5%
Outside of the EU, but still in the EEA we also have:
Iceland 5.5%
The 7.7% in the UK is not good by itself, it's also not good when looking at quite a few other nearby countries.
(figures taken from eurostat)
Austria 4.8%
Germany 5.3%
Luxembourg 5.7%
Malta 6%
Netherlands 7%
Outside of the Eurozone, but still in the EU we have:
Denmark 6.7%
Czech Republic 6.8%
Romania 7.5%
Outside of the EU, but still in the EEA we also have:
Iceland 5.5%
The 7.7% in the UK is not good by itself, it's also not good when looking at quite a few other nearby countries.
(figures taken from eurostat)
I wouldn't organize my life on the basis of looking at the above figures and thinking, "Oh, Iceland or Malta are going to be the best places to live."
A certain kind of person just has to get the boot into the UK at little or no provocation, I don't understand it all all, we as a nation have always been a bit like that but it's got massively worse in my lifetime.
#879
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
Meaning UK has unemployment above a number of countries in the Eurozone. Let's see what some of these unemployment rates are:
Austria 4.8%
Germany 5.3%
Luxembourg 5.7%
Malta 6%
Netherlands 7%
Outside of the Eurozone, but still in the EU we have:
Denmark 6.7%
Czech Republic 6.8%
Romania 7.5%
Outside of the EU, but still in the EEA we also have:
Iceland 5.5%
The 7.7% in the UK is not good by itself, it's also not good when looking at quite a few other nearby countries.
(figures taken from eurostat)
Austria 4.8%
Germany 5.3%
Luxembourg 5.7%
Malta 6%
Netherlands 7%
Outside of the Eurozone, but still in the EU we have:
Denmark 6.7%
Czech Republic 6.8%
Romania 7.5%
Outside of the EU, but still in the EEA we also have:
Iceland 5.5%
The 7.7% in the UK is not good by itself, it's also not good when looking at quite a few other nearby countries.
(figures taken from eurostat)
Austria unemployment rate August '13 - 6.9%.
Germany 5.3% (as you say).
Luxembourg 7%
Malta 6.1%
Netherlands 8.6%
Denmark 4.4%
Czech Republic 7.5%
Romania 7.5% (as your figure)
Iceland 4.7%
Frankly, the smaller countries in the above list, such as Malta and Luxembourg, are hardly relevant. The UK government is not likely to learn anything by taking tips from Luxembourg or Iceland.
I was sceptical about the Coalition's economic policy, but actually I don't think they've done too badly. Apart from the question of debt, there are massive imbalances in the UK economy, yet as well as the modest economic growth, there has been some rebalancing with a growth in manufacturing jobs.
What has astonished me, however, that is that under 'Lord Snooty' Osborne, Britain has become more equal with the top losing real income and the bottom gaining some.
Under Labour, Britain became a more unequal society. So, I think it is a case of: Don't believe what they say, look at what they do.
#880
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
Meaning UK has unemployment above a number of countries in the Eurozone. Let's see what some of these unemployment rates are:
Austria 4.8%
Germany 5.3%
Luxembourg 5.7%
Malta 6%
Netherlands 7%
Outside of the Eurozone, but still in the EU we have:
Denmark 6.7%
Czech Republic 6.8%
Romania 7.5%
Outside of the EU, but still in the EEA we also have:
Iceland 5.5%
The 7.7% in the UK is not good by itself, it's also not good when looking at quite a few other nearby countries.
(figures taken from eurostat)
Austria 4.8%
Germany 5.3%
Luxembourg 5.7%
Malta 6%
Netherlands 7%
Outside of the Eurozone, but still in the EU we have:
Denmark 6.7%
Czech Republic 6.8%
Romania 7.5%
Outside of the EU, but still in the EEA we also have:
Iceland 5.5%
The 7.7% in the UK is not good by itself, it's also not good when looking at quite a few other nearby countries.
(figures taken from eurostat)
Austria unemployment rate August '13 - 6.9%.
Germany 5.3% (as you say).
Luxembourg 7%
Malta 6.1%
Netherlands 8.6%
Denmark 4.4%
Czech Republic 7.5%
Romania 7.5% (as your figure)
Iceland 4.7%
Frankly, the smaller countries in the above list, such as Malta and Luxembourg, are hardly relevant. The UK government is not likely to learn anything by taking tips from Luxembourg or Iceland.
I was sceptical about the Coalition's economic policy, but actually I don't think they've done too badly. Apart from the question of debt, there are massive imbalances in the UK economy, yet as well as the modest economic growth, there has been some rebalancing with a growth in manufacturing jobs.
What has astonished me, however, that is that under 'Lord Snooty' Osborne, Britain has become more equal with the top losing real income and the bottom gaining some.
Under Labour, Britain became a more unequal society. So, I think it is a case of: Don't believe what they say, look at what they do.
#881
Heading for Poppyland
Joined: Jul 2007
Location: North Norfolk and northern New York State
Posts: 14,546
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
I have completely lost track of what you're trying to prove.
I wouldn't organize my life on the basis of looking at the above figures and thinking, "Oh, Iceland or Malta are going to be the best places to live."
A certain kind of person just has to get the boot into the UK at little or no provocation, I don't understand it all all, we as a nation have always been a bit like that but it's got massively worse in my lifetime.
I wouldn't organize my life on the basis of looking at the above figures and thinking, "Oh, Iceland or Malta are going to be the best places to live."
A certain kind of person just has to get the boot into the UK at little or no provocation, I don't understand it all all, we as a nation have always been a bit like that but it's got massively worse in my lifetime.
Me, I would like to move back to England and the issues I need to overcome to achieve this have little to do with macroeconomic facts or fictions.
#882
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 41,518
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
I believe he's in an obscure, kabuki theatre feud with another member who is posting in this thread but I have no idea what the underlying issue is.
Me, I would like to move back to England and the issues I need to overcome to achieve this have little to do with macroeconomic facts or fictions.
Me, I would like to move back to England and the issues I need to overcome to achieve this have little to do with macroeconomic facts or fictions.
May all your dreams come true.
#883
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
Well obviously I've butted into a private conversation then. My apologies, and for the weird bug that is posting everything from me twice.
I had not noticed that the unemployment figures Roaringmouse quotes are attributed by him to Eurostat, and asked him if they were Wikipedia. I've checked the Eurostat figures, which only go up to the end of 2012, and they don't correspond to his figures either.
I had not noticed that the unemployment figures Roaringmouse quotes are attributed by him to Eurostat, and asked him if they were Wikipedia. I've checked the Eurostat figures, which only go up to the end of 2012, and they don't correspond to his figures either.
#884
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
Well obviously I've butted into a private conversation then. My apologies, and for the weird bug that is posting everything from me twice.
I had not noticed that the unemployment figures Roaringmouse quotes are attributed by him to Eurostat, and asked him if they were Wikipedia. I've checked the Eurostat figures, which only go up to the end of 2012, and they don't correspond to his figures either.
I had not noticed that the unemployment figures Roaringmouse quotes are attributed by him to Eurostat, and asked him if they were Wikipedia. I've checked the Eurostat figures, which only go up to the end of 2012, and they don't correspond to his figures either.
#885
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 41,518
Re: Is the situation in the UK really that bad?
Well obviously I've butted into a private conversation then. My apologies, and for the weird bug that is posting everything from me twice.
I had not noticed that the unemployment figures Roaringmouse quotes are attributed by him to Eurostat, and asked him if they were Wikipedia. I've checked the Eurostat figures, which only go up to the end of 2012, and they don't correspond to his figures either.
I had not noticed that the unemployment figures Roaringmouse quotes are attributed by him to Eurostat, and asked him if they were Wikipedia. I've checked the Eurostat figures, which only go up to the end of 2012, and they don't correspond to his figures either.