Suitcases - hard or soft
#1
Capt Hilts
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2008
Location: Sunny Adelaide :)
Posts: 1,573
Suitcases - hard or soft
Hopefully emigrating in Aug and starting to look for suitcases, anyones thoughts on type? We probably would use them again for other travel.
We have 4 young kids if that makes any difference
Also, may look on ebay.
thanks for any help,
Cooler
We have 4 young kids if that makes any difference
Also, may look on ebay.
thanks for any help,
Cooler
#2
Banned
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 22,348
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
You'll probably find some in a pound shop or your local China Town.
Last edited by paulry; May 21st 2009 at 11:41 am.
#3
Forum Regular
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 147
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
We bought some trolly bags from ebay that only weigh abour 2 kilos each. Much less than suitcases that are around 5-6 kilos.
#4
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
don't go for the hard suitcases, they weigh alot more, we got couple good ones & couple cheap ones from argos.
#5
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jan 2008
Location: Sydney AUS - Leeds/Selby/York UK - Sydney AUS (April 2011)
Posts: 797
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
Hard ones can crack/break when dropped etc on a hard surface, soft ones can be cut with a knife/easily get into by baddies............but soft weighs more
#6
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
I prefer hard cases but they do tend to be heavier than soft cases. Whatever you choose make sure it has 4 wheels...much easier to wheel than the 2 wheel ones.
#7
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Feb 2008
Location: A Small Village in Somerset.......out in the sticks
Posts: 1,476
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
We travelled to Oz last week with hard cases and won't be using them again!
One has cracked, one has a stand broken off and now has 2 screws poking out of it, (not sure how to get rid of them as they are in the lining of the case and poking out through by about an inch) 2 are dented and another has a split in it.
Will be buying some holdall ones with wheels for the next time we travel.
One has cracked, one has a stand broken off and now has 2 screws poking out of it, (not sure how to get rid of them as they are in the lining of the case and poking out through by about an inch) 2 are dented and another has a split in it.
Will be buying some holdall ones with wheels for the next time we travel.
#8
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
My father - in law uses cheap cases (20 pound ones) and throws them away whenever they are broken.
Just depends what you want.
#9
Capt Hilts
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2008
Location: Sunny Adelaide :)
Posts: 1,573
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
Thanks all, think it will be cheap soft ones with four wheels.
Great advice, cheers,
Cooler
Great advice, cheers,
Cooler
#10
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 554
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
If there are a few of you, deffo go for the ones with four wheels, they are soo much easier to drag around - even the kids can pull/push them, which isnt always the case with the two wheel ones which tend to fall over and arent always that easy to manoeuver (did I spell that right, it looks weird!)
#11
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
Arrived 4 months ago via America so had large luggage allowance. We had 2 hard cases and 2 trolley cases and planned to just use them. When it came to it though, we had loads more to pack than we planned (due to spending christmas with parents and them buying the kids shitloads of stuff!) so we had to use Mum's wheely holdalls too.
So, 8 bags in total from Manchester to Heathrow to LA (3 nights stop) to Aukland to Brisbane.
The best of the lot were the large wheeled holdall bags. Light as a feather, packed absolutely loads into them. Easy to carry or wheel. Clothes packed in them arrived relatively crease free and the gifts packed (in the middle of the clothes) were all fine.
OH and I both agreed we would never bother with cases in the future, just use the holdall bags. Also, when not being used they go fairly flat so are easy to store and they are much cheaper than buying cases. Another point is that they can be used for small trips, the kids staying at friends or school camps etc, when you would not really want to use a proper suit case.
Hope this helps,
Ren xx
So, 8 bags in total from Manchester to Heathrow to LA (3 nights stop) to Aukland to Brisbane.
The best of the lot were the large wheeled holdall bags. Light as a feather, packed absolutely loads into them. Easy to carry or wheel. Clothes packed in them arrived relatively crease free and the gifts packed (in the middle of the clothes) were all fine.
OH and I both agreed we would never bother with cases in the future, just use the holdall bags. Also, when not being used they go fairly flat so are easy to store and they are much cheaper than buying cases. Another point is that they can be used for small trips, the kids staying at friends or school camps etc, when you would not really want to use a proper suit case.
Hope this helps,
Ren xx
#12
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Nov 2006
Location: Camberwell, Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 781
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
All depends on your baggae allowance but as you will probabaly use it all, I;d recommend one hard case for the breakable stuff and vlauable stuff, and soft for everything else.
Hard always weigh more (natural as they are thick plastic) but poretect far better.
We ended up with about 12 bags on three trolleys for a family of 5, with three kids under 5 so they were not pushing any trollies.
But as it's just at one end and the other you need to get them, you can survive.
Typical hard case weighs between 5-7 kg. Typical soft bag weighs between 1-2kg. Big difference....
Hard always weigh more (natural as they are thick plastic) but poretect far better.
We ended up with about 12 bags on three trolleys for a family of 5, with three kids under 5 so they were not pushing any trollies.
But as it's just at one end and the other you need to get them, you can survive.
Typical hard case weighs between 5-7 kg. Typical soft bag weighs between 1-2kg. Big difference....
#13
Capt Hilts
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2008
Location: Sunny Adelaide :)
Posts: 1,573
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
Thanks for the extra posts, will have a look at holdalls.
If anyone perusing this thread, did you take your golf clubs and bags as well? OH and I both have bags and clubs. I've not found hard cases in AG or elswhere yet.
Cheers,
Cooler
If anyone perusing this thread, did you take your golf clubs and bags as well? OH and I both have bags and clubs. I've not found hard cases in AG or elswhere yet.
Cheers,
Cooler
#14
Capt Hilts
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2008
Location: Sunny Adelaide :)
Posts: 1,573
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
Old thread started by me but I thought I'd update from the experience.
Thanks to all the responses on this thread as it made us go for soft sports bags which were perfect. They weighed a kilo and the suitcases we had (handle and wheels) were 5kgs. As we we were bringing two sets of golf clubs, buggy and travel cot as well, it made it easier. We had to do an internal flight with Virgin Blue so had to keep the excess down so the light bags worked. Should have realised that golf bags were counted as excess at Mel though Let us off so that saved $500.
Thanks,
Cooler
Thanks to all the responses on this thread as it made us go for soft sports bags which were perfect. They weighed a kilo and the suitcases we had (handle and wheels) were 5kgs. As we we were bringing two sets of golf clubs, buggy and travel cot as well, it made it easier. We had to do an internal flight with Virgin Blue so had to keep the excess down so the light bags worked. Should have realised that golf bags were counted as excess at Mel though Let us off so that saved $500.
Thanks,
Cooler
#15
Re: Suitcases - hard or soft
I bought 3 jazzibags holdalls with pullout handle and 2 wheels - each weighed 2kgs and each easily fit 20kg of stuff. Very easy to maneuver (single parent on long haul flight) and they only cost gbp20 each!