real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
#736
Account Closed
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 0
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
I'd say it's the same eveywhere and while doctors and dentists seem to be the kind of people who nominally have "good jobs' for the older generation, it's very different today. People working in the so called service industry can make a fortune and the whole job landscape has changed. Even plumbers and electricians can make more money than the average lawyer today.
#737
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
My SIL went to lawschool, worked as a lawyer for a bit, but then had kids, lawyer job wasn't paying well enough as they live in a smaller city with limited upward trajectory due to lack of big law firms, so she went to work for ICBC instead. (by ICBC I donn't mean autoplan, she works as some sort of claims adjuster directly employed by ICBC)
#738
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Feb 2013
Posts: 6,148
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
My SIL went to lawschool, worked as a lawyer for a bit, but then had kids, lawyer job wasn't paying well enough as they live in a smaller city with limited upward trajectory due to lack of big law firms, so she went to work for ICBC instead. (by ICBC I donn't mean autoplan, she works as some sort of claims adjuster directly employed by ICBC)
#739
Account Closed
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 0
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
True and unless you own the law firm or work for the very big law firms, salaries don't seem to be great. There are so many new jobs around us oldies don't know about. It's sad to hear that a tier 2 help desk employee makes more than a nurse and they would be considered low paid in the tech sector.
Paramedics in BC are not paid all that well either.
#740
Banned
Joined: Apr 2009
Location: SW Ontario
Posts: 19,879
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
Isn't that the whole issue? Many people in Canada would not be able to afford the house they now live in, if they hadn't bought it years ago. In the case of Vancouver, "years ago" is 2015. People who owned houses at that time suddenly had lots of equity and were able to buy more houses to rent to the new "working poor", people like newly qualified CPAs, associates in law firms, doctors and dentists, the kind of people who nominally have "good jobs' but who will never be able to catch up with those who had the same jobs in 2015.
It's this sort of price escalation that leads people like, say Adele, to have to move to cities that are their second choice, LA in her case, because Lahdons too pricey, innit?
Aren't you a home owner in Hamilton? Soon to be a member of the bourgeois.
It's this sort of price escalation that leads people like, say Adele, to have to move to cities that are their second choice, LA in her case, because Lahdons too pricey, innit?
Aren't you a home owner in Hamilton? Soon to be a member of the bourgeois.
Making it personal are we Dbd - that's low, even for you.
Unlike you, I don't own a spread in the country with land, horses, multiple vehicles etc., :I own a piece of crap in the city, don't have a vehicle - can't afford one - have a mortgage and no job.
The house I own (with someone else who has also lost their job) is a very small bungalow that is (and was when we bought it) basically a knock down - the basement has cracks in each corner that you can see through to the outside (the only way to repair will cost thousands - which I don't have)... the electrics are the original 1950's - as are the windows, kitchen and bathroom. It's a piece of crap and worth very little more than when we bought it for a low price 10 years ago, due to the amount of work it needs (i.e. knocking down and rebuilding)... I had to have the roof repaired last winter, another $1300 I didn't have. I wish it was worth money - even if I could sell it, I couldn't afford to buy anything else nor even rent somewhere, due to the increase in prices in Hamilton! I'm quite likely to lose the house anyway - I have ZERO income. I can't afford the $500 gas bill that is outstanding, nor the electric bill outstanding - let alone the city taxes. I'm about to give up.
Want to make another dig at me? Go right ahead... make my day.
Last edited by Siouxie; Oct 19th 2021 at 9:18 pm.
#741
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
OK. I think that, from time-to-time, you mistake the tone of a post.
I don't think that owning a home necessarily makes one a bourgeois rentier capitalist but owning a home in a place that becomes gentrified is exactly how that transformation comes about.
I don't think that owning a home necessarily makes one a bourgeois rentier capitalist but owning a home in a place that becomes gentrified is exactly how that transformation comes about.
#742
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
Some, perhaps, but in the Thatcher era the tabloids celebrated a bricklayers assistant, a man with a giant hod, who was making a fortune. I suspect this is the same, the high earning trades are wild exceptions.
<goes off in search of giant hod man>
https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-ma...-84181197.html
<goes off in search of giant hod man>
https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-ma...-84181197.html
#743
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Dec 2020
Location: Ontario
Posts: 761
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
About a month ago there was a neat little article in the Economist. Based on the US data, I am afraid, but chances are it applies to us too. Well, it turns out that Gen X families are a lot wealthier than the Boomers were at their age. And the same goes for (oh, horror!) Millennials in relation to Gen X. Even wealthier.
With the unheard of government handouts targeting Millennials and discriminating against other age groups in the Trudeau’s new platform, the trend will likely accelerate.
So, dare I say, young CPAs, doctors, lawyers and good tradesmen will be able to buy a house if they so wish. The people who might not be so lucky are the ones who put all their energy into whinging. Regardless of age.
With the unheard of government handouts targeting Millennials and discriminating against other age groups in the Trudeau’s new platform, the trend will likely accelerate.
So, dare I say, young CPAs, doctors, lawyers and good tradesmen will be able to buy a house if they so wish. The people who might not be so lucky are the ones who put all their energy into whinging. Regardless of age.
Last edited by Mordko; Oct 20th 2021 at 2:20 am.
#744
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 704
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
noun
- An industry that does not produce any goods, but only provides a service such as a bank or insurance company.
- an industry that provides services rather than tangible objects
And with all due respect, even as a resident of Hamilton, I sense that you are missing a sea-change in the city's economy that is currently happening. It is not (just) the "next bedroom suburb" for GTA after Mississauga and Oakville.
That's unfortunate. But you were the first to suggest that I had been "hoisted by my own petard", based on your own misunderstanding of what constitutes a "service industry" job.
But I'm happy to bury the hatchet.
#745
Account Closed
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 0
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
At least in Coastal San Diego area the weather is nicer than anywhere in Canada, and Mexican food.
$1.2 million, built in 1961, on the market for 13 days, last sale was in 1970.
Opportunity of a life time, in the sought after neighborhood of Avocado Acres in Encinitas / Leucadia Costal North County! Only 1 mile from the ocean.
3 bedroom 2 bath, 10,000sq foot lot.
Asssed value for property taxes $50,000 (whoever bought it for $1.2 million, wont be paying taxes based on the assessed value of $50,000 as when a house sells it gets reassed, California does property taxes a little differently that many places.) 2020 property tax was only $693 for the year, will be much higher now that it wont have the 50k assessment for the new owner.
It's perfect starter home for someone...... in 1971 when this house sold last, it's selling price was about 2 times the median household income of the era, at $1.2 million it is 11.2 times the median household income of that area (note this is a wealthy area of San Diego, median household income is $35,000 more than the median income household for the region as a whole.)
I don't know anyone can say working class today can truly afford homes, 2 times annual income seems more manaegable to buy than 11 times the annual income does..... By working class I don't mean high paid professionals, in 1970 a school janitor could have bought this home, today they can barely rent because labor has been so devalued over the decades.
Listing
$1.2 million, built in 1961, on the market for 13 days, last sale was in 1970.
Opportunity of a life time, in the sought after neighborhood of Avocado Acres in Encinitas / Leucadia Costal North County! Only 1 mile from the ocean.
3 bedroom 2 bath, 10,000sq foot lot.
Asssed value for property taxes $50,000 (whoever bought it for $1.2 million, wont be paying taxes based on the assessed value of $50,000 as when a house sells it gets reassed, California does property taxes a little differently that many places.) 2020 property tax was only $693 for the year, will be much higher now that it wont have the 50k assessment for the new owner.
It's perfect starter home for someone...... in 1971 when this house sold last, it's selling price was about 2 times the median household income of the era, at $1.2 million it is 11.2 times the median household income of that area (note this is a wealthy area of San Diego, median household income is $35,000 more than the median income household for the region as a whole.)
I don't know anyone can say working class today can truly afford homes, 2 times annual income seems more manaegable to buy than 11 times the annual income does..... By working class I don't mean high paid professionals, in 1970 a school janitor could have bought this home, today they can barely rent because labor has been so devalued over the decades.
Spoiler:
Listing
#746
Account Closed
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 0
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
MST Development Corp., which is run by the Musqueam, Squamish and Tsleil-Waututh Nations, and Canada Lands Co. is proposing to build three, 38-storey towers, and 10,000 new homes on Jericho lands. Will be interesting, I venture NIMBY's will come out in full force, and see if the city makes them shrink the size of the development as Jericho Lands development must comply with city policies and regulations, where another project Squamish Nation is building near the Burrard Street bridge isn't obligated to follow city policies and regulations as that project called Senakw development is fully within reserve lands.
https://vancouversun.com/business/ea...0000-new-homes
This is the size of projects Vancouver needs, building 2,000 units at a time wont solve the housing problem, but building 10,000 a time would make pretty significant progress.
https://vancouversun.com/business/ea...0000-new-homes
This is the size of projects Vancouver needs, building 2,000 units at a time wont solve the housing problem, but building 10,000 a time would make pretty significant progress.
#747
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
About a month ago there was a neat little article in the Economist. Based on the US data, I am afraid, but chances are it applies to us too. Well, it turns out that Gen X families are a lot wealthier than the Boomers were at their age. And the same goes for (oh, horror!) Millennials in relation to Gen X. Even wealthier.
With the unheard of government handouts targeting Millennials and discriminating against other age groups in the Trudeau’s new platform, the trend will likely accelerate.
So, dare I say, young CPAs, doctors, lawyers and good tradesmen will be able to buy a house if they so wish. The people who might not be so lucky are the ones who put all their energy into whinging. Regardless of age.
With the unheard of government handouts targeting Millennials and discriminating against other age groups in the Trudeau’s new platform, the trend will likely accelerate.
So, dare I say, young CPAs, doctors, lawyers and good tradesmen will be able to buy a house if they so wish. The people who might not be so lucky are the ones who put all their energy into whinging. Regardless of age.
It's what Conservatives vote for but, my word, that's some stupid.
#748
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Dec 2020
Location: Ontario
Posts: 761
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
If the suggestion is that successively younger cohorts have more dollars at a specific age than older ones did, that makes sense, inflation often makes that true.
Of course the economists who did the actual study corrected for inflation. Younger generations are richer in real terms than the previous generations were at their age.
Average GenX has $1.1M. Boomers at that age had inflation corrected $730K.
Average Millennial has $196K (and is 32). GenX households had inflation corrected $158K at 32.
#749
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
Great catch, or it would have been had the analysis been done by the amateur epidemiologists, statisticians and economists who all seem to congregate around here.
Of course the economists who did the actual study corrected for inflation. Younger generations are richer in real terms than the previous generations were at their age.
Average GenX has $1.1M. Boomers at that age had inflation corrected $730K.
Average Millennial has $196K (and is 32). GenX households had inflation corrected $158K at 32.
Of course the economists who did the actual study corrected for inflation. Younger generations are richer in real terms than the previous generations were at their age.
Average GenX has $1.1M. Boomers at that age had inflation corrected $730K.
Average Millennial has $196K (and is 32). GenX households had inflation corrected $158K at 32.
1. How old is a GenX?
2. Do you have a link to this contrarian article?
#750
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Dec 2020
Location: Ontario
Posts: 761
Re: real estate prices in Canada sustainable?
1. Average GenX age is 48 year old.
2. You have to pay for the Economist. https://subscribenow.economist.com/ They'll give you access to back issues as well. I can find out which issue but it will take a bit of time to scroll through recent magazines so let me know if you need me to do that. Guessing it was around September 15th.
Unfortunately I am not aware of any studies focusing on Thatcher refugees, professional whiners and common cold survivors. Suspect it's a conservative-lead conspiracy to cover up the data.
2. You have to pay for the Economist. https://subscribenow.economist.com/ They'll give you access to back issues as well. I can find out which issue but it will take a bit of time to scroll through recent magazines so let me know if you need me to do that. Guessing it was around September 15th.
Unfortunately I am not aware of any studies focusing on Thatcher refugees, professional whiners and common cold survivors. Suspect it's a conservative-lead conspiracy to cover up the data.