Do you save in $ or £
#1
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 12
Do you save in $ or £
Hi,
Just trying to figure out what the best course of action is with regards to savings. I'm moving out to Dubai in late June.
My idea so far: as the AED is pegged to the USD, if I open an offshore USD savings account - I will know exactly how much money is being saved each month in a stable currency. Assuming I want to return to the UK in future, and am able to wait till there is a good exchange rate between USD and GBP (good for me, i.e. USD strong against GBP) before I transfer the money back to GBP.
The pitfall for this route is that I'm transferring currency twice, from AED to USD, then USD to GBP. So two fx transactions, although as the amounts will be large from USD to GBP, I would get a reasonable wholesale rate/low spread.
Benefits: the monthly USD savings will be fixed as the currency is pegged. If anything were to happen to the AED (e.g. depeg from USD and suffer on the markets) my savings would be USD and so hopefully secure.
Any views from the experts? Do you save offshore in GBP directly?
Thanks.
Just trying to figure out what the best course of action is with regards to savings. I'm moving out to Dubai in late June.
My idea so far: as the AED is pegged to the USD, if I open an offshore USD savings account - I will know exactly how much money is being saved each month in a stable currency. Assuming I want to return to the UK in future, and am able to wait till there is a good exchange rate between USD and GBP (good for me, i.e. USD strong against GBP) before I transfer the money back to GBP.
The pitfall for this route is that I'm transferring currency twice, from AED to USD, then USD to GBP. So two fx transactions, although as the amounts will be large from USD to GBP, I would get a reasonable wholesale rate/low spread.
Benefits: the monthly USD savings will be fixed as the currency is pegged. If anything were to happen to the AED (e.g. depeg from USD and suffer on the markets) my savings would be USD and so hopefully secure.
Any views from the experts? Do you save offshore in GBP directly?
Thanks.
#2
Re: Do you save in $ or £
Hi,
Just trying to figure out what the best course of action is with regards to savings. I'm moving out to Dubai in late June.
My idea so far: as the AED is pegged to the USD, if I open an offshore USD savings account - I will know exactly how much money is being saved each month in a stable currency. Assuming I want to return to the UK in future, and am able to wait till there is a good exchange rate between USD and GBP (good for me, i.e. USD strong against GBP) before I transfer the money back to GBP.
The pitfall for this route is that I'm transferring currency twice, from AED to USD, then USD to GBP. So two fx transactions, although as the amounts will be large from USD to GBP, I would get a reasonable wholesale rate/low spread.
Benefits: the monthly USD savings will be fixed as the currency is pegged. If anything were to happen to the AED (e.g. depeg from USD and suffer on the markets) my savings would be USD and so hopefully secure.
Any views from the experts? Do you save offshore in GBP directly?
Thanks.
Just trying to figure out what the best course of action is with regards to savings. I'm moving out to Dubai in late June.
My idea so far: as the AED is pegged to the USD, if I open an offshore USD savings account - I will know exactly how much money is being saved each month in a stable currency. Assuming I want to return to the UK in future, and am able to wait till there is a good exchange rate between USD and GBP (good for me, i.e. USD strong against GBP) before I transfer the money back to GBP.
The pitfall for this route is that I'm transferring currency twice, from AED to USD, then USD to GBP. So two fx transactions, although as the amounts will be large from USD to GBP, I would get a reasonable wholesale rate/low spread.
Benefits: the monthly USD savings will be fixed as the currency is pegged. If anything were to happen to the AED (e.g. depeg from USD and suffer on the markets) my savings would be USD and so hopefully secure.
Any views from the experts? Do you save offshore in GBP directly?
Thanks.
Re: Sterling vs USD
If you transfer from AED to GBP on a regular basis (monthly?) over many years then sometimes you'll have done well and sometimes you won't have...it might average out ok.
Or you can take the riskier route and hold USD until you think the GBP is at a favourable (low) rate for you. The way things are in the UK this might be the best course of action....but exchange rates are notoriously difficult to predict at the best of times....let alone right now.
Personally, I'd keep it in USD for now as I think the USD is about to stage some sort of recovery and the sterling has further to fall (looking over the course of the next year...). But who really knows
#3
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 13,553
Re: Do you save in $ or £
Hi,
Just trying to figure out what the best course of action is with regards to savings. I'm moving out to Dubai in late June.
My idea so far: as the AED is pegged to the USD, if I open an offshore USD savings account - I will know exactly how much money is being saved each month in a stable currency. Assuming I want to return to the UK in future, and am able to wait till there is a good exchange rate between USD and GBP (good for me, i.e. USD strong against GBP) before I transfer the money back to GBP.
The pitfall for this route is that I'm transferring currency twice, from AED to USD, then USD to GBP. So two fx transactions, although as the amounts will be large from USD to GBP, I would get a reasonable wholesale rate/low spread.
Benefits: the monthly USD savings will be fixed as the currency is pegged. If anything were to happen to the AED (e.g. depeg from USD and suffer on the markets) my savings would be USD and so hopefully secure.
Any views from the experts? Do you save offshore in GBP directly?
Thanks.
Just trying to figure out what the best course of action is with regards to savings. I'm moving out to Dubai in late June.
My idea so far: as the AED is pegged to the USD, if I open an offshore USD savings account - I will know exactly how much money is being saved each month in a stable currency. Assuming I want to return to the UK in future, and am able to wait till there is a good exchange rate between USD and GBP (good for me, i.e. USD strong against GBP) before I transfer the money back to GBP.
The pitfall for this route is that I'm transferring currency twice, from AED to USD, then USD to GBP. So two fx transactions, although as the amounts will be large from USD to GBP, I would get a reasonable wholesale rate/low spread.
Benefits: the monthly USD savings will be fixed as the currency is pegged. If anything were to happen to the AED (e.g. depeg from USD and suffer on the markets) my savings would be USD and so hopefully secure.
Any views from the experts? Do you save offshore in GBP directly?
Thanks.
I've just passed 33 years in the foreign exchange market/industry (in one form or another), so I'm fully qualified to advise you about the likely future path for exchange rates.
My verdict: I haven't a clue.
As Jeeper says, there are so many factors that influence rates - cross-border trade flows, investment trends, speculators, tourists, etc.
Question - what are you saving for? And where will you be when you finally spend those savings? Do share with us, please.
The GBP is much weaker (i.e. cheaper to buy) than it has been for over a year, so you would already be ahead of the game on that score........
#4
Re: Do you save in $ or £
Firstly - defo don't save in AED. Send savings offshore in a 'real' currency....probably USD.
Re: Sterling vs USD
If you transfer from AED to GBP on a regular basis (monthly?) over many years then sometimes you'll have done well and sometimes you won't have...it might average out ok.
Or you can take the riskier route and hold USD until you think the GBP is at a favourable (low) rate for you. The way things are in the UK this might be the best course of action....but exchange rates are notoriously difficult to predict at the best of times....let alone right now.
Personally, I'd keep it in USD for now as I think the USD is about to stage some sort of recovery and the sterling has further to fall (looking over the course of the next year...). But who really knows
Re: Sterling vs USD
If you transfer from AED to GBP on a regular basis (monthly?) over many years then sometimes you'll have done well and sometimes you won't have...it might average out ok.
Or you can take the riskier route and hold USD until you think the GBP is at a favourable (low) rate for you. The way things are in the UK this might be the best course of action....but exchange rates are notoriously difficult to predict at the best of times....let alone right now.
Personally, I'd keep it in USD for now as I think the USD is about to stage some sort of recovery and the sterling has further to fall (looking over the course of the next year...). But who really knows
Save in USD for now, and start converting to £ in small clumps in a few years pending the situation at that time (if you can wait that long).
#6
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 12
Re: Do you save in $ or £
Hi there..........
Question - what are you saving for? And where will you be when you finally spend those savings? Do share with us, please.
The GBP is much weaker (i.e. cheaper to buy) than it has been for over a year, so you would already be ahead of the game on that score........
Question - what are you saving for? And where will you be when you finally spend those savings? Do share with us, please.
The GBP is much weaker (i.e. cheaper to buy) than it has been for over a year, so you would already be ahead of the game on that score........
Where: probably UK, although could potentially be USA. Most likely a western English speaking country.
When: 5 years? Don't know yet...
Thanks for the advice all who replied!
#8
Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 3,890
Re: Do you save in $ or £
Hi there..........
I've just passed 33 years in the foreign exchange market/industry (in one form or another), so I'm fully qualified to advise you about the likely future path for exchange rates.
My verdict: I haven't a clue.
As Jeeper says, there are so many factors that influence rates - cross-border trade flows, investment trends, speculators, tourists, etc.
Question - what are you saving for? And where will you be when you finally spend those savings? Do share with us, please.
The GBP is much weaker (i.e. cheaper to buy) than it has been for over a year, so you would already be ahead of the game on that score........
I've just passed 33 years in the foreign exchange market/industry (in one form or another), so I'm fully qualified to advise you about the likely future path for exchange rates.
My verdict: I haven't a clue.
As Jeeper says, there are so many factors that influence rates - cross-border trade flows, investment trends, speculators, tourists, etc.
Question - what are you saving for? And where will you be when you finally spend those savings? Do share with us, please.
The GBP is much weaker (i.e. cheaper to buy) than it has been for over a year, so you would already be ahead of the game on that score........
Talking about weak Sterling, do you have a clue at what kind of rate the Eurozone would likely accept Britain's joining the Euro (inevitable sooner or later IMO)? They surely wouldn't take the kinds of 1.1 ratio we are seeing now, would be too much of a competitive advantage. The Pound has halved vs the Yen in the last 2/3 yrs. Funny old game.
Thanks.
#9
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 12
Re: Do you save in $ or £
Yes, I am planning on opening a Jersey HSBC account to begin with, they guarantee upto 50k GBP in savings like the UK Gov scheme. I've banked with HSBC for a long time, happy to use their online banking to transfer money around.
#10
Re: Do you save in $ or £
Hope you don't use them to actually change your cash from one currency to another? Their rates are a rip!
Last edited by Jeeper; Apr 6th 2010 at 4:01 pm. Reason: doh
#11
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 13,553
Re: Do you save in $ or £
The Dean
Talking about weak Sterling, do you have a clue at what kind of rate the Eurozone would likely accept Britain's joining the Euro (inevitable sooner or later IMO)? They surely wouldn't take the kinds of 1.1 ratio we are seeing now, would be too much of a competitive advantage. The Pound has halved vs the Yen in the last 2/3 yrs. Funny old game.
Thanks.
Talking about weak Sterling, do you have a clue at what kind of rate the Eurozone would likely accept Britain's joining the Euro (inevitable sooner or later IMO)? They surely wouldn't take the kinds of 1.1 ratio we are seeing now, would be too much of a competitive advantage. The Pound has halved vs the Yen in the last 2/3 yrs. Funny old game.
Thanks.
That would be my second preference. My first preference would be to get struck by lightning while standing barefoot in a pool of water while holding a metal rod high above my head.
Why on earth would the UK give up the right to control its own economic and monetary policy? Look at the mess the rest have made. Only the basically anti-British Lib Dems even contemplate it at the moment, and they can be ignored.
I predict a different future - the EUR will crumble to pieces before the GBP gets round to joining. It was always a political project, cobbled together by supra-nationalists who didn't understand market forces.
#13
Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 3,890
Re: Do you save in $ or £
The GBP joining the EUR?
That would be my second preference. My first preference would be to get struck by lightning while standing barefoot in a pool of water while holding a metal rod high above my head.
Why on earth would the UK give up the right to control its own economic and monetary policy? Look at the mess the rest have made. Only the basically anti-British Lib Dems even contemplate it at the moment, and they can be ignored.
I predict a different future - the EUR will crumble to pieces before the GBP gets round to joining. It was always a political project, cobbled together by supra-nationalists who didn't understand market forces.
That would be my second preference. My first preference would be to get struck by lightning while standing barefoot in a pool of water while holding a metal rod high above my head.
Why on earth would the UK give up the right to control its own economic and monetary policy? Look at the mess the rest have made. Only the basically anti-British Lib Dems even contemplate it at the moment, and they can be ignored.
I predict a different future - the EUR will crumble to pieces before the GBP gets round to joining. It was always a political project, cobbled together by supra-nationalists who didn't understand market forces.
#14
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Sep 2009
Location: Abu Dhabi
Posts: 1,805
Re: Do you save in $ or £
I'm interested in this thread too, after I've finished Ikea-ing the house I'll be aiming to start some savings.
Christ only knows what currency mind, earning AED and eventually needing BRL. missed the boat on that currency me thinks... I guess USD does seem the safer one since you know what your getting with the AED.