Coming to Canada - dream over?
#62
Re: Coming to Canada - dream over?
Put the boot on the other foot an pretend you were back in the UK, would you want some newly landed 'fresh off the boat' immigrant coming into the workplace on a higher salary than you? Or even worse, as your Boss?
#63
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Aug 2007
Location: North
Posts: 1,357
Re: Coming to Canada - dream over?
Might the 'stats' that Alan quotes from be distorted by many immigrants from non-English speaking countries that arrive with basic or no English, and also those with qualifications that don't directly transfer without retraining (e.g. Doctors)?
#64
Binned by Muderators
Joined: Jul 2007
Location: White Rock BC
Posts: 11,682
Re: Coming to Canada - dream over?
I wasn't trying to - I was responding to a specific post that said there was no point in moving unless there was a good well paid job on offer.
No need - I don't dispute it. However, for a British Expat I think a five year hit is a reasonable expectation. And there are always opportunities that come your way from time to time. Sometimes you have to see them for what they are.
It is not a question of blaming someones attitude, more their expectations. It is a question of motivation. If the motivation is material or career gain then Canada is tough gig at the moment. If the motivation is to live in Canada come what may then most people will find a way to make it happen. It may not be pretty right now but it can be done.
I don't blame anyone who it trying to do their best for their career or bank balance. It is a perfectly reasonable thing. However, a new immigrant from the UK expecting to land a more senior job with more money than they were earning needs a reality check.
As you say, another argument for another time.
Attitude is important in finding a good job. If someone has an attitude that they will not accept Canadian ways, or that they are only here for the money, that is their prerogative but it is going make finding a job all that more difficult. Telling someone that is helping them, not blaming them.
And for the people who's motivation in moving to Canada is not to amass wealth or climb the corporate ladder it is only fair to tell than it can be done, even in the middle of a recession, if they are prepared to make the sacrifices and compromises that are needed.
The first, and probably the last, time I've been accused of that!
1 - The stats say otherwise. Most immigrants never catch up with their local peers; and this is especially so for those with higher education. You can verify this on stats canada's website.
2 - There are large sectors of industry that are just not hiring at all, or hiring very few (EA just laid off a bunch of people for instance). Blaming peoples attitude for not finding a job is almost certainly way off the mark for the majority.
I don't blame anyone who it trying to do their best for their career or bank balance. It is a perfectly reasonable thing. However, a new immigrant from the UK expecting to land a more senior job with more money than they were earning needs a reality check.
3 - I think you are over optimistic on the economy - short term you might be right, medium to long term there is still too much debt out there. (that's a whole topic on it's own though).
As I said in an earlier post, it's very easy for people that came and found work to judge those who have not and blame them for their misfortune
And for the people who's motivation in moving to Canada is not to amass wealth or climb the corporate ladder it is only fair to tell than it can be done, even in the middle of a recession, if they are prepared to make the sacrifices and compromises that are needed.
but that really is rush limbaugh thinking.
#65
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 14,227
Re: Coming to Canada - dream over?
I wasn't trying to - I was responding to a specific post that said there was no point in moving unless there was a good well paid job on offer.
No need - I don't dispute it. However, for a British Expat I think a five year hit is a reasonable expectation. And there are always opportunities that come your way from time to time. Sometimes you have to see them for what they are.
It is not a question of blaming someones attitude, more their expectations. It is a question of motivation. If the motivation is material or career gain then Canada is tough gig at the moment. If the motivation is to live in Canada come what may then most people will find a way to make it happen. It may not be pretty right now but it can be done.
I don't blame anyone who it trying to do their best for their career or bank balance. It is a perfectly reasonable thing. However, a new immigrant from the UK expecting to land a more senior job with more money than they were earning needs a reality check.
As you say, another argument for another time.
Attitude is important in finding a good job. If someone has an attitude that they will not accept Canadian ways, or that they are only here for the money, that is their prerogative but it is going make finding a job all that more difficult. Telling someone that is helping them, not blaming them.
And for the people who's motivation in moving to Canada is not to amass wealth or climb the corporate ladder it is only fair to tell than it can be done, even in the middle of a recession, if they are prepared to make the sacrifices and compromises that are needed.
The first, and probably the last, time I've been accused of that!
No need - I don't dispute it. However, for a British Expat I think a five year hit is a reasonable expectation. And there are always opportunities that come your way from time to time. Sometimes you have to see them for what they are.
It is not a question of blaming someones attitude, more their expectations. It is a question of motivation. If the motivation is material or career gain then Canada is tough gig at the moment. If the motivation is to live in Canada come what may then most people will find a way to make it happen. It may not be pretty right now but it can be done.
I don't blame anyone who it trying to do their best for their career or bank balance. It is a perfectly reasonable thing. However, a new immigrant from the UK expecting to land a more senior job with more money than they were earning needs a reality check.
As you say, another argument for another time.
Attitude is important in finding a good job. If someone has an attitude that they will not accept Canadian ways, or that they are only here for the money, that is their prerogative but it is going make finding a job all that more difficult. Telling someone that is helping them, not blaming them.
And for the people who's motivation in moving to Canada is not to amass wealth or climb the corporate ladder it is only fair to tell than it can be done, even in the middle of a recession, if they are prepared to make the sacrifices and compromises that are needed.
The first, and probably the last, time I've been accused of that!
As for career aspirations. Does anybody immigrating to Canada really have those (especially those coming west); opportunities to climb the corporate ladder aren't exactly extensive around here as far as I can tell.
(and the rush limbaugh comment was a bit tongue in cheek as iaink accused somebody of it on the 800,000 starving canadians thread)
#66
Just Joined
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 11
Re: Coming to Canada - dream over?
Well you've help me make my mind up reading this!
I've been studing Credit Mangement for 18 months hoping the qualifications will help!
I am getting right on to enrol on the Credit Instutes of Canada's next deadline for 25 November to start on their and abandon the english curiculum!
Looks like I need all the help I can get eh!
Lets hope the ask for my medicals soon, so I can take the exam when we get out there!
Wishing everyone one a little hope and a light at the end of your tunnels! x
I've been studing Credit Mangement for 18 months hoping the qualifications will help!
I am getting right on to enrol on the Credit Instutes of Canada's next deadline for 25 November to start on their and abandon the english curiculum!
Looks like I need all the help I can get eh!
Lets hope the ask for my medicals soon, so I can take the exam when we get out there!
Wishing everyone one a little hope and a light at the end of your tunnels! x
#67
Re: Coming to Canada - dream over?
Well you've help me make my mind up reading this!
I've been studing Credit Mangement for 18 months hoping the qualifications will help!
I am getting right on to enrol on the Credit Instutes of Canada's next deadline for 25 November to start on their and abandon the english curiculum!
Looks like I need all the help I can get eh!
Lets hope the ask for my medicals soon, so I can take the exam when we get out there!
Wishing everyone one a little hope and a light at the end of your tunnels! x
I've been studing Credit Mangement for 18 months hoping the qualifications will help!
I am getting right on to enrol on the Credit Instutes of Canada's next deadline for 25 November to start on their and abandon the english curiculum!
Looks like I need all the help I can get eh!
Lets hope the ask for my medicals soon, so I can take the exam when we get out there!
Wishing everyone one a little hope and a light at the end of your tunnels! x
Someone mentioned about adapting ones methods to those of Canada. If you are applying for a job in Canada (or any other country for that matter) adapting to the local ways make sense doesn't it?. Complaining about the methods here is the same as me immigrating to the UK and expecting the British to forget their ways and do things my way.
My advice for those in Canada looking for a specific job is to visit those companies in person and deliver your resume in person rather than sending an email. Mass emails are viewed as not much more than spam in many cases. When you are meeting a prospective employer or having an interview,.... SMILE .... act positive, upbeat and confident. Tell them why they should pay you.
#70
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 593
Re: Coming to Canada - dream over?
If there's one thing that stinks, I think it's your attitude.
Sorry, but if you've not got a job, there's something you're not doing right. Plenty of people have come over and got themselves jobs; plenty of people still are.
Change your attitude and you might have better luck.
Sorry, but if you've not got a job, there's something you're not doing right. Plenty of people have come over and got themselves jobs; plenty of people still are.
Change your attitude and you might have better luck.
#72
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Nov 2009
Location: Gastown - East Van
Posts: 413
Re: Coming to Canada - dream over?
No, I'm not comfortable attempting to network with complete strangers, with the sole motive of trying to secure a job. If I knew loads of people and it was that easy to set myself up, I'd wouldn't complain for sure. Maybe, I'm just more comfortable with some old fashioned notion of employing the best qualified person for the job, rather than some friend of my cousins.
Canada is swamped with people making superficial connections which are meaningless other than for advancing themselves. Britain is NOWHERE NEAR THIS BAD. And here is the problem. You either lower yourself to be like them. Or you fail. This is a moral dilemma. I have mouths to feed but I also have principles.
And yes why does everyone hire their best mate or people in their network? It's probably why Canada has such a high turnover of people in jobs. Also why skilled professionals end up feeling like they're being short changed. Yet I've been far from impressed with Canada's offering in my field. Truth is they'd rather hire from their facebook network than choose the right person for the job. Pathetic really
#73
Re: Coming to Canada - dream over?
Just for the record I do pick up the phone. Many times (but not all the time) I just end up speaking to automated voice systems or voice mail where I always leave a message asking if they could ring me back or that I will ring them later (which I do to the same result). I have also tried going to the company only to be brick-walled by the receptionist that any enquiries about vacancies need to be addressed or sent via there website. I rang a company only yesterday just to 'confirm' if they'd received my resume from a week ago and she refused to put me through to HR and to say they don't reveal such information ! I'm just asking for confirmation for christs sake ! Anyway, I do understand what you're saying about attitude and I do intend to keep trying, reviewing and pesisting. I'm not moaning, just frustrated.
#74
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Aug 2007
Location: North
Posts: 1,357
Re: Coming to Canada - dream over?
Got to agree with you there trouncer, the exact same has happened to me....when I do ring companies I can never get thro to anyone of any relvance, and thats if im lucky, more often than not its automated answering system where you leave a message on the relavant person's voice mail, only for them to never return your call, and many emails are never acknowledged. So I can definitely empathise with you and the OP, but just have to keep trying Im here now, it cant stay like this for ever surely!
Last edited by bodgerx; Nov 22nd 2009 at 12:36 pm.
#75
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 3,054
Re: Coming to Canada - dream over?
You are a genius. I wish I could have put it so well myself. This is why I find it difficult in Canada. Because I feel making friends to advance my career is just bloody awful. I have swiped many many people from my linked in account because I've tried to help people who then go incommunicado when they don't need my help any more. I think this is a cultural thing. But putting cultural differences aside, I'm not sure I'm going to change to be like this as it's just shallow, self-obsessed and rude.
Canada is swamped with people making superficial connections which are meaningless other than for advancing themselves. Britain is NOWHERE NEAR THIS BAD. And here is the problem. You either lower yourself to be like them. Or you fail. This is a moral dilemma. I have mouths to feed but I also have principles.
And yes why does everyone hire their best mate or people in their network? It's probably why Canada has such a high turnover of people in jobs. Also why skilled professionals end up feeling like they're being short changed. Yet I've been far from impressed with Canada's offering in my field. Truth is they'd rather hire from their facebook network than choose the right person for the job. Pathetic really
Canada is swamped with people making superficial connections which are meaningless other than for advancing themselves. Britain is NOWHERE NEAR THIS BAD. And here is the problem. You either lower yourself to be like them. Or you fail. This is a moral dilemma. I have mouths to feed but I also have principles.
And yes why does everyone hire their best mate or people in their network? It's probably why Canada has such a high turnover of people in jobs. Also why skilled professionals end up feeling like they're being short changed. Yet I've been far from impressed with Canada's offering in my field. Truth is they'd rather hire from their facebook network than choose the right person for the job. Pathetic really
You are starting to come across as bitter.