NHS verses Medicare
#1
I have just read in the local paper that a local lady is having to raise funds for her cancer treatment. I can't believe that Chemo is not covered on Medicare.
I know that many Brits dish the NHS but please it has to be better than Medicare. I hope
I know that many Brits dish the NHS but please it has to be better than Medicare. I hope
#2





Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 511

Originally Posted by woodyinoz
I have just read in the local paper that a local lady is having to raise funds for her cancer treatment. I can't believe that Chemo is not covered on Medicare.
I know that many Brits dish the NHS but please it has to be better than Medicare. I hope
I know that many Brits dish the NHS but please it has to be better than Medicare. I hope

Here I pay about $34 (~£14) for my script - and it goes up by about $1 every month!!!
#3
Originally Posted by kendodd
At least the NHS charges a "flat" fee for presciptions - around £6??
Here I pay about $34 (~£14) for my script - and it goes up by about $1 every month!!!
Here I pay about $34 (~£14) for my script - and it goes up by about $1 every month!!!
And yeah, coverage does vary a lot by where you live in the UK, but generally you get pretty good cover, whilst over here in the US, you could very well be without a paddle...
#4
Lost in BE Cyberspace










Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 10,375











Originally Posted by woodyinoz
I have just read in the local paper that a local lady is having to raise funds for her cancer treatment. I can't believe that Chemo is not covered on Medicare.
I know that many Brits dish the NHS but please it has to be better than Medicare. I hope
I know that many Brits dish the NHS but please it has to be better than Medicare. I hope

#5
Originally Posted by kendodd
At least the NHS charges a "flat" fee for presciptions - around £6??
Here I pay about $34 (~£14) for my script - and it goes up by about $1 every month!!!
Here I pay about $34 (~£14) for my script - and it goes up by about $1 every month!!!
#6
Originally Posted by jumping doris
I think you pay per item on an NHS prescription, at least you did when we left last year.
#7
Homebody










Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 23,190
From: HOME











Originally Posted by Bob
per drug yeah, but then you do that in the US too....and it certainly ain't as cheap as £6...especially if you don't have or have shite medical insurance...
And 75% of Brits don't pay at all - kids, pregnant women, pensioners, people on benefits, the unemployed, people with certain chronic illnesses like diabetes...
#8
I figure there are good and bad point about both systems.
In Aus, I get to see a doctor the same day I call for an appointment; but I have to pay. In the UK, I might have had to wait a few days (and before anyone jumps in, I know how long depends on where you are, but this is my story
) but the visit was not charged.
In the UK, I got a flat, per item rate for prescriptions. I did not get charged for contraception. In Aus, 'scripts are usually more expensive, but I do get the choice of brand or generic, meaning I can lower certain costs. I do get charged for contraceptives.
In the UK, I did not have (or need) health insurance. In Aus, I should (but don't) have health insurance; I find it a rip off. Whilst in the UK I got nominal charges for dental visits (as a private patient), in Aus I have spent several thousand dollars on this (wisdom teeth
).
Personally speaking, weighing it all up, I prefer the UK system. A wait is worth not having the financial cost.
GG
In Aus, I get to see a doctor the same day I call for an appointment; but I have to pay. In the UK, I might have had to wait a few days (and before anyone jumps in, I know how long depends on where you are, but this is my story
) but the visit was not charged. In the UK, I got a flat, per item rate for prescriptions. I did not get charged for contraception. In Aus, 'scripts are usually more expensive, but I do get the choice of brand or generic, meaning I can lower certain costs. I do get charged for contraceptives.
In the UK, I did not have (or need) health insurance. In Aus, I should (but don't) have health insurance; I find it a rip off. Whilst in the UK I got nominal charges for dental visits (as a private patient), in Aus I have spent several thousand dollars on this (wisdom teeth
).Personally speaking, weighing it all up, I prefer the UK system. A wait is worth not having the financial cost.
GG
#9
Homebody










Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 23,190
From: HOME











Originally Posted by Geordie George
I figure there are good and bad point about both systems.
In Aus, I get to see a doctor the same day I call for an appointment; but I have to pay. In the UK, I might have had to wait a few days (and before anyone jumps in, I know how long depends on where you are, but this is my story
) but the visit was not charged. GG
In Aus, I get to see a doctor the same day I call for an appointment; but I have to pay. In the UK, I might have had to wait a few days (and before anyone jumps in, I know how long depends on where you are, but this is my story
) but the visit was not charged. GGAFAIK, in the UK, your GP has to offer you an appointment within 2 days...
#10
Account Closed










Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 15,019

Originally Posted by Elvira
AFAIK, in the UK, your GP has to offer you an appointment within 2 days...
afaik if you insist they are required by law to see you on the day but that is kept hush hush
#11
Homebody










Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 23,190
From: HOME











Originally Posted by TruBrit
afaik if you insist they are required by law to see you on the day but that is kept hush hush 

Whenever I've had something urgent, they would see me (or rather the kids!) striaghtaway.
And they still do home visits FFS!!! Unheard of here...
Not to mention health visitor visits for mums with new babies
#12
Account Closed










Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 15,019

Originally Posted by Elvira
Whenever I've had something urgent, they would see me (or rather the kids!) striaghtaway.
And they still do home visits FFS!!! Unheard of here...
Not to mention health visitor visits for mums with new babies
And they still do home visits FFS!!! Unheard of here...
Not to mention health visitor visits for mums with new babies

#13
That was always my experience (in Sheffield, Newcastle and Oxford). And I liked that they had before and after work appointments - I didn't have to take time off just to get a repeat 'script or whatever. Here, they offer earlier/later appointments, but at a higher cost. So, I take time off work as I don't want to pay extra.
(As an aside, it annoys the hell out of me that they always book me in for a standard appointment, when a brief one would do me fine - take blood pressure, re-prescribe Femodene, I'm outta there. But then that would be cheaper, so they spend time rabbiting on about my general health and what to do if I forget to take a pill, so they can make the appointment last longer to charge more.
I really prefer UK health care.)
(As an aside, it annoys the hell out of me that they always book me in for a standard appointment, when a brief one would do me fine - take blood pressure, re-prescribe Femodene, I'm outta there. But then that would be cheaper, so they spend time rabbiting on about my general health and what to do if I forget to take a pill, so they can make the appointment last longer to charge more.
I really prefer UK health care.)
Originally Posted by Elvira
AFAIK, in the UK, your GP has to offer you an appointment within 2 days...
#14
Originally Posted by Elvira
And 75% of Brits don't pay at all - kids, pregnant women, pensioners, people on benefits, the unemployed, people with certain chronic illnesses like diabetes...
#15
Originally Posted by Geordie George
I figure there are good and bad point about both systems.
In Aus, I get to see a doctor the same day I call for an appointment; but I have to pay. In the UK, I might have had to wait a few days (and before anyone jumps in, I know how long depends on where you are, but this is my story
) but the visit was not charged.
GG
In Aus, I get to see a doctor the same day I call for an appointment; but I have to pay. In the UK, I might have had to wait a few days (and before anyone jumps in, I know how long depends on where you are, but this is my story
) but the visit was not charged. GG
This year I have paid out $700 in kids glasses. In the UK they are free but do you get a choice in frames or are they still the thick ones
My daughter also needs dental work to be done and we have been advised by the dentist here to get it done in the UK as it is free and whatever is done here will need to be removed ($1K) and re-done anyway due to different cement's being used. He has advised that we get her on a waiting list now, but can this be done from a parents address or will they wish to see us first

I for one can't wait to be in the UK and know that my holiday saving will not need to be put towards some emergency care for the kids. To think that so far this year we should have spent $2.4K on health for just 2 kids is ridiculous. They are healthy kids too! One just smashed her teeth in the playground and the work is not covered by the school dental. These costs do not even take into account asthma stuff which is also free in the UK.
I know that we could have insurance to cover these costs but when we have looked into it the basic insurance doesn't cover glasses or dental anyway and the others the excess is stupid.




