Someone doesn't like the AVE
#16










Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 12,053
From: In the middle of 10million Olive Trees











on the positive side...
new vehicles mean peoples job will remain for a bit longer
companies will have to put people onto cleaning up after the event and removing to scrap location
security will be improved - both electronic and manned, providing more short term and medium term jobs
on the negative side...
all this will have to be paid for out of the insurance, which will be spread across the premiums of the ordinary man (and woman) in the street.
It will not delay the inevitable of the AVE eventually being finished, although it may force the operator to reconsider the security for the medium term.
.
new vehicles mean peoples job will remain for a bit longer
companies will have to put people onto cleaning up after the event and removing to scrap location
security will be improved - both electronic and manned, providing more short term and medium term jobs
on the negative side...
all this will have to be paid for out of the insurance, which will be spread across the premiums of the ordinary man (and woman) in the street.
It will not delay the inevitable of the AVE eventually being finished, although it may force the operator to reconsider the security for the medium term.
.
#17
Thread Starter
Banned










Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 8,824
From: Living in a good place











Not the first time it has happened in the area, the last time all the trucks/machinery set alight were constructing the toll road. Probably a Luddite living nearby
#18
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 7,749











On that point I agree, health and education before fast trains!
#19
Banned










Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 19,367
From: Mallorca











It must be hard seeing billions being spent on a train near your door step while people are losing their jobs everywhere, millions of peoples wages are being cut and they have slashed spending on health and education
On that point I agree, health and education before fast trains!
On that point I agree, health and education before fast trains!
You can only pay generous benefits to an increasingly declining taxpayer base for so long ...
#21










Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 12,053
From: In the middle of 10million Olive Trees











It must be hard seeing billions being spent on a train near your door step while people are losing their jobs everywhere, millions of peoples wages are being cut and they have slashed spending on health and education
On that point I agree, health and education before fast trains!
On that point I agree, health and education before fast trains!
its only in the past couple of years that it has come home to roost.
so should they stop building the AVE because there isnt enough money to pay out so much on health & education?
Or should they get rid of the rotten to the core corruption in H&E as in other parts of government and get better value for money ?
#22
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 7,749











but when it was started Spain had everything, so there was no problem
its only in the past couple of years that it has come home to roost.
so should they stop building the AVE because there isnt enough money to pay out so much on health & education?
Or should they get rid of the rotten to the core corruption in H&E as in other parts of government and get better value for money ?
its only in the past couple of years that it has come home to roost.
so should they stop building the AVE because there isnt enough money to pay out so much on health & education?
Or should they get rid of the rotten to the core corruption in H&E as in other parts of government and get better value for money ?
Btw, there hasnt really been cases of corruption in these areas in Spain. Most corruption centres on corruption, tax or "consultancy" projects
The Spanish health service is one of the best in the world. Education, not so much, partly because they invest so little in it, especially on the university side
#23
Banned










Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 19,367
From: Mallorca











Spain has histrically been amongst the most generous in Europe - especially for the public sector. Highest public wages, guaranteed employment, generous pensions, lots of paid holidays, inefficient system requiring double the public labour force of other nations, just about the lowest cost health care costs in Europe (fully subsidised)..
Sounds great, right?
So, let's see, 25% (official) unemployment, 40% in some areas, youth unemployment highest in Europe, most of those unemployed working in the black economy, all legally exempt from taxes...
Sounds pretty generous to me. Even Germans don't get that kind of generosity. Fortunately, their economy doesn't need it, because they don't have the public burdens Spain does.
Sounds great, right?
So, let's see, 25% (official) unemployment, 40% in some areas, youth unemployment highest in Europe, most of those unemployed working in the black economy, all legally exempt from taxes...
Sounds pretty generous to me. Even Germans don't get that kind of generosity. Fortunately, their economy doesn't need it, because they don't have the public burdens Spain does.
#24
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 7,749












And fwiw, public sector wages are way higher in the UK and Germany than in Spain
My mother-in-law used to be head of social services, about a 50k salary here, closer to 150k salary in the UK
You are spouting out rheteric that has no relation to the facts
#26
Banned










Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 19,367
From: Mallorca











They're not benefits you loon 
And fwiw, public sector wages are way higher in the UK and Germany than in Spain
My mother-in-law used to be head of social services, about a 50k salary here, closer to 150k salary in the UK
You are spouting out rheteric that has no relation to the facts

And fwiw, public sector wages are way higher in the UK and Germany than in Spain
My mother-in-law used to be head of social services, about a 50k salary here, closer to 150k salary in the UK
You are spouting out rheteric that has no relation to the facts
Well, OK.. Whatever...
here's just one of many analysis which will confirm it, but I'll quote the good bits for you:
Spanish Economy: What's to blame for its problems?
Spending habit
Unfortunately for Spain, a burst housing bubble isn't the biggest problem the country faces.
That's because Spain also experienced another bubble - in its labour markets.
Wages rose far too quickly during the boom years of the last decade. Labour unit costs - a measure of how internationally competitive a country's labour force is - rose 40% relative to levels in Germany during the past decade.
That loss of competitiveness has left Spain - not just the government, but the entire country - with a big overspending problem.
With imports so cheap, and Spanish exports so expensive, the country's economy as a whole found itself spending 10% more than it was earning from the rest of the world in 2007 and 2008.
Unfortunately for Spain, a burst housing bubble isn't the biggest problem the country faces.
That's because Spain also experienced another bubble - in its labour markets.
Wages rose far too quickly during the boom years of the last decade. Labour unit costs - a measure of how internationally competitive a country's labour force is - rose 40% relative to levels in Germany during the past decade.
That loss of competitiveness has left Spain - not just the government, but the entire country - with a big overspending problem.
With imports so cheap, and Spanish exports so expensive, the country's economy as a whole found itself spending 10% more than it was earning from the rest of the world in 2007 and 2008.
Doesn't it seem logical that the most responsible thing to do is to get people employed before spending on social benefits that not only encourage sustained unemployment, but require tax collections to pay for it? Or shall we maintain Europe's highest unemployment and depend on EU bailouts for the foreseeable future?
Labour reforms and spending on infrastructure (instead of welfare) to get people working again are a very wise first step.
In case you haven't noticed, your idealism is precisely the kind of thinking that's brought us to this point. Somebody needs to quit dreaming and figure out how to get the economy moving again.
Last edited by amideislas; Jul 19th 2012 at 11:28 pm.
#27
Banned










Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 5,008











Erm... super-subsidised health care, high wages, guaranteed employment, zillions of days of paid holiday, .. and all that .. aren't benefits?
Well, OK.. Whatever...
here's just one of many analysis which will confirm it, but I'll quote the good bits for you:
Spanish Economy: What's to blame for its problems?
Well, OK.. Whatever...
here's just one of many analysis which will confirm it, but I'll quote the good bits for you:
Spanish Economy: What's to blame for its problems?
wages and holiday pay are not benefits.
#28










Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 12,053
From: In the middle of 10million Olive Trees











why does everyone trot out the comparison with Germany ??
Germany is an industrial/agro economy whilst
Spain is an agro/industrial economy
if you want to compare (although it is really hard to have true comparison) then try comparing with Portugal or Italy
But NOT Germany
Germany is an industrial/agro economy whilst
Spain is an agro/industrial economy
if you want to compare (although it is really hard to have true comparison) then try comparing with Portugal or Italy
But NOT Germany
#30
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 7,749











And a whole generation will miss out on an education
You have your piorities completely wrong
Anyway, it is not a case of a good health system OR growing the economy. That isnt the choice. You sound like you've been brainwashed by evil neo-liberal free market devil worshippers!



