bobd22

The problem I see is say you got your new TIE December 2020 and you were a permanent resident your TIE would be valid for 10 years if temporary resident your TIE would be valid 5 years. It could be that in 18 months your UK passport runs out when you renew it you will get a new passport number. Are you suggesting that when we renew our passport we then need to renew or update our TIE?

SanNico

Yes, it was Madrid airport. We are both residents and we presented passports along with residency cards. My understanding is that all non EU passports should be stamped. Certainly the other half has had hers stamped every time we travel outside of the Schengen zone. My son has flown from the UK to Madrid twice since Brexit and has not had his stamped on either occasion.

Regarding the PCR, I believe it's a random check but they were checking every passenger for the FCS health control form/QR code.

DLC

I don't think they would issue a new card, they would just note the new passport number.

This says we have 30 days to tell them about a change in circumstances and cites the law.

But even though they do know, I still wouldn't try entering without showing my card.

bobd22

Thanks that's interesting and something I wasn't aware of, as you say it was no doubt the same with green card.

Lynn R

I renewed my old cuidadano de la Union resident certificate when I got a new passport - used the option "cambio de documento de identidad" option on the EX23 form.

bobd22

As per the link I attached on an earlier post some officials have been stamping the passports of people who are resident which shouldn't happen.

Notdunroamin

I got my TIE in early August so amongst the early traches.

It has a chip in the top LH corner just by the e-MRTD symbol.

It's readable on a mobile phone with NFC although the info revealed seems to relate only to the chip type and technology as apart from Card/Tag Serial no. (edited out) there is nothing which appears personal to me.

Notdunroamin

Regarding stamps.

According to the 2019 Schengen Handbook p.56

6.2.
No entry or exit stamp must be affixed in the following cases:
a) to the travel documents of nationals of the EU Member States, Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein and Switzerland;
b) to the travel documents of Heads of State and dignitaries whose arrival has been officially announced in advance through diplomatic channels;
c) to pilots' licences or the certificates of aircraft crew members;
d) to the travel documents of seamen who are present within the territory of a Schengen State only when their ship calls in and in the area of the port of call;
e) to the travel documents of crew and passengers of cruise ships who are not subject to border checks, in those cases provided for in point 2, Section IV;
f) to documents enabling nationals of Andorra, Monaco and San Marino to cross the border;
g) to documents of border residents enjoying a local border traffic regime (point 3, Section II).
h) to the travel documents of crews of passengers and goods trains on international connections;
i) to the travel documents of nationals of third countries who present a residence card provided for in Directive 2004/38/EC.
The travel document of family members of EU, EEA and CH citizens who are third-country nationals must also be stamped, unless they present a residence card issued in
accordance with Directive 2004/38/EC as submitted in line with Article 39 of the Schengen Border Code or otherwise clearly indicating a family member of an EU citizen or
a family member of an EEA or CH citizen.

The last item j) is what relates to TIE holders.

It goes on to say: p.68

"There can be cases where a stamp that has already been affixed on a passport has to be
annulled (for example, if the wrong stamp was affixed by mistake by the border guard). In
such cases, the traveller bears no responsibility for it and therefore the stamp cannot be
cancelled in the same ways as when a person is refused entry. It is therefore recommended
to annul the stamp by running two parallel lines through the top left-hand corner of it like
in the example below:

EU.flag

Very wrong guess.
When passport is swiped, its checked for red flags on SIS II system for lost/stolen/wanted/banned flags. That's why you must present your residency card, which can be scanned against national registar database.
https://edps.europa.eu/data-protecti...tion-system_en

Rosemary

We all know that what is written down is often not what actually occurs. There will be many conflicting stories of peoples experiences compared with what should happen.

Rosemary

DLC

I do know that they can obtain the passport number by swiping the residency card (saw the screen when getting a green certificate ages ago) and they can obtain the NIE by swiping the passport (went to social security and asked for my Vida Laboral and gave them my passport and it came back with my NIE) so I assume this information is available to border police.

But I wouldn't leave Spain without my TIE now, unlike the green certificate which I never took with me.

Barriej

Agree with this.

But, can I ask with my Mr sensible hat on?

Does it actually matter if your passport gets stamped or not?
If you are legally resident here (TIE or green card) the stamp wont mean anything. (or shouldn't)
If you are a tourist it will (or should)

Unless someone is saying that, if I get a stamp when coming into Spain from the Uk even as a resident. The next time I leave its going to get me questioned as to why there is a stamp and why I overstayed??

I for one may start asking for the bloody thing to be stamped, its what it was made for after all.

bobd22

I Would guess (I don't know) it probably wouldn't be an issue really in Spain as you would have your TIE or Green card. However I think it may cause an issue if visiting other Schengen countries as they will see the stamp saying you arrived in Schengen zone as per the stamp?

Joppa

Always show your residency document whenever you travel in Schengen/EU together with your passport, so there will be no misunderstanding of your status as resident in a Schengen/EU state.

agree_to_disagree

EU is not a 'state', it is a 'union' of countries.