It finally happened in real life "I'm a republican"
#1
It finally happened in real life "I'm a republican"
In this time of lock down, I am back at college studying via Zoom.
The instructor sometimes picks on me for my English/Britishness, he is quite chatty and likes to joke.
He wanted examples of US versus British democracy, to go over Task Analysis, he asked me to get the British examples rolling, I gave him Monarch as head of State.
Later he asks me if Charles will ever he head of State, "I hope not" I say. He sounds genuinely shocked, "I am a republican" I offer as explanation.
"small r, republican" I add realizing my mistake. The session comes to an end, and I realize my explanation addendum probably didnt make things any clearer.
Now on Monday when we Zoom again, do I explain or just forget it?
The instructor sometimes picks on me for my English/Britishness, he is quite chatty and likes to joke.
He wanted examples of US versus British democracy, to go over Task Analysis, he asked me to get the British examples rolling, I gave him Monarch as head of State.
Later he asks me if Charles will ever he head of State, "I hope not" I say. He sounds genuinely shocked, "I am a republican" I offer as explanation.
"small r, republican" I add realizing my mistake. The session comes to an end, and I realize my explanation addendum probably didnt make things any clearer.
Now on Monday when we Zoom again, do I explain or just forget it?
#2
Forum Regular
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 211
Re: It finally happened in real life "I'm a republican"
What field is this instructor in? Anyway, it's true that many/most Americans don't know what 'republican' means in the British context unless you explain it to them.
#3
Re: It finally happened in real life "I'm a republican"
In this time of lock down, I am back at college studying via Zoom.
The instructor sometimes picks on me for my English/Britishness, he is quite chatty and likes to joke.
He wanted examples of US versus British democracy, to go over Task Analysis, he asked me to get the British examples rolling, I gave him Monarch as head of State.
Later he asks me if Charles will ever he head of State, "I hope not" I say. He sounds genuinely shocked, "I am a republican" I offer as explanation.
"small r, republican" I add realizing my mistake. The session comes to an end, and I realize my explanation addendum probably didnt make things any clearer.
Now on Monday when we Zoom again, do I explain or just forget it?
The instructor sometimes picks on me for my English/Britishness, he is quite chatty and likes to joke.
He wanted examples of US versus British democracy, to go over Task Analysis, he asked me to get the British examples rolling, I gave him Monarch as head of State.
Later he asks me if Charles will ever he head of State, "I hope not" I say. He sounds genuinely shocked, "I am a republican" I offer as explanation.
"small r, republican" I add realizing my mistake. The session comes to an end, and I realize my explanation addendum probably didnt make things any clearer.
Now on Monday when we Zoom again, do I explain or just forget it?
Vive la différence
And the misunderstanding
ps: You could muddy the perennial "pond" even more on Mon. by reminding him of James Madison's famous utterance
Last edited by MMcD; Jun 12th 2020 at 4:12 pm.
#4
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Mar 2017
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 455
Re: It finally happened in real life "I'm a republican"
#5
Re: It finally happened in real life "I'm a republican"
Depends on what subject you're studying.
If it's Poli/Sci I wouldn't bother, he probably did get it.
If it's Liberal Arts, then an expanded explanation will probably make things clearer.
If it's Poli/Sci I wouldn't bother, he probably did get it.
If it's Liberal Arts, then an expanded explanation will probably make things clearer.
#6
Re: It finally happened in real life "I'm a republican"
If you want to dare to offer more tongue in cheek confusion, you could always say, "absolutely do I believe in - Make America Great .... Britain, Again" .....
#8
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jan 2017
Posts: 2,900
Re: It finally happened in real life "I'm a republican"
In this time of lock down, I am back at college studying via Zoom.
The instructor sometimes picks on me for my English/Britishness, he is quite chatty and likes to joke.
He wanted examples of US versus British democracy, to go over Task Analysis, he asked me to get the British examples rolling, I gave him Monarch as head of State.
Later he asks me if Charles will ever he head of State, "I hope not" I say. He sounds genuinely shocked, "I am a republican" I offer as explanation.
"small r, republican" I add realizing my mistake. The session comes to an end, and I realize my explanation addendum probably didnt make things any clearer.
Now on Monday when we Zoom again, do I explain or just forget it?
The instructor sometimes picks on me for my English/Britishness, he is quite chatty and likes to joke.
He wanted examples of US versus British democracy, to go over Task Analysis, he asked me to get the British examples rolling, I gave him Monarch as head of State.
Later he asks me if Charles will ever he head of State, "I hope not" I say. He sounds genuinely shocked, "I am a republican" I offer as explanation.
"small r, republican" I add realizing my mistake. The session comes to an end, and I realize my explanation addendum probably didnt make things any clearer.
Now on Monday when we Zoom again, do I explain or just forget it?
#9
Re: It finally happened in real life "I'm a republican"
FWIW when I am asked about the royal family I always mention that the alternative is that you end up with a head of state mired in party politics and it doesn't matter whether you're a Republican, and Democrat, or a center-ground floater, there has to be some value in having a head of state who can be above the political BS. I am resigned to spending about 40-50%% of my life, on average, utterly disgusted with the occupant of the Whitehouse.
Last edited by Pulaski; Jun 17th 2020 at 11:19 pm.
#10
Forum Regular
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 211
Re: It finally happened in real life "I'm a republican"
FWIW when I am asked about the royal family I always mention that the alternative is that you end up with a head of state mired in party politics and it doesn't matter whether you're a Republican, and Democrat, or a center-ground floater, there has to be some value in having a head of state who can be above the political BS. I am resigned to spending about 40-50%% of my life, on average, utterly disgusted with the occupant of the Whitehouse.
#11
Re: It finally happened in real life "I'm a republican"
They also have a multi-party/ PR electoral system, (unlike the UK and US, which have predominantly a two party system) so there is more often broad political centre-ground support for leading political figures.