Hunting... why does anyone?
#1
Hunting... why does anyone?
Saw the hunts on UK boxing day news... and was reminded about the Royal family and it's shooting outings... and then a BE raised 'roo shooting on another thread.
Is it just me, or do others share my view that there is there something wrong with hunting animals for entertainment or so-called sport?
I get hunting for food, no problem. I get shooting a rogue, chicken-eating, fox.
But where's the satisfaction in killing animals just for fun?
Is it just me, or do others share my view that there is there something wrong with hunting animals for entertainment or so-called sport?
I get hunting for food, no problem. I get shooting a rogue, chicken-eating, fox.
But where's the satisfaction in killing animals just for fun?
#2
Re: Hunting... why does anyone?
Saw the hunts on UK boxing day news... and was reminded about the Royal family and it's shooting outings... and then a BE raised 'roo shooting on another thread.
Is it just me, or do others share my view that there is there something wrong with hunting animals for entertainment or so-called sport?
I get hunting for food, no problem. I get shooting a rogue, chicken-eating, fox.
But where's the satisfaction in killing animals just for fun?
Is it just me, or do others share my view that there is there something wrong with hunting animals for entertainment or so-called sport?
I get hunting for food, no problem. I get shooting a rogue, chicken-eating, fox.
But where's the satisfaction in killing animals just for fun?
#3
Re: Hunting... why does anyone?
That said, I think people with serious psychological issues should receive treatment, whereas I'd have hunters stripped naked, smeared in honey and then dropped into the forests of northern Maine so that they could finally give something back to the animal world.
#4
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 1,130
Re: Hunting... why does anyone?
Saw the hunts on UK boxing day news... and was reminded about the Royal family and it's shooting outings... and then a BE raised 'roo shooting on another thread.
Is it just me, or do others share my view that there is there something wrong with hunting animals for entertainment or so-called sport?
I get hunting for food, no problem. I get shooting a rogue, chicken-eating, fox.
But where's the satisfaction in killing animals just for fun?
Is it just me, or do others share my view that there is there something wrong with hunting animals for entertainment or so-called sport?
I get hunting for food, no problem. I get shooting a rogue, chicken-eating, fox.
But where's the satisfaction in killing animals just for fun?
Last edited by sheene; Dec 27th 2011 at 1:16 pm.
#5
Re: Hunting... why does anyone?
A fox will kill not just the chicken it wants to eat, but the rest of the flock, just for fun. Have you ever seen the aftermath when a fox gets into your coop? I do not condone hunting for fun, but yes, I'd want the fox destroyed.
#6
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Mar 2006
Location: Riverland, SA - Beds/Cambs/Nhants was home in UK
Posts: 1,503
Re: Hunting... why does anyone?
And no we don't eat the chickens, they're layers.
But I am a fan of hunting, used to have a glorious hunting springer spaniel in the UK. My OH used to shoot and I'd follow along as part of the picking up team. If you haven't ever participated you can't really understand.
We'd eat what we shot, or give away the surplus. Remembering all pheasants were solely raised for such purposes. I also support fox hunting. And deer.
#7
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 1,130
Re: Hunting... why does anyone?
Distruction is too nice a word for what foxes do, every year I lose chooks to the flipping things! I reinforce the pen, lock them away at night etc etc and still the foxes win!
And no we don't eat the chickens, they're layers.
But I am a fan of hunting, used to have a glorious hunting springer spaniel in the UK. My OH used to shoot and I'd follow along as part of the picking up team. If you haven't ever participated you can't really understand.
We'd eat what we shot, or give away the surplus. Remembering all pheasants were solely raised for such purposes. I also support fox hunting. And deer.
And no we don't eat the chickens, they're layers.
But I am a fan of hunting, used to have a glorious hunting springer spaniel in the UK. My OH used to shoot and I'd follow along as part of the picking up team. If you haven't ever participated you can't really understand.
We'd eat what we shot, or give away the surplus. Remembering all pheasants were solely raised for such purposes. I also support fox hunting. And deer.
The fact that the pheasants were solely raised to to be shot for pleasure actually makes it worse, but you probably wouldn't understand.
#8
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 1,130
Re: Hunting... why does anyone?
The wily fox, can pick padlocks, carries portable welding gear - build a better coop ffs, it's not that difficult - or do you not care for your chickens either.
#9
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Mar 2006
Location: Riverland, SA - Beds/Cambs/Nhants was home in UK
Posts: 1,503
Re: Hunting... why does anyone?
Which bit would we not understand? The shooting? The picking them up? - seems pretty straightforward, unless you are just trying to justify your actions?
The fact that the pheasants were solely raised to to be shot for pleasure actually makes it worse, but you probably wouldn't understand.
The fact that the pheasants were solely raised to to be shot for pleasure actually makes it worse, but you probably wouldn't understand.
I can only presume that you don't eat any meat Sheene? Pigs are solely raised for bacon, they get shot in the head too .... or didn't you realise that?
Use of the term "shot for pleasure" could be misunderstood. Just because we enjoy the challenge of shooting doesn't make it any different from a golfer enjoying a hole in one --- it's a gun yes but a golf club can also be a lethal weapon in the wrong hands.
#10
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 1,253
Re: Hunting... why does anyone?
I have mixed emotions on this one. I do not in any way come from a hunt background, but my family background does come from that which was involved in hunts, training the horses mainly I believe, I am talking before the war here when many were employed by the rich landowners. Some in my family had a reputation for being the best horse groom's in the country.
The thing is whether by the hunt of by the farmer the fox is going to be culled, numbers do need to be kept under control.
Farmers will shoot a fox and not always kill it straight away, the fox will limp off and die a slow painful death. Some farmers will also put out traps which will trap the animals leg in its grip. The fox will try and chew its own leg off and get very distressed, again it is a slow and painful death.
The hunt dogs are trained to go straight for the animals throat and the death is a quick one. But I understand totally the stress put on the animal from being chased for so long also, this I can appreciate. It looks bad when the dogs go in, but the fox is dealt with quickly.
Since hunting foxes was banned I do not doubt for a second that there are more foxes suffering more slower and painful deaths out there. Farmers get very **** off if they start losing animals and will use any means possible.
The thing is whether by the hunt of by the farmer the fox is going to be culled, numbers do need to be kept under control.
Farmers will shoot a fox and not always kill it straight away, the fox will limp off and die a slow painful death. Some farmers will also put out traps which will trap the animals leg in its grip. The fox will try and chew its own leg off and get very distressed, again it is a slow and painful death.
The hunt dogs are trained to go straight for the animals throat and the death is a quick one. But I understand totally the stress put on the animal from being chased for so long also, this I can appreciate. It looks bad when the dogs go in, but the fox is dealt with quickly.
Since hunting foxes was banned I do not doubt for a second that there are more foxes suffering more slower and painful deaths out there. Farmers get very **** off if they start losing animals and will use any means possible.
#11
Re: Hunting... why does anyone?
Hunting is for the absolute lowest of the low. I guess it taps back into some primordial instinct where humans needed to chase down animals inorder to survive . Most of us have evolved beyond that thankfully. Inflicting fear and pain on any animal is utterly disgusting and I don't think I'd be able to even hold a conversation with someone who does hunt I'd be so repulsed.
I don't get the dichotomy in Oz between protecting wildlife, national parks etc but then ruthlessly 'culling' anything they decide is infringing upon their livelihood/pleasure. Pig shoots, roo shoots, even sport fishing (30 dead marlin in the marina the other day hanging up) - pointless murder.
I don't get the dichotomy in Oz between protecting wildlife, national parks etc but then ruthlessly 'culling' anything they decide is infringing upon their livelihood/pleasure. Pig shoots, roo shoots, even sport fishing (30 dead marlin in the marina the other day hanging up) - pointless murder.
Last edited by Turban Explorer; Dec 27th 2011 at 9:14 pm.
#12
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 1,130
Re: Hunting... why does anyone?
I don't need to justify my actions - but the thread asked why does anyone hunt? If you wanted to understand a little more then perhaps joining in a local hunt for a day, even an hour, would help see why many people enjoy the experience.
I can only presume that you don't eat any meat Sheene? Pigs are solely raised for bacon, they get shot in the head too .... or didn't you realise that?
Use of the term "shot for pleasure" could be misunderstood. Just because we enjoy the challenge of shooting doesn't make it any different from a golfer enjoying a hole in one --- it's a gun yes but a golf club can also be a lethal weapon in the wrong hands.
I can only presume that you don't eat any meat Sheene? Pigs are solely raised for bacon, they get shot in the head too .... or didn't you realise that?
Use of the term "shot for pleasure" could be misunderstood. Just because we enjoy the challenge of shooting doesn't make it any different from a golfer enjoying a hole in one --- it's a gun yes but a golf club can also be a lethal weapon in the wrong hands.
I have no desire to watch, and will never understand why it would be enjoyable.
A challenge? - give the pheasant a couple of napalm bombs to even the odds a little.
Last edited by sheene; Dec 27th 2011 at 9:13 pm.
#13
Banned
Joined: Jan 2011
Location: The REAL Utopia.
Posts: 9,910
Re: Hunting... why does anyone?
Ah yes, the challenge of the hunt. The ferocious kangaroo, fox or deer against a nutter with a high powered gun. I have never understood it and don't need to go along on a hunt to understand it. A few nights ago a goof friend, who is a rabid hunter, was showing a photo on his phone of a hare he had shot. Shot is actually too nice a word, he had blown the top of it's head off. The biggest problem I have with this particular individual is the fact that he is a manic depressive and at times incredibly unstable.
Using being a meat eater as some kind of justification is absurd. Hunters hunt to fulfil the need to kill.
Using being a meat eater as some kind of justification is absurd. Hunters hunt to fulfil the need to kill.
#14
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 335
Re: Hunting... why does anyone?
Saw the hunts on UK boxing day news... and was reminded about the Royal family and it's shooting outings... and then a BE raised 'roo shooting on another thread.
Is it just me, or do others share my view that there is there something wrong with hunting animals for entertainment or so-called sport?
I get hunting for food, no problem. I get shooting a rogue, chicken-eating, fox.
But where's the satisfaction in killing animals just for fun?
Is it just me, or do others share my view that there is there something wrong with hunting animals for entertainment or so-called sport?
I get hunting for food, no problem. I get shooting a rogue, chicken-eating, fox.
But where's the satisfaction in killing animals just for fun?