Another curious "Citizenship" case
#1
Thread Starter
Forum Regular




Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 291
From: Costa de Caparica: 2007-2010. Then Olivais, Lisboa: 2010-2017. Currently back in Cambridge, UK.











Has this always been happening, but simply never reported in national newspapers - or have laws tightened up significantly in the past 6 months ?
In a nutshell: Man born in UK in 1974 (to German parents), with birth certificate, lived all his life (42 years) in the UK, asked by Home Office to apply for residency (and prove he can speak English etc). I'd like to think that this another one of those beauracratic type cases - an oversight on the part of the applicant, rather than outright xenophobia.
https://www.theguardian.com/politics...ire-life-in-uk
In a nutshell: Man born in UK in 1974 (to German parents), with birth certificate, lived all his life (42 years) in the UK, asked by Home Office to apply for residency (and prove he can speak English etc). I'd like to think that this another one of those beauracratic type cases - an oversight on the part of the applicant, rather than outright xenophobia.
https://www.theguardian.com/politics...ire-life-in-uk
#2
Has this always been happening, but simply never reported in national newspapers - or have laws tightened up significantly in the past 6 months ?
In a nutshell: Man born in UK in 1974 (to German parents), with birth certificate, lived all his life (42 years) in the UK, asked by Home Office to apply for residency (and prove he can speak English etc). I'd like to think that this another one of those beauracratic type cases - an oversight on the part of the applicant, rather than outright xenophobia.
https://www.theguardian.com/politics...ire-life-in-uk
In a nutshell: Man born in UK in 1974 (to German parents), with birth certificate, lived all his life (42 years) in the UK, asked by Home Office to apply for residency (and prove he can speak English etc). I'd like to think that this another one of those beauracratic type cases - an oversight on the part of the applicant, rather than outright xenophobia.
https://www.theguardian.com/politics...ire-life-in-uk

I'm sure these cases have occurred before, but impending Brexit has drawn focus on them. However, as I've said before, the problem now is that it's almost impossible to get through the bureaucratic smokescreen to actually talk to someone and resolve it. Pressure of demand, allied to cutbacks, have resulted in a system that has no tolerance for anything but straightforward cases.
#3
BE Forum Addict






Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 1,385
From: Viana do Castelo











Seems to me that Home Office is targeting some Europeans first to avoid the Muslims shouting "racism".
#4
Has this always been happening, but simply never reported in national newspapers - or have laws tightened up significantly in the past 6 months ?
In a nutshell: Man born in UK in 1974 (to German parents), with birth certificate, lived all his life (42 years) in the UK, asked by Home Office to apply for residency (and prove he can speak English etc). I'd like to think that this another one of those beauracratic type cases - an oversight on the part of the applicant, rather than outright xenophobia.
https://www.theguardian.com/politics...ire-life-in-uk
In a nutshell: Man born in UK in 1974 (to German parents), with birth certificate, lived all his life (42 years) in the UK, asked by Home Office to apply for residency (and prove he can speak English etc). I'd like to think that this another one of those beauracratic type cases - an oversight on the part of the applicant, rather than outright xenophobia.
https://www.theguardian.com/politics...ire-life-in-uk
Under the rules in force at the time means he would need to demonstrate that his mother, as a citizen of an EEC country, was exercising her Treaty rights in the UK at the time of his birth. If so then he would be a British citizen by birth under Section 1(1)(b) BNA 1981. Not a problem if his parents had bothered to apply for his British passport thirty years ago, more of a problem now.
The Home Office has made it clear it did not ask him to sit a Life in the UK Test exam or apply for residency so The Grauniad's headline is just more of the clickbait 'fake news' they supposedly rail against.
No doubt there are those here who will say it's his fault for his parents being johnny foreigners!
I'm sure these cases have occurred before, but impending Brexit has drawn focus on them. However, as I've said before, the problem now is that it's almost impossible to get through the bureaucratic smokescreen to actually talk to someone and resolve it. Pressure of demand, allied to cutbacks, have resulted in a system that has no tolerance for anything but straightforward cases.

I'm sure these cases have occurred before, but impending Brexit has drawn focus on them. However, as I've said before, the problem now is that it's almost impossible to get through the bureaucratic smokescreen to actually talk to someone and resolve it. Pressure of demand, allied to cutbacks, have resulted in a system that has no tolerance for anything but straightforward cases.
#5
Thread Starter
Forum Regular




Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 291
From: Costa de Caparica: 2007-2010. Then Olivais, Lisboa: 2010-2017. Currently back in Cambridge, UK.











Understood. Seems even the broadsheets (or "quality" papers as they used to be called in my time) are not immune to sensationalising stories.
#7
It's an issue now because of brexit; even those who've lived in the UK all their lives on EU passports now need UK citizenship to be sure they're not going to be kicked out or discriminated against regarding employment and so on, because it is unclear what if any rights they'll retain.
#8
Banned










Joined: Oct 2012
Posts: 26,724











They are either legal or not, ifillegal then they risk deportation..
Nothiig to do with your peculiar viewpoint.




