British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Spain (https://britishexpats.com/forum/spain-75/)
-   -   Interpreter for Hospital Appointments (https://britishexpats.com/forum/spain-75/interpreter-hospital-appointments-828667/)

Domino Mar 15th 2014 8:27 am

Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 
on visiting the Anaesthethist at the local hospital we were told that we shouldn't be there without an interpreter and this should be provided by the local GP's practice at our local Central Salud.

anyone any information on this please ??

Rosemary Mar 15th 2014 8:52 am

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 
In my area if you need an interpreter it is up to you to find one and pay them but I understand that in some places this is different.

Rosemary

lynnxa Mar 15th 2014 9:02 am

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 
it's definitely different in different areas

at my centro de salud you'd need to take a private interpreter, but at teh hospital there is just about always a free one available on the wards & in urgencias, but you need a private one for outpatients appointments

Rosemary Mar 15th 2014 9:21 am

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 
I suppose that it may also be down to how geared up an area is regarding expats.

Rosemary

HBG Mar 15th 2014 10:44 am

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 
In my heavily populated expat area interpreters are now big business, sadly. Many doctors and consultants insist on their British patients coming with an interpreter, which is understandable in serious cases where there shouldn't be any room for mistakes when a condition is life threatening.

There is an ample choice of interpreters for patients, with an accompanying ample choice of translating skills, some of which are woeful.

The average charges appear to be 20 Euros an hour and I know of many expats who have had to go home when they could no longer afford to pay them.

In more charitable times some interpreters offered their services for free on occasions, but those times are long gone.

lynnxa Mar 15th 2014 7:59 pm

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 

Originally Posted by HBG (Post 11174832)
In my heavily populated expat area interpreters are now big business, sadly. Many doctors and consultants insist on their British patients coming with an interpreter, which is understandable in serious cases where there shouldn't be any room for mistakes when a condition is life threatening.

There is an ample choice of interpreters for patients, with an accompanying ample choice of translating skills, some of which are woeful.

The average charges appear to be 20 Euros an hour and I know of many expats who have had to go home when they could no longer afford to pay them.

In more charitable times some interpreters offered their services for free on occasions, but those times are long gone.

yes - 20€ an hour which includes travelling & waiting time!

I've sat in the waiting area of outpatients at our hospital & heard the appalling Spanish of some of these 'interpreters' - their basic skills are often poor, so how they manage with the medical stuff is anyone's guess :(

I'm often asked to accompany people to the hospital, or translate medical records - I always refuse

in my opinion only someone who has specifically studied to be a medical translator should do this

surreygirl Mar 15th 2014 8:57 pm

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 
Most hospitals have interpreters who work as volunteers and as such their Spanish is very good. Inquire at the hospital you are going if they have interpreters available. If they do the anesthetist will ask one to join you. You dont say where you are and what hospital you are going to.

jackytoo Mar 15th 2014 9:40 pm

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 
The CDS hospital in Marbella has a large team of voluntary interpreters run by a co-ordinator. Available in many languages. OH did it for about a year....he even had to pay his own parking:sneaky:

Rosemary Mar 15th 2014 10:15 pm

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 

Originally Posted by Domino (Post 11174629)
on visiting the Anaesthethist at the local hospital we were told that we shouldn't be there without an interpreter and this should be provided by the local GP's practice at our local Central Salud.

anyone any information on this please ??


Originally Posted by surreygirl (Post 11175195)
Most hospitals have interpreters who work as volunteers and as such their Spanish is very good. Inquire at the hospital you are going if they have interpreters available. If they do the anesthetist will ask one to join you. You dont say where you are and what hospital you are going to.

Surreygirl, if you re-read Domino´s post you will see that the anaesthetist did not provide an interpreter but expected that the central de salud would. Domino is in Granada.

Saying that most hospitals have interpreters is misleading as many do not.

Rosemary

surreygirl Mar 15th 2014 11:06 pm

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 

Originally Posted by Rosemary (Post 11175247)
Surreygirl, if you re-read Domino´s post you will see that the anaesthetist did not provide an interpreter but expected that the central de salud would. Domino is in Granada.

Saying that most hospitals have interpreters is misleading as many do not.

Rosemary

It is not misleading at all as many do. I am merely asking the OP to inquire at the hospital she is attending to find out if they have that facility so I do not know how that can be misleading:confused:

lynnxa Mar 15th 2014 11:58 pm

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 

Originally Posted by surreygirl (Post 11175267)
It is not misleading at all as many do. I am merely asking the OP to inquire at the hospital she is attending to find out if they have that facility so I do not know how that can be misleading:confused:

you said 'most' - & it was the specialist at the hospital who told him to bring an interpreter from the centro de salud


which just goes to show how things can be very different in different areas

bxpuser24710519 Mar 16th 2014 12:34 am

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 

Originally Posted by surreygirl (Post 11175267)
It is not misleading at all as many do. I am merely asking the OP to inquire at the hospital she is attending to find out if they have that facility so I do not know how that can be misleading:confused:

Most hospitals may have BUT getting them is an art all of its own where I lived in the past. Here where I am now the local clinic can be good bad or indifferent depending on the day the month, the staff and the patient.

I think you will find that the OP is a man, clue in (little ..sorry Domino ) :) blue symbol by the user name.

surreygirl Mar 16th 2014 12:38 am

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 

Originally Posted by lynnxa (Post 11175290)
you said 'most' - & it was the specialist at the hospital who told him to bring an interpreter from the centro de salud


which just goes to show how things can be very different in different areas

I did say "most" and most do, I have not said "all" and obvious there are some or the anetheatist would not of asked the OP to bring one from the centro de salud!! I am sorry I do not know what your argument is/are. Most does not mean "all" it means most ie most do but some dont!! ALL three of the hospitals and all of the centro de saluds I visit have translators available so to me that is most!

surreygirl Mar 16th 2014 12:44 am

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 

Originally Posted by The Capitans Wench (Post 11175303)
Most hospitals may have BUT getting them is an art all of its own where I lived in the past. Here where I am now the local clinic can be good bad or indifferent depending on the day the month, the staff and the patient.

I think you will find that the OP is a man, clue in (little ..sorry Domino ) :) blue symbol by the user name.

True but there is no harm in trying is there if you need a translator you need a translator and so you have to - as with everything in life - check out all avenues and if that is no good than the only option is to pay for one. The only thing people are trying to do is to help the OP and that can only be by making suggestions.

lynnxa Mar 16th 2014 2:26 am

Re: Interpreter for Hospital Appointments
 

Originally Posted by surreygirl (Post 11175306)
I did say "most" and most do, I have not said "all" and obvious there are some or the anetheatist would not of asked the OP to bring one from the centro de salud!! I am sorry I do not know what your argument is/are. Most does not mean "all" it means most ie most do but some dont!! ALL three of the hospitals and all of the centro de saluds I visit have translators available so to me that is most!

but neither centro de salud in my town, nor the two nearest hospitals do, for outpatients appointments

so in my area that means none.....

although I do know that many in other areas do have them


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 4:24 am.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.