Debt Help needed
#16
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 8
Re: Debt Help needed
Originally Posted by dunroving
Considering the two of you have 13 posts between you, your observations are laughable. Try searching back through the posts of some of the "arseholes", and you'll find that generally we are extremely helpful and have spent hours giving useful advice. But sometimes we just tell it like it is, especially when a neophyte asks for free advice and gets all whingy when they get opinion in return.
Like I said, if you try searching the site (you know, using the Search facility that most Web sites have) you'll find plenty of helpful advice on the topic of debt problems - you might be surprised to find that some of that advice came from "us arseholes". Or maybe you'd prefer to pay some lawyer $250 an hour to tell you the same thing we will.
Like I said, if you try searching the site (you know, using the Search facility that most Web sites have) you'll find plenty of helpful advice on the topic of debt problems - you might be surprised to find that some of that advice came from "us arseholes". Or maybe you'd prefer to pay some lawyer $250 an hour to tell you the same thing we will.
Dunroving, I don't know why I've upset you, but if I have I apologise. As I explained, I didn't realise there was a site search and if that offends you, I also apologise for that.
When did you tell me like it is? I asked 2 questions and as far as I can see you haven't even tried to answer them. All you've done is decided that I'm trying to avoid paying these debts, which I'm not, and getiing whingy because of the "telling it like it is", which I'm not. Just finding it a bit strange that I look at a forum where many people ask advice on a multitude of subjects and you're right, get decent and good natured answers, but I ask a couple of questions, I get "grow up", etc. I shall repeat that I never once said that I have no intention to repay the debts.
"Don't expect sympathy from everyone". Not looking for sympathy, just looking for some good honest advice from good honest people. Sorry again if this offends you.
#17
Re: Debt Help needed
Originally Posted by Yosser
There is no easy way to pay off credit card debt back in the U.K, out of my $250 check I send, only 65 quid actually comes off the account, its ball breaking I know, but its just got to be done.
#18
Re: Debt Help needed
Originally Posted by peregrine
Dunroving, I don't know why I've upset you, .....
Just to show I'm not a complete arsehole, look here: http://britishexpats.com/forum/showthread.php?t=105504 for a previous thread which I think you'll find enlightening. You'll see a post from me partway down with links to two other similar threads. I believe the second of these threads might be a little too much for you as it contains some pretty damning condemnation of people who don't accept responsibility for their debts. So, it comes with a parental warning.
Before you go calling me an arsehole again, please read through the entirety of these threads to get a better perspective of who I am - and if you still think I'm an arsehole after that, fair enough.
#19
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 8
Re: Debt Help needed
Originally Posted by dunroving
Well, for a start you called me an arsehole - I don't think I used that kind of language on you, I was just up front with you.
Just to show I'm not a complete arsehole, look here: http://britishexpats.com/forum/showthread.php?t=105504 for a previous thread which I think you'll find enlightening. You'll see a post from me partway down with links to two other similar threads. I believe the second of these threads might be a little too much for you as it contains some pretty damning condemnation of people who don't accept responsibility for their debts. So, it comes with a parental warning.
Before you go calling me an arsehole again, please read through the entirety of these threads to get a better perspective of who I am - and if you still think I'm an arsehole after that, fair enough.
Just to show I'm not a complete arsehole, look here: http://britishexpats.com/forum/showthread.php?t=105504 for a previous thread which I think you'll find enlightening. You'll see a post from me partway down with links to two other similar threads. I believe the second of these threads might be a little too much for you as it contains some pretty damning condemnation of people who don't accept responsibility for their debts. So, it comes with a parental warning.
Before you go calling me an arsehole again, please read through the entirety of these threads to get a better perspective of who I am - and if you still think I'm an arsehole after that, fair enough.
I never at any time called you an Arsehole, you'll find that this is what I replied to Brit Vic
"Thanks Brit Vic, I'm sure I'll get it all sorted through time. As for arseholes, ah well, each to their own eh? Life's too short."
If you take from that that I meant you then thats up to you.
As I say, I asked 2 civil questions and you took it upon yourself to call me lazy, say I was whining and that I didn't follow the way of getting out. Well if thats the way you see the situation with the minimum of facts thats fine by me.
I'm not on here for an argument. I just happened across this site as I'm new to the web and thought it might be good to "chat" to fellow expats and maybe get some help along the way.
#22
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 8
Re: Debt Help needed
Originally Posted by Bob
You not able to pay quaterly instead of monthly? Save on the transfer fees and the like...never know, might be worth asking?
Thanks for that Bob. It has never been offered but I will ask, nothing to lose and will save me quite a few $$$$$$
#23
Re: Debt Help needed
Originally Posted by peregrine
Dunrovin,
I never at any time called you an Arsehole, you'll find that this is what I replied to Brit Vic
"Thanks Brit Vic, I'm sure I'll get it all sorted through time. As for arseholes, ah well, each to their own eh? Life's too short."
If you take from that that I meant you then thats up to you.
As I say, I asked 2 civil questions and you took it upon yourself to call me lazy, say I was whining and that I didn't follow the way of getting out. Well if thats the way you see the situation with the minimum of facts thats fine by me.
I'm not on here for an argument. I just happened across this site as I'm new to the web and thought it might be good to "chat" to fellow expats and maybe get some help along the way.
I never at any time called you an Arsehole, you'll find that this is what I replied to Brit Vic
"Thanks Brit Vic, I'm sure I'll get it all sorted through time. As for arseholes, ah well, each to their own eh? Life's too short."
If you take from that that I meant you then thats up to you.
As I say, I asked 2 civil questions and you took it upon yourself to call me lazy, say I was whining and that I didn't follow the way of getting out. Well if thats the way you see the situation with the minimum of facts thats fine by me.
I'm not on here for an argument. I just happened across this site as I'm new to the web and thought it might be good to "chat" to fellow expats and maybe get some help along the way.
#24
British/Irish(ish) Duncs
Joined: Jan 2003
Location: Cambridge MA, via Mississippi and Belfast Northern Ireland.
Posts: 700
Re: Debt Help needed
Originally Posted by peregrine
I divorced a few years ago leaving me nothing but the debt which included around 25,000 gbp with 3 credit cards. I moved to the US 2 years ago and due to health reason, didn't work for a while, therefore nothing was paid. I then secureda low paid job and with the help of a debt management co. in the UK I managed to negotiate a monthly payments to the card companies. (My new girlfriend also helped me meet the payments). With the exchange rate the way it is and with wiring costs I just found it impossible to pay these every month, so done the real sensible thing and stuck my head in the sand and stopped paying them.
Now out of the bluse a company calls me from Illinois, claiming to have bought MBNA card debt and info and they now want payment. My 2 questions are:
1. Does this mean I now have bad debt in the UK and the US?
2. Is it legal to sell my debt and info to a US company?
Thanks in advance.
Now out of the bluse a company calls me from Illinois, claiming to have bought MBNA card debt and info and they now want payment. My 2 questions are:
1. Does this mean I now have bad debt in the UK and the US?
2. Is it legal to sell my debt and info to a US company?
Thanks in advance.
1. No.
2. this is not possible. Debt liability can not be transferred from the UK to a US company, this is not legally possible.
On the wider issue of dealing with debts i suggest strongly you check out other previous posts. I am not starting a new discussion on this issue as i am tired of it.
I suggest you refuse payment to the ILL company unless they produce evidence of a UK court order and the subseqeunt US court order for enforcement of this order in your current state jurisdiction.
You should also take steps to resolve the debt in the UK before it ends up as a CCJ registered against you and buggers your credit for 6 years.
Last edited by Duncs; Nov 18th 2004 at 4:18 am.
#25
Re: Debt Help needed
Originally Posted by Duncs
I am not trying to undermine other comments but actually:
1. No.
2. this is not possible. Debt liability can not be transferred from the UK to a US company, this is not legally possible.
On the wider issue of dealing with debts i suggest strongly you check out other previous posts. I am not starting a new discussion on this issue as i am tired of it.
I suggest you refuse payment to the ILL company unless they produce evidence of a UK court order and the subseqeunt US court order for enforcement of this order in your current state jurisdiction.
You should also take steps to resolve the debt in the UK before it ends up as a CCJ registered against you and buggers your credit for 6 years.
1. No.
2. this is not possible. Debt liability can not be transferred from the UK to a US company, this is not legally possible.
On the wider issue of dealing with debts i suggest strongly you check out other previous posts. I am not starting a new discussion on this issue as i am tired of it.
I suggest you refuse payment to the ILL company unless they produce evidence of a UK court order and the subseqeunt US court order for enforcement of this order in your current state jurisdiction.
You should also take steps to resolve the debt in the UK before it ends up as a CCJ registered against you and buggers your credit for 6 years.
#26
British/Irish(ish) Duncs
Joined: Jan 2003
Location: Cambridge MA, via Mississippi and Belfast Northern Ireland.
Posts: 700
Re: Debt Help needed
Originally Posted by dunroving
Hey, Duncs, I was hoping you'd jump in at some point. Haven't seen you too much lately. Are they treating you all right at Harvard?
I didnt want to have another major discussion on the ethics of paying or not paying debts but i felt it was important to clarify the issue of whether debts could be easily transferred. It is important to remember that the foundation of all debt liability is in contract law. In that way it operates on a jurisdiction by jurisdiction basis and its usually only enforceable in the jurisdiction in which the contract was made unless the agreement specifically states otherwise ie a term that says the law of england and wales applies to a contract made in scotland etc. Enforcement overseas is a really big hassle and people have a major piece of leverage available to them if they use the fact of their non Uk residence. However i do not advocate putting your head in the sand debts generally wont just go away if you ignore them and in many cases the 6 years limit in the statute of limitations can be avoided by simplying getting summary judgement. this is easy enough if no defendant appears to enter a defence to a writ and then you sit on your judgement until the person comes home or you move to enforce in the USA(hassle and expensive to do but possible).
It seems best to be precise though in these matters so just trying to help.
#27
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Oct 2004
Location: The Big Apple
Posts: 1,834
Re: Debt Help needed
Originally Posted by Duncs
I am not trying to undermine other comments but actually:
1. No.
2. this is not possible. Debt liability can not be transferred from the UK to a US company, this is not legally possible.
On the wider issue of dealing with debts i suggest strongly you check out other previous posts. I am not starting a new discussion on this issue as i am tired of it.
I suggest you refuse payment to the ILL company unless they produce evidence of a UK court order and the subseqeunt US court order for enforcement of this order in your current state jurisdiction.
You should also take steps to resolve the debt in the UK before it ends up as a CCJ registered against you and buggers your credit for 6 years.
1. No.
2. this is not possible. Debt liability can not be transferred from the UK to a US company, this is not legally possible.
On the wider issue of dealing with debts i suggest strongly you check out other previous posts. I am not starting a new discussion on this issue as i am tired of it.
I suggest you refuse payment to the ILL company unless they produce evidence of a UK court order and the subseqeunt US court order for enforcement of this order in your current state jurisdiction.
You should also take steps to resolve the debt in the UK before it ends up as a CCJ registered against you and buggers your credit for 6 years.
Might be something to do with the fact that MBNA is an American company that they have tracked you down? Seems a bit dodgy thought selling UK debt to US company! Proper legal advice would be the best way to go I reckon
#28
British/Irish(ish) Duncs
Joined: Jan 2003
Location: Cambridge MA, via Mississippi and Belfast Northern Ireland.
Posts: 700
Re: Debt Help needed
Originally Posted by Big D
Might be something to do with the fact that MBNA is an American company that they have tracked you down? Seems a bit dodgy thought selling UK debt to US company! Proper legal advice would be the best way to go I reckon
#29
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 8
Re: Debt Help needed
Originally Posted by Duncs
Dodgy and impossible. What kind of idiot buys a non enforceable contractual liability? Transfer of debts works by selling the contractual liability to another party for a reduced fee on the debt amount, usually around 5% of the total debt by the way. MBNA is a multinational is UK operation is a seperate legal entity registered as a company in the UK. It cannot legally transfer information or debts between its UK and USA arms. doesnt mean they dont try though i suppose. Seriously tell the US company to **** off and sort out your debts with MBNA UK.
I have been in touch with the CC companies since I made the original post and offered payments. Just waiting for them to accept or decline.
Thanks again.
#30
Re: Debt Help needed
Originally Posted by Duncs
Dodgy and impossible. ... MBNA is a multinational is UK operation is a seperate legal entity registered as a company in the UK. It cannot legally transfer information or debts between its UK and USA arms.
I don't know -- I think Big D has a point here.
MBNA is a US company with its international headquarters in Delaware with several overseas operations, including in the UK. Ultimately MBNA is a US bank, so it's not too far-fetched that they made an internal decision to charge off this account and sell it to a 3rd party debt collector in the States, where the OP is now living.
To answer the OP's question, "Is it legal to sell my debt and info to a US company?" -- my answer would be yes, I believe it is, since MBNA is a US bank, and you currently live in the US.
FWIW, I opened an MBNA (US) account last year, and when I asked if I could transfer a balance from my husband's British credit card account, I was told yes -- as long as his account wasn't with MBNA (UK). If it was then that would be considered an internal balance transfer, which MBNA (and most credit card companies) doesn't allow. The fact that my account was MBNA (US) and his was MBNA (UK) was irrelevant -- MBNA=MBNA.
~ Jenney