The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
#16
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
Well they were wrong to refuse Boris entry then. What happens you you at the border is a lottery, nothing, fine, refused entry - any could happen
#17
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
http://www.boris-johnson.com/2006/08...ican-passport/
#18
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
He wasn't refused entry. The airline security staff spotted it and he wasn't allowed to board the aircraft to Houston.
http://www.boris-johnson.com/2006/08...ican-passport/
http://www.boris-johnson.com/2006/08...ican-passport/
"The US Immigration say you have to travel on an American passport if you want to enter the United States."
would seem to be false according to a previous post.
So maybe the US has to let you in if you are a US citizen with or without a US passport, but a US carrier can refuse to take you to the US with out a US passport.......either way you are courting trouble as a US citizen if you attempt to fly to the US on another passport.
#19
Account Closed
Joined: Aug 2002
Location: Kentucky
Posts: 38,865
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
Ian
#20
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
Unfortunately I'm already on decaf. So what's the exact situation with US citizens coming to the the US on another passport? It's obviously not advisible. I was commenting on what seems to be a highly confusing situation, my intent was not to further confuse matters. What's the policy of US carriers? and is it different from the official immigration rules?
Last edited by nun; Dec 24th 2012 at 8:51 pm.
#21
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
Unfortunately I'm already on decaf. So what's the exact situation with US citizens coming to the the US on another passport? It's obviously not advisible. I was commenting on what seems to be a highly confusing situation, my intent was not to further confuse matters. What's the policy of US carriers? and is it different from the official immigration rules?
The airlines policy is the airlines policy. Again most countries levy a fine on the carrier if they bring in someone without the correct paperwork. Most airlines will go on the side of safety and refuse to take you if they think there will be a problem on arrival. They don't have to be right, but it is their decision.
#22
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
It's pretty much the same with the US and UK, and most other comparable countries. If you are a citizen of that country the relevant immigration authority cannot refuse you entry. The onus is on you to provide proof of such citizenship. A British passport showing you were born in the US, might be ample proof of such. But then again there are exceptions to getting automatic citizenship just because you were born in the US.
The airlines policy is the airlines policy. Again most countries levy a fine on the carrier if they bring in someone without the correct paperwork. Most airlines will go on the side of safety and refuse to take you if they think there will be a problem on arrival. They don't have to be right, but it is their decision.
The airlines policy is the airlines policy. Again most countries levy a fine on the carrier if they bring in someone without the correct paperwork. Most airlines will go on the side of safety and refuse to take you if they think there will be a problem on arrival. They don't have to be right, but it is their decision.
So what exactly happens if a US citizen gets to US immigration and presents a UK passport and the immigration officer sees a US place of birth and asks if the passport holder is a US citizen?
The US Embassy in London has an interesting opinion on this, 3rd paragraph down.
http://london.usembassy.gov/cons_new...tizenship.html
Last edited by nun; Dec 24th 2012 at 9:29 pm.
#23
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
The other option is to come into compliance and then keep filing US taxes or renounce US citizenship. Tax is the least of the issues here as there is probably no US tax due because of tax treaties and IRS code. So file a few years of taxes showing zero tax due and there will be no penalties or fines. However, the nasty issues are the large fines associated with delinquent FBARs or 8938s.
Here is an article that discusses the new tax amnesty for low risk non-US residents. It might be appropriate for you.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/robertwo...-for-everyone/
I would take some professional advice before you proceed, but getting squared away for US tax is the thing I'd do and then renounce if I had no desire to live in the US.
Here is an article that discusses the new tax amnesty for low risk non-US residents. It might be appropriate for you.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/robertwo...-for-everyone/
I would take some professional advice before you proceed, but getting squared away for US tax is the thing I'd do and then renounce if I had no desire to live in the US.
The standard way to come into compliance is simply to file 6 years tax returns and FBAR, etc. forms. That's what most Americans overseas who don't owe any money to the IRS have done. I am not sure what is the real benefit (for someone in this situation, who probably owes little or no tax) of joining any tax amnesty or disclosure program - just seems to complicate matters.
If taking professional advice, then the option of simply filing 6 years returns without joining an amnesty program should be the first option and the others only considered after some serious discussion. At a minimum, calculate taxes owed and if it's zero or close to zero, consider strongly the option of filing the returns via the standard method.
The potential fines for FBAR are significant but except for those in the "disclosure" programs and for those criminally prosecuted (not that common) I have not heard of a single reported case where the IRS has levied a penalty.
What concerns me is that U.S. citizens are being scared into renouncing their U.S. citizenship. In coming years we will see some of them wanting it back and that won't be an option unless they can qualify as an immigrant like anyone else.
#24
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
If no tax is due on back taxes then there will be no fines for filing. There are possible fines for filing of late FBARS, the uncertainty of how or whether the IRS will impose those fines is part of the dilemma faced by non-compliant US citizens. Given the complexity of international taxation I would get professional advice in all but the simplest of situations.
Last edited by nun; Dec 25th 2012 at 1:29 am.
#25
Account Closed
Joined: Aug 2002
Location: Kentucky
Posts: 38,865
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
"If your U.S. passport has been lost or stolen, or if it has expired, you must apply to replace it before traveling to the United States... in order to avoid any possible fine for not using your US passport to enter the US, but you'll still be allowed to enter."
Ian
#26
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
Indeed, but it is opinion only, and does not reflect the whole truth. I've fixed it to reflect what might actually happen:
"If your U.S. passport has been lost or stolen, or if it has expired, you must apply to replace it before traveling to the United States... in order to avoid any possible fine for not using your US passport to enter the US, but you'll still be allowed to enter."
Ian
"If your U.S. passport has been lost or stolen, or if it has expired, you must apply to replace it before traveling to the United States... in order to avoid any possible fine for not using your US passport to enter the US, but you'll still be allowed to enter."
Ian
#27
BE Forum Addict
Joined: May 2007
Location: London
Posts: 1,248
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
If I remember correctly (the article has since disappeared) he was actually denied boarding in the UK on a US-bound flight.
#28
Account Closed
Joined: Aug 2002
Location: Kentucky
Posts: 38,865
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
Ian
#29
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
There is no confusion surrounding this matter. Whether the airline gave him correct or incorrect information is irrelevant - US citizens have the right of entry to the US... regardless of what the airline says. If the airline refuses to allow him to board, that's between him and the airline... nothing to do with him and US immigration.
Ian
Ian
Last edited by nun; Dec 25th 2012 at 5:05 pm.
#30
Account Closed
Joined: Aug 2002
Location: Kentucky
Posts: 38,865
Re: The Odd Case of a British Citizen born in US but Dual Citizen/Living in Canada
I'm guessing they're not actually confused. What's on the web site is their easiest solution to the situation... whether or not it actually reflects what the law says. Most people will simply follow their suggestion... but they don't actually need to.
They may be fined, but they won't be refused entry.
I think you're assuming they're confused when, in fact, they're not.
Yes, but more likely fined rather than detained.
I'm sure there are.
Unless there's an overt indication that a person is a USC (such as a US place of birth on a foreign passport), then CBP likely won't know that the person is a USC.
Well, a US birth certificate or passport would do the trick... but I believe that claim to US citizenship is an affirming act, so the US government would need to prove that he wasn't a USC. I'm sure someone will correct me if I'm off base on this.
Ian
What actually happens if a US citizen presents a non-US passport to US immigration...
... and what recourse do you have if the immigration official is as confused as the Embassy.
Would you be allowed to enter but then fined or detained for not using the US passport?
Are there any actual examples of this happening?
The law seems to be quite explicit, but how is it enforced?
... what documentation would be required to prove US citizenship.
Ian