The melanie mcguire case
#1
BE Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 557
The melanie mcguire case
Did any of you follow this case where the fertility nurse was found guilty of killing the chopping up her husband?
What are your thoughts on it? it really interested me and Im a bit miffed its over!
What are your thoughts on it? it really interested me and Im a bit miffed its over!
#2
Homebody
Joined: Jan 2005
Location: HOME
Posts: 23,181
Re: The melanie mcguire case
Sorry haven't got a clue but I'm sure Nancy Grace will have something to say on the matter!
#4
BE Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 557
Re: The melanie mcguire case
I find the whole case really interesting as they found no DNA evidence in her apartment where they claim she killed him and used a saw to cut him into 3 pieces, must of had help and wonder if she will now give up that info .
#5
Re: The melanie mcguire case
Put them into 3 suitcases and threw them away!
I find the whole case really interesting as they found no DNA evidence in her apartment where they claim she killed him and used a saw to cut him into 3 pieces, must of had help and wonder if she will now give up that info .
I find the whole case really interesting as they found no DNA evidence in her apartment where they claim she killed him and used a saw to cut him into 3 pieces, must of had help and wonder if she will now give up that info .
#6
BE Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 557
Re: The melanie mcguire case
you know i just dont know weater I think she did it or not, on the surface it seems so but it was all pretty circumstantional evidence, I just have a feeling it isnt as cut and dried as has been made out to be.
I dont think she did it alone even if she had a part in it, nor do I think it was because she was having an affair as shed been seeing him 2 years.
How can you shoot dead, then drain the body, then cut it up using a saw without any one hearing any thing or any dna being found in the bathroom?
Then get it out of the appartment?
On the other hand, how the heck would the killer get hold of your suitcases? and why does cctv footage seem to be you that kind of puts you in the scene of trying to distract attentionfrom yourself?
I dunno but I really feel theres more to this, either shes 100% innocent and has been set up ( which i dont believe) or he was kileed n cut up in another place.
I mean a bathroom with no DNA and the smell of bleach does not mean he was killed there.
I will await with interest further developments.
#7
Re: The melanie mcguire case
has she been found guilty? I saw some pictures of the bridge where she was supposed to have thrown the cases off, with quite high railings. No easy job with a full suitcase??
#8
BE Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 557
Re: The melanie mcguire case
i found this link, quite interesting.
http://www.courttv.com/trials/mcguir...ml?curPhoto=17
#9
Re: The melanie mcguire case
Yes shes been found guilty on monday, will get at least 30 years.
i found this link, quite interesting.
http://www.courttv.com/trials/mcguir...ml?curPhoto=17
i found this link, quite interesting.
http://www.courttv.com/trials/mcguir...ml?curPhoto=17
#10
BE Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 557
Re: The melanie mcguire case
Yep he was a sweetie wasnt he, lied to police, was really jumpy in court and apparently owns a saw that would have been used to cut him up.
I rekon shell go o appeal and if no joy will sing out who helped her if indeed she was involved.
I rekon shell go o appeal and if no joy will sing out who helped her if indeed she was involved.
#11
Re: The melanie mcguire case
looks like lots of circumstantial evidence, ie same sort of weights in the house, same sort of linen ---- like half my town buys their linen at the same shop. plus, who searches on their own computer on ways to top someone!!!
#12
BE Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 557
Re: The melanie mcguire case
I dunno I just got odd feeling on the whole thing.