Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

I can't stand the new version on 'One' that U2 did with Mary J Blige and I cringe whenever I hear that X Factor winners version of 'Hallelujah', it's just not the same as when Jeff Buckley sings it!

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

I can't stand any song thats regurgitated.Its never as good as the original.

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

Previous post. Hallelujah. :p

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

Which itself is a cover of Leonard Cohen's original.

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

I think it depends.

IMHO Kiss by the Art of Noise was much better than the original.

Spiderbait's Black Betty is another that I thought was better than the original.

Obviously it comes down to personal taste.

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

Apart from Hendrix - All Along The Watchtower and countless others, obviously ...

Back to the plot ... apart from Madge's version of American Pie (taken as a given) ... er ... when that boy band did We Will Rock You (with Brian May's blessing ...), I'll go along with that.

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

I quite liked that one. Not as good as the original but not a complete balls up.

Wasn't that awful boy band version of Seasons in the Sun the UK's number one for the new millennium? :ohmy:

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

I've blanked that one ... I'm not keen on the original come to that ...

Johnny Cash's versions of One and Hurt were obviously just pointless regurgitations ... :rofl:

Crap ones? ... OK ... the whole of Bob Dylan's Christmas album ...

<Blatant Google>

Ronan Keating - Fairytale Of New York? :blink:
Avril Lavigne - Knockin' on Heaven's Door? :eek:

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

Personally, I think that Amy Winehouse's version of "Valerie" was as good, if not better than the original.

Sinead O'Connor's version of Nothing Compares 2 U and The Foo Fighters' "Band on the Run" were both infinitely superior.

Oh, speaking of Wings, Guns n Roses version of "Live and Let Die" was much better too :)

I used to like listening to Jo Whiley's Live Lounge. Sometimes the 'cover versions' were outstanding.

Here's someone elses list of the top 33 cover songs that are better than the original (a few mentioned in this thread already)

Great Cover Songs

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

Didn't Britney Spears do Joan Jet's I Love Rock and Roll.
Plus That soap star from brook side did Trans vision Vamps Baby i Don't Care
Truly awful

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

We've already had one version of Rocket Man (Shatner) - but at least that was intended to be a bit cheesy (I think :huh: ).............

................... on the other hand, Kate Bush turning it into a reggae singalong ditty was not........... nice to know she'll "...miss her wife..." :blink:

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

Florence and the machines version of 'dirty love' does my head in - why does she have to screech the chorus?? :sneaky:

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

Kate Bush is a legend :thumbsup:

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

Any of the (many) covers by Westlife. An absolute intenional rip off of nieve gullible young fans who don't know any better.

Re: The worst cover version of a song ever?
 

oh, and who can ever forget this classic tune being mutilated ?..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZJvGd...eature=related