The Rugby Union Thread
#436
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 14,040











I guess the point of that is to infer that Union is superior/harder than League and you are also referring to Israel Folau. I suggest basketball next after his incredibly expensive and disastrous flirt with AFL.
No Cookies | Fox Sports News, Live Sport, Sports | Fox Sports
Union is basically only offered/taught in private (read public for UK) schools in Melbourne (league not in any schools). Horses for courses - a game where you pass the ball backwards to go forwards and you get rewarded for kicking the ball out of the field of play (rather than penalised) and where you are allowed a minute to kick a penalty and a few minutes to get a scrum organised is alien to most sports and it's why it won't catch on in a lot of places.
No Cookies | Fox Sports News, Live Sport, Sports | Fox Sports
Union is basically only offered/taught in private (read public for UK) schools in Melbourne (league not in any schools). Horses for courses - a game where you pass the ball backwards to go forwards and you get rewarded for kicking the ball out of the field of play (rather than penalised) and where you are allowed a minute to kick a penalty and a few minutes to get a scrum organised is alien to most sports and it's why it won't catch on in a lot of places.
BTW they do play league in Melbourne schools, but no one cares
http://www.hallamssc.vic.edu.au/en-AU/content/rugby-league
#437
Last resort... format c:/







Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 2,095
From: Singapore to Surfers Paradise to... Tenerife... to Gran Canaria!











#439
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 16,623
From: Hill overlooking the SE Melbourne suburbs











#440
However:
Burgess can become a decent union player but as it stands he has been rushed into the highest level too quickly. No problem with him playing for England but Lancaster built his whole back line around him - and we have seen the results. He needs to give it time
Folau has been a great union convert IMO. Sure at the moment he is struggling but he has proven that he can play top-level union
All good rugby teams need bench players that can come on in the 2nd half and make an impact and SBW fits this bill. He played really well against the Bokke. Someone's got to do it
#441
Account Closed
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 0

Definitely where I'm from, it's that, and the piss drinking/shitting in ashtrays antics of the public schoolboy players that switches people off. That may well have little truth attached to it but it's a reputation that's stuck in my part of the world
#442
I dunno where the posh thing comes from TBH.
I'm from the SW coast, Bournemouth and all the boy schools played rugby whether they were grammar school, posh school or council house kids school. They also played footie and cricket. Had swimming lessons and learnt to play tennis.
My school played hockey. Ugh! Posh? No. Council 'ouse every one of us.
Husband is from the Midlands. Lowhill ,Wolverhampton actually which was a vast council house pit where others could fear to tred and it was the same for him. Husband was actually spotted & had trials . Reason he didn't progress wasn't about who he was. It was about parental time and money. Had he lived closer to the training place he could have got there. As it was it was not a goer .
The RFU clubs in Bournemouth were & are a right mix. Blokes joined to play rugby and it really didn't matter what their background was.
As far as Rugby League goes, that is the domain of the North of England. Not really played in the Midlands , nor the SW.
Sonny Bill is apparently seen as an impact player for the last 20 mins or so, unless injury brings him on earlier.
He tends to replace Nonu who is more seen as a battering ram of sorts.
I'm from the SW coast, Bournemouth and all the boy schools played rugby whether they were grammar school, posh school or council house kids school. They also played footie and cricket. Had swimming lessons and learnt to play tennis.
My school played hockey. Ugh! Posh? No. Council 'ouse every one of us.
Husband is from the Midlands. Lowhill ,Wolverhampton actually which was a vast council house pit where others could fear to tred and it was the same for him. Husband was actually spotted & had trials . Reason he didn't progress wasn't about who he was. It was about parental time and money. Had he lived closer to the training place he could have got there. As it was it was not a goer .
The RFU clubs in Bournemouth were & are a right mix. Blokes joined to play rugby and it really didn't matter what their background was.
As far as Rugby League goes, that is the domain of the North of England. Not really played in the Midlands , nor the SW.
Sonny Bill is apparently seen as an impact player for the last 20 mins or so, unless injury brings him on earlier.
He tends to replace Nonu who is more seen as a battering ram of sorts.
#443
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 14,040











It's interesting how many players struggle to move between league and union. At that level of skill you would have thought it would be easy
However:
Burgess can become a decent union player but as it stands he has been rushed into the highest level too quickly. No problem with him playing for England but Lancaster built his whole back line around him - and we have seen the results. He needs to give it time
Folau has been a great union convert IMO. Sure at the moment he is struggling but he has proven that he can play top-level union
All good rugby teams need bench players that can come on in the 2nd half and make an impact and SBW fits this bill. He played really well against the Bokke. Someone's got to do it
However:
Burgess can become a decent union player but as it stands he has been rushed into the highest level too quickly. No problem with him playing for England but Lancaster built his whole back line around him - and we have seen the results. He needs to give it time
Folau has been a great union convert IMO. Sure at the moment he is struggling but he has proven that he can play top-level union
All good rugby teams need bench players that can come on in the 2nd half and make an impact and SBW fits this bill. He played really well against the Bokke. Someone's got to do it
I'd really like to see them roll Burgess out at No 6 or even a lock like the AB's did with Brad Thorn.
Wingers and Fullbacks need to kick in Union and League wingers generally can't or at least the convert attempts can't.
The offloading centre like SBW and Burgess is a bit one dimensional and centres, especially the inside centre needs to be a second fly half in union.
#444
Well "harder" is not a term I would use. Both have pretty hard nuts. Brad Thorn was the best crossover merchant. He could apply his "hardness" to both league and union very successfully. He could also play in the forwards in both sports which is an entirely different style of play.
BTW they do play league in Melbourne schools, but no one cares
Rugby League | hallamssc.vic.edu.au
BTW they do play league in Melbourne schools, but no one cares
Rugby League | hallamssc.vic.edu.au
Interesting that Hallam has an AFL for girls academy!
#445
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 14,040











The guy was sick for a week after that. Fair play though ..... it was a good effort.
#446
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 14,040











For those who like to frame rugby boys as some type of upper class breed only accessible by those with money and a silver spoon, well think again.
http://m.smh.com.au/rugby-union/rugby-world-cup/rugby-world-cup-final-2015-all-smiles-for-wallabies-selfie-as-they-prepare-for-world-cup-final-20151026-gkj5cj.html
Pocock got arrested a few years ago for chaining himself to a digger or something at an anti coal mine protest.
As for the private school thing, I think you would find most in the Wallabies did not attend private schools, but who cares anyway. School is a school and private schools offer more than public. If you can afford it why wouldn't you?
http://m.smh.com.au/rugby-union/rugby-world-cup/rugby-world-cup-final-2015-all-smiles-for-wallabies-selfie-as-they-prepare-for-world-cup-final-20151026-gkj5cj.html
Pocock got arrested a few years ago for chaining himself to a digger or something at an anti coal mine protest.
As for the private school thing, I think you would find most in the Wallabies did not attend private schools, but who cares anyway. School is a school and private schools offer more than public. If you can afford it why wouldn't you?
#447
Account Closed
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 0

For those who like to frame rugby boys as some type of upper class breed only accessible by those with money and a silver spoon, well think again. Rugby World Cup final 2015: All smiles for Wallabies selfie as they prepare for decider | smh.com.au Pocock got arrested a few years ago for chaining himself to a digger or something at an anti coal mine protest. As for the private school thing, I think you would find most in the Wallabies did not attend private schools, but who cares anyway. School is a school and private schools offer more than public. If you can afford it why wouldn't you?
#448
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 14,040











The point is the Wallaby team are wide and varied in their backgrounds. Something you can't attribute to most league teams.
#449
For those who like to frame rugby boys as some type of upper class breed only accessible by those with money and a silver spoon, well think again.
Rugby World Cup final 2015: All smiles for Wallabies selfie as they prepare for decider | smh.com.au
Pocock got arrested a few years ago for chaining himself to a digger or something at an anti coal mine protest.
As for the private school thing, I think you would find most in the Wallabies did not attend private schools, but who cares anyway. School is a school and private schools offer more than public. If you can afford it why wouldn't you?
Rugby World Cup final 2015: All smiles for Wallabies selfie as they prepare for decider | smh.com.au
Pocock got arrested a few years ago for chaining himself to a digger or something at an anti coal mine protest.
As for the private school thing, I think you would find most in the Wallabies did not attend private schools, but who cares anyway. School is a school and private schools offer more than public. If you can afford it why wouldn't you?





