Direct Flights versus One Stop Flights
#1
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 22
Direct Flights versus One Stop Flights
Hi,
I live in the USA and have family come over pretty much every year. Whenever we look at flights we always notice that the one stop flights are less expensive sometimes but a considerable amount.
An Example would be that a flight from Manchester to Atlanta could be 800GBP direct but a flight from Manchester to Jacksonville via Atlanta could be 500GBP. This is when still catching same flight from Manchester to Atlanta but just connecting.
1, Is there a reason behind the flight price differences?
2, What stops people from booking a one stop flight but then clearing immigration and customs in Atlanta and exiting there, so no connection?
Any knowledge or advice would be appreciated.
Thanks
Tamhawk1969
I live in the USA and have family come over pretty much every year. Whenever we look at flights we always notice that the one stop flights are less expensive sometimes but a considerable amount.
An Example would be that a flight from Manchester to Atlanta could be 800GBP direct but a flight from Manchester to Jacksonville via Atlanta could be 500GBP. This is when still catching same flight from Manchester to Atlanta but just connecting.
1, Is there a reason behind the flight price differences?
2, What stops people from booking a one stop flight but then clearing immigration and customs in Atlanta and exiting there, so no connection?
Any knowledge or advice would be appreciated.
Thanks
Tamhawk1969
#2
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jul 2015
Location: Panama City, FL
Posts: 2,064
Re: Direct Flights versus One Stop Flights
No idea why, but this related story is very interesting:
How a 23-year-old beat United Airlines - Dec. 31, 2015
How a 23-year-old beat United Airlines - Dec. 31, 2015
#3
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jul 2015
Location: Watford
Posts: 1,147
Re: Direct Flights versus One Stop Flights
You are paying for convenience!
When Mrs DJ and myself were dating I would fly any route that was cheap
LHR to JFK to ATL to LAS my worst, think it worked out close to 22 hours from start to finish
I even booked short notice package deals with hotel included, these bizarrely enough worked out cheaper than a flight alone, Virgin used to have screaming short notice deals
But booking an indirect flight has been the savvy travellers way of getting a cheaper flight, fly to the 'stopover' destination but not continue further
I have a sneaking suspicion airlines cottoned on and were reflecting that in the pricing
When Mrs DJ and myself were dating I would fly any route that was cheap
LHR to JFK to ATL to LAS my worst, think it worked out close to 22 hours from start to finish
I even booked short notice package deals with hotel included, these bizarrely enough worked out cheaper than a flight alone, Virgin used to have screaming short notice deals
But booking an indirect flight has been the savvy travellers way of getting a cheaper flight, fly to the 'stopover' destination but not continue further
I have a sneaking suspicion airlines cottoned on and were reflecting that in the pricing
#5
Re: Direct Flights versus One Stop Flights
If you don't complete the flight the airline cancels all onward/ return legs. It can be done on a limited basis on the return leg if you can get hold of your luggage, but you're playing with fire if you try it on the outward leg.
A family friend tried to use the return leg of a ticket that he had not used the outward leg of, and found himself stranded in California with no way to buy a ticket - one way tickets cannot be bought by non-US citizens, or at least they couldn't then, in the years shortly after 9/11.
A family friend tried to use the return leg of a ticket that he had not used the outward leg of, and found himself stranded in California with no way to buy a ticket - one way tickets cannot be bought by non-US citizens, or at least they couldn't then, in the years shortly after 9/11.
#6
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jul 2015
Location: Watford
Posts: 1,147
Re: Direct Flights versus One Stop Flights
If you don't complete the flight the airline cancels all onward/ return legs. It can be done on a limited basis on the return leg if you can get hold of your luggage, but you're playing with fire if you try it on the outward leg.
A family friend tried to use the return leg of a ticket that he had not used the outward leg of, and found himself stranded in California with no way to buy a ticket - one way tickets cannot be bought by non-US citizens, or at least they couldn't then, in the years shortly after 9/11.
A family friend tried to use the return leg of a ticket that he had not used the outward leg of, and found himself stranded in California with no way to buy a ticket - one way tickets cannot be bought by non-US citizens, or at least they couldn't then, in the years shortly after 9/11.
For example I want to fly to Atlanta it costs $1000, if I fly to Vegas via Atlanta it costs $800
So I book the Vegas trip but get off at Atlanta
It tends to work better international because you have to physically claim your luggage at POE
If you fly internally take carry on only, otherwise your hold luggage will automatically transfer to wherever your final destination was
As I said I think the loophole has been 'adjusted'
#7
Re: Direct Flights versus One Stop Flights
A family friend tried to use the return leg of a ticket that he had not used the outward leg of, and found himself stranded in California with no way to buy a ticket - one way tickets cannot be bought by non-US citizens, or at least they couldn't then, in the years shortly after 9/11.
I personally try to go for whatever route has least transfers.
A) I don't trust luggage handlers if I was forced into checking luggage. I try do all my trips just on hand luggage allowance if I can help it.
B) I never trust how long the customs / immigration line is
#8
Re: Direct Flights versus One Stop Flights
But if you book UK- Vegas- UK, but get out at Atlanta and not fly to Vegas, how do you get home?
#9
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jul 2015
Location: Watford
Posts: 1,147
Re: Direct Flights versus One Stop Flights
Mrs DJ used to fly like this
Book previously mentioned ticket, get out at Atlanta, fly on another ticket to perhaps Dallas
She would have meetings around the US, using various 'portions' of tickets, its a complete faff, but saves companies a ton of money
She would never go to Vegas and may not even return to Atlanta
As you know returns are cheaper than singles, and the return portion not used, standby flights become available
Her itinerary was a crazy binder of flight bookings
Like I said its for the savvy traveller, and a great way to save cash for the frequent flyer
#10
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2006
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 12,865
Re: Direct Flights versus One Stop Flights
Really this trick only works on the return portion or one-way tickets, or if you simply don't want to take the return. I toyed with the idea of doing it on a return to San Francisco last year, as the layover city turned out subsequent to buying the ticket to be somewhere I would have liked to have been and it would have saved me $$ just to skip the last leg back to SFO. But... the airline then changed my flight to a non-stop to SFO! The bottom line is when you buy a ticket, the airline is contracting to take you from point A to point B; they are not contracting to take you via a specific point C even if that is what was originally ticketed.
Last edited by Giantaxe; Jan 27th 2016 at 4:24 pm.
#11
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jul 2015
Location: Watford
Posts: 1,147
Re: Direct Flights versus One Stop Flights
Indeed.
Really this trick only works on return flights or one-way tickets, or if you simply don't want to take the return. I toyed with the idea of doing it on a return to San Francisco last year, as the layover city turned out subsequent to buying the ticket to be somewhere I would have liked to have been and it would have saved me $$ just to skip the last leg back to SFO. But... the airline then changed my flight to a non-stop to SFO! The bottom line is when you buy a ticket, the airline is contracting to take you from point A to point B; they are not contracting to take you via a specific point C even if that is what was originally ticketed.
Really this trick only works on return flights or one-way tickets, or if you simply don't want to take the return. I toyed with the idea of doing it on a return to San Francisco last year, as the layover city turned out subsequent to buying the ticket to be somewhere I would have liked to have been and it would have saved me $$ just to skip the last leg back to SFO. But... the airline then changed my flight to a non-stop to SFO! The bottom line is when you buy a ticket, the airline is contracting to take you from point A to point B; they are not contracting to take you via a specific point C even if that is what was originally ticketed.
She got upgraded to business..........was over the moon, but changed to direct...... oh lordy lol
As I said a faff! I had more than one phone call from Mrs DJ, helping her via Skyscanner/Expedia/Travelzoo, I got pretty good at it!
#12
Re: Direct Flights versus One Stop Flights
Right, but buying two transatlantic returns isn't going to save the OP and money, so while it can be a viable strategy for domestic flights within the US (which I didn't mean to deny), it doesn't help the OP at all.
#13
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jul 2015
Location: Watford
Posts: 1,147
Re: Direct Flights versus One Stop Flights
Maybe I went a little off tangent at some point, just a little