British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   The Maple Leaf (https://britishexpats.com/forum/maple-leaf-98/)
-   -   Who gets the flu shot? (https://britishexpats.com/forum/maple-leaf-98/who-gets-flu-shot-774347/)

dbd33 Oct 11th 2012 6:12 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by iaink (Post 10326058)
You are probably sharing random germs with random members of the public all the time, but as far a flu goes in a pandemic year something like 1 in 4 show symptoms and more will be carriers.

I remember the pandemic. It was a bother because I was working in the UK, the client wouldn't allow anyone visiting from Toronto on site so I had to drive to Montreal and fly from there. I don't believe I killed anyone, I didn't hear that I did.

iaink Oct 11th 2012 6:13 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by dbd33 (Post 10326094)
I remember the pandemic. It was a bother because I was working in the UK, the client wouldn't allow anyone visiting from Toronto on site so I had to drive to Montreal and fly from there. I don't believe I killed anyone, I didn't hear that I did.

Not that pandemic, the proper one that killed 3% of the global population. We are about due another one, 1918, 1958, 1968, 20??

dbd33 Oct 11th 2012 6:26 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by iaink (Post 10326097)
Not that pandemic, the proper one that killed 3% of the global population. We are about due another one, 1918, 1958, 1968, 20??

Shouldn't it have been along in late 1970?

iaink Oct 11th 2012 6:38 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by dbd33 (Post 10326121)
Shouldn't it have been along in late 1970?

In which case we are even more overdue right? Like Vancouver and a major earthquake. except there are no shots for that though that I know of...

dbd33 Oct 11th 2012 6:48 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by iaink (Post 10326137)
In which case we are even more overdue right? Like Vancouver and a major earthquake. except there are no shots for that though that I know of...

Pah! I sneeze at your numerology.

iaink Oct 11th 2012 6:57 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 
Bless you...

Souvy Oct 11th 2012 7:16 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by dbd33 (Post 10326016)
And what is my chance of having met a random member of the public and shared my germs with him or her?

In your case, probably quite high.

BristolUK Oct 11th 2012 7:56 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by iaink (Post 10325966)
Death rates in Canada from influenza are typically 500-1500 in an average year.

According to Public Health Agency of Canada it's 4k to 8k a year.

Just looking over some figures. They're quite scary.

It appears that the rate of Canadians being hospitalised is double the rate of UK folk just seeing their doctor.

This might just mean that Canadians overreact. But then deaths from flu in Canada appear between 7 and 13 times what the UK had in a bad year (602). That's on PHAC figures.

Even on Iaink's figures, that's deaths in Canada of 2 and a half times that of a bad UK year.

Whichever is the more accurate, Canada's annual death totals from flu are somewhere between double and 13 times that of a bad year in the UK.

For a country with half the UK population, that's going some isn't it?


It seems flu is a far bigger problem in Canada than it is in the UK. Perhaps we should view it that way?

iaink Oct 11th 2012 8:05 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 
I expect its more likely just one of those reporting variances that screw up statistical comparisons all the time. Canadians are perhaps more likely to be labelled as dying from "influenza" rather then "respiratory complications" or whatever...

my made up numbers came from here by the way...

Novocastrian Oct 11th 2012 8:22 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by iaink (Post 10326263)
I expect its more likely just one of those reporting variances that screw up statistical comparisons all the time. Canadians are perhaps more likely to be labelled as dying from "influenza" rather then "respiratory complications" or whatever...

my made up numbers came from here by the way...

It seems as if the rate is increasing year over year. It's prolly the vaccine.

Jingsamichty Oct 11th 2012 8:46 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 
For all the claims about 'outdoor lifestyles', I think Canadians probably spend a greater proportion of time in the winter cooped up inside public buildings alongside strangers compared to the UK.

dbd33 Oct 11th 2012 10:26 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by Jingsamichty (Post 10326310)
For all the claims about 'outdoor lifestyles', I think Canadians probably spend a greater proportion of time in the winter cooped up inside public buildings alongside strangers compared to the UK.

I don't think Canadians claim "outdoor lifestyles", I think that's an immigrant thing. It seems to me that proper Canadians huddle indoors plotting their move to the US.

Novocastrian Oct 11th 2012 10:46 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by dbd33 (Post 10326429)
I don't think Canadians claim "outdoor lifestyles", I think that's an immigrant thing. It seems to me that proper Canadians huddle indoors plotting their move to the US.

Or to Norfolk. But I agree, outdoor winter lifestyles in Canada are for kids and other immature folk. Let's just face the muskox in the room. It's f***ing cold.

geedee Oct 12th 2012 1:29 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 
I have found taking vitamin D3 works very well.... I've not had the seasonal "heavy cold" since I've been here.... which is when I started to take vit D in the winter. Maybe it's that or maybe Canada has less germs....!!

iaink Oct 12th 2012 2:13 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by Novocastrian (Post 10326460)
Or to Norfolk. But I agree, outdoor winter lifestyles in Canada are for kids and other immature folk. Let's just face the muskox in the room. It's f***ing cold.

Thats why you need to find something you enjoy doing in the winter. I find skiing when its warm incredibly tedious to be honest; It works much better when the snow doesnt melt.

Maybe Im just immature...:ohmy:

dbd33 Oct 12th 2012 2:19 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by iaink (Post 10327406)
Thats why you need to find something you enjoy doing in the winter.

I think that's pretty rare. People in Canada generally endure a miserable time for five months a year during their working lives and then, if they can afford it, spend the winters in America. Those who do find something enjoyable typically do it indoors, crochet, quilting and scrapbooking are very popular.

iaink Oct 12th 2012 2:33 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by dbd33 (Post 10327420)
I think that's pretty rare. People in Canada generally endure a miserable time for five months a year during their working lives and then, if they can afford it, spend the winters in America. Those who do find something enjoyable typically do it indoors, crochet, quilting and scrapbooking are very popular.

There are some that do, some that dont. There is no shortage of old timers hockey and the like going on, Curling, that sort of thing. Maybe cos you dont get out, you just assume no one else does? When I go out there are people of all ages out there too.

Then there are people who leave if they can too of course, it takes all sorts, but if you are going to prosper here then you need something to do over the winter, either inside or out.

dbd33 Oct 12th 2012 2:45 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by iaink (Post 10327446)
Then there are people who leave if they can too of course, it takes all sorts, but if you are going to prosper here then you need something to do over the winter, either inside or out.

Well, no. I've prospered here. It seems to me now that a major reason for that is that, for most of my time here, I've had no interests in Canada. Like my colleagues and associates, I've been willing to work all the time because, for five months of the year, there's really nothing better to do. Television is hugely popular, of course, if you enjoy Survivor you'll likely want to go home and see that.

I don't think, btw, that curling, essentially lawn green bowling indoors, counts as "getting out".

Jingsamichty Oct 12th 2012 2:47 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 
Believe it or not, my comment wasn't a dig at Canadians (well, not really!) but it was a genuine observation that in winter, Canadians do seem to spend a lot of time indoors which may go some way to explaining the apparent higher incidence of flu.

Not wandering down blustery high streets or standing on freezing terraces or staggering across town on pub crawls obviously makes you sick.

dbd33 Oct 12th 2012 2:50 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by Jingsamichty (Post 10327477)
Canadians do seem to spend a lot of time indoors which may go some way to explaining the apparent higher incidence of flu.

If they spent a lot of time outdoors they'd be frozen to death. Flu seems a good alternative.

Jingsamichty Oct 12th 2012 2:57 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by dbd33 (Post 10327487)
If they spent a lot of time outdoors they'd be frozen to death. Flu seems a good alternative.

Going to work this morning it was pitch black, -10C and snowing. In October. There are seven months of this ahead. I thought of the First Nations that lived up here and, for the millionth time, wondered why on earth they decided that this was the perfect place to set up home.

iaink Oct 12th 2012 3:01 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by dbd33 (Post 10327468)
Well, no. I've prospered here. It seems to me now that a major reason for that is that, for most of my time here, I've had no interests in Canada. Like my colleagues and associates, I've been willing to work all the time because, for five months of the year, there's really nothing better to do. Television is hugely popular, of course, if you enjoy Survivor you'll likely want to go home and see that.

I don't think, btw, that curling, essentially lawn green bowling indoors, counts as "getting out".

Prospered as in "enjoyed living here", not prospered as in "made money".


Curling is suprisingly hard physical work, as you would know if you had ever tried it before knocking it.

BristolUK Oct 12th 2012 5:31 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by geedee (Post 10327310)
... maybe Canada has less germs....!!

It's all those hand sanitizers everywhere.

Steve_ Oct 12th 2012 6:43 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 
Rick Mercer: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gsMnsWvKEJs

Steve_ Oct 12th 2012 6:50 am

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by dbd33 (Post 10327420)
I think that's pretty rare. People in Canada generally endure a miserable time for five months a year during their working lives and then, if they can afford it, spend the winters in America. Those who do find something enjoyable typically do it indoors, crochet, quilting and scrapbooking are very popular.

They attend the Slusherville Winterfest.

wonderwoman1st Oct 13th 2012 5:04 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by Jingsamichty (Post 10325642)
Never had a flu shot, never had flu (and neither have most people).

speak for yourself, I have had the flu when not had a shot.
I also commonly had it when I did have the shot at age 10.. Not sure how you can speak for 'most' people to be honest.
A good reason why you can get mild symptoms after having a shot is any innoculation gives you a bit of the virus or the bacteria (the dead cells) and that is how the body starts to build up it's immunity against it. I admit I did avoid having the flu shots commonly for years after I left school, because commonly at school when we were made to have it I did end up with flu for 3 days leading me to believe that alone was what gave me the flu.
However, I did still get the flu.

I have the flu shot nowadays and I don't get the flu, I hope it stays that way from now on.

It's a good idea to get the shot.. better to reduce the chances of getting full blown flu, or it going away sooner than if you hadn't had the shot

I prefer to get it for me and my little one with him being around children his age all day at preschool nowadays.

I quite enjoy giving out flu shots too, and during Nov and Dec I will be busy doing so :D

wonderwoman1st Oct 13th 2012 5:19 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by britsnake (Post 10325656)
I get the Flu shot every year.

When you get the shot, they list a whole lot of possible side effects, but I have not had any of them so far. I have had flu once in my life and never want to go through that again if I can avoid it.

Same here though I had it more than once.

My little man of age 3 had his first flu shot yesterday and I have to say he's run down for 24 hrs quite soon after, today speaking with a croaky voice and had a bit of a cough. Last night he burned up a bit, took, his temp and gave a dose of tylenol and removed his pyjama top, and he was aok again. I hope it's not me at age 10 again, when I commonly got the flu after the shot during my school years. More likely in the youngsters as they are still building up their immunity system.

wonderwoman1st Oct 13th 2012 5:22 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by Howefamily (Post 10325660)
Its the thought of that needle stuck in my arm that really puts me off

It doesn't hurt, it's a small needle not an intramuscular one.

Turning away also helps so you don't have to see it it, then you hardly feel it at all.

wonderwoman1st Oct 13th 2012 5:29 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by iaink (Post 10325685)
The point is it may not be sufficient to kill you, but if you get flu, it may be sufficient to kill someone you pass it onto.

The more people that have the shot, the less any outbreak that that shot covers will spread and impact those that are at danger of serious consequences.

I consider it a civic duty, but then I wonder how effective the people developing the shot are at picking the active strains for any particular year.

I dont really see a downside, even if you get minor symptoms for a day or two, chances are you are going to be like that at some point over the winter anyway, and if it is a bonanza year for flu you are hopefully protected and helping to minimise the potential spread to others.


100% correct, could not have put that better myself. Iain is absolutely right on this one folks, I have to say. There should be more education out there on this, I see it easily as I'm a nurse, but I don't commonly see it around, something for me to work on I think (health education and health promotion).

Here's a good website to keep you all well informed:

http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/index-eng.php

wonderwoman1st Oct 13th 2012 5:46 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by iaink (Post 10325720)
Doncha think if the flu shot had that effect on everyone in a given year it would have made the news? Thats just weird. Ive had the shot for the last ten years or more, and nothing like that has ever happened to me or anyone else in the group here:confused:

Agreed, wise words yet again.

And even though I commonly did end up with the flu aged 10 it wasn't for 2 weeks, it would have likely been just 2 days had the nurses not been so harsh at my school and uniformly/ automatically kicked us out of the sanitorium after 3 days regardless, I'd end up back in there again the same night no thanks for them.. after suffering a long evening chapel service usually.. seemed to be the same time every year after getting my shot back then (our medical center at our boarding school was called a sanitorium) must have been worse jabs when I was 10 yrs old, or likely my immunity still building up.
Anyway, I don't get the flu nowadays for having had the shot, even if that bad experience at school did put me off having it for years.

Some occupations are compulsory for having it.. mine too, but I opt for it more now anyway.

wonderwoman1st Oct 13th 2012 5:47 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by dbd33 (Post 10325762)
So is getting a library card but I haven't bothered with that either. If people want to have it, good for them but, as you say, it's no big deal either way.

It is for those with a lowered immunity system, or for older adults who commonly die from it for not being immunized.
And as Iain mentioned, it also helps prevent it spreading to others when you have the flu shot even if you don't suffer from it yourself.

wonderwoman1st Oct 13th 2012 5:54 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by Jingsamichty (Post 10325791)
I suspect the efficacy of the flu shot in preventing deaths by limiting the spread to vulnerable members of society is similar to the efficacy of full-body scanners at airports preventing deaths to air travellers... statistically miniscule but tremendously profitable for the manufacturers.

Never paid for one.
It's free here with your health card via your doctor too. Just avoid having it done via pharmacists elsewhere, they do charge, it's not really their role anyway to give flu shots it's the nurses role, but has become their role in Canada now at least, my doctors technique wasn't exactly brilliant either, he held it with one hand and just inserted it, not how us nurses are trained to give an injection at all.. and he gave it intramuscularly on my arm when it's meant to be subcutaneously.

wonderwoman1st Oct 13th 2012 5:58 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by dbd33 (Post 10325932)
Steady on, it's flu we're talking about here, not TB. How many people in Guelph died of the flu last winter?

steady on? steady on yourself, he's right on what he's saying on all this, listen up and learn I say..

wonderwoman1st Oct 13th 2012 6:01 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by dbd33 (Post 10326016)
And what is my chance of having met a random member of the public and shared my germs with him or her?

Do you have any idea how germs spread? It's not just through physical touch you know..

Danny B Oct 13th 2012 6:04 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 
Flu shot my arse. I thought Canadian's were a hardy outdoor bunch?

wonderwoman1st Oct 13th 2012 6:20 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by dbd33 (Post 10327420)
I think that's pretty rare. People in Canada generally endure a miserable time for five months a year during their working lives and then, if they can afford it, spend the winters in America. Those who do find something enjoyable typically do it indoors, crochet, quilting and scrapbooking are very popular.

I don't know where you have been hiding or where your inaccurate assumptions come from exactly, but there seems to be plenty of them on this thread. It's certainly not what I've seen the time I've lived over here on moving to BC in 2007 then Toronto 2012, quite the opposite and I love the Canadians for their outdoor pursuits, ice skating rinks outside, not seen many indoors to be honest. Or skiing down mountains, snow shoeing, ice climbing.. the list goes on. I'm sure if I showed your post to my Canadian friends from coast to coast you'd soon be put back in your place on this one.

wonderwoman1st Oct 13th 2012 6:23 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by iaink (Post 10327406)
Thats why you need to find something you enjoy doing in the winter. I find skiing when its warm incredibly tedious to be honest; It works much better when the snow doesnt melt.

Maybe Im just immature...:ohmy:

Gosh, me too! Or maybe I'm just a big kid who enjoys life and keeping fit and healthy and loves the outdoors and healthy good fresh air, rather than being huddled indoors where germs get breathed in from others who don't like to open their windows.

Since when was outdoor pursuits just for kids exactly?????! FAIL on that inaccurate comment :thumbdown:

wonderwoman1st Oct 13th 2012 6:25 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by dbd33 (Post 10327468)
Well, no. I've prospered here. It seems to me now that a major reason for that is that, for most of my time here, I've had no interests in Canada. Like my colleagues and associates, I've been willing to work all the time because, for five months of the year, there's really nothing better to do. Television is hugely popular, of course, if you enjoy Survivor you'll likely want to go home and see that.

I don't think, btw, that curling, essentially lawn green bowling indoors, counts as "getting out".

??? So why are you in Canada then? Why stay here if you dislike it so much? Maybe you really are in the wrong place.

wonderwoman1st Oct 13th 2012 6:29 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by iaink (Post 10327507)
Prospered as in "enjoyed living here", not prospered as in "made money".


Curling is suprisingly hard physical work, as you would know if you had ever tried it before knocking it.

I think there's plenty he's not tried, just likes to criticize and state things he's not that clued up about, plain old ignorance that is, and clearly strongly dislikes Canada (possibly Canadians too), I can't work out why you are here in that case dbbd (sorry if I spelt that name tag wrong btw).

Eeek excuse all the posts at one time, just read through it all and posted as I read through.

Jingsamichty Oct 13th 2012 11:36 pm

Re: Who gets the flu shot?
 

Originally Posted by wonderwoman1st (Post 10329756)
Eeek excuse all the posts at one time, just read through it all and posted as I read through.

I think the flu shot is the least of your medication concerns.


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 5:53 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.