British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Middle East (https://britishexpats.com/forum/middle-east-60/)
-   -   Burkini's are out (https://britishexpats.com/forum/middle-east-60/burkinis-out-625308/)

954RR Aug 13th 2009 5:38 am

Burkini's are out
 
It looks like the French are getting even stricter with the wearing of the Burka.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/8197917.stm

meonline Aug 13th 2009 5:42 am

Re: Burkini's are out
 

Originally Posted by 954RR (Post 7838623)
It looks like the French are getting even stricter with the wearing of the Burka.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/8197917.stm

I am all for a balance in society but considering France is home to 5 million Muslims, this does not bode well for race relations. The French Government risk further alienating French Muslims who are an integral part of French society.

klaus3974 Aug 13th 2009 7:13 am

Re: Burkini's are out
 

Originally Posted by meonline (Post 7838630)
I am all for a balance in society but considering France is home to 5 million Muslims, this does not bode well for race relations. The French Government risk further alienating French Muslims who are an integral part of French society.

5 million Muslims are less than 8% of the French population. If you count only legal Muslims that number will be less than 7%. How many Non-Muslims live in the UAE? I guess far more than 7% and the government does not allow me to kiss my wife in public, wear shorts in a Malls, drive a female colleague to her house, drink water in public during one month a year when outside is 45C... gosh.... now I really feel alienated!!!

BurpusMe Aug 13th 2009 7:16 am

Re: Burkini's are out
 

Originally Posted by klaus3974 (Post 7838755)
5 million Muslims are less than 8% of the French population. If you count only legal Muslims that number will be less than 7%. How many Non-Muslims live in the UAE? I guess far more than 7% and the government does not allow me to kiss my wife in public, wear shorts in a Malls, drive a female colleague to her house, drink water in public during one month a year when outside is 45C... gosh.... now I really feel alienated!!!

Does this mean the Sports Illustrate Burkini Issue is cancelled?

klaus3974 Aug 13th 2009 7:25 am

Re: Burkini's are out
 

Originally Posted by BurpusMe (Post 7838763)
Does this mean the Sports Illustrate Burkini Issue is cancelled?

It is not cancelled. The photo shooting has been moved from Champs Elysees to the KSA. It will take place during the Saudi Beauty Pageant Contest...

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/new...cle6244354.ece

MataHari Aug 13th 2009 7:47 am

Re: Burkini's are out
 
I truly fail to see why people have a problem with this...is there some sort of law that tells us exactly how much flesh needs to be on display in order to be allowed to go swimming...
If anything, hideous beerbellied men in Speedos should be banned for life...

Are wetsuits offending as well...

Patsy Stoned Aug 13th 2009 8:28 am

Re: Burkini's are out
 

Originally Posted by MataHari (Post 7838828)
I truly fail to see why people have a problem with this...is there some sort of law that tells us exactly how much flesh needs to be on display in order to be allowed to go swimming...
If anything, hideous beerbellied men in Speedos should be banned for life...

Are wetsuits offending as well...

http://www.banmoco.co.uk/speedos-ban...htening-11500/

there you go MH, you wish is granted lol

MataHari Aug 13th 2009 8:36 am

Re: Burkini's are out
 

Originally Posted by Patsy Stoned (Post 7838900)
http://www.banmoco.co.uk/speedos-ban...htening-11500/

there you go MH, you wish is granted lol

lol...I knew I had a point there...

954RR Aug 13th 2009 8:56 am

Re: Burkini's are out
 

Originally Posted by Patsy Stoned (Post 7838900)
http://www.banmoco.co.uk/speedos-ban...htening-11500/

there you go MH, you wish is granted lol

"Alton Towers has said that is also considering offering body waxing services to men"

Wow Back, Sack and Crack services offered at Alton Towers? Whatever next.

Bonny Boy Aug 13th 2009 9:05 am

Re: Burkini's are out
 

Originally Posted by klaus3974 (Post 7838755)
5 million Muslims are less than 8% of the French population. If you count only legal Muslims that number will be less than 7%. How many Non-Muslims live in the UAE? I guess far more than 7% and the government does not allow me to kiss my wife in public, wear shorts in a Malls, drive a female colleague to her house, drink water in public during one month a year when outside is 45C... gosh.... now I really feel alienated!!!

The Muslims in France are French citizens.

The non-Muslims in the UAE are tolerated visitors/residents.

The European's style themselves as multi-cultural, multi-racial, tolerant etc.

The Gulf states do not.

Hence whilst the Gulf states do not conform to western liberal ideals, at least they are not hypocritical about it.

Hello.Kitty Aug 13th 2009 9:26 am

Re: Burkini's are out
 

Originally Posted by Bonny Boy (Post 7838959)
The Muslims in France are French citizens.

The non-Muslims in the UAE are tolerated visitors/residents.

The European's style themselves as multi-cultural, multi-racial, tolerant etc.

The Gulf states do not.

Hence whilst the Gulf states do not conform to western liberal ideals, at least they are not hypocritical about it.

I know I've said this before, but in France, these various "rules" (like not wearing any kind of religious symbol/garment in schools) have been in force for a long, long time, and yes, it is to make sure that religion does not have any effect on state business.

So the swimming pool has rules that say you can't jump in fully clothed? Just like it has a rule that you have to pay the entrace fee, not run around, etc... big deal. If you don't respect the other rules, you either don't get in or get chucked out... why should this be any different?

Oh yeah, sorry... it's roflstomping my human rights if religion is lurking behind my choice. :frown:

klaus3974 Aug 13th 2009 9:29 am

Re: Burkini's are out
 

Originally Posted by Bonny Boy (Post 7838959)
The Muslims in France are French citizens.

The non-Muslims in the UAE are tolerated visitors/residents.

The European's style themselves as multi-cultural, multi-racial, tolerant etc.

The Gulf states do not.

Hence whilst the Gulf states do not conform to western liberal ideals, at least they are not hypocritical about it.

Well... the French citizens (Muslims or not) voted for the government that decides over the laws and regulations of the country. One of those regulations been the No Burkini. If they do not like it, they can vote for another government in a few years. The citizens here (Muslims or not) do not have that privilege... as laws are dictated (and changed every day) by non elected figures that often have a very narrow mind about what is right or wrong.

On the other hand... been multi-cultural, multi-racial, multi-whatever does not mean everything goes! My understanding is that the French government (maybe in a wrong way) understand some muslim outfits to be an element of oppression for women and they put the person over the religion. If it is at all that the Muslim religion requires women to wear this kind of cloth... what I am not totally sure.

I do not see the French government been hypocritical about it... they are choosing based on their values.

Bonny Boy Aug 13th 2009 10:28 am

Re: Burkini's are out
 

Originally Posted by klaus3974 (Post 7839013)
Well... the French citizens (Muslims or not) voted for the government that decides over the laws and regulations of the country. One of those regulations been the No Burkini. If they do not like it, they can vote for another government in a few years. The citizens here (Muslims or not) do not have that privilege... as laws are dictated (and changed every day) by non elected figures that often have a very narrow mind about what is right or wrong.

On the other hand... been multi-cultural, multi-racial, multi-whatever does not mean everything goes! My understanding is that the French government (maybe in a wrong way) understand some muslim outfits to be an element of oppression for women and they put the person over the religion. If it is at all that the Muslim religion requires women to wear this kind of cloth... what I am not totally sure.

I do not see the French government been hypocritical about it... they are choosing based on their values.

OK, but were the latest restrictions in the manifesto at the time of election? I'm not sure, I admit.

Also, western democracies are constitutional democracies - rights of minorities are meant to be protected. It isn't 3 foxes and a chicken voting on what is for lunch!

The real issue is to what extent women are forced into wearing this garb. If it is a free choice, I have nothing against it (libertarian leanings on my part I'm afraid). However, if an element are coerced, is there any other mechanism of tackling this other than an out-right ban?

klaus3974 Aug 13th 2009 10:49 am

Re: Burkini's are out
 

Originally Posted by Bonny Boy (Post 7839148)
OK, but were the latest restrictions in the manifesto at the time of election? I'm not sure, I admit.

Also, western democracies are constitutional democracies - rights of minorities are meant to be protected. It isn't 3 foxes and a chicken voting on what is for lunch!

The real issue is to what extent women are forced into wearing this garb. If it is a free choice, I have nothing against it (libertarian leanings on my part I'm afraid). However, if an element are coerced, is there any other mechanism of tackling this other than an out-right ban?

The restrictions (that applies to other religions and issues) have been for decades. It is not something new and most of the French Muslims are former colonies arabs who became French citizens in the 50s, 60s knowing these restrictions. The problem is that, funny enough, the children of this old generation are more radical than their parents.

By the way, I do not agree with the Burkini ban myself but I do understand the French government.

Hello.Kitty Aug 13th 2009 1:25 pm

Re: Burkini's are out
 

Originally Posted by klaus3974 (Post 7839201)
The restrictions (that applies to other religions and issues) have been for decades.

The principle of a secular state, and consequently the laws and rules separating state from religion have been in force in France since Napoleonic times, and were kicked off during the French Revolution...220-odd years ago.


All times are GMT. The time now is 3:19 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.