Redress
#1
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 14
Redress
I had an arrest over 30 years ago but no conviction: the case was thrown out and it was not, in any case, a CIMT offence.
Prior to getting a GC I was pulled into secondary processing and questioned a couple of times. No real problem, always allowed in.
However, I returned from a UK vacation a few weeks ago and was, for the first time with my GC, referred to secondary processing. Again, kept me waiting for a bit but a few questions and I was on my way.
Firstly, why the need to keep pulling me? If I was vetted for and got both a H1B and then a GC surely they have all the answers they need? Failing that, if they can see that I've been let in before, why stop me again? Do they believe that something may have changed?
The officer told me to get citizenship as they would then not pull me in again. I replied that they told me that about the Green Card a couple of years ago. I know they are allowed to lie but what is the point in this instance? He offered the info, I didn't ask.
So, my question is: can I use the Redress system to overcome this? Does it work or will I simply make things worse? Is there any other approach I should take or is it something I have to live with until I get citizenship (another 3 years)?
Thanks
Prior to getting a GC I was pulled into secondary processing and questioned a couple of times. No real problem, always allowed in.
However, I returned from a UK vacation a few weeks ago and was, for the first time with my GC, referred to secondary processing. Again, kept me waiting for a bit but a few questions and I was on my way.
Firstly, why the need to keep pulling me? If I was vetted for and got both a H1B and then a GC surely they have all the answers they need? Failing that, if they can see that I've been let in before, why stop me again? Do they believe that something may have changed?
The officer told me to get citizenship as they would then not pull me in again. I replied that they told me that about the Green Card a couple of years ago. I know they are allowed to lie but what is the point in this instance? He offered the info, I didn't ask.
So, my question is: can I use the Redress system to overcome this? Does it work or will I simply make things worse? Is there any other approach I should take or is it something I have to live with until I get citizenship (another 3 years)?
Thanks
#2
American Expat
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 7,598
Re: Redress
Go ahead and do the redress. Was the arrest in the US?
#4
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 14
Re: Redress
Yes: it was an INS issue that got tossed out of court but the arrest stayed on my record.
#5
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 14
Re: Redress
I have no idea what a T country is. Are you referring to the tea growing regions of the world? In that case you would be incorrect. Perhaps you meant as in Yorkshire with "Ay, lads from t'north".
#7
Re: Redress
I had an arrest over 30 years ago but no conviction: the case was thrown out and it was not, in any case, a CIMT offence.
Prior to getting a GC I was pulled into secondary processing and questioned a couple of times. No real problem, always allowed in.
However, I returned from a UK vacation a few weeks ago and was, for the first time with my GC, referred to secondary processing. Again, kept me waiting for a bit but a few questions and I was on my way.
Firstly, why the need to keep pulling me? If I was vetted for and got both a H1B and then a GC surely they have all the answers they need? Failing that, if they can see that I've been let in before, why stop me again? Do they believe that something may have changed?
The officer told me to get citizenship as they would then not pull me in again. I replied that they told me that about the Green Card a couple of years ago. I know they are allowed to lie but what is the point in this instance? He offered the info, I didn't ask.
So, my question is: can I use the Redress system to overcome this? Does it work or will I simply make things worse? Is there any other approach I should take or is it something I have to live with until I get citizenship (another 3 years)?
Thanks
Prior to getting a GC I was pulled into secondary processing and questioned a couple of times. No real problem, always allowed in.
However, I returned from a UK vacation a few weeks ago and was, for the first time with my GC, referred to secondary processing. Again, kept me waiting for a bit but a few questions and I was on my way.
Firstly, why the need to keep pulling me? If I was vetted for and got both a H1B and then a GC surely they have all the answers they need? Failing that, if they can see that I've been let in before, why stop me again? Do they believe that something may have changed?
The officer told me to get citizenship as they would then not pull me in again. I replied that they told me that about the Green Card a couple of years ago. I know they are allowed to lie but what is the point in this instance? He offered the info, I didn't ask.
So, my question is: can I use the Redress system to overcome this? Does it work or will I simply make things worse? Is there any other approach I should take or is it something I have to live with until I get citizenship (another 3 years)?
Thanks
BTW, J Fong mentioned being amused by the use of the word "surely" by the English. It is said in good humor seeing how his husband is English.
#8
Re: Redress
Question INS issue?
#10
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 14
Re: Redress
Nickname: given to me by colleagues: apparently means "white master" or something else equally offensive.
#11
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 14
Re: Redress
For being pulled into secondary because I have an arrest from 30+ years ago. It just seems like a waste of time as the case was tossed and plenty of people get arrested and nothing further happens. I'd like to be able to get through immigration without having to go to secondary every time I come back in. I thought that was what the redress service was for. Is that incorrect?
Note: was an INS issue. Arrested, erroneously, for being out of status when, in fact, was already a long way down getting a green card which I got about a month after the arrest. The judge was quite annoyed that they had wasted the court's time by not showing some common sense. It was a very long time ago - not sure why it would still be an issue, especially if I was never convicted nor had my passport stamped or anything of that nature.
Just trying to find out if it is worth using the redress system for this.
Note: was an INS issue. Arrested, erroneously, for being out of status when, in fact, was already a long way down getting a green card which I got about a month after the arrest. The judge was quite annoyed that they had wasted the court's time by not showing some common sense. It was a very long time ago - not sure why it would still be an issue, especially if I was never convicted nor had my passport stamped or anything of that nature.
Just trying to find out if it is worth using the redress system for this.
Last edited by gorasahib; Jun 30th 2014 at 10:47 pm.
#13
Account Closed
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 2
Re: Redress
I might be inclined to find out what it means or could mean!