British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   The Rovers Return (https://britishexpats.com/forum/rovers-return-111/)
-   -   Perception vs Reality (https://britishexpats.com/forum/rovers-return-111/perception-vs-reality-802466/)

Zen10 Jul 22nd 2013 6:58 am

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by chris955 (Post 10813290)
The trouble is you say you only look at facts then you make assumptions and personal opinions dressed as facts. The undeniable fact that Australia is materially better for most people ?? Australia offers an easier, more comfortable place to raise kids than Britain ?? Not facts, your opinions.

One good example of this is the childcare allowance. This is many times more generous than the British one, and directly affects living standards for parents and children. Fact. My wife's two sisters in Britain cannot afford to have more than one child because of the poor childcare, but have both said they would have two or three kids under the Australian allowance. Fact.

chris955 Jul 22nd 2013 7:15 am

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by Zen10 (Post 10813341)
One good example of this is the childcare allowance. This is many times more generous than the British one, and directly affects living standards for parents and children. Fact. My wife's two sisters in Britain cannot afford to have more than one child because of the poor childcare, but have both said they would have two or three kids under the Australian allowance. Fact.

OK, fair enough I can tell you are set in your ways. As I say just be careful of making an opinion a fact ;)
Im happy where I am and you are happy where you are so there is really no reason to disagree :)

Bud the Wiser Jul 22nd 2013 9:00 am

Re: Perception vs Reality
 
Can't perception affect reality though? For example, I have several friends who won't go into their town center on a Friday or Saturday night for a perceived fear that they would encounter trouble from drunken youths. Therefore, because their perceived fear causes them not to go into town they are never going to end up as a statistic that would affect the results of reality.

Zen10 Jul 22nd 2013 12:22 pm

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by chris955 (Post 10813375)
OK, fair enough I can tell you are set in your ways. As I say just be careful of making an opinion a fact ;)
Im happy where I am and you are happy where you are so there is really no reason to disagree :)

You are determined to turn our opinions into some kind of binary debate. No, I am not happy where I am. My concern is that I would be unhappy in Britain but for different reasons. The issue I have is I must choose between two different sets of problems. Wages are higher in Australia, tax is lower, childcare payments are massively higher, and property is (slightly) cheaper. Great. But what is the point of a materially superior existence when your entire family lives 16,000 kms away?

The difference in our arguments seems to be that you are almost exclusively biased in favour of Britain, saying practically nothing in favour of Australia at all and glossing over countless obvious issues in Britain, whereas I have clearly praised and criticised both countries, as is evident from all of my posts.

treasuredr Jul 22nd 2013 12:58 pm

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by Zen10 (Post 10813880)
You are determined to turn our opinions into some kind of binary debate. No, I am not happy where I am. My concern is that I would be unhappy in Britain but for different reasons. The issue I have is I must choose between two different sets of problems. Wages are higher in Australia, tax is lower, childcare payments are massively higher, and property is (slightly) cheaper. Great. But what is the point of a materially superior existence when your entire family lives 16,000 kms away?

The difference in our arguments seems to be that you are almost exclusively biased in favour of Britain, saying practically nothing in favour of Australia at all and glossing over countless obvious issues in Britain, whereas I have clearly praised and criticised both countries, as is evident from all of my posts.

:nod::nod:

TheEmperorIsNaked Jul 22nd 2013 9:53 pm

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by Bud the Wiser (Post 10813602)
Can't perception affect reality though? For example, I have several friends who won't go into their town center on a Friday or Saturday night for a perceived fear that they would encounter trouble from drunken youths. Therefore, because their perceived fear causes them not to go into town they are never going to end up as a statistic that would affect the results of reality.

Yes. I have finally traced my brother after 42 years, he lives close to London, but will not go there 'because of the terrorists'.

TheEmperorIsNaked Jul 22nd 2013 10:00 pm

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by treasuredr (Post 10813908)
:nod::nod:

:thumbdown: A 'two can play thing' eh?

We are certainly proving one thing: there is indeed no reality only perception!

The cup half full/half empty thing is an ongoing working model. I do it as well.

What I don't like is to have it dressed up as something else, when espousing one view and subtly denigrating another.

TheEmperorIsNaked Jul 22nd 2013 10:14 pm

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by Zen10 (Post 10813278)
I have no need to justify my stay in Australia. I look only at facts. I would prefer to be with family, overall, but I must balance this with the undeniable fact that life in Australia is materially superior for me and indeed most people. There will always be people who can go back cashed-up and not have to work, or run successful businesses, who can live in large isolated properties. But back in the real world, where I would be, with the majority of people, a return would mean normal living conditions - working, neighbours, commuting. Along with other facts like superior childcare, Australia offers an easier, more comfortable place to raise kids than Britain. This is the agony of choice.

...............just a hint; this lays false the statement that you only 'look at facts'. You cannot possibly know this for a 'fact', even if you come up with statistics to support your point of view. We can all come up with stats to support our pov.

Look Zen, each to his own. What I object to is that you deny what is so blatantly obvious in your posts. The highlighted statement is testimony to it!

I have to be honest. I really would like to write some blistering opinions about Australia, but what is the point? For starters it's bloody impolite, and besides many are happy and settled here.

Above all else, I would never want to dampen the hopes and dreams of those who plan to settle here, because they may well make a happy and enduring home in Australia.

Sally Redux Jul 23rd 2013 5:23 am

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by Zen10 (Post 10813880)
whereas I have clearly praised and criticised both countries, as is evident from all of my posts.

Have you? It never feels like that.

chris955 Jul 23rd 2013 5:34 am

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by Sally Redux (Post 10815251)
Have you? It never feels like that.

I must admit I feel the same, any praise directed at this country always seems to be tinged with a proviso.

pommybird Jul 23rd 2013 6:26 am

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by Zen10 (Post 10813341)
One good example of this is the childcare allowance. This is many times more generous than the British one, and directly affects living standards for parents and children. Fact. My wife's two sisters in Britain cannot afford to have more than one child because of the poor childcare, but have both said they would have two or three kids under the Australian allowance. Fact.

I find it very strange that a woman would make a decision on how many children to have based solely on the amount of child benefit they would get. Maybe it's just me?

And secondly is it really that vastly different? I get £135 a month in the UK for 2 kids, how much would I get in Oz?

Still Game Jul 23rd 2013 7:11 am

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by chris955 (Post 10815263)
I must admit I feel the same, any praise directed at this country always seems to be tinged with a proviso.

If I'm honest Chris955, and I haven't commented on this before, I feel the same about your posts. Very happy you and your family are in your own piece of paradise, that's a huge achievement on all levels and something most of us others can only strive for (I hope to be saying the same one day!). However, it does seem to me reading over your many threads that the same could be said about your posts on Australia. You do post positively, but always twinged with a little deep sourness about Australia. But guess what, you're completely allowed that opinion. As is Zen, as are all of us.

However many threads you folk write, I don't think you and Zen will ever convince each other of the opposite! It's natural to feel a sense to stick up for the place we're in (if we're happy there of course).

You asked above how people could have completely different experiences than you (on levels of service, happiness of people etc..) and that is because they do. Because we're all different and we all do have different experiences. Simples! I personally think service levels are much better in Oz, and that's just my personal experience speaking. You have found the opposite, due to your personal experience.

I'm not looking to get into debate so I'll leave it at one comment, just an observation really.

Courses for horses I guess, we're happy where we're happy....let's all be happy we're all happy ! :D

chris955 Jul 23rd 2013 7:21 am

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by pommybird (Post 10815322)
I find it very strange that a woman would make a decision on how many children to have based solely on the amount of child benefit they would get. Maybe it's just me?

And secondly is it really that vastly different? I get £135 a month in the UK for 2 kids, how much would I get in Oz?

Yes a bit of an odd comment, most friends have 2 or more kids and one have 5 kids. I dont think Zen meant child benefit but the amount of childcare they have to pay. Its strange when you see the number of people complaining about the cost.
http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politi...319-2gdlo.html

Zen10 Jul 23rd 2013 9:37 am

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by chris955 (Post 10815263)
I must admit I feel the same, any praise directed at this country always seems to be tinged with a proviso.

I can't help it if the facts lead me to your proviso thing. As I say, my desire is to return, for family reasons, but I am very cautious because Australia has a very high standard of living in most categories. It turns out this measures poorly against family.

Zen10 Jul 23rd 2013 9:38 am

Re: Perception vs Reality
 

Originally Posted by pommybird (Post 10815322)
I find it very strange that a woman would make a decision on how many children to have based solely on the amount of child benefit they would get. Maybe it's just me?

And secondly is it really that vastly different? I get £135 a month in the UK for 2 kids, how much would I get in Oz?

I'm not sure of the exact amount but it's considerably more than that. I'd like to know this woman you're talking about, who's making a decision on country of birth based solely on childcare though. What's her name?


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 10:24 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.