what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather!!
#31
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Oct 2005
Location: Hill overlooking the SE Melbourne suburbs
Posts: 16,622
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
Just curious: For those who don't think there is much opportunity for kids to have an outdoor lifestyle in the UK, what are the reasons for this? Is it weather? costs? space?
I now live in Brixton, and even though its ultra-urban central London there are almost unlimited outdoor sports/activities for kids here.
Yes, it's not swimming in the sea etc but you could play sport outside every night of the week if you want. You can even play AFL here!
Not trying to defend the UK in any way, but given that I played lots of outdoor sports as a kid myself in the UK I find it interesting when people say its not as readily available here.
If the reason is weather, does that only apply to the summer? My memories of my Melbourne winters are day after day of rain.
I now live in Brixton, and even though its ultra-urban central London there are almost unlimited outdoor sports/activities for kids here.
Yes, it's not swimming in the sea etc but you could play sport outside every night of the week if you want. You can even play AFL here!
Not trying to defend the UK in any way, but given that I played lots of outdoor sports as a kid myself in the UK I find it interesting when people say its not as readily available here.
If the reason is weather, does that only apply to the summer? My memories of my Melbourne winters are day after day of rain.
I'm one of those who thinks neither country has a particular advantage on this score. We played outside all the time in England, all through the seasons. Cold and rain can drive you in there, but so can the extreme weather in Aus. Same thing. Maybe a technical counting of days might give the nod to Aus but the margin would be slight, I'm sure.
Fishermen and walkers are out in all weathers but most people would be put off.
When it is warm and mild in the UK in summer it is very pleasant - people tend to remember washed out August's in the UK and forget that the best weather is in May or June say. They then go to the Med in High summer and feel let down by the local weather.
I personally think that the culture in Australia is sort of technically more outdoors - people own boats etc, there is more of a culture for it even if it's not excluded in the UK. In the UK, people would choose to go down the pub, or watch the box - here people are visibly excited about camping and fishing and eating a tonne of praws - I've see Australians reduced to nervous wrecks on the promise of a plate - in the UK perhaps, people would be excited about the latest Jeremy Kyle boxset being released, and go water-skiing once on their holidays in France. Here a family might go every weekend if that was their thing.
I would also say that some outdoor sports in the UK are a tad elitist. 'Hiking', mountaineering can be rather - and can end up being a gear race. Over here, I find it a bit more inclusive.
#32
Forum Regular
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 200
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
I think the masses in general are scared of any weather that is vaguely inclement and people tend to attribute sun and warmth to outdoor play.
Fishermen and walkers are out in all weathers but most people would be put off.
When it is warm and mild in the UK in summer it is very pleasant - people tend to remember washed out August's in the UK and forget that the best weather is in May or June say. They then go to the Med in High summer and feel let down by the local weather.
I personally think that the culture in Australia is sort of technically more outdoors - people own boats etc, there is more of a culture for it even if it's not excluded in the UK. In the UK, people would choose to go down the pub, or watch the box - here people are visibly excited about camping and fishing and eating a tonne of praws - I've see Australians reduced to nervous wrecks on the promise of a plate - in the UK perhaps, people would be excited about the latest Jeremy Kyle boxset being released, and go water-skiing once on their holidays in France. Here a family might go every weekend if that was their thing.
I would also say that some outdoor sports in the UK are a tad elitist. 'Hiking', mountaineering can be rather - and can end up being a gear race. Over here, I find it a bit more inclusive.
Fishermen and walkers are out in all weathers but most people would be put off.
When it is warm and mild in the UK in summer it is very pleasant - people tend to remember washed out August's in the UK and forget that the best weather is in May or June say. They then go to the Med in High summer and feel let down by the local weather.
I personally think that the culture in Australia is sort of technically more outdoors - people own boats etc, there is more of a culture for it even if it's not excluded in the UK. In the UK, people would choose to go down the pub, or watch the box - here people are visibly excited about camping and fishing and eating a tonne of praws - I've see Australians reduced to nervous wrecks on the promise of a plate - in the UK perhaps, people would be excited about the latest Jeremy Kyle boxset being released, and go water-skiing once on their holidays in France. Here a family might go every weekend if that was their thing.
I would also say that some outdoor sports in the UK are a tad elitist. 'Hiking', mountaineering can be rather - and can end up being a gear race. Over here, I find it a bit more inclusive.
Maybe my view is shaped by my own experiences. I've always played outdoor sports in the UK and most of my mates in Oz spend as much time in the pub (if not more) than my mates here do.
I do think outdoor activities in Oz can be prohibitively expensive (both skiing lift tickets and national park camping passes in oz are now officially the most expensive in the world) but with being close to the sea there is perhaps more opportunity for a wider variety of sports.
#33
Banned
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 3,300
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
I don't think it will be much longer before everything in Aus is the most expensive in the world, and I'm being literal and serious. Sydney is now the world's third most expensive city after Tokyo and Osaka. Melbourne is joint 4th.
#34
Forum Regular
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 200
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
There was comment on it saying 10 years ago no Oz cities were in the top 50. Now two are in the top 4. Apparently the group doing the survey had never seen such a jump.
When I first moved to Oz in 2004, if someone had said to me it would soon be more expensive to live there than Zurich I would have burst out laughing. It's a real concern.
#35
Banned
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 3,300
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
I saw that survey, and it's one I respect as well (unlike the ones which have agenda's it seemed to be an accurate and fair comparison).
There was comment on it saying 10 years ago no Oz cities were in the top 50. Now two are in the top 4. Apparently the group doing the survey had never seen such a jump.
When I first moved to Oz in 2004, if someone had said to me it would soon be more expensive to live there than Zurich I would have burst out laughing. It's a real concern.
There was comment on it saying 10 years ago no Oz cities were in the top 50. Now two are in the top 4. Apparently the group doing the survey had never seen such a jump.
When I first moved to Oz in 2004, if someone had said to me it would soon be more expensive to live there than Zurich I would have burst out laughing. It's a real concern.
#36
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
We have a 5 year resident return visa which expires 2018. We are presently considering moving to Melbourne when our eldest daughter has completed her GCSE's in 4 years. A main motivator for this is we expect her to have a better chance of employment opportunities in whatever her chosen field is in Australia, rather than in the UK.
I appreciate that the UK economy could be looking much rosier by 2017, but I'm not holding out much hope.
We are looking at the move back as a long term plan for our two daughters, currently 5 and 12.
I appreciate that the UK economy could be looking much rosier by 2017, but I'm not holding out much hope.
We are looking at the move back as a long term plan for our two daughters, currently 5 and 12.
#37
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 1,253
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
I think there are real advantages for any kid in Australia with regards to the climate.
In the UK in the middle of winter when it is rainly / overcast it can be pretty much dark for the school run, and it can be pretty dark when they finish school as well. This doesn't impact on their edication of course, but it can be a bit depressing.
Even in the middle of winter in Sydney it is never dark for the school runs. I never leave work in the dark also. it is dark by the time I get home in June /July but it isn't that bad. Also my sons school has an outside covered teaching area that he loves being under. The kids do spend more of their time outdoors at school here which I think is a good thing.
We take advantage of the familty fun day Sundays in Sydney and go regularly to a beach all year round. Even in the middle of winter we go to the beach and again my son loves it
In the UK in the middle of winter when it is rainly / overcast it can be pretty much dark for the school run, and it can be pretty dark when they finish school as well. This doesn't impact on their edication of course, but it can be a bit depressing.
Even in the middle of winter in Sydney it is never dark for the school runs. I never leave work in the dark also. it is dark by the time I get home in June /July but it isn't that bad. Also my sons school has an outside covered teaching area that he loves being under. The kids do spend more of their time outdoors at school here which I think is a good thing.
We take advantage of the familty fun day Sundays in Sydney and go regularly to a beach all year round. Even in the middle of winter we go to the beach and again my son loves it
#38
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 10,375
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
Cheap university fees.
Easy laid back education system, not much effort required in primary, so kids have a ball, party time at school. Not that way in grade 10+, schools then panic to finally teach them something.
The weather is not an advantage, UV in many places is a problem year round. Plus who the hell really enjoys such extremes of climate, take your pick.. extreme UV, extreme heat, flies, humidity floods or bushfires. Terrible climate especially in summer. Winters the nice bit in most of oz.
Easy laid back education system, not much effort required in primary, so kids have a ball, party time at school. Not that way in grade 10+, schools then panic to finally teach them something.
The weather is not an advantage, UV in many places is a problem year round. Plus who the hell really enjoys such extremes of climate, take your pick.. extreme UV, extreme heat, flies, humidity floods or bushfires. Terrible climate especially in summer. Winters the nice bit in most of oz.
#39
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
Thats before we even think about what Oz may or may not be like in 10 years.
#40
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
In the long term your children should benefit from the sunshine providing increased vitamin D which helps with increased bone density. However exercise is also a factor, and I am confident from my own very long experience in Australia, that in Oz there is more opportunity for children to play outdoors.
#41
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Oct 2005
Location: Hill overlooking the SE Melbourne suburbs
Posts: 16,622
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
Good response (apart from the stereotyped bit about Brits just wanting to watch Jeremy Kyle etc).
Maybe my view is shaped by my own experiences. I've always played outdoor sports in the UK and most of my mates in Oz spend as much time in the pub (if not more) than my mates here do.
I do think outdoor activities in Oz can be prohibitively expensive (both skiing lift tickets and national park camping passes in oz are now officially the most expensive in the world) but with being close to the sea there is perhaps more opportunity for a wider variety of sports.
Maybe my view is shaped by my own experiences. I've always played outdoor sports in the UK and most of my mates in Oz spend as much time in the pub (if not more) than my mates here do.
I do think outdoor activities in Oz can be prohibitively expensive (both skiing lift tickets and national park camping passes in oz are now officially the most expensive in the world) but with being close to the sea there is perhaps more opportunity for a wider variety of sports.
A lot of us were into outdoor activities in the UK and if you mentioned it in the pub or office you would get looks of disbelief or even horror. It's the same here to an extent. I think if you are into mainstream activity there is a chance here which people think they don't get in the UK - even if they are 'wrong'.
Look at boats - here it is very likely, I would say it is more likely that anyone will know of someone with a boat, and, have gone out in it, and indeed take it somewhere. How many people in a London office will let you know they are out on the Thames or South Coast for the weekend? I say it would be less likely.
Still.
As for the expense...hmmm...I get out in the mountains in the snow and you can take a tent and cross-country ski or crampon out on the plains without spending a ton. Having said that I did 'gear up' out of the US!
I think there are real advantages for any kid in Australia with regards to the climate.
In the UK in the middle of winter when it is rainly / overcast it can be pretty much dark for the school run, and it can be pretty dark when they finish school as well. This doesn't impact on their edication of course, but it can be a bit depressing.
Even in the middle of winter in Sydney it is never dark for the school runs. I never leave work in the dark also. it is dark by the time I get home in June /July but it isn't that bad. Also my sons school has an outside covered teaching area that he loves being under. The kids do spend more of their time outdoors at school here which I think is a good thing.
We take advantage of the familty fun day Sundays in Sydney and go regularly to a beach all year round. Even in the middle of winter we go to the beach and again my son loves it
In the UK in the middle of winter when it is rainly / overcast it can be pretty much dark for the school run, and it can be pretty dark when they finish school as well. This doesn't impact on their edication of course, but it can be a bit depressing.
Even in the middle of winter in Sydney it is never dark for the school runs. I never leave work in the dark also. it is dark by the time I get home in June /July but it isn't that bad. Also my sons school has an outside covered teaching area that he loves being under. The kids do spend more of their time outdoors at school here which I think is a good thing.
We take advantage of the familty fun day Sundays in Sydney and go regularly to a beach all year round. Even in the middle of winter we go to the beach and again my son loves it
I think that the majority of people in mainstream activities could spend more time outside in Australia if that's their thing. I find a far greater portion of people camp here but I didn't know quite so many in London. It's hard to say. I think it's a bit disingenious to think that a city population cowers at home because there is a bushfire 4 hours away. Extreme heat is unpleasant but people start earlier or wait until later - in Victoria anyhow. Even this last week in Melbourne it has been a lot cooler - and very pleasant.
And some people move to Australia and do get a bit more outdoorsy.
#42
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
It only ever comes up in the same, cliched - look at the proles(!) - fashion in which you just used it!
#43
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Oct 2005
Location: Hill overlooking the SE Melbourne suburbs
Posts: 16,622
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
And it does comes up when people talk about what they miss. And did.
#44
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Oct 2005
Location: Hill overlooking the SE Melbourne suburbs
Posts: 16,622
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
I don't mean Jeremy Kyle at all. I am mixing that name with the name of some comedians who have come out of the UK in recent years. And it seems that Kyle is a show, universally derided, not a comedy standup.
And a google by chance tells me it is Peter KAY..
I tell you now - when it comes to TV you can rely on me to get it wrong - and I DO rely on BE to tell me - it's my source of truth. This is what happens when you have been out of a place for a while.
It's been said before - migrants do eventually fail to pick up on references that are easily known elsewhere.
Last edited by BadgeIsBack; Feb 4th 2013 at 11:14 pm.
#45
Banned
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 3,300
Re: what are the main benefits for children in Oz over Uk? apart from obvious weather
Guys....I think I have found the error.
I don't mean Jeremy Kyle at all. I am mixing that name with the name of some comedians who have come out of the UK in recent years. And it seems that Kyle is a show, universally derided, not a comedy standup.
And a google by chance tells me it is Peter KAY..
I tell you now - when it comes to TV you can rely on me to get it wrong - and I DO rely on BE to tell me - it's my source of truth. This is what happens when you have been out of a place for a while.
It's been said before - migrants do eventually fail to pick up on references that are easily known elsewhere.
I don't mean Jeremy Kyle at all. I am mixing that name with the name of some comedians who have come out of the UK in recent years. And it seems that Kyle is a show, universally derided, not a comedy standup.
And a google by chance tells me it is Peter KAY..
I tell you now - when it comes to TV you can rely on me to get it wrong - and I DO rely on BE to tell me - it's my source of truth. This is what happens when you have been out of a place for a while.
It's been said before - migrants do eventually fail to pick up on references that are easily known elsewhere.