The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
#1
The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
As the blurb says for the US section of this forum. Well, I don't want to be a moaning minnie but, having just noticed that, I have to disagree. (Hey, it gives me something to moan about, right? ha ha).
So far, in my (admittedly limited experience) America is so far from a 'melting pot' of cultures, creeds, religion and races that it is untrue.
Anyone who has ever ridden a bus will tell you the same. African Americans avoid Caucasian Americans, or Europeans, studiously. They live in financially, socially and, dare I say it educationally separated neighbourhoods. Latinos don't even bother. America is so much more segregated than even the UK, with it's inherently seperationalist island culture, that to call it (the USA) a melting pot is laughable. A melting pot suggests everyone mixes up and gets along just fine and dandy. That doesn't seem to be the case.
I may be wrong here and invite opinions on this. So far I have seen nothing but segregation and suspicion of other cultures and creeds. Any thoughts?
So far, in my (admittedly limited experience) America is so far from a 'melting pot' of cultures, creeds, religion and races that it is untrue.
Anyone who has ever ridden a bus will tell you the same. African Americans avoid Caucasian Americans, or Europeans, studiously. They live in financially, socially and, dare I say it educationally separated neighbourhoods. Latinos don't even bother. America is so much more segregated than even the UK, with it's inherently seperationalist island culture, that to call it (the USA) a melting pot is laughable. A melting pot suggests everyone mixes up and gets along just fine and dandy. That doesn't seem to be the case.
I may be wrong here and invite opinions on this. So far I have seen nothing but segregation and suspicion of other cultures and creeds. Any thoughts?
#2
Account Closed
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 15,455
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
It doesn't feel quite as bad as that around here.
#3
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
Originally Posted by Sally
It doesn't feel quite as bad as that around here.
#4
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
Originally Posted by Silly Sod
Not at all, and not around here, But I have heard that 'melting pot' theory all of my life, like all UK folk growing up on westerns and Hollywood movies I thought it was one big happy family; the blacks were freed and everyone lived happily ever after etc etc. Just questioning the melting pot thing. I mean, c'mon? Get a bus downtown late at night lol. It aint like croc dundee in NYC and the 'hood' aint really full of guys like Chris Rock and Ice Cube in Friday. I thought Moss Side was bad. Uh uh, Naa, etc, Moss Side is heaven compared!
#5
Account Closed
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 15,455
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
Originally Posted by Silly Sod
Not at all, and not around here, But I have heard that 'melting pot' theory all of my life, like all UK folk growing up on westerns and Hollywood movies I thought it was one big happy family; the blacks were freed and everyone lived happily ever after etc etc. Just questioning the melting pot thing. I mean, c'mon? Get a bus downtown late at night lol. It aint like croc dundee in NYC and the 'hood' aint really full of guys like Chris Rock and Ice Cube in Friday. I thought Moss Side was bad. Uh uh, Naa, etc, Moss Side is heaven compared!
#6
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
So, rather than how it "feels", how many of you have racial minorities as neighbours, which would be a better measuring stick.
In our street there are two hispanic families, the other 18-20 are white.
In our street there are two hispanic families, the other 18-20 are white.
#7
Account Closed
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 15,455
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
Originally Posted by Mrs Danvers
So, rather than how it "feels", how many of you have racial minorities as neighbours, which would be a better measuring stick.
In our street there are two hispanic families, the other 18-20 are white.
In our street there are two hispanic families, the other 18-20 are white.
The kids' schools are more mixed racially and seem harmonious, in the course of one of the endless girl troubles though I was told that Latinos don't like Blacks, cannot substantiate that.
#8
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
Originally Posted by Mrs Danvers
So, rather than how it "feels", how many of you have racial minorities as neighbours, which would be a better measuring stick.
In our street there are two hispanic families, the other 18-20 are white.
In our street there are two hispanic families, the other 18-20 are white.
#9
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
Originally Posted by Mrs Danvers
So, rather than how it "feels", how many of you have racial minorities as neighbours, which would be a better measuring stick.
In our street there are two hispanic families, the other 18-20 are white.
In our street there are two hispanic families, the other 18-20 are white.
#10
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
Originally Posted by irnbru4u
At least 3 black families and quite a few Hispanic.
#11
Account Closed
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 15,455
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
Originally Posted by Silly Sod
We may have lost the point of my original post here. I was not trying to get everybody to justify living in the US along side nations of people living at third world levels in one of the richest western nations on the planet - merely querying the 'melting pot' theory.
#12
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
Originally Posted by Sally
I think melting pot originally referred to people of all ethnic backgrounds absorbing and living "the American Way". This seems currently less attractive to some groups.
#13
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
Originally Posted by Silly Sod
We may have lost the point of my original post here. I was not trying to get everybody to justify living in the US along side nations of people living at third world levels in one of the richest western nations on the planet - merely querying the 'melting pot' theory.
#14
Account Closed
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 15,455
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
Originally Posted by Silly Sod
Sheeeit Sally, that is controversial!!!! The American Way? Explain? (Oh dear, is this becoming an actual forum convo rather than the usual lets stop discussing and talk about the weather in various different states scenario ha ha)
#15
Re: The Melting Pot Of The Western World?
Originally Posted by irnbru4u
I know but the thread was evolving into something else and Mrs Danvers asked a question which I answered.