British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Spain (https://britishexpats.com/forum/spain-75/)
-   -   An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad (https://britishexpats.com/forum/spain-75/mp-mps-expats-living-abroad-888291/)

Hornets_Nest Nov 30th 2016 9:51 am

An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 
With Brexit and all that is going on in the EU/UK at the moment should Ex-Pats in the EU (and beyond) not have some representation in Partliament based on the numbers living abroad?

Dxf Nov 30th 2016 10:26 am

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 
No, No, No and thrice times NO. We live abroad and therefore are not directly affected by most English laws; only laws appertaining to our finances really affect us if the UK is not our normal domicile

Davexf

Hornets_Nest Nov 30th 2016 11:48 am

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 

Originally Posted by dmu (Post 12117862)
This exists in France for French citizens living worldwide. My daughter in Germany has her "own" député in the Assemblée Nationale, but whether his and the other 10's voices are heard is another matter.

Well not such a daft idea maybe ;)

christmasoompa Nov 30th 2016 11:51 am

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 

Originally Posted by Hornets_Nest (Post 12117879)
Well not such a daft idea maybe ;)

I think most of the UK taxpayers, who would have to cover the cost of the MP for people that have chosen to leave the UK and who pay little or no tax there, would think it was a very daft idea indeed. :lol:

snikpoh Nov 30th 2016 12:20 pm

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 
I, personally, think it's extremely daft for the reasons @Dxf states.

We live in Spain and pay our taxes here, why do we need representation in a country we have left and can't vote in (after 15 years)?

bobd22 Nov 30th 2016 12:57 pm

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 

Originally Posted by snikpoh (Post 12117902)
I, personally, think it's extremely daft for the reasons @Dxf states.

We live in Spain and pay our taxes here, why do we need representation in a country we have left and can't vote in (after 15 years)?

Good points surely at the moment there are MEPS for eu issues? Funny but pre brexit most expats I spoke to re anything to do with politics or uk matters would give the stock answer " we have no interest in the uk we have made our lives here" funny now they think they should be one of the major parts of policy. Maybe if they had shown more interest pre 2016 they may just have seen this coming and realised that as far as majority are concerned they have no interest in expats as they have chosen to leave UK. Works both ways !

dmu Nov 30th 2016 1:05 pm

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 

Originally Posted by Hornets_Nest (Post 12117879)
Well not such a daft idea maybe ;)

Hi, I've found myself on the Spain forum by magic!
Actually, I agree with the others, that tax-payers (i.e. me) in France are paying all the costs and expenses involved with these extra bods, for those who have chosen to leave the country.
(P.S. Maybe I should specify that my daughter is French)

chopera Nov 30th 2016 2:18 pm

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 

Originally Posted by Dxf (Post 12117805)
No, No, No and thrice times NO. We live abroad and therefore are not directly affected by most English laws; only laws appertaining to our finances really affect us if the UK is not our normal domicile

Davexf

You've got more than "thrice" NOs in there, and could probably drop the "times" ;)

chopera Nov 30th 2016 2:32 pm

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 

Originally Posted by Hornets_Nest (Post 12117787)
With Brexit and all that is going on in the EU/UK at the moment should Ex-Pats in the EU (and beyond) not have some representation in Partliament based on the numbers living abroad?

No representation without taxation! If you don't pay your taxes in the UK you can't really expect to be represented in the UK parliament. However if the UK starts to tax its citizens abroad then you might have a case.

Pulaski Nov 30th 2016 2:50 pm

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 

Originally Posted by Dxf (Post 12117805)
No, No, No and thrice times NO. We live abroad and therefore are not directly affected by most English laws; only laws appertaining to our finances really affect us if the UK is not our normal domicile. .....

Finances are potentially pivotal to everything else in life, especially if you intend to return to the UK sooner or later.

My concern and objection would be that given the incredible range of situations of British citizens living overseas, the MP for expats would have a huge problem addressing the issues of all British citizens living overseas, with a constituency comprising international executives and those living in close to poverty, and everyone in between. And if the MP isn't in the ruling party then they would carry no weight and have negligible impact on government policy. ..... Perhaps a junior ministerial position for "expat affairs" would be more useful? :unsure:

bobd22 Nov 30th 2016 4:21 pm

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 

Originally Posted by chopera (Post 12118019)
No representation without taxation! If you don't pay your taxes in the UK you can't really expect to be represented in the UK parliament. However if the UK starts to tax its citizens abroad then you might have a case.

I would imagine very many expats do in fact pay tax to the uk government. Any one on a government pensions certainly will.

christmasoompa Nov 30th 2016 4:30 pm

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 

Originally Posted by bobd22 (Post 12118116)
I would imagine very many expats do in fact pay tax to the uk government. Any one on a government pensions certainly will.

Why? If all they are getting is the state pension, then their income is under the Personal Allowance, so no tax due?

But even if they're earning over that, don't most countries tax their residents on income i.e somebody living in Canada would be taxed by the Canadian government on any income, even if earned in the UK. The UK government wouldn't usually get any tax from it if one is tax resident elsewhere and there is a tax treaty in place between the two countries. Is Spain different then?

bobd22 Nov 30th 2016 4:44 pm

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 

Originally Posted by christmasoompa (Post 12118125)
Why? If all they are getting is the state pension, then their income is under the Personal Allowance, so no tax due?

But even if they're earning over that, don't most countries tax their residents on income i.e somebody living in Canada would be taxed by the Canadian government on any income, even if earned in the UK. The UK government wouldn't usually get any tax from it if one is tax resident elsewhere and there is a tax treaty in place between the two countries. Is Spain different then?

Because if a person is a government pensioner I.e. Military, police most NHS etc then those pensions can only be taxed in the uk irrespective of where you live. If they are also state pensioners then the state pension will be taxed in their contry of residence

bobd22 Nov 30th 2016 4:45 pm

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 
I am referring to government not state pension

christmasoompa Nov 30th 2016 4:58 pm

Re: An MP (or MPs) for Expats living abroad
 

Originally Posted by bobd22 (Post 12118136)
I am referring to government not state pension

Ah, ok. I'd call a state pension a government pension, but I see what you mean now. Still a very small percentage of expats that will be taxed on their pensions in the UK though, few will be paying tax there at all.


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:14 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.