Fry, on the difference between our comedy
#31
Banned






Joined: Jun 2012
Posts: 1,065











I like the films done by the Coen brothers- they don't "glamourize" American culture. I also enjoy South Park- I'd love to hang out with the guys who write it (they are very brave
)I'm also a fan of Monty Python, and I enjoy the "Harry and Paul" show.
Anything/body that shows the absurdity of the human condition (Sacha Baren Cohen) is good by me, regardless of nationality. I also enjoy some Japanese comedians- many of them have a good sense of the absurd..
#32
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 41,517











#35
Banned




Joined: Apr 2011
Posts: 329











Or the woman voted Best Female Comic on TV at this year's British Comedy Awrads - Jo Brand.
I mean, Dear God, some has-been currently performing almost exclusively on Dave doing the same of schtick about her weight that she's been doing for years.
Jo Brand for goodness sake.
#36
Banned






Joined: Jun 2012
Posts: 1,065











Much the same as the truly dreadful Michael McIntyre.
Or the woman voted Best Female Comic on TV at this year's British Comedy Awrads - Jo Brand.
I mean, Dear God, some has-been currently performing almost exclusively on Dave doing the same of schtick about her weight that she's been doing for years.
Jo Brand for goodness sake.
Or the woman voted Best Female Comic on TV at this year's British Comedy Awrads - Jo Brand.
I mean, Dear God, some has-been currently performing almost exclusively on Dave doing the same of schtick about her weight that she's been doing for years.
Jo Brand for goodness sake.
#37
BE Forum Addict







Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 2,847











Much the same as the truly dreadful Michael McIntyre.
Or the woman voted Best Female Comic on TV at this year's British Comedy Awrads - Jo Brand.
I mean, Dear God, some has-been currently performing almost exclusively on Dave doing the same of schtick about her weight that she's been doing for years.
Jo Brand for goodness sake.
Or the woman voted Best Female Comic on TV at this year's British Comedy Awrads - Jo Brand.
I mean, Dear God, some has-been currently performing almost exclusively on Dave doing the same of schtick about her weight that she's been doing for years.
Jo Brand for goodness sake.
I saw her years ago at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe - after she'd been 'famous' on TV for a bit - she was decidedly unfunny - along with that donkey knob from 'The Word' (IIRC) - he stripped off when he admitted he was sh1t that night - it was not a good image - I'm still getting therapy...
#38
Banned






Joined: Jun 2012
Posts: 1,065











Jo Brand - WTF?
I saw her years ago at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe - after she'd been 'famous' on TV for a bit - she was decidedly unfunny - along with that donkey knob from 'The Word' (IIRC) - he stripped off when he admitted he was sh1t that night - it was not a good image - I'm still getting therapy...
I saw her years ago at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe - after she'd been 'famous' on TV for a bit - she was decidedly unfunny - along with that donkey knob from 'The Word' (IIRC) - he stripped off when he admitted he was sh1t that night - it was not a good image - I'm still getting therapy...


What made you go and see her show????
#39
Much the same as the truly dreadful Michael McIntyre.
Or the woman voted Best Female Comic on TV at this year's British Comedy Awrads - Jo Brand.
I mean, Dear God, some has-been currently performing almost exclusively on Dave doing the same of schtick about her weight that she's been doing for years.
Jo Brand for goodness sake.
Or the woman voted Best Female Comic on TV at this year's British Comedy Awrads - Jo Brand.
I mean, Dear God, some has-been currently performing almost exclusively on Dave doing the same of schtick about her weight that she's been doing for years.
Jo Brand for goodness sake.
We also saw Jo Brand a long time ago at the Fringe, she had a signer on stage with her, the only thing I remember about the show was how funny the signer was, I especially liked the sign for incontinence.
We went to see Dylan Moran (pronounced Moron by the introducer
) on Saturday night. He was very good, not hysterical or cutting edge, but there is something great about seeing a comedian who is very comfortable with who he is and his material, they aren't trying too hard to please or shock.
#40
BE Forum Addict







Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 2,847











Laziness...
...Well, I think it was free, and it was raining, and to not go would have required us to come up with an alternative - and walking somewhere in the rain - again. Besides, I think she'd been funny once, for 5 minutes on TV, and I stupidly thought that was representative...
...Well, I think it was free, and it was raining, and to not go would have required us to come up with an alternative - and walking somewhere in the rain - again. Besides, I think she'd been funny once, for 5 minutes on TV, and I stupidly thought that was representative...
#41
Forum Regular

Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 37




#44
I approved this message







Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 2,425
From: Chicago











After watching this video and thinking about it briefly, I totally disagree with Fry's assessment of American humor.
Thank about the most famous American stand-ups:
Richard Pryor - famous for talking bluntly and hilariously about his failings including his drug addiction, misogyny and rage. Also not shy in showing America up.
George Carlin - famous for pointing out the ridiculousness of American life and systematically destroying its pretentions
Chris Rock - famous for skewering black and white American culture equally
Bill Hicks - enraged but hilarious fuming about the state of America
Sam Kinison - ditto
Take the best American sit coms:
Seinfeld - about some truly awful but definitively American people doing awful things, celebrates their shallowness and inhumanity
Cheers - about good friends and belonging despite constant failure and melancholy. Everything is going wrong always for these characters and that's what makes it endearing.
MASH - about making the best out of a horrific situation, also not shy about pointing out failings in American culture and foreign policy
Or best comedic movies:
Mel Brooks - either destroys American racism (Blazing Saddles) or simply celebrates absurd failures (Young Frankenstein)
Cohen Brothers - Fargo, Barton Fink, Big Lebowski, all are hardly "ra ra America", all are suffused with irony
Animal House or Caddyshack or any other "slob vs. snob" movie - all about how "losers" and "misfits" are much more fun to hang out with than captains of the football team or captains of industry
Fry is categorically wrong.
Thank about the most famous American stand-ups:
Richard Pryor - famous for talking bluntly and hilariously about his failings including his drug addiction, misogyny and rage. Also not shy in showing America up.
George Carlin - famous for pointing out the ridiculousness of American life and systematically destroying its pretentions
Chris Rock - famous for skewering black and white American culture equally
Bill Hicks - enraged but hilarious fuming about the state of America
Sam Kinison - ditto
Take the best American sit coms:
Seinfeld - about some truly awful but definitively American people doing awful things, celebrates their shallowness and inhumanity
Cheers - about good friends and belonging despite constant failure and melancholy. Everything is going wrong always for these characters and that's what makes it endearing.
MASH - about making the best out of a horrific situation, also not shy about pointing out failings in American culture and foreign policy
Or best comedic movies:
Mel Brooks - either destroys American racism (Blazing Saddles) or simply celebrates absurd failures (Young Frankenstein)
Cohen Brothers - Fargo, Barton Fink, Big Lebowski, all are hardly "ra ra America", all are suffused with irony
Animal House or Caddyshack or any other "slob vs. snob" movie - all about how "losers" and "misfits" are much more fun to hang out with than captains of the football team or captains of industry
Fry is categorically wrong.





