practising law in Canada..
#31
BE Enthusiast




Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 360











Yeh - been there. Partner with 3 degrees up to doctorate level still had to do a uni course to get qualified here. Why do we as immigrants put up with this? Are we just grateful that we have been allowed to come here?
What was amazing on the W5 programme about qualified immigrants not getting jobs is that it did not include UK immigrants in the disaster -they used visible ethnic immigrants. But it happens to all of us. We are included in the racism. We had 2 family members who both went to Australia because of the easier system of becoming qualified there.
What was amazing on the W5 programme about qualified immigrants not getting jobs is that it did not include UK immigrants in the disaster -they used visible ethnic immigrants. But it happens to all of us. We are included in the racism. We had 2 family members who both went to Australia because of the easier system of becoming qualified there.My situation is quite unique, I am doing time for the TN, my long term goals are in the US, and given that takes a good few years, I knew I must qualify here or go crazy!
So, I am hoping it will all be worth it,and as Almost canadian says, we just have to swallow that bitter pill!!!!!!!
Certainly I feel my lifestyle, once admitted to the Bar and earning good money will be far better than I had in England as a legal aid lawyer.
#32
Just Joined
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 9

Hi there,
I'm a newbie here! I was searching the internet concerning british lawyers/law students qualifying for legal jobs in Canada. To my surprise, I came across some quite nasty opinions of British law students/British lawyers. The argument went as follows: British lawyers are not as well trained and do not receive as good an education as in Canada, and Canadian lawyers are protective/borderline zenophobic about giving law jobs to foreign-lawyers. The education issue seemed to centre on the fact that Ca. law degree is postgraduate and the Brit equivalent is undergraduate (despite the fact the bar exams and training contract takes much longer in the UK).
I am not sure how much truth lies in the line of thinking, (possibly I just came across an agressively charged forum full of stressed out lawyers/law students on both sides of the pond). I am in the last year of my PhD studies (so will have a doctrate by the time I would leave britiain, and also a LLM and LLB but I am not professionally qualified). I am seriously considering moving to Canada, and qualifying as a Canadian lawyer from scratch, rather than qualifying in the UK and moving to Canada for requalification.
I would like to know if any of you here practice law in Ca. or teach law in Ca. and if the experience is so negative? or generally, in other professions have you come across a superiority complex about Ca. education being better than British (ironically it's normally the other way around).
Thanks!! Jen
I'm a newbie here! I was searching the internet concerning british lawyers/law students qualifying for legal jobs in Canada. To my surprise, I came across some quite nasty opinions of British law students/British lawyers. The argument went as follows: British lawyers are not as well trained and do not receive as good an education as in Canada, and Canadian lawyers are protective/borderline zenophobic about giving law jobs to foreign-lawyers. The education issue seemed to centre on the fact that Ca. law degree is postgraduate and the Brit equivalent is undergraduate (despite the fact the bar exams and training contract takes much longer in the UK).
I am not sure how much truth lies in the line of thinking, (possibly I just came across an agressively charged forum full of stressed out lawyers/law students on both sides of the pond). I am in the last year of my PhD studies (so will have a doctrate by the time I would leave britiain, and also a LLM and LLB but I am not professionally qualified). I am seriously considering moving to Canada, and qualifying as a Canadian lawyer from scratch, rather than qualifying in the UK and moving to Canada for requalification.
I would like to know if any of you here practice law in Ca. or teach law in Ca. and if the experience is so negative? or generally, in other professions have you come across a superiority complex about Ca. education being better than British (ironically it's normally the other way around).
Thanks!! Jen
I'm glad to see I'm not the only lawyer looking to leave the UK- I guess the system and the country fill us with so much joy we look elsewhere!
I'm currently preparing my application for NCA accreditation, hopefully I will receive a reasonable amount of exemptions. I've been at the Bar full time since since call in 1998, I hold an LLB and an LLM and hope to get the maximum exemptions. The guidance on NCA website seems to suggest 1 or 2 papers will be required, presumably Canadian Constitution and the like.
I applied to CIC in Sept 2006 as a skilled worker and wonder if others would share experiences of job hunting pre or post NCA exams.
Jamie
#33
BE Enthusiast




Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 360











Hi all
I'm glad to see I'm not the only lawyer looking to leave the UK- I guess the system and the country fill us with so much joy we look elsewhere!
I'm currently preparing my application for NCA accreditation, hopefully I will receive a reasonable amount of exemptions. I've been at the Bar full time since since call in 1998, I hold an LLB and an LLM and hope to get the maximum exemptions. The guidance on NCA website seems to suggest 1 or 2 papers will be required, presumably Canadian Constitution and the like.
I applied to CIC in Sept 2006 as a skilled worker and wonder if others would share experiences of job hunting pre or post NCA exams.
Jamie
I'm glad to see I'm not the only lawyer looking to leave the UK- I guess the system and the country fill us with so much joy we look elsewhere!
I'm currently preparing my application for NCA accreditation, hopefully I will receive a reasonable amount of exemptions. I've been at the Bar full time since since call in 1998, I hold an LLB and an LLM and hope to get the maximum exemptions. The guidance on NCA website seems to suggest 1 or 2 papers will be required, presumably Canadian Constitution and the like.
I applied to CIC in Sept 2006 as a skilled worker and wonder if others would share experiences of job hunting pre or post NCA exams.
Jamie
I chose not to go down the Paralegal route pre NCA/School, would not have worked for me.
I found articles a year agao, the firm were prepared to wait for me.
What province are you coming to?
Feel free to PM me.
Almost Canadian is working pre NCA in calgary, he will probably respond and is very helpful.
If you get two exams, it will likely be Tax and Consituitional.
I have passed those two, so again feel free to ask questions.
Good luck
#34
Hi all
I'm glad to see I'm not the only lawyer looking to leave the UK- I guess the system and the country fill us with so much joy we look elsewhere!
I'm currently preparing my application for NCA accreditation, hopefully I will receive a reasonable amount of exemptions. I've been at the Bar full time since since call in 1998, I hold an LLB and an LLM and hope to get the maximum exemptions. The guidance on NCA website seems to suggest 1 or 2 papers will be required, presumably Canadian Constitution and the like.
I applied to CIC in Sept 2006 as a skilled worker and wonder if others would share experiences of job hunting pre or post NCA exams.
Jamie
I'm glad to see I'm not the only lawyer looking to leave the UK- I guess the system and the country fill us with so much joy we look elsewhere!
I'm currently preparing my application for NCA accreditation, hopefully I will receive a reasonable amount of exemptions. I've been at the Bar full time since since call in 1998, I hold an LLB and an LLM and hope to get the maximum exemptions. The guidance on NCA website seems to suggest 1 or 2 papers will be required, presumably Canadian Constitution and the like.
I applied to CIC in Sept 2006 as a skilled worker and wonder if others would share experiences of job hunting pre or post NCA exams.
Jamie
As London7 has said, I have applied to NCA (they said they will inform me of their decision by mid-June) and I am working in a law firm at the moment.
I am "assisting" a litigator who was called less than 2 years ago at the moment and it is painful but something that must be done.
I am in Calgary so feel free to PM me if I can be of any assistance at all.
#35
I am in the last year of my PhD studies (so will have a doctrate by the time I would leave britiain, and also a LLM and LLB but I am not professionally qualified). I am seriously considering moving to Canada, and qualifying as a Canadian lawyer from scratch, rather than qualifying in the UK and moving to Canada for requalification.
#36
BE Enthusiast




Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 360











Hi all
I'm glad to see I'm not the only lawyer looking to leave the UK- I guess the system and the country fill us with so much joy we look elsewhere!
I'm currently preparing my application for NCA accreditation, hopefully I will receive a reasonable amount of exemptions. I've been at the Bar full time since since call in 1998, I hold an LLB and an LLM and hope to get the maximum exemptions. The guidance on NCA website seems to suggest 1 or 2 papers will be required, presumably Canadian Constitution and the like.
I applied to CIC in Sept 2006 as a skilled worker and wonder if others would share experiences of job hunting pre or post NCA exams.
Jamie
I'm glad to see I'm not the only lawyer looking to leave the UK- I guess the system and the country fill us with so much joy we look elsewhere!
I'm currently preparing my application for NCA accreditation, hopefully I will receive a reasonable amount of exemptions. I've been at the Bar full time since since call in 1998, I hold an LLB and an LLM and hope to get the maximum exemptions. The guidance on NCA website seems to suggest 1 or 2 papers will be required, presumably Canadian Constitution and the like.
I applied to CIC in Sept 2006 as a skilled worker and wonder if others would share experiences of job hunting pre or post NCA exams.
Jamie
Your yahoo account keeps bouncing back!
Send a PM to this account, may be easier!
cheers
#38
possibly.
have i missed something. just having a trawl on a lazy sunday morning for an hour, as you do, and it seem to have all kicked off just because 2 people are discussing differences in their profession between the UK and Canada. i don't think i'm cynical or twisted enough to be on here sometimes, which is a surprise let me tell you.
anyway, are you prosecuting/defending criminally. i'm interested if the opposition, is going to be tougher or not over there or whether the version of the CPS does a better job?
have i missed something. just having a trawl on a lazy sunday morning for an hour, as you do, and it seem to have all kicked off just because 2 people are discussing differences in their profession between the UK and Canada. i don't think i'm cynical or twisted enough to be on here sometimes, which is a surprise let me tell you.
anyway, are you prosecuting/defending criminally. i'm interested if the opposition, is going to be tougher or not over there or whether the version of the CPS does a better job?
#39
Thread Starter
Just Joined
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 12

Perhaps you had a life before law but you know that you will not qualify as a skilled worker without some skilled work experience? Or do you have academic work experience? I don't know what your chances of scoring a work permit would be in the field of law, but the academic route is an option. The student visa would also be a possible option if you decided to study in Canada (again, I don't know the intricacies).
#40
Thread Starter
Just Joined
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 12

Hi all
I'm glad to see I'm not the only lawyer looking to leave the UK- I guess the system and the country fill us with so much joy we look elsewhere!
I'm currently preparing my application for NCA accreditation, hopefully I will receive a reasonable amount of exemptions. I've been at the Bar full time since since call in 1998, I hold an LLB and an LLM and hope to get the maximum exemptions. The guidance on NCA website seems to suggest 1 or 2 papers will be required, presumably Canadian Constitution and the like.
I applied to CIC in Sept 2006 as a skilled worker and wonder if others would share experiences of job hunting pre or post NCA exams.
Jamie
I'm glad to see I'm not the only lawyer looking to leave the UK- I guess the system and the country fill us with so much joy we look elsewhere!
I'm currently preparing my application for NCA accreditation, hopefully I will receive a reasonable amount of exemptions. I've been at the Bar full time since since call in 1998, I hold an LLB and an LLM and hope to get the maximum exemptions. The guidance on NCA website seems to suggest 1 or 2 papers will be required, presumably Canadian Constitution and the like.
I applied to CIC in Sept 2006 as a skilled worker and wonder if others would share experiences of job hunting pre or post NCA exams.
Jamie
Hi Jamie,
Can I ask why you are leaving the law in the UK?
I am also interested to know of employment experiences post NCA exams. I plan to go on a fact finding mission and talk to some ca. lawyers later in the year.
I don't know if holding an LLM will make any difference to the NCA exams. But LLM degrees do seem to be more highly regarded in N.America with respect to jobs - particularly if they are specialised.
Good luck with your NCA application - I am holding out till I have my PhD in the hope that I may have one less paper to sit!
#41
possibly.
have i missed something. just having a trawl on a lazy sunday morning for an hour, as you do, and it seem to have all kicked off just because 2 people are discussing differences in their profession between the UK and Canada. i don't think i'm cynical or twisted enough to be on here sometimes, which is a surprise let me tell you.
anyway, are you prosecuting/defending criminally. i'm interested if the opposition, is going to be tougher or not over there or whether the version of the CPS does a better job?
have i missed something. just having a trawl on a lazy sunday morning for an hour, as you do, and it seem to have all kicked off just because 2 people are discussing differences in their profession between the UK and Canada. i don't think i'm cynical or twisted enough to be on here sometimes, which is a surprise let me tell you.
anyway, are you prosecuting/defending criminally. i'm interested if the opposition, is going to be tougher or not over there or whether the version of the CPS does a better job?
I have no direct experience of the criminal bar here although a police friend of mine (he worked for West Midlands in the UK and CPS here said to me that the police over here would have real problems if a competent criminal defence lawyer ever came over from the UK - I guess that answers your question and just confirms what I said earlier about the competency of the advocates over here in comparison to what we are used to in the UK.
#42
BE Enthusiast




Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 360











possibly.
have i missed something. just having a trawl on a lazy sunday morning for an hour, as you do, and it seem to have all kicked off just because 2 people are discussing differences in their profession between the UK and Canada. i don't think i'm cynical or twisted enough to be on here sometimes, which is a surprise let me tell you.
anyway, are you prosecuting/defending criminally. i'm interested if the opposition, is going to be tougher or not over there or whether the version of the CPS does a better job?
have i missed something. just having a trawl on a lazy sunday morning for an hour, as you do, and it seem to have all kicked off just because 2 people are discussing differences in their profession between the UK and Canada. i don't think i'm cynical or twisted enough to be on here sometimes, which is a surprise let me tell you.
anyway, are you prosecuting/defending criminally. i'm interested if the opposition, is going to be tougher or not over there or whether the version of the CPS does a better job?
I am the criminal defence lawyer and very proud of it! I specialise in Juvenille law.
I cannot say yet as to whether their Crown Counsel (cps equivalent) do a better job, I start work in June so will know then once back in the court system, but the advocacy I have personally witnessed in the courts here is pretty dire.
I also get the feeling they are much softer than the UK, in sentencing.
#43
Just Joined
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 1

Hi there
As London7 has said, I have applied to NCA (they said they will inform me of their decision by mid-June) and I am working in a law firm at the moment.
I am "assisting" a litigator who was called less than 2 years ago at the moment and it is painful but something that must be done.
I am in Calgary so feel free to PM me if I can be of any assistance at all.
As London7 has said, I have applied to NCA (they said they will inform me of their decision by mid-June) and I am working in a law firm at the moment.
I am "assisting" a litigator who was called less than 2 years ago at the moment and it is painful but something that must be done.
I am in Calgary so feel free to PM me if I can be of any assistance at all.
How easy is it to get a job with a Canadian law firm pre-conversion like you've done? did you just go to Canada and apply or did you secure the job before you moved over? I would love to work and study the conversion exams because I have to write 11 subjects as I have a South African law degree so I've divided it to write 3 this august, 4 in Jan 2008 and the last 4 Aug 2008. it's a MISSION but I've swallowed the pill and had my cup of hot water so I'm ready. it would just be really nice to work and start gaining Canadian work experience in the legal field. I would appreciate any info you can give me.
To those who've written the challenge exams: I'm in Scotland and will be writing my first 3 NCA exams this August 2007 and I would like to ask those who've written before how best to read through these MASSIVE textbooks? Im studying for Admin law, Contracts and Torts. Im still only reading Admin law cos it's quite a bit to get through. Regarding the cases, is it enough to just grasp the ratio decidendi and leave out all the history and build up to the case conclusion? How intense are the actual NCA exams? I'm really struggling to see what to leave out or what to focus on more than the other bits and as a result i'm reading the textbooks page by page and will never get done in time for August at this rate. If anyone can help me and offer some guidance I would be indebted to you. I tried to contact the NCA for guidance and was told 'this is completely self-study etc'. ANY help would be really welcome.
#44
hello Almost Canadian and everyone on the NCA conversion route.
How easy is it to get a job with a Canadian law firm pre-conversion like you've done? did you just go to Canada and apply or did you secure the job before you moved over? I would love to work and study the conversion exams because I have to write 11 subjects as I have a South African law degree so I've divided it to write 3 this august, 4 in Jan 2008 and the last 4 Aug 2008. it's a MISSION but I've swallowed the pill and had my cup of hot water so I'm ready. it would just be really nice to work and start gaining Canadian work experience in the legal field. I would appreciate any info you can give me.
To those who've written the challenge exams: I'm in Scotland and will be writing my first 3 NCA exams this August 2007 and I would like to ask those who've written before how best to read through these MASSIVE textbooks? Im studying for Admin law, Contracts and Torts. Im still only reading Admin law cos it's quite a bit to get through. Regarding the cases, is it enough to just grasp the ratio decidendi and leave out all the history and build up to the case conclusion? How intense are the actual NCA exams? I'm really struggling to see what to leave out or what to focus on more than the other bits and as a result i'm reading the textbooks page by page and will never get done in time for August at this rate. If anyone can help me and offer some guidance I would be indebted to you. I tried to contact the NCA for guidance and was told 'this is completely self-study etc'. ANY help would be really welcome.
How easy is it to get a job with a Canadian law firm pre-conversion like you've done? did you just go to Canada and apply or did you secure the job before you moved over? I would love to work and study the conversion exams because I have to write 11 subjects as I have a South African law degree so I've divided it to write 3 this august, 4 in Jan 2008 and the last 4 Aug 2008. it's a MISSION but I've swallowed the pill and had my cup of hot water so I'm ready. it would just be really nice to work and start gaining Canadian work experience in the legal field. I would appreciate any info you can give me.
To those who've written the challenge exams: I'm in Scotland and will be writing my first 3 NCA exams this August 2007 and I would like to ask those who've written before how best to read through these MASSIVE textbooks? Im studying for Admin law, Contracts and Torts. Im still only reading Admin law cos it's quite a bit to get through. Regarding the cases, is it enough to just grasp the ratio decidendi and leave out all the history and build up to the case conclusion? How intense are the actual NCA exams? I'm really struggling to see what to leave out or what to focus on more than the other bits and as a result i'm reading the textbooks page by page and will never get done in time for August at this rate. If anyone can help me and offer some guidance I would be indebted to you. I tried to contact the NCA for guidance and was told 'this is completely self-study etc'. ANY help would be really welcome.
I have no idea how to answer the textbook issue as I have not taken any exams yet (I write my first in August). I have just decided to learn the entire book in as much detail as I did when doing the LL.B. in England. A huge undertaking but I see no other way around it. It seems to me that the NCA are determined to put foreign lawyers off but, as none of the Universities near me will allow "NCA students" to take courses, I have no alternative but to go down the NCA exam route.
Feel free to PM me if I can be of any assistance.
#45
Forum Regular


Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 74
From: Calgary

AC,
As a matter of interest, is it the NCA who sets the exams or would it be in your case (Alberta) UofC or the UofA law schools?
Cheers,
Hart
As a matter of interest, is it the NCA who sets the exams or would it be in your case (Alberta) UofC or the UofA law schools?
Cheers,
Hart




