Border Control
#152
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Dec 2020
Posts: 702
Re: Border Control
God knows how that’s going to work. Do they just stamp on top of stamps?
#153
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jun 2017
Location: Alicante
Posts: 928
Re: Border Control
First and foremost it's always the travellers responsibity to ensure that there is space in a passport for a visa and the recommendation is that two full pages are kept available for that.
Obviously I don't know the actual size of the Schengen stamp but I wouldn't imagine it to be excessively large leading to the possibility of accommodating perhaps four on a page equating to two round trips.
That being so a standard UK passport should be good for about a year's worth of weekend visits, or a couple of years in the case of the 50 page frequent traveller one, after which it will need replacing, an expense and inconvenience you will need to factor into your travel plans.
Obviously I don't know the actual size of the Schengen stamp but I wouldn't imagine it to be excessively large leading to the possibility of accommodating perhaps four on a page equating to two round trips.
That being so a standard UK passport should be good for about a year's worth of weekend visits, or a couple of years in the case of the 50 page frequent traveller one, after which it will need replacing, an expense and inconvenience you will need to factor into your travel plans.
#154
Re: Border Control
The Spanish would put their stamps on a clean area of a page, often bypass clean pages or maybe a single stamp, therefore passports would only last few weeks.
Fortunately a new Gibraltar passport could then have been issued within 24 hrs.
Spaniards were stamped in and out of Spain plus also into Gibraltar, Three stamps a day!
#155
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 1,153
Re: Border Control
6.4. It may also happen that, in practice, the document enabling a third-country national to cross the border is no longer suitable for affixing a stamp, as there are no longer available pages. In such a case, the third-country national should be recommended to apply for a new passport, so that stamps can continue to be affixed there in the future.
However, as an exception- and particularly in the case of regular cross-border commuters- a separate sheet can be used, to which further stamps can be affixed. The sheet must be given to the third-country national.
In any case, the lack of empty pages in a passport is not, in itself, a valid and sufficient ground to refuse the entry of a person (see point 8, Section I, on the grounds for refusal).
However, as an exception- and particularly in the case of regular cross-border commuters- a separate sheet can be used, to which further stamps can be affixed. The sheet must be given to the third-country national.
In any case, the lack of empty pages in a passport is not, in itself, a valid and sufficient ground to refuse the entry of a person (see point 8, Section I, on the grounds for refusal).
#156
Re: Border Control
If I was border guard and there was no free space for stamp, I would be tempted to stamp it on passport photo. :-)
Or passenger forehead, if he objects to photo stamp.
Or passenger forehead, if he objects to photo stamp.
#157
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Feb 2020
Location: Nerja
Posts: 601
Re: Border Control
If there is absolutely no room left on passport pages, the normal border practice is to stamp on a separate sheet of paper and staple it to the passport, with an advice that the holder should get a new passport.
#158
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Feb 2015
Posts: 513
Re: Border Control
Flew recently from a Balkan country direct to Germany - with UK passport.
Immigration stamped it on entry.
Returned via a transit in Vienna yesterday. No passport check between Germany and Austria and Immigration check on leaving Vienna.
Immigration officer didn't stamp passport, but swiped it. I asked him why no stamp out of Schengen area - his reply was "I'm not allowed to."
I asked him if, because he swiped it, there is a record of me leaving Schengen, namely at Austria so as to not affect my 90/180 day allowance ( - if I enter Schengen via another country later and so it can be seen how long I stayed this time.)
His reply was, "I'm not allowed to stamp it."
That didn't really answer my question (I just wanted confirmation that swiping makes a record and no need then for a stamp) so I asked him, "If you're not allowed to stamp me out, why did the official in Germany stamp me in?"
His attitude became tetchy and his reply was, "I'm not allowed to (stamp it)."
I wasn't in a position to stand there and discuss more as our connection was late and we had to rush to get the next plane anyway.
Any of that make sense?
(Just in case anyone wonders if there was a miscommunication due to language, this was in German which I speak well enough and his answer was always a short, "Ich darf nicht," which was easy enough to understand and translate.)
Immigration stamped it on entry.
Returned via a transit in Vienna yesterday. No passport check between Germany and Austria and Immigration check on leaving Vienna.
Immigration officer didn't stamp passport, but swiped it. I asked him why no stamp out of Schengen area - his reply was "I'm not allowed to."
I asked him if, because he swiped it, there is a record of me leaving Schengen, namely at Austria so as to not affect my 90/180 day allowance ( - if I enter Schengen via another country later and so it can be seen how long I stayed this time.)
His reply was, "I'm not allowed to stamp it."
That didn't really answer my question (I just wanted confirmation that swiping makes a record and no need then for a stamp) so I asked him, "If you're not allowed to stamp me out, why did the official in Germany stamp me in?"
His attitude became tetchy and his reply was, "I'm not allowed to (stamp it)."
I wasn't in a position to stand there and discuss more as our connection was late and we had to rush to get the next plane anyway.
Any of that make sense?
(Just in case anyone wonders if there was a miscommunication due to language, this was in German which I speak well enough and his answer was always a short, "Ich darf nicht," which was easy enough to understand and translate.)
Last edited by Mark604; May 13th 2021 at 4:29 pm.
#159
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Dec 2020
Posts: 702
Re: Border Control
Flew recently from a Balkan country direct to Germany - with UK passport.
Immigration stamped it on entry.
Returned via a transit in Vienna yesterday. No passport check between Germany and Austria and Immigration check on leaving Vienna.
Immigration officer didn't stamp passport, but swiped it. I asked him why no stamp out of Schengen area - his reply was "I'm not allowed to."
I asked him if, because he swiped it, there is a record of me leaving Schengen, namely at Austria so as to not affect my 90/180 day allowance ( - if I enter Schengen via another country later and so it can be seen how long I stayed this time.)
His reply was, "I'm not allowed to stamp it."
That didn't really answer my question (I just wanted confirmation that swiping makes a record and no need then for a stamp) so I asked him, "If you're not allowed to stamp me out, why did the official in Germany stamp me in?"
His attitude became tetchy and his reply was, "I'm not allowed to (stamp it)."
I wasn't in a position to stand there and discuss more as our connection was late and we had to rush to get the next plane anyway.
Any of that make sense?
(Just in case anyone wonders if there was a miscommunication due to language, this was in German which I speak well enough and his answer was always a short, "Ich darf nicht," which was easy enough to understand and translate.)
Immigration stamped it on entry.
Returned via a transit in Vienna yesterday. No passport check between Germany and Austria and Immigration check on leaving Vienna.
Immigration officer didn't stamp passport, but swiped it. I asked him why no stamp out of Schengen area - his reply was "I'm not allowed to."
I asked him if, because he swiped it, there is a record of me leaving Schengen, namely at Austria so as to not affect my 90/180 day allowance ( - if I enter Schengen via another country later and so it can be seen how long I stayed this time.)
His reply was, "I'm not allowed to stamp it."
That didn't really answer my question (I just wanted confirmation that swiping makes a record and no need then for a stamp) so I asked him, "If you're not allowed to stamp me out, why did the official in Germany stamp me in?"
His attitude became tetchy and his reply was, "I'm not allowed to (stamp it)."
I wasn't in a position to stand there and discuss more as our connection was late and we had to rush to get the next plane anyway.
Any of that make sense?
(Just in case anyone wonders if there was a miscommunication due to language, this was in German which I speak well enough and his answer was always a short, "Ich darf nicht," which was easy enough to understand and translate.)
#160
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 1,153
Re: Border Control
And I'm pretty sure all of the points you've raised so far in this thread are answered in the Border Guards Handbook.
In this case it may be due to visa-free travel between the Schengen area and Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Montenegro, North Macedonia, and Serbia.
In this case it may be due to visa-free travel between the Schengen area and Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Montenegro, North Macedonia, and Serbia.
#161
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Feb 2020
Location: Nerja
Posts: 601
Re: Border Control
Flew recently from a Balkan country direct to Germany - with UK passport.
Immigration stamped it on entry.
Returned via a transit in Vienna yesterday. No passport check between Germany and Austria and Immigration check on leaving Vienna.
Immigration officer didn't stamp passport, but swiped it. I asked him why no stamp out of Schengen area - his reply was "I'm not allowed to."
I asked him if, because he swiped it, there is a record of me leaving Schengen, namely at Austria so as to not affect my 90/180 day allowance ( - if I enter Schengen via another country later and so it can be seen how long I stayed this time.)
His reply was, "I'm not allowed to stamp it."
That didn't really answer my question (I just wanted confirmation that swiping makes a record and no need then for a stamp) so I asked him, "If you're not allowed to stamp me out, why did the official in Germany stamp me in?"
His attitude became tetchy and his reply was, "I'm not allowed to (stamp it)."
I wasn't in a position to stand there and discuss more as our connection was late and we had to rush to get the next plane anyway.
Any of that make sense?
(Just in case anyone wonders if there was a miscommunication due to language, this was in German which I speak well enough and his answer was always a short, "Ich darf nicht," which was easy enough to understand and translate.)
Immigration stamped it on entry.
Returned via a transit in Vienna yesterday. No passport check between Germany and Austria and Immigration check on leaving Vienna.
Immigration officer didn't stamp passport, but swiped it. I asked him why no stamp out of Schengen area - his reply was "I'm not allowed to."
I asked him if, because he swiped it, there is a record of me leaving Schengen, namely at Austria so as to not affect my 90/180 day allowance ( - if I enter Schengen via another country later and so it can be seen how long I stayed this time.)
His reply was, "I'm not allowed to stamp it."
That didn't really answer my question (I just wanted confirmation that swiping makes a record and no need then for a stamp) so I asked him, "If you're not allowed to stamp me out, why did the official in Germany stamp me in?"
His attitude became tetchy and his reply was, "I'm not allowed to (stamp it)."
I wasn't in a position to stand there and discuss more as our connection was late and we had to rush to get the next plane anyway.
Any of that make sense?
(Just in case anyone wonders if there was a miscommunication due to language, this was in German which I speak well enough and his answer was always a short, "Ich darf nicht," which was easy enough to understand and translate.)
#162
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Feb 2015
Posts: 513
Re: Border Control
"In this case it may be due to visa-free travel between the Schengen area and Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Montenegro, North Macedonia, and Serbia."
I'd need that explaining to me. I'm not a resident of any of those and yes, do not need a visa with a UK passport, but then I don't need a visa for Germany/Austria either so I'm not sure what relevance that has as to why being stamped in, but not out.
"And I'm pretty sure all of the points you've raised so far in this thread are answered in the Border Guards Handbook."
6.2. No entry or exit stamp must be affixed in the following cases:
a) to the travel documents of nationals of the EU Member States, Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein and Switzerland;
6.1. The travel documents of all third-country nationals must be stamped systematically on entry and exit.
Stamping is also intended to ensure that it is possible to verify, during checks on entry and exit whether the allowed maximum duration of a third-country national’s stay in the area without internal border controls or in the territory of Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus and Romania taken separately– 90 days in any 180 days period – has been respected.
Unless I've missed something, if the UK is not in the EU it is a third country by which nationals should be stamped in and out. No?
"If you hold residence permit/document for a Schengen state, then your passport should not be stamped in or out." - UK resident, not of a Schengen state otherwise the stamping thing I know, is moot.
I'd need that explaining to me. I'm not a resident of any of those and yes, do not need a visa with a UK passport, but then I don't need a visa for Germany/Austria either so I'm not sure what relevance that has as to why being stamped in, but not out.
"And I'm pretty sure all of the points you've raised so far in this thread are answered in the Border Guards Handbook."
6.2. No entry or exit stamp must be affixed in the following cases:
a) to the travel documents of nationals of the EU Member States, Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein and Switzerland;
6.1. The travel documents of all third-country nationals must be stamped systematically on entry and exit.
Stamping is also intended to ensure that it is possible to verify, during checks on entry and exit whether the allowed maximum duration of a third-country national’s stay in the area without internal border controls or in the territory of Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus and Romania taken separately– 90 days in any 180 days period – has been respected.
Unless I've missed something, if the UK is not in the EU it is a third country by which nationals should be stamped in and out. No?
"If you hold residence permit/document for a Schengen state, then your passport should not be stamped in or out." - UK resident, not of a Schengen state otherwise the stamping thing I know, is moot.
#163
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 1,153
Re: Border Control
Meanwhile, on the UK border:
EU citizens arriving in UK being locked up and expelled
The rules state you are allowed to visit the UK as a tourist to carry out job interviews then apply for a working visa from outside the UK if you have an offer.
This kind of treatment to please the Mail and Express peanut gallery is only going to backfire on Brits visiting or living in the EU.
EU citizens arriving in UK being locked up and expelled
Eugenia, a 24-year-old woman from the Basque region of northern Spain, reached Gatwick on Sunday 2 May on a flight from Bilbao. She planned to look for a job offer, go home to apply for a visa and then return to live with her Spanish boyfriend, an NHS worker who has been in the UK for four years. “I had a return ticket and had filled out an online travel form in which I explained all that,” she said.
At Gatwick, Eugenia had her mobile phone taken away and was locked in a holding room for 24 hours, sleeping on a fold-out bed with half a dozen others. Then she was put on a flight to Barcelona along with another Spanish woman who had arrived for a job interview.
[...]
Eugenia said cabin staff on her return flight had seen several similar cases. Frontier police who met them at Barcelona confirmed this. “They didn’t understand why it was happening. British citizens entering Spain are not treated that way.”
Eugenia said the experience was so traumatic that she had given up on trying to live with her boyfriend. “I’m not going back,” she said. “I don’t want to go through that again. The idea of moving to Britain appals me.”
At Gatwick, Eugenia had her mobile phone taken away and was locked in a holding room for 24 hours, sleeping on a fold-out bed with half a dozen others. Then she was put on a flight to Barcelona along with another Spanish woman who had arrived for a job interview.
[...]
Eugenia said cabin staff on her return flight had seen several similar cases. Frontier police who met them at Barcelona confirmed this. “They didn’t understand why it was happening. British citizens entering Spain are not treated that way.”
Eugenia said the experience was so traumatic that she had given up on trying to live with her boyfriend. “I’m not going back,” she said. “I don’t want to go through that again. The idea of moving to Britain appals me.”
This kind of treatment to please the Mail and Express peanut gallery is only going to backfire on Brits visiting or living in the EU.
#164
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Feb 2020
Location: Nerja
Posts: 601
Re: Border Control
Meanwhile, on the UK border:
EU citizens arriving in UK being locked up and expelled
The rules state you are allowed to visit the UK as a tourist to carry out job interviews then apply for a working visa from outside the UK if you have an offer.
This kind of treatment to please the Mail and Express peanut gallery is only going to backfire on Brits visiting or living in the EU.
EU citizens arriving in UK being locked up and expelled
The rules state you are allowed to visit the UK as a tourist to carry out job interviews then apply for a working visa from outside the UK if you have an offer.
This kind of treatment to please the Mail and Express peanut gallery is only going to backfire on Brits visiting or living in the EU.
#165
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 1,153
Re: Border Control
If every tourist from neighbouring countries who visits the UK has to show evidence of a job or study back home to avoid being held and expelled then something's gone seriously wrong somewhere.