British wife moving to US, has an unsecured loan
#91
Forum Regular
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 232
Re: British wife moving to US, has an unsecured loan
As others have done, you also miss the small but very important point of "intent". But lawyers the world over thank you for it - it keeps them in business
#92
Re: British wife moving to US, has an unsecured loan
Or the reverse which is the Bank taking it from the taxpayer and handing it out to senior execs in the form of a bonus. After all it ISN'T stealing if you are rich is it?
As others have done, you also miss the small but very important point of "intent". But lawyers the world over thank you for it - it keeps them in business
As others have done, you also miss the small but very important point of "intent". But lawyers the world over thank you for it - it keeps them in business
And if I can go to my bank, take out what I put in plus interest, what has been stolen?
If you are referring to Goldman Sachs bonuses, unless I'm mistaken, they repaid the bailout money some time ago.
#93
Forum Regular
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 232
Re: British wife moving to US, has an unsecured loan
I didn't miss the intent. If you take out a loan and don't intend to repay it...
And if I can go to my bank, take out what I put in plus interest, what has been stolen?
If you are referring to Goldman Sachs bonuses, unless I'm mistaken, they repaid the bailout money some time ago.
And if I can go to my bank, take out what I put in plus interest, what has been stolen?
If you are referring to Goldman Sachs bonuses, unless I'm mistaken, they repaid the bailout money some time ago.
#94
Re: British wife moving to US, has an unsecured loan
.....waiting patiently for everyone to agree that this is a completely fine thing to do whilst working out on my calculator how much I can save by running away and not paying all those loans.....
Seriously, it never even occurred to me. The world is a lot smaller than it was, maybe 50 years ago those who went off to Amerikay were never to be seen or heard of again (so my Mum says) and could avoid their debts. I am not brave enough to chance it.
Seriously, it never even occurred to me. The world is a lot smaller than it was, maybe 50 years ago those who went off to Amerikay were never to be seen or heard of again (so my Mum says) and could avoid their debts. I am not brave enough to chance it.
#95
And YOU'RE paying for it!
Joined: May 2007
Location: kipper tie?
Posts: 2,328
Re: British wife moving to US, has an unsecured loan
Even people who have been convicted of offences involving dishonesty and who for example buy a car on credit make reasonable attempts to repay or the car gets repoed. There is no correlation between loan defaults and honesty/dishonesty, no matter how counterintuitive that may appear to people.
In fact the mis named "honest majority" have the highest default rates - go figure
In fact the mis named "honest majority" have the highest default rates - go figure
...you're in a different position from the OP's OH.
#97
Just Joined
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 13
Re: British wife moving to US, has an unsecured loan
It is much easier for HSBC to chase you in the US than a lot of people in this topic think! It is mostly determined by the law of the particular State you are in. It will be a pain in the **** for HSBC and could be costly for them, but it is definitely possible. The earlier estimate of a $35k cost to the bank is way over the top.
Whether they'd bother to pursue you over a £6k debt or not I don't know. I imagine they would have a pretty good go, or at least hand you over to a collection agency as other posters mentioned. Not to mention that you large costs and interest if you ever return to the UK, or if they do manage to get a US court to enforce the debt. It is definitely a risk.
(I'm a trainee corporate lawyer BTW... don't specialise in this kind of thing but have an outline knowledge)
Whether they'd bother to pursue you over a £6k debt or not I don't know. I imagine they would have a pretty good go, or at least hand you over to a collection agency as other posters mentioned. Not to mention that you large costs and interest if you ever return to the UK, or if they do manage to get a US court to enforce the debt. It is definitely a risk.
(I'm a trainee corporate lawyer BTW... don't specialise in this kind of thing but have an outline knowledge)
#98
Forum Regular
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 232
Re: British wife moving to US, has an unsecured loan
It is much easier for HSBC to chase you in the US than a lot of people in this topic think! It is mostly determined by the law of the particular State you are in. It will be a pain in the **** for HSBC and could be costly for them, but it is definitely possible. The earlier estimate of a $35k cost to the bank is way over the top.
Whether they'd bother to pursue you over a £6k debt or not I don't know. I imagine they would have a pretty good go, or at least hand you over to a collection agency as other posters mentioned. Not to mention that you large costs and interest if you ever return to the UK, or if they do manage to get a US court to enforce the debt. It is definitely a risk.
(I'm a trainee corporate lawyer BTW... don't specialise in this kind of thing but have an outline knowledge)
Whether they'd bother to pursue you over a £6k debt or not I don't know. I imagine they would have a pretty good go, or at least hand you over to a collection agency as other posters mentioned. Not to mention that you large costs and interest if you ever return to the UK, or if they do manage to get a US court to enforce the debt. It is definitely a risk.
(I'm a trainee corporate lawyer BTW... don't specialise in this kind of thing but have an outline knowledge)
Flying witnesses in hoteling them + Billable hours, depos, document retrieval etc etc. HSBC do not use in house counsel they have panel firms and the hourly rates for non standard default judgement collection is pretty steep.
Any collectors here can be sent a simple cease and desist letter and they are gone. The chances of any JDB proving a case based on bought UK paper here in the US for consumer debt is slightly better than a snowball in hell but not by much.
I have seen a lot of misinformation in various threads on this subject and much of it is well intentioned but very misinformed.
Your outline knowledge should make you aware of the venue and jurisdictional issues that arise and each state has its own version of FDCPA.
Then there is the whole other problem of consumer protection legislation in two very different countries to contend with.
The bottom line is if a person wishes to conduct their affairs in that fashion the chances of them avoiding the debt whilst living in the USA are exceptionally high. As to what happens if they return to the UK well that is a whole other matter.
As to whether or not they should act in this way I make no comment either way. I simply want to correct some of the misinformation I have seen in older posts on similar sets of circumstances.
I had one client recently who was being sued for an $11,500 credit card debt that was still with the original (USA) creditor. The CC company was able to provide the original contract signed, a full accounting for 5 years plus of the account. There is no doubt they owed the money and were quite candid about it. Easy pickings for the bank to collect right?
Not quite the client walked away with judgement against the CC company and a check for damages. Recovery of consumer debt when it is defended is not as simple in the USA as people believe it is.
In fact practically all credit card debt, and a large percentage of other consumer debt presently owed in the USA is simply not recoverable through court action.
#99
And YOU'RE paying for it!
Joined: May 2007
Location: kipper tie?
Posts: 2,328
Re: British wife moving to US, has an unsecured loan
Well, it ain't substantiated here, so I'm afraid I'm treating you like the Joker by default!
For instance - that last claim often pops up t'internet (moneysavingexpert, here...), often accompanied by C&P odysseys bringing up the Magna Carta, Dred Scott and the moon landings. But I haven't seen anyone ever substantiate it with a credible source. It might well be perfectly true but there hasn't been anything (I've seen) to support the claims.
Can you be the first??? The mission, should you choose to accept it, is there...
For instance - that last claim often pops up t'internet (moneysavingexpert, here...), often accompanied by C&P odysseys bringing up the Magna Carta, Dred Scott and the moon landings. But I haven't seen anyone ever substantiate it with a credible source. It might well be perfectly true but there hasn't been anything (I've seen) to support the claims.
Can you be the first??? The mission, should you choose to accept it, is there...
#100
Forum Regular
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 232
Re: British wife moving to US, has an unsecured loan
Well, it ain't substantiated here, so I'm afraid I'm treating you like the Joker by default!
For instance - that last claim often pops up t'internet (moneysavingexpert, here...), often accompanied by C&P odysseys bringing up the Magna Carta, Dred Scott and the moon landings. But I haven't seen anyone ever substantiate it with a credible source. It might well be perfectly true but there hasn't been anything (I've seen) to support the claims.
Can you be the first??? The mission, should you choose to accept it, is there...
For instance - that last claim often pops up t'internet (moneysavingexpert, here...), often accompanied by C&P odysseys bringing up the Magna Carta, Dred Scott and the moon landings. But I haven't seen anyone ever substantiate it with a credible source. It might well be perfectly true but there hasn't been anything (I've seen) to support the claims.
Can you be the first??? The mission, should you choose to accept it, is there...
The substantiation is available to you at your local court house. Go pull the dockets and amaze yourself.
Learning by reading is much better than learning by spoon feeding - at least that is what I was told at Uni.
Or keep the batmask on and continue to be blinded.
#101
And YOU'RE paying for it!
Joined: May 2007
Location: kipper tie?
Posts: 2,328
Re: British wife moving to US, has an unsecured loan
Unfortunately that confuses people looking for advice, lets people delude themselves into unwise decisions and dilutes what might be the useful advice of people who might actually know what they're talking about - like you!
#102
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Sep 2007
Posts: 525
Re: British wife moving to US, has an unsecured loan
No complaints here - I spent the money and agreed to the stupid arse interest rates!