The issue of Euthanasia
#31
In Andalucia the Law of Dignified Death was passed in 2010, but didn't get passed in the rest of the country because the party now in power doesn't support it.It means that, when there is absolutely no possibility of recovery, it is no longer illegal to withdraw treatment which is keeping someone alive artificially, if that is what the patient and/or family want.
Not quite the same as euthanasia, and there are lots of safeguards built in.
As for the church's role, most of the hospice care in Spain is provided by nuns, who do their best to alleviate suffering on a practical level. I'm pretty sure they wouldn't keep someone alive at all costs.
Not quite the same as euthanasia, and there are lots of safeguards built in.
As for the church's role, most of the hospice care in Spain is provided by nuns, who do their best to alleviate suffering on a practical level. I'm pretty sure they wouldn't keep someone alive at all costs.
Rosemary
Last edited by Rosemary; Oct 27th 2012 at 8:12 pm.
#32
BE Enthusiast





Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 530
From: Catalonia, Spain











Now nobody dare do this so the law needs changing. How to manage this though? If you suggest in consulation with family, what if the family are a bunch of money grabbing individuals who don't care about the patient and just want to get their hands on the will? What if there is no family and the patient has left their money to their friendly GP? Its so difficult to come up with a formula that protects people from the unscruplous.
Then you've got the patients themselves. What if they are able to ask to die, like some of the cases in the press recently? I would argue that should be enough but the counter argument is that they may be under pressure from relatives or just having a bad day.
#33
Joined on April fools day










Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 10,644
From: 30 miles from a decent grocery store.











Yes , but that's my point. He was doing it to healthy people not the terminally ill in obvious pain or distress. It's never been legal in the UK but before Shipman I believe that caring medical professionals quite often hastened the death of the terminally ill to alleviate their obvious suffering. They were breaking the letter of the law but common sense prevailed.
Now nobody dare do this so the law needs changing. How to manage this though? If you suggest in consulation with family, what if the family are a bunch of money grabbing individuals who don't care about the patient and just want to get their hands on the will? What if there is no family and the patient has left their money to their friendly GP? Its so difficult to come up with a formula that protects people from the unscruplous.
Then you've got the patients themselves. What if they are able to ask to die, like some of the cases in the press recently? I would argue that should be enough but the counter argument is that they may be under pressure from relatives or just having a bad day.
Now nobody dare do this so the law needs changing. How to manage this though? If you suggest in consulation with family, what if the family are a bunch of money grabbing individuals who don't care about the patient and just want to get their hands on the will? What if there is no family and the patient has left their money to their friendly GP? Its so difficult to come up with a formula that protects people from the unscruplous.
Then you've got the patients themselves. What if they are able to ask to die, like some of the cases in the press recently? I would argue that should be enough but the counter argument is that they may be under pressure from relatives or just having a bad day.
#34
BE Enthusiast





Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 530
From: Catalonia, Spain











That's interesting. I always thought the US had such a strong religious lobby that would have been against this. Are there many other states where this is allowed? Can you take a one way trip from another state if yours has different rules?
#35
Joined on April fools day










Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 10,644
From: 30 miles from a decent grocery store.











I'm afraid that I don't know. The law has been in effect over ten years here and is used reguraly, though not frequently. Many start the process, acquire the means, yet never use it. The bible belt is about 10 states, most of the rest are not much influenced by religious influences. Oregon is one of the least church attended states.





