British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Canada (https://britishexpats.com/forum/canada-56/)
-   -   What to expect from the NHS ! (https://britishexpats.com/forum/canada-56/what-expect-nhs-382063/)

Butch Cassidy Jun 29th 2006 3:51 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 

Originally Posted by Canada Bob
Do you want to read that again? maybe you should rephrase that ?

I'm not going to do anything for you LOL !!!

Still struggling to challenge my earlier posts I notice.

dormy Jun 29th 2006 3:54 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 

Originally Posted by dbd33
Three hundred quid a month is nothing, just nothing, in terms of healthcare premiums.

I would be very happy to pay much more, privately, if I could see my doctor the same day I needed to. 10 years ago this was possible, why is it not now.

Last time i visited my doctor was in 1996, 20 minute wait in and out all happy, went down there on monday, next available appointment is 2nd August, as it is not an emergency.

Dont get me wrong the staff are exceptional, the Nurses carers and doctors are deyond reproach, but massively underfunded

What is the underlying coincidence here, their colour is red

Calgal Jun 29th 2006 3:58 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 
<pours cup of morning tea, and pulls up comfy chair.......>

Butch Cassidy Jun 29th 2006 3:59 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 

Originally Posted by Calgal
<pours cup of morning tea, and pulls up comfy chair.......>

Can you stay on topic please. :D

dbd33 Jun 29th 2006 4:20 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 

Originally Posted by dormy
I would be very happy to pay much more, privately, if I could see my doctor the same day I needed to. 10 years ago this was possible, why is it not now.

Last time i visited my doctor was in 1996, 20 minute wait in and out all happy, went down there on monday, next available appointment is 2nd August, as it is not an emergency.

Dont get me wrong the staff are exceptional, the Nurses carers and doctors are deyond reproach, but massively underfunded

What is the underlying coincidence here, their colour is red

I don't see your problem. You say you are willing to pay. You say that the doctor will see you in due course and your condition is not an emergency. So, you can either wait or go somewhere else. I know about the facilities in the US but I don't suppose that's the only place where a doctor would be happy to be paid to take a look at a non-urgent condition; Switzerland might be more convenient. Come to that I expect there are still private doctors in Harley St. Why don't you go to one of them?

I also don't see the red reference, if you think the state healthcare system is underfunded, don't you think a dose of socialism would fix that?

TrishP Jun 29th 2006 4:33 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 

Originally Posted by Canada Bob

Don't know if you saw that program on the BBC a couple of days ago, about the extent of MRSA and how Dr's were covering up the real cause of death on the Death Certificate by putting it down to Pneumonia. That may be tolerable to some folks, but it sure aint to me...

Bob.

The doctor probably wrote pneumonia on the death cert because that's what they died of. Duh! You don't die of MRSA, you die of something else because your immune system is lowered (beyond it's already low level because of existing illness).

MRSA has been around for years, just like the flu bug has been around for years. You're more likely to die being run over in the street by a car than die of any infection arising from MRSA.

Have you ever seen the statistics of how many drug-related deaths there are per year? Try slagging off the drug companies!

Novocastrian Jun 29th 2006 4:47 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 

Originally Posted by dbd33
I also don't see the red reference, if you think the state healthcare system is underfunded, don't you think a dose of socialism would fix that?

hi dbd33.... I've forwarded this whole thread to Jack Layton. He says he's going to drop by your place in a few days to make your acquaintance. :beer:

Canada Bob Jun 29th 2006 4:48 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 

Originally Posted by Butch Cassidy
Ok here is what I've gathered about you.
1) you blew the whistle (rightly or wrongly I'm not commenting)
2) you apparently had your life threatend (wrongly I agree)
3) you got sick and decided to move back to the UK where you happily used the NHS
4) you have done some 'public works'
5) you actually believe that wilson was a socialist (and you question others intelligence)
6) you are a massive self publicist
7) you dont like people disagreeing with you.

Let's see how close to the truth you are.

1) Blowing the whistle, you might now want to comment on if that was the right or wrong thing to do, but Iain Angus {et-al} Canadian MP had a lot to say in support of what I did, add to that a letter of Commendation from the Governor General in 2001.

2) I guess we can agree on...

3) I bought a house back here in 1998, and have owned it and lived here much of the time since than. I was diagnosed with cancer in May of 2004.

Let me know if you'd like to put your money where your mouth is on any of this, I'm hoping that your money is as big as your mouth that is.

4) Oh ! Thank You, you have NO IDEA what I have done, where I have been, what I have seen, and how I responded to it, let's just throw in adopting 2 children from Africa in the last 10 years.

5) no point in arguing that one, but I see your spelling has improved...

6) Does that mean if I have something to say I shouldn't say it ? I can tell you this that due to the campaigns I have organised the benefits have gone far and wide, at home and abroad... There's a good number of folks that are thankful that I stepped up to the plate for them, {want to see some of their letters} ??? or did you read them too ???

7) Believe me, I don't give a damn, folks like you aren't worth the bother.

Any points you'd like to correct above ? anything you'd like to bet on ?

There's a calm comfort when folks who assail you miss their target by such wide margins...

Canada Bob.

dormy Jun 29th 2006 5:00 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 

Originally Posted by dbd33
I don't see your problem. You say you are willing to pay. You say that the doctor will see you in due course and your condition is not an emergency. So, you can either wait or go somewhere else. I know about the facilities in the US but I don't suppose that's the only place where a doctor would be happy to be paid to take a look at a non-urgent condition; Switzerland might be more convenient. Come to that I expect there are still private doctors in Harley St. Why don't you go to one of them?

I also don't see the red reference, if you think the state healthcare system is underfunded, don't you think a dose of socialism would fix that?

The health service has always been poorly funded, but the exceptionally poor funding that they are experiencing at the moment commenced at the "appointment" of the bunch of Jokers known as the labour party, sorry New Labour!

In my, uneducated, opinion what I believe to be a trapped nerve in my back, is an emergency. In the opinion of the two crows behind the doctors surgery desk it is not an emergency, and to the A&E dept locally it is a matter for my GP not for them. Not really worth going to Switzerland or Houston for, so despite paying over £40,000 over the last few years I cannot see a GP and will lose a months pay, as I cannot provide a doctors certificate stating that I should not be lifting heavy objects.

Souvenir Jun 29th 2006 5:01 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 

Originally Posted by Canada Bob
2) I guess we can agree on...Canada Bob.

In addition to 6 & 7.

Canada Bob Jun 29th 2006 5:07 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 

Originally Posted by TrishB
The doctor probably wrote pneumonia on the death cert because that's what they died of. Duh! You don't die of MRSA, you die of something else because your immune system is lowered (beyond it's already low level because of existing illness). MRSA has been around for years, just like the flu bug has been around for years. You're more likely to die being run over in the street by a car than die of any infection arising from MRSA.
Have you ever seen the statistics of how many drug-related deaths there are per year? Try slagging off the drug companies!

Hello Trish, I guess you didn't have the benefit of the program on TV over here, the fact is people do die of MRSA but their deaths are being recorded as Pneumonia etc, to the point that the Dept of Health has had to send out a directive informing Dr's to put MRSA when that's the cause of death.

One of the folks on the show commented that "folks who are in a car crash die of Pneumonia over here" !!! what he was saying was they had been infected by MRSA and the like {Hospital bugs} and died from them. This was also supported by other professionals interviewed in the program.

It's a bit absurd to say we shouldn't concern ourselves about MRSA and the like as long as more folks are getting killed on the road. If we can avoid any "accidental" deaths then we should strive to do so...

Afterall, wehn we cross the road we have decisions to make about the exposure to risk that we are prepared to take, some folks take more risks than others. When we are in hospital then the decision isn't ours anymore, you trust you life to someone else.

The "Duh" ! indicates both abuse and your ignorance...

Go speak with the leading Microbiologist from Edinburgh they had on the show, he was absolute about that fact, maybe you'd like a bet as well ?

Looks like I could clean up here...

Canada Bob.

Stu-pot Jun 29th 2006 5:25 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 

Originally Posted by Canada Bob
Hello Trish, I guess you didn't have the benefit of the program on TV over here, the fact is people do die of MRSA but their deaths are being recorded as Pneumonia etc, to the point that the Dept of Health has had to send out a directive informing Dr's to put MRSA when that's the cause of death.

One of the folks on the show commented that "folks who are in a car crash die of Pneumonia over here" !!! what he was saying was they had been infected by MRSA and the like {Hospital bugs} and died from them. This was also supported by other professionals interviewed in the program.

It's a bit absurd to say we shouldn't concern ourselves about MRSA and the like as long as more folks are getting killed on the road. If we can avoid any "accidental" deaths then we should strive to do so...

Afterall, wehn we cross the road we have decisions to make about the exposure to risk that we are prepared to take, some folks take more risks than others. When we are in hospital then the decision isn't ours anymore, you trust you life to someone else.

The "Duh" ! indicates both abuse and your ignorance...

Go speak with the leading Microbiologist from Edinburgh they had on the show, he was absolute about that fact, maybe you'd like a bet as well ?

Looks like I could clean up here...

Canada Bob.


On a roll Bob :)

Stuart

Garfielduk Jun 29th 2006 5:27 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 

Originally Posted by dormy
The health service has always been poorly funded, but the exceptionally poor funding that they are experiencing at the moment commenced at the "appointment" of the bunch of Jokers known as the labour party, sorry New Labour!

In my, uneducated, opinion what I believe to be a trapped nerve in my back, is an emergency. In the opinion of the two crows behind the doctors surgery desk it is not an emergency, and to the A&E dept locally it is a matter for my GP not for them. Not really worth going to Switzerland or Houston for, so despite paying over £40,000 over the last few years I cannot see a GP and will lose a months pay, as I cannot provide a doctors certificate stating that I should not be lifting heavy objects.

Forgive me all for posting on topic ;) but I will anyway. I do not want to be attacked over my opinion either as that is all it is and someone can have the opposite view if they wish.

My opinion is based on facts from my past experience and I have worked in the NHS, for a private community care charity and also for more commercial organisations in finance roles.

1 - Such a large organisation like the NHS is an out of control dinosaur that no Government has been able to control (so its not a party political thing at all)
2 - Following on from point 1 the dinosaur could be brought under some control IF ANY Government were serious about reviewing every nook and cranny that it has BUT they are not (fear factor)
3 - Many Authorities are millions overspent and yet when they Interviewed Financial Candidates from Industry and Commercial Companies the Press Release said that many were not upto the job ! I find that hard to believe and pretty damned ridiculous when the Guys there at the moment cannot control it.
4 - Most Government led organisations are overstaffed and that includes the NHS in many areas (not all disciplines). For example I took my wife to the local hospital for a clinic appointment and we were faced with 3 receptionists booking people in, all dealing with 1 or 2 consultants; they just don't have busy periods because appointments are better timed nowadays so 2 receptionists could have done the jobs of 3, now that's a 33% saving and it's just a simple example that could be rolled out across a lot of areas.

I'm sure I am going to be garrotted by some one, but go ahead as I have seen it first hand and it's fact and truth. :beer:

daft batty Jun 29th 2006 5:42 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 

Originally Posted by TrishB
As someone who has worked in both the NHS and Canadian healthcare I can say that the NHS is a much superior system. I'm fed up with people feeding off the UK media wagon that jumps on any negative story about the NHS and pumps it up into something huge. Canada Bob, how much have YOU used the NHS?

Yes, the NHS may appear to be underfunded, but that's because of the ever increasing numbers of people who
a) don't turn up to appointments
b) waste clinicians' time through turning up at A&E to have something checked out that the family doctor could've done
c) hypochondriacs, abusive drunken louts who've fallen over or gotten in a fight and
d) people who don't take responsibility for their own health and expect others to pick up the pieces for them when things go wrong.

I've come across them all and believe me, it's incredibly irritating as a clinician to have to kill time because some pratt couldn't be bothered turning up for an apppointment. And don't give it the "but you can never get an appointment" crap - yes you can if you NEED it! Compared with Canada where thousands, if not millions, of people don't actually have a family doctor, we do OK in the UK. And the UK has just about double the population of Canada, so the NHS is treating a hell of a lot more people. A lot of very dedicated people work in the NHS and pull out the stops when people NEED a service.

Take into consideration the advances in medical technology and the much superior team approach to working with patients (unlike here where it's very much old school bowing to the doctor for all the decision-making), people are now living much longer, despite the increase in chronic conditions, and are requiring more care at home and more equipment - this is all provided free in the UK - you have to pay in Canada (well, Ontario anyway) for home equipment, eg. powered bath seat - Canada $1500, NHS free.

I have animals that came with me from the UK and have required veterinary care in both countries - the vet system is totally privately funded in both countries and operates within the private sector, so of course the vet is going to carry out an operation asap as he knows you'll go elsewhere if he/she doesn't!

A poor comparison overall - and don't get on your high horse about tongue-in-cheek humour or it was a comment made only for a laugh. Joking about the system that I put heart and soul into for 12 years for patients I cared deeply about is no laughing matter when ignorant types like you decide to slag it off. And most of my NHS colleagues felt the same way.

this NHS employee certainly agrees with you

Canada Bob Jun 29th 2006 6:03 am

Re: What to expect from the NHS !
 
It was "Just an Administrative error" {we weren't lying}...


Click on the "Hospital cover up" link from this page.

http://www.bdrecorder.co.uk/content/...A10%3A13%3A287

Add to that the recent audit of Death Certificates that said upto 55% weren't filled in either truthfully or correctly.

http://observer.guardian.co.uk/uk_ne...805460,00.html

This case below was just down the road from where I live, add to that two men I knew for over 40 years died within the last 12 months of MRSA in Royal Bolton Hospital while they were being treated for MRSA {after operations}
both of them died, neither of their death certificates mentioned MRSA.

The wife of one of them was threatened with legal action if she went to the press about it ! Yea, really, I can give you her phone number...

http://www.manchestereveningnews.co....rsa_death.html

"MRSA DEATH Rate Doubles", as long as you can't die from it, who cares...

http://www.politics.co.uk/public-services/health/mrsa-death-rate-doubles-$7875629.htm

Other peoples experiences:

http://www.robprince.net/mrsa/forum.asp?page=3

I'll rest my case...

Canada Bob.


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 3:04 am.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.