British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Spain (https://britishexpats.com/forum/spain-75/)
-   -   Impossible for Expats to return to UK? (https://britishexpats.com/forum/spain-75/impossible-expats-return-uk-935933/)

megmet Dec 4th 2020 4:07 am

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 
Family members with UK citizenship or settled status can live permanently in the UK and will not need to take further action to do so.

Family members without UK citizenship or settled status will be able to live permanently in the UK subject to immigration rules,

This was copied directly off the UK Government site, so it's obviously untrue to say UK citizens can't return, it came about through bad journalism.

Notdunroamin Dec 8th 2020 4:33 am

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 
Never let the truth get in the way of a good headline!

quixote Dec 8th 2020 5:19 am

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 

This was copied directly off the UK Government site, so it's obviously untrue to say UK citizens can't return, it came about through bad journalism.
A citizen can always return, but if returning is only possible without the prospect of his/her family joining ever then that's a very qualified right, it's true to say not all British citizens have the right to return with their immediate family, and that that limitation applies to a great many more people after the end of the transition period.

missile Dec 8th 2020 8:47 am

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 

Originally Posted by quixote (Post 12944144)
A citizen can always return, but if returning is only possible without the prospect of his/her family joining ever then that's a very qualified right, it's true to say not all British citizens have the right to return with their immediate family, and that that limitation applies to a great many more people after the end of the transition period.

I believe that has always been the case for those who are married to a non EU national? Now we are leaving EU, it should come as no surprise that partners who are not UK citizens will require permission to reside in UK. BoJo is taking back control of our borders :-(

Chipmonk Dec 8th 2020 5:55 pm

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 
All nationals living outside of UK prior to Brexit and married to EU partners should have been granted the right to return at anytime. Changing a law like Brexit does punishes law abiding citizens and is immoral

BEVS Dec 8th 2020 6:07 pm

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 

Originally Posted by missile (Post 12944208)
I believe that has always been the case for those who are married to a non EU national? Now we are leaving EU, it should come as no surprise that partners who are not UK citizens will require permission to reside in UK.

OK, So I do not get this really. What's the issue? There is a visa AFAIK that allows the partners of UK citizens to join, go and live in the UK with their partner. They do however need to meet the UK criteria regarding relationship , income , support , work and the like.

The UK decided to leave the EU so the above will then pertain if whoever are not already relocated. This is what is applicable for all those outside of the EU so will surely be applicable once the UK is not a part of the EU. Why would this not be so or unfair. It was a choice the UK took.

Same re UK state pensions really.

This is no different to many many countries and their immigration policies with regard to non-citizen/resident partners and family. One needs to meet the requirements & be habitually resident.



Chipmonk Dec 8th 2020 6:22 pm

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 

Originally Posted by BEVS (Post 12944318)
OK, So I do not get this really. What's the issue? There is a visa AFAIK that allows the partners of UK citizens to join, go and live in the UK with their partner. They do however need to meet the UK criteria regarding relationship , income , support , work and the like.

The UK decided to leave the EU so the above will then pertain if whoever are not already relocated. This is what is applicable for all those outside of the EU so will surely be applicable once the UK is not a part of the EU. Why would this not be so or unfair. It was a choice the UK took.

Same re UK state pensions really.

This is no different to many many countries and their immigration policies with regard to non-citizen/resident partners and family. One needs to meet the requirements & be habitually resident.


It is unfair because some UK / EU families moved to EU countries to work, live ,have families etc. Many did this well before there was any hint of Brexit. Their actions were legal and at no point could they have foreseen Brexit. These people now find themselves faced with a situation where they have to meet stringent conditions to return. The income requirements and type of jobs determines if they can bring their families. In many cases they lived in UK before moving and contributed tax and NI. My non EU wife cannot return to UK having lived there for 20 years. She has property there which she pays UK tax on. She even paid for a private pension. Is that fair that the UK government should consider her a drain on their resources when she actually contributes to them?

missile Dec 8th 2020 6:30 pm

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 

Originally Posted by Chipmonk (Post 12944317)
All nationals living outside of UK prior to Brexit and married to EU partners should have been granted the right to return at anytime. Changing a law like Brexit does punishes law abiding citizens and is immoral

Why? That is what "we" voted for. Taking back control of "our" borders <LOL>

missile Dec 8th 2020 6:32 pm

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 

Originally Posted by BEVS (Post 12944318)
OK, So I do not get this really. What's the issue? There is a visa AFAIK that allows the partners of UK citizens to join, go and live in the UK with their partner. They do however need to meet the UK criteria regarding relationship , income , support , work and the like.

The UK decided to leave the EU so the above will then pertain if whoever are not already relocated. This is what is applicable for all those outside of the EU so will surely be applicable once the UK is not a part of the EU. Why would this not be so or unfair. It was a choice the UK took.

Same re UK state pensions really.

This is no different to many many countries and their immigration policies with regard to non-citizen/resident partners and family. One needs to meet the requirements & be habitually resident.

Exactly :-)

Chipmonk Dec 8th 2020 7:01 pm

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 

Originally Posted by missile (Post 12944331)
Why? That is what "we" voted for. Taking back control of "our" borders <LOL>

We= English

missile Dec 8th 2020 7:31 pm

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 

Originally Posted by Chipmonk (Post 12944346)
We= English

Better together <LOL>

Chipmonk Dec 8th 2020 7:43 pm

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 

Originally Posted by missile (Post 12944351)
Better together <LOL>

I imagine if Boris refuses to accept a trade deal then Scotland will call a referendum after May elections. Polls show a definitive lead for independence at moment and a no deal will most likely convert more Scots to vote Yes as a means to rejoin the EU

bfg69bug Dec 8th 2020 7:43 pm

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 

Originally Posted by Chipmonk (Post 12944346)
We= English


shouldn´t it be "We = any person that was allowed to vote" ? i think you´ll find that thres alot of non-english people who voted.

missile Dec 8th 2020 7:53 pm

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 

Originally Posted by Chipmonk (Post 12944354)
I imagine if Boris refuses to accept a trade deal then Scotland will call a referendum after May elections. Polls show a definitive lead for independence at moment and a no deal will most likely convert more Scots to vote Yes as a means to rejoin the EU

I would imagine most Scots, Welsh and Northern Irish will welcome independence as an opportunity, the only benefit and possibly the best outcome from the Brexit fiasco.

Chipmonk Dec 8th 2020 8:00 pm

Re: Impossible for Expats to return to UK?
 

Originally Posted by missile (Post 12944359)
I would imagine most Scots, Welsh and Northern Irish will welcome independence as an opportunity, the only benefit and possibly the best outcome from the Brexit fiasco.

I think that we could possibly be about to to witness a colossal historical moment in the next 24 hours. If a no deal is allowed it will be ( privately) what the SNP want. It will be the start of a process that will change irreversibly the nature of identity, culture, and nationaliy of everyone in the UK. It will not be seen as the result of exterior consequences but solely the politics of one single party and a few dozen MPs. RIP UK!!!


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 2:15 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.