University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
#61
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
However I have many relatives that couldn't afford to pay for their kids college costs and I know others that would rather spend their money on very expensive toys for themselves.
#62
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Apr 2011
Location: Ohio
Posts: 1,834
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
Most parents would do the same in similar circumstances, I think. I appreciate it's completely different if there's a lot less money sloshing around and harder choices to be made between college and a retirement above a cat food level; sensible retirement savings should always come first.
#63
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 1,966
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
Fair enough, I guess I just thought it was a "nice to do" thing rather than expected as it seemed.
#64
Heading for Poppyland
Joined: Jul 2007
Location: North Norfolk and northern New York State
Posts: 14,546
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
Well, we got ours for free (or near enough, I think hubby and I had a couple of thou of debt between us, paid off in a matter of months after graduating in the early 90s). So it seems only fair to pass it on, within workable limits (we're not doing anything into 6-figures or subsidizing some extravagant brand name lifestyle choice). We've had some great life breaks, and the kids have been extremely amiable about the country moves that've made hubby's current generous income possible, and worked hard and uncomplainingly across multiple school systems/ educational languages, so we'd like to share the benefits. The difference between paying for (reasonable) college and not, is hubby being able to retire in his early or mid-50s, so it's a fair trade to start the kids off without something equating to a second mortgage.
Most parents would do the same in similar circumstances, I think. I appreciate it's completely different if there's a lot less money sloshing around and harder choices to be made between college and a retirement above a cat food level; sensible retirement savings should always come first.
Most parents would do the same in similar circumstances, I think. I appreciate it's completely different if there's a lot less money sloshing around and harder choices to be made between college and a retirement above a cat food level; sensible retirement savings should always come first.
In our case, we were 56 years old when our youngest graduated college. Coincidentally, that year we paid off our mortgage. Gave us a few working years to both contribute the IRS legal max into our retirement accounts.
#65
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
Playing devil's advocate by asking why shouldn't they be responsible for the cost? In your case, it sounds like both your children selected to attend very pricey universities. I myself attended a state uni for 7 years to get my masters in engineering and racked up around $56k in student loans that are all my responsibility to pay back. Rather than put the financial pressure on my folks to cough up money (which wouldn't have happened anyways) for tuition, I went down the FAFSA loan route (no private or co-signed loans).
I don't know, maybe it's just me, but some kind of expectation that parents are the ones to cough up tuition & living expenses when they are hitting close to their retirement years is unreasonable - and selfish of children to expect to happen. Of course I feel hindered by the loans still hanging around my neck (and will for the next 15-20ish years), but I can only imagine how much more pressure or guilt I would feel if my education costs affected either of my parents future financial needs.
I don't know, maybe it's just me, but some kind of expectation that parents are the ones to cough up tuition & living expenses when they are hitting close to their retirement years is unreasonable - and selfish of children to expect to happen. Of course I feel hindered by the loans still hanging around my neck (and will for the next 15-20ish years), but I can only imagine how much more pressure or guilt I would feel if my education costs affected either of my parents future financial needs.
#66
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
Exactly. When I went to university in England in 1969, there were no fees (or minimal) and the government paid me a generous grant to cover living expenses (going to the cinema and the pub on a daily basis, for instance.). We then dragged our uncomplaining kids to America at a young age, and put pressure on them to attend four year college. One chose to go to state school (total notional cost, approx $100,000) the other chose to go to a private liberal arts college (total notional cost, approx $260,000.). They should be responsible for those costs? No.
In our case, we were 56 years old when our youngest graduated college. Coincidentally, that year we paid off our mortgage. Gave us a few working years to both contribute the IRS legal max into our retirement accounts.
In our case, we were 56 years old when our youngest graduated college. Coincidentally, that year we paid off our mortgage. Gave us a few working years to both contribute the IRS legal max into our retirement accounts.
In our case, having only just come to the US at almost 50, it's just not possible to scrimp together the amount of money required to fund college in the US in just 5 years. There's absolutely no way I would want that amount of pressure hanging over my hubby, especially as it was not a situation that we have ever planned for. Paying our daughters living costs while at university, yes; but funding the whole shebang, no.
Last edited by HartleyHare; May 21st 2014 at 1:33 pm. Reason: Missing word
#67
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Mar 2010
Location: Oakland County, Michigan
Posts: 846
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
Playing devil's advocate by asking why shouldn't they be responsible for the cost? In your case, it sounds like both your children selected to attend very pricey universities. I myself attended a state uni for 7 years to get my masters in engineering and racked up around $56k in student loans that are all my responsibility to pay back. Rather than put the financial pressure on my folks to cough up money (which wouldn't have happened anyways) for tuition, I went down the FAFSA loan route (no private or co-signed loans).
I don't know, maybe it's just me, but some kind of expectation that parents are the ones to cough up tuition & living expenses when they are hitting close to their retirement years is unreasonable - and selfish of children to expect to happen. Of course I feel hindered by the loans still hanging around my neck (and will for the next 15-20ish years), but I can only imagine how much more pressure or guilt I would feel if my education costs affected either of my parents future financial needs.
I don't know, maybe it's just me, but some kind of expectation that parents are the ones to cough up tuition & living expenses when they are hitting close to their retirement years is unreasonable - and selfish of children to expect to happen. Of course I feel hindered by the loans still hanging around my neck (and will for the next 15-20ish years), but I can only imagine how much more pressure or guilt I would feel if my education costs affected either of my parents future financial needs.
I always assumed that my stepdaughter would go to university in the UK, where, although the fees are getting higher, the system is still relatively fair with regards to student loans and you only pay back a percentage of what you earn. We would have helped her, but she still would have been fine without it. Then we moved here, and had potentially only 8 years to figure out how to fund her higher education. My son, meanwhile, was born here shortly afterwards, and we've been saving to his college fund since birth. Putting aside a much smaller amount for him each month will still appreciate into a decent amount in 18 years. I hope we can at least fund their tuition costs, if not their living costs, but I can see how much more difficult it is when you only have a few years instead of a full 18 years to plan for it.
#68
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Sep 2008
Location: Rural Virginia
Posts: 1,076
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
We have four in a row 17,18,19 and 20 did the Virginia 529 plan.
One ended up getting at full ride in Army ROTC.
In state is usually cheaper, some states will grant in state status to non residents, South Carolina is one where North Carolina does not.
One ended up getting at full ride in Army ROTC.
In state is usually cheaper, some states will grant in state status to non residents, South Carolina is one where North Carolina does not.
#69
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 41,518
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
Playing devil's advocate by asking why shouldn't they be responsible for the cost? In your case, it sounds like both your children selected to attend very pricey universities. I myself attended a state uni for 7 years to get my masters in engineering and racked up around $56k in student loans that are all my responsibility to pay back. Rather than put the financial pressure on my folks to cough up money (which wouldn't have happened anyways) for tuition, I went down the FAFSA loan route (no private or co-signed loans).
I don't know, maybe it's just me, but some kind of expectation that parents are the ones to cough up tuition & living expenses when they are hitting close to their retirement years is unreasonable - and selfish of children to expect to happen. Of course I feel hindered by the loans still hanging around my neck (and will for the next 15-20ish years), but I can only imagine how much more pressure or guilt I would feel if my education costs affected either of my parents future financial needs.
I don't know, maybe it's just me, but some kind of expectation that parents are the ones to cough up tuition & living expenses when they are hitting close to their retirement years is unreasonable - and selfish of children to expect to happen. Of course I feel hindered by the loans still hanging around my neck (and will for the next 15-20ish years), but I can only imagine how much more pressure or guilt I would feel if my education costs affected either of my parents future financial needs.
#70
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
Ah, forgot about that option. A friend of mine had a full ride through undergrad and medical school both at Northwestern (a very not cheap university) thanks to the Navy. She still owes them a year or two of service but then she could retire on full pension.
#71
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Apr 2011
Location: Ohio
Posts: 1,834
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
What wasn't factored in, of course, was college costing $250k+. But I don't imagine the 'average' American parent really has this stuffed away by 18 anyway, do they?! Because that's a spooky large number if you compound it over 30 or 40 years at a historical 7% - I'd be inclined to advise them to skip anything other than basic community/ in-state college, and retire in their 40s instead!
#72
Heading for Poppyland
Joined: Jul 2007
Location: North Norfolk and northern New York State
Posts: 14,546
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
The key thing is that when you came to the US your children were a young age, so I guess this gave you time to save towards meeting the costs.
In our case, having only just come to the US at almost 50, it's just not possible to scrimp together the amount of money required to fund college in the US in just 5 years. There's absolutely no way I would want that amount of pressure hanging over my hubby, especially as it was not a situation that we have ever planned for. Paying our daughters living costs while at university, yes; but funding the whole shebang, no.
In our case, having only just come to the US at almost 50, it's just not possible to scrimp together the amount of money required to fund college in the US in just 5 years. There's absolutely no way I would want that amount of pressure hanging over my hubby, especially as it was not a situation that we have ever planned for. Paying our daughters living costs while at university, yes; but funding the whole shebang, no.
#73
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Mar 2010
Location: Oakland County, Michigan
Posts: 846
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
We've always known we were paying for our kids though, even in the UK; I think our oldest was about 3 or 4 when tuition fees were announced. So college costing $80-100k was always on the cards. We're budgeting in-state for 4 years; they'll have to chip in for choosing somewhere else, or if they faff about and take more than 4 years.
#74
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
Yes, and as I mentioned in an earlier post, my career choice in America, where I got a degree in librarianship and then a faculty position in a university was informed by the idea of getting tuition benefits from my employer for my children's future undergrad costs. Hard to quantify it exactly, but it probably was a total benefit of at least $120,000.
#75
Heading for Poppyland
Joined: Jul 2007
Location: North Norfolk and northern New York State
Posts: 14,546
Re: University costs for your kids -- do you have a plan?
We've always known we were paying for our kids though, even in the UK; I think our oldest was about 3 or 4 when tuition fees were announced. So college costing $80-100k was always on the cards. We're budgeting in-state for 4 years; they'll have to chip in for choosing somewhere else, or if they faff about and take more than 4 years.
What wasn't factored in, of course, was college costing $250k+. But I don't imagine the 'average' American parent really has this stuffed away by 18 anyway, do they?! Because that's a spooky large number if you compound it over 30 or 40 years at a historical 7% - I'd be inclined to advise them to skip anything other than basic community/ in-state college, and retire in their 40s instead!
What wasn't factored in, of course, was college costing $250k+. But I don't imagine the 'average' American parent really has this stuffed away by 18 anyway, do they?! Because that's a spooky large number if you compound it over 30 or 40 years at a historical 7% - I'd be inclined to advise them to skip anything other than basic community/ in-state college, and retire in their 40s instead!
This is one reason why it is hard for me to quantify how much my college employer's tuition benefits were worth to me. My son was subsidised by my employer to the tune of (say) $20,000 a year. But if he hadn't got that, he would have got more in discounts and scholarships from the college he went to.