*Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
#1
Forum Regular
Thread Starter
Joined: Oct 2010
Posts: 63
*Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
I am the proud holder of a CR-1 immigrant visa via marriage to a US citizen. It was issued in June and we plan to move over in November (my wife and I currently live in the UK), but my company might require me to travel to the US on business in the meantime.
I believe that I am not permitted to immigrate into the US before my wife, so I am wondering if my business trip could be done as a visit rather than immigration, then we stick to our November plan? (I have visited before and have an ESTA)
The only alternative I can see is that my wife join me on my business trip and we trigger the immigration, but obviously that will cost money we'd prefer to use for other things, as well as having some tax implications due to me becoming a US resident sooner than planned etc.
Refusing to do the business trip is possible but a last resort.
Any advice?
I believe that I am not permitted to immigrate into the US before my wife, so I am wondering if my business trip could be done as a visit rather than immigration, then we stick to our November plan? (I have visited before and have an ESTA)
The only alternative I can see is that my wife join me on my business trip and we trigger the immigration, but obviously that will cost money we'd prefer to use for other things, as well as having some tax implications due to me becoming a US resident sooner than planned etc.
Refusing to do the business trip is possible but a last resort.
Any advice?
#2
Account Closed
Joined: Aug 2002
Location: Kentucky
Posts: 38,865
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
I am wondering if my business trip could be done as a visit rather than immigration, then we stick to our November plan? (I have visited before and have an ESTA)
Hopefully, others will be along shortly to offer something more.
Ian
#3
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
I was in a similar position last year although my proposed work trip wasn't vital. I looked around BE and elsewhere and couldn't find a definitive answer bu the consensus seemed to be it'd probably be at the CBP officer's discretion. In the end I decided not to risk complicating things unnecessarily.
#4
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
I was in a similar position last year although my proposed work trip wasn't vital. I looked around BE and elsewhere and couldn't find a definitive answer bu the consensus seemed to be it'd probably be at the CBP officer's discretion. In the end I decided not to risk complicating things unnecessarily.
Rene
#5
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
Sorry, should have clarified that entry under the VWP would be at the officer's discretion. I agree that neither myself nor the OP could have been admitted as an immigrant under this scenario.
#6
Forum Regular
Thread Starter
Joined: Oct 2010
Posts: 63
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
Thanks for the responses. I'm not keen on flying all that way with a greater than normal risk of being turned back, so I'll try calling the premium rate helpline to see if they know. I'll wait and see if I definitely need to make the trip first though.
#7
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
Rene
#8
Forum Regular
Thread Starter
Joined: Oct 2010
Posts: 63
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
I can see why rpjs decided not to risk it!
#9
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
They don't respond all that quickly (when I e-mailed with a query I got a response about a week later) but perhaps you have time.
#10
Forum Regular
Thread Starter
Joined: Oct 2010
Posts: 63
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
From the ESTA website:
Seems to suggest that I should be able to travel on my ESTA rather than my CR-1. I have emailed them to ask for my specific circumstances and I'll update here if I receive a reply.
Do I need to apply for ESTA if...?
I have a visa? No. ESTA is not required for people traveling to the U.S. with a valid visa for the purpose in which it was issued. However, if you have a visa, but are traveling under the Visa Waiver Program (VWP) instead of your visa, then you will need to apply for ESTA. For instance, if you have an F1 visa, but are coming to the U.S. for business or pleasure for no more than 90 days, (and are a citizen of a VWP country) then you would be traveling under the VWP, which requires you to apply for ESTA before you travel.
I have a visa? No. ESTA is not required for people traveling to the U.S. with a valid visa for the purpose in which it was issued. However, if you have a visa, but are traveling under the Visa Waiver Program (VWP) instead of your visa, then you will need to apply for ESTA. For instance, if you have an F1 visa, but are coming to the U.S. for business or pleasure for no more than 90 days, (and are a citizen of a VWP country) then you would be traveling under the VWP, which requires you to apply for ESTA before you travel.
#11
Forum Regular
Thread Starter
Joined: Oct 2010
Posts: 63
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
I just received a response:
Actually, my wife should be travelling with me on this trip now, so I'll take the do-not-open envelope and if there's a problem entering under VWP we'll just immigrate.
For your business trip you will need to enter the US under the Visa Waiver Program as a business traveler with the approved ESTA.
#12
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
[/QUOTE] so I am wondering if my business trip could be done as a visit rather than immigration, then we stick to our November plan?
Any advice? [/QUOTE]
If you are planning on moving to the U.S. in 3 months or less, why not enter on the CR-1? You can be out of the U.S. on temporary trips as an LPR. CBP looks at your intent for each of these trips. You go back temporarily, you wrap up your affairs, and move to the U.S. That does not sound like an LPR abandonment issue to me.
#13
Account Closed
Joined: Aug 2002
Location: Kentucky
Posts: 38,865
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
Ian
#14
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
OP is discussing his first entry after the immigrant visa interview, not the I-864. The I-864 requires the Petitioner to be domiciled (or re-estabish her domicile) in the U.S. Given that the I-864 has been submitted and approved already and the CR-1 issued, the U.S. citizen petitioner has satisfied this requirement already.
#15
Re: *Must* I use my CR-1 immigrant visa first time?
OP is discussing his first entry after the immigrant visa interview, not the I-864. The I-864 requires the Petitioner to be domiciled (or re-estabish her domicile) in the U.S. Given that the I-864 has been submitted and approved already and the CR-1 issued, the U.S. citizen petitioner has satisfied this requirement already.
The I-864 has been "accepted" and the Immigrant Visa has been issued....but the I-864 won't come into effect until the Immigrant enters the USA, right? And at THAT moment, the USC needs to be resident in the USA, isn't that correct? If the USC spouse is still overseas, then they aren't resident in the USA....they only established "intent" to be domiciled in the USA.
Rene