Small money transfers - Xoom vs XE
#1
Small money transfers - Xoom vs XE
This isn't rocket science but just a quick share as I've been using XE.com for several years to send relatively small amounts (less than $1k) monthly back to UK for misc. bills and hadn't really looked around:
I got quotes on both this week to compare. The exchange rate was a tiny bit better for XE but for a small transfer, the $22 fee made the difference. For my transaction:
It doesn't save much but it'll pay for a few pints and it's much quicker with Xoom. Large transactions still good for XE.
- XE.com were charging $22 per transfer (which takes several days).
- Xoom.com charge $4.99 per transfer (took about 30 minutes).
I got quotes on both this week to compare. The exchange rate was a tiny bit better for XE but for a small transfer, the $22 fee made the difference. For my transaction:
- Xoom was better up until $2,100 was being exchanged into GBP.
- XE was better thereafter as the better exchange rate caught up with the transaction fee.
It doesn't save much but it'll pay for a few pints and it's much quicker with Xoom. Large transactions still good for XE.
#3
Re: Small money transfers - Xoom vs XE
Crap - you're right. I'll get my coat...
Last edited by Dougster75; Jan 22nd 2014 at 7:55 pm.
#5
Re: Small money transfers - Xoom vs XE
Because most people probably haven't heard of ACH, but every one has heard of doing a wire, would be my guess....so it's easy money for them.
#7
Forum Regular
Joined: Aug 2013
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 92
Re: Small money transfers - Xoom vs XE
I recently transferred GB pound from bank accounts in the UK online (not a wire transfer)
I had two transfers, both set up for online payments from Mine and the other from my wife's bank accounts: the money was converted in US $'s at Lloyds and transferred online to our BofA accounts here in California
The fees came down to this my transfer 10 GB pounds from Lloyds for my transfer (under 5k GBP) and 17.50 GBP for my wife's transfer (over 5k GBP)
When the money which took 2 days arrived my BoA account charge $16 and the same for my wife, the BoA statement said incomming wire transfer fee? on top of that we received statements from BoA that $35 was deducted from my total and $40 from my wife's. After speaking with an manger of the BoA exchange dept. she said the amount was taken out before it arrived, must be by a 3rd party bank, I argued that there was no 3rd party bank involved and as she could not name the 3rd party bank and this was not a transfer the fee was incorrect, Lloyds bank also confirmed there were no 3rd party bank involved.
Has anyone else come across this problem??
I just thinking that this may happen again and again when I transfer my UK pension when I start receiving it later this year. If I have it paid into my BofA account here what will the charges be then I wonder??
Does anyone else have a better solution?
#9
Re: Small money transfers - Xoom vs XE
Yes.
I log into my account with World First and book a currency exchange selling pounds and buying dollars.
I then log into my Natwest account and transfer the required amount in pounds to World First's account at Barclays.
When World First receive my payment they send the dollars to my account at a Credit Union on the day I asked them to send the money. World First do not offer ACH payment, at least I can't find the option, and send it as a wire transfer.
Total cost to me for the whole transfer is $8 charged by my credit union for an incoming wire transfer. World First offer a much better exchange rate then Natwest. Their exchange rate improves for amounts over £10k. I use World First to bring over my UK pensions becasue they are licensed to trade in Oregon. There are other currency brokers you just need to find one that you like who can trade to your State.
I log into my account with World First and book a currency exchange selling pounds and buying dollars.
I then log into my Natwest account and transfer the required amount in pounds to World First's account at Barclays.
When World First receive my payment they send the dollars to my account at a Credit Union on the day I asked them to send the money. World First do not offer ACH payment, at least I can't find the option, and send it as a wire transfer.
Total cost to me for the whole transfer is $8 charged by my credit union for an incoming wire transfer. World First offer a much better exchange rate then Natwest. Their exchange rate improves for amounts over £10k. I use World First to bring over my UK pensions becasue they are licensed to trade in Oregon. There are other currency brokers you just need to find one that you like who can trade to your State.
#10
Some Where in the Desert
Joined: Jul 2006
Location: AZ
Posts: 247
Re: Small money transfers - Xoom vs XE
Transfer of money fro UK to USA: ??? Whats the Cheapest way to go?
I recently transferred GB pound from bank accounts in the UK online (not a wire transfer)
I had two transfers, both set up for online payments from Mine and the other from my wife's bank accounts: the money was converted in US $'s at Lloyds and transferred online to our BofA accounts here in California
The fees came down to this my transfer 10 GB pounds from Lloyds for my transfer (under 5k GBP) and 17.50 GBP for my wife's transfer (over 5k GBP)
When the money which took 2 days arrived my BoA account charge $16 and the same for my wife, the BoA statement said incomming wire transfer fee? on top of that we received statements from BoA that $35 was deducted from my total and $40 from my wife's. After speaking with an manger of the BoA exchange dept. she said the amount was taken out before it arrived, must be by a 3rd party bank, I argued that there was no 3rd party bank involved and as she could not name the 3rd party bank and this was not a transfer the fee was incorrect, Lloyds bank also confirmed there were no 3rd party bank involved.
Has anyone else come across this problem??
I recently transferred GB pound from bank accounts in the UK online (not a wire transfer)
I had two transfers, both set up for online payments from Mine and the other from my wife's bank accounts: the money was converted in US $'s at Lloyds and transferred online to our BofA accounts here in California
The fees came down to this my transfer 10 GB pounds from Lloyds for my transfer (under 5k GBP) and 17.50 GBP for my wife's transfer (over 5k GBP)
When the money which took 2 days arrived my BoA account charge $16 and the same for my wife, the BoA statement said incomming wire transfer fee? on top of that we received statements from BoA that $35 was deducted from my total and $40 from my wife's. After speaking with an manger of the BoA exchange dept. she said the amount was taken out before it arrived, must be by a 3rd party bank, I argued that there was no 3rd party bank involved and as she could not name the 3rd party bank and this was not a transfer the fee was incorrect, Lloyds bank also confirmed there were no 3rd party bank involved.
Has anyone else come across this problem??
#11
Forum Regular
Joined: Aug 2013
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 92
Re: Small money transfers - Xoom vs XE
I have used TorFX to do a couple of wire transfers and though they say there is no fee on their end in the two transfer I did using different receiving banks there was a $20 fee that neither TorFX or the receiving banks could explain. They both pointed to the other party in the wire transfer.
Last edited by Westham; Jan 23rd 2014 at 1:34 pm.
#12
Forum Regular
Joined: Aug 2013
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 92
Re: Small money transfers - Xoom vs XE
Yes.
I log into my account with World First and book a currency exchange selling pounds and buying dollars.
I then log into my Natwest account and transfer the required amount in pounds to World First's account at Barclays.
When World First receive my payment they send the dollars to my account at a Credit Union on the day I asked them to send the money. World First do not offer ACH payment, at least I can't find the option, and send it as a wire transfer.
Total cost to me for the whole transfer is $8 charged by my credit union for an incoming wire transfer. World First offer a much better exchange rate then Natwest. Their exchange rate improves for amounts over £10k. I use World First to bring over my UK pensions becasue they are licensed to trade in Oregon. There are other currency brokers you just need to find one that you like who can trade to your State.
I log into my account with World First and book a currency exchange selling pounds and buying dollars.
I then log into my Natwest account and transfer the required amount in pounds to World First's account at Barclays.
When World First receive my payment they send the dollars to my account at a Credit Union on the day I asked them to send the money. World First do not offer ACH payment, at least I can't find the option, and send it as a wire transfer.
Total cost to me for the whole transfer is $8 charged by my credit union for an incoming wire transfer. World First offer a much better exchange rate then Natwest. Their exchange rate improves for amounts over £10k. I use World First to bring over my UK pensions becasue they are licensed to trade in Oregon. There are other currency brokers you just need to find one that you like who can trade to your State.
Also does anyone have their British pension sent in US$'s to their bank in the USA? If so what charges are involved?
Any information appreciated.
Last edited by Westham; Jan 23rd 2014 at 1:36 pm.
#13
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 906
#14
Re: Small money transfers - Xoom vs XE
I have used TorFX to do a couple of wire transfers and though they say there is no fee on their end in the two transfer I did using different receiving banks there was a $20 fee that neither TorFX or the receiving banks could explain. They both pointed to the other party in the wire transfer.
Last edited by Pulaski; Jan 23rd 2014 at 2:15 pm.
#15
Rootbeeraholic
Joined: Aug 2009
Location: Houston, Tx
Posts: 2,280
Re: Small money transfers - Xoom vs XE
Transfer of money fro UK to USA: ??? Whats the Cheapest way to go?
I recently transferred GB pound from bank accounts in the UK online (not a wire transfer)
I had two transfers, both set up for online payments from Mine and the other from my wife's bank accounts: the money was converted in US $'s at Lloyds and transferred online to our BofA accounts here in California
The fees came down to this my transfer 10 GB pounds from Lloyds for my transfer (under 5k GBP) and 17.50 GBP for my wife's transfer (over 5k GBP)
When the money which took 2 days arrived my BoA account charge $16 and the same for my wife, the BoA statement said incomming wire transfer fee? on top of that we received statements from BoA that $35 was deducted from my total and $40 from my wife's. After speaking with an manger of the BoA exchange dept. she said the amount was taken out before it arrived, must be by a 3rd party bank, I argued that there was no 3rd party bank involved and as she could not name the 3rd party bank and this was not a transfer the fee was incorrect, Lloyds bank also confirmed there were no 3rd party bank involved.
Has anyone else come across this problem??
I just thinking that this may happen again and again when I transfer my UK pension when I start receiving it later this year. If I have it paid into my BofA account here what will the charges be then I wonder??
Does anyone else have a better solution?
I recently transferred GB pound from bank accounts in the UK online (not a wire transfer)
I had two transfers, both set up for online payments from Mine and the other from my wife's bank accounts: the money was converted in US $'s at Lloyds and transferred online to our BofA accounts here in California
The fees came down to this my transfer 10 GB pounds from Lloyds for my transfer (under 5k GBP) and 17.50 GBP for my wife's transfer (over 5k GBP)
When the money which took 2 days arrived my BoA account charge $16 and the same for my wife, the BoA statement said incomming wire transfer fee? on top of that we received statements from BoA that $35 was deducted from my total and $40 from my wife's. After speaking with an manger of the BoA exchange dept. she said the amount was taken out before it arrived, must be by a 3rd party bank, I argued that there was no 3rd party bank involved and as she could not name the 3rd party bank and this was not a transfer the fee was incorrect, Lloyds bank also confirmed there were no 3rd party bank involved.
Has anyone else come across this problem??
I just thinking that this may happen again and again when I transfer my UK pension when I start receiving it later this year. If I have it paid into my BofA account here what will the charges be then I wonder??
Does anyone else have a better solution?
UK to US is WAY quicker than US to UK. Transfers from the UK are frequently in my US account the next day. This is mainly due to the fact that wires from my Lloyds account are free and free to the xe.com account (which is also in the UK). I pay no wire fees and get the exchange rate I lock in when I place the transaction. Just don't choose the wire option for the US end.